Generated case pages
Search by case title, citation, date, short overview, ratio decidendi summary, or obiter dicta summary.
AI Notice: Any short overview shown on this page is AI-generated, provided only to help users assess potential relevance more quickly, and may be wholly inaccurate. No liability is accepted for the accuracy of any such summary, regardless of any AI confidence rating shown. Users should check the underlying decision and obtain appropriate legal advice rather than relying on any summary.
- Y Dozie v Moorfields Eye Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 172 12 November 2026 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal erred or acted unfairly by making findings on sex discrimination/harassment claims that it had concluded were not included in the list of issues. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Tribunal correctly interpreted the Hodgson list as excluding the sex-based claims, but erred in nevertheless considering those claims without giving the parties an opportunity to call evidence or cross-examine; that error was not material to the outcome and the appeal was dismissed.
- Dr Theodore Piepenbrock v London School of Economics and Political Science [2026] EAT 173 11 November 2026 This case concerns the effect of the claimant's bankruptcy (and subsequent automatic discharge) on two EAT appeals from dismissed employment tribunal complaints and a costs order. The EAT held the costs appeal academic and dismissed it because the underlying liability was a provable bankruptcy debt; unfair dismissal complaints were personal and did not vest in the Official Receiver so the claimant may pursue that part of the liability appeal; Equality Act claims that sought both personal remedies and loss of earnings vested in the Official Receiver and remain vested after discharge unless the claimant irrevocably relinquishes loss-of-earnings remedies by amendment or the OR assigns them back.
- Janna Linde v University of East London [2026] EAT 175 11 November 2026 This appeal concerned whether the claimant was an employee of the University for a 2020/21 placement or instead had no contract. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Employment Tribunal erred in treating the absence of a written bilateral contract as decisive, found there was evidence of an agreement (signatures on the 20/21 PLA and payment via payroll), allowed the appeal and remitted the case to a newly constituted Employment Tribunal to determine the true terms, personal-service requirement and whether the claimant was in business on her own account. The appeal against refusal of reconsideration was dismissed as academic.
- P&O European Ferries (Irish Sea) Ltd v Craig Rennie [2026] EAT 177 11 November 2026 This appeal concerned whether practicability under s.117(4) Employment Rights Act must be assessed as at the re‑engagement order’s compliance date and whether the tribunal had to make a fresh positive finding that the advertised PTAM post existed on that date. The EAT held practicability is assessed as at the compliance date (1 August 2024 here) and that the ET was not required to make an affirmative finding of existence once it had rejected the respondent’s sole evidential case; the appeal was dismissed and the ET’s orders and compensation awards stand.
- Lynne Amidon v North London NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 171 10 November 2026 This is an appeal by Ms Amidon against a Central London Employment Tribunal’s rejection of her whistleblowing (protected-disclosure) detriment claims and direct race discrimination and harassment claims. The EAT dismissed all ten grounds of appeal, upholding the ET’s findings that only some of the alleged disclosures were protected, that the ET applied the correct legal tests (including for “reasonable belief” and for what amounts to a “miscarriage of justice”), and that there was no error of law or perversity in the ET’s factual conclusions about causation and the race claims. The ET’s decision is therefore upheld.
- Department for Work and Pensions v Tasneem Kiani [2026] EAT 168 6 November 2026 This appeal concerned an employee dismissed for accessing her adult son’s Universal Credit account without authorisation; the Employment Tribunal found dismissal unfair and ordered reinstatement with a 20% reduction for contributory fault. The EAT held the Tribunal had fallen into a substitution mindset, blended mitigation into the objective question of gross misconduct and failed to give adequate reasons for the 20% reduction, allowed the DWP’s appeal and directed further submissions on disposal.
- Al-Ateeqi v Kuwait Investment Authority [2026] EAT 169 5 November 2026 This appeal concerned whether the Kuwait Investment Authority (KIA) enjoyed state immunity from Employment Tribunal claims by its London CEO, who also held diplomatic status as Financial Attaché. The EAT upheld the ET: the appointment and dismissal were acts done in the exercise of sovereign authority because the CEO role was functionally indistinguishable from diplomatic status, and the State of Kuwait would likewise have been immune. The result is that the KIA is immune from the claimant’s whistleblowing and unfair dismissal claims.
- A Byczko v Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 167 2 November 2026 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's strike‑out of multiple claims brought by a litigant in person after repeated preliminary hearings failed to identify and narrow the issues. The EAT held the ET had provided extensive assistance and reasonable adjustments, explored alternatives (including an intermediary), and lawfully concluded that the claimant's persistent refusal to engage made a fair trial impossible; the strike‑out was proportionate and the appeal was dismissed.
- LMN v SIMON BRADSHAW AND OTHERS [2026] EAT 164 29 October 2026 This is an EAT appeal about whether an employment tribunal erred in refusing to anonymise a claimant where her disabled child was anonymised to guard against jigsaw identification. The EAT held the tribunal had considered jigsaw risks and anonymised several contextual details but failed to expressly decide whether the claimant’s personal and/or professional names should also be anonymised. The question was remitted to the original judge for fresh decision at a hearing with submissions; the EAT did not decide the anonymisation issue itself.
