Scottish Water v Lynne Edgar
Decision date: 6 March 2024
Neutral citation: [2024] EAT 32
Overall AI summary confidence: high
Short overview
This short overview is intended to summarise the case, issues and outcome so far as they are supported by the judgment.
AI confidence in this short overview: high
This EAT appeal concerned whether Scottish Water had proved a material factor defence to an equal pay claim where a male comparator, appointed after the claimant, was paid higher in the same band. The Employment Tribunal had required proof of the identity and subjective state of mind of the specific pay decision‑maker and excluded comparative evidence of skills and performance after appointment; the EAT held those were legal errors. The Tribunal's preliminary ruling was set aside and the preliminary issue remitted to a differently constituted Tribunal for rehearing.
Ratio decidendi
This summary is intended to identify the ratio decidendi, meaning the legal reasons for deciding and the binding part of the decision.
AI confidence in this ratio decidendi summary: high
The EAT held that proving a material factor defence does not invariably require direct evidence identifying a particular decision‑maker's subjective thought process; causation can be established by objective evidence showing a sufficient causal link, including admissible circumstantial or second‑hand evidence from knowledgeable witnesses about why pay differences arose and were maintained.
Obiter dicta
This summary is intended to identify obiter dicta, meaning observations made by the way that were not necessary to deciding the case and are not binding.
AI confidence in this obiter dicta summary: medium
The judgment also commented (obiter) that tribunal reasons should be clear, concise and properly proof‑read, and that characterising a case as a "recruitment case" does not change the central question of what objectively caused the pay difference.