- MC v G [2026] EAT 161 29 October 2026 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal’s refusal to make a permanent Restricted Reporting Order (RRO) after finding that consensual private sexual messages had been exchanged between the claimant and an individual respondent. The EAT held the ET erred in law by failing adequately to identify and apply the specific confidentiality limb of Rule 50(1) (and related public‑interest test) and by mis‑weighing open‑justice considerations against a legitimate expectation of privacy. The EAT ordered removal of an irrelevant paragraph (para 419), preserved an EAT RRO pending redetermination, and remitted the RRO issue to the same ET for reconsideration.
- E Ukwu v Tritax Management LLP & Ors [2026] EAT 165 27 October 2026 This appeal concerns an Employment Tribunal’s strike‑out of a claimant’s race discrimination and harassment complaints after he failed to identify relevant passages in over 20 hours of audio recordings as required by a case management order. The EAT found the Tribunal was wrong to strike out those equality claims without first considering or recording proportionate alternatives (for example excluding the recordings), and also erred in treating proof of an ulterior motive (knowledge of protected disclosures) as a necessary element of the direct race/harassment causes of action. The EAT set aside the strike‑out of the race and harassment complaints and remitted them to a different Tribunal, while upholding strike‑out of certain whistleblowing complaints as having no reasonable prospect of success.
- FARGRO LIMITED v MR DAVID HIDE [2026] EAT 162 21 October 2026 This Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment concerns an unfair dismissal claim where the employer outsourced investigation, disciplinary and appeal functions to consultants but the managing director accepted their recommendations and dismissed the claimant and rejected his appeal. The EAT dismissed the employer's appeal that the Employment Judge should have made findings enabling a contributory-fault reduction, holding there was insufficient evidence to make primary findings of culpability. The claimant's cross‑appeal succeeded in part because the EJ failed to address material submissions about whether the decision‑maker had an opportunity to hear the claimant, requiring reconsideration of the Polkey reduction if further procedural unfairness is found.
- MR KAMRAN HUSSAIN v LONDON FIRE COMMISSIONER [2026] EAT 159 19 October 2026 This appeal considered (1) whether the employer ought to have known earlier about the claimant’s dyslexia (constructive knowledge) and (2) whether the ET mischaracterised the claimant’s s.15 claim that anxiety/depression (and resulting unwillingness to give a witness statement) amounted to something arising in consequence of the disability. The EAT dismissed the constructive-knowledge challenge, holding the tribunal reasonably found no obligation to inquire further before 14 October 2019, but allowed the s.15 ground, finding the ET had misidentified the “something arising” and remitted that issue for reconsideration.
- MS D v GREATER GLASGOW [2026] EAT 160 15 October 2026 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's decision to strike out a multi-claim ET case under rule 37(1)(e) because the claimant's PTSD and related mental ill-health, worsened by litigation, made attendance at any final hearing in the foreseeable future unrealistic. The tribunal found no proportionate lesser sanction (including a stay) would secure a fair trial and took into account respondent prejudice and resource implications. The EAT reviewed the tribunal's reasoning, found no error of law, and dismissed the appeal, affirming the strike-out.
- TALWINDER SINGH NAGRA v UNIPART GROUP LIMITED [2026] EAT 157 13 October 2026 This EAT appeal arose from an Employment Tribunal's preliminary judgment dismissing claims by Mr Nagra, who had worked via an agency and had been earlier told about an alternative Equality Act "contract‑worker" route which he chose not to pursue. The central issue was whether the ET was obliged to raise and decide that unpleaded Equality Act claim despite the claimant's election not to adopt it and as a litigant in person. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the ET was not required to reformulate or substitute that unpleaded cause of action, and that there was no error in findings on employment status, adequacy of reasons, or change of circumstances.
- MR WYC SHING v UNIVERSITY OF THE ARTS LONDON [2026] EAT 154 12 October 2026 This appeal concerned whether the employment tribunal erred in refusing to treat two colleagues (G and H) as comparators or to construct a hypothetical comparator, and whether HR involvement rendered the claimant’s summary dismissal unfair. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s factual findings that G and H were materially different and that constructing a hypothetical comparator would have been pointless, and it rejected the contention that routine HR involvement made the dismissal unfair. The appeal was dismissed.
- MR R BRYCE v COVENTRY CITY COUNCIL [2026] EAT 153 9 October 2026 This case concerns a job applicant with Asperger’s and dyslexia who sought adjustments to an interview process (extra time to process questions and asking closed/yes‑no questions). The EAT upheld the Tribunal’s finding that the employer did not breach its s.20 reasonable‑adjustments duty because it had provided closed questions in line with NAS guidance and the claimant’s proposed yes/no restriction was not reasonable. The EAT allowed the claimant’s s.15 discrimination‑arising‑from‑disability appeal, finding the Tribunal had wrongly preferred interviewers’ neurotypical impressions over evidence of the claimant’s stress and remitted that issue for rehearing.
- MRS T MCMANUS v BRITISH AIRWAYS PLC [2026] EAT 155 9 October 2026 This appeal concerned whether remarks made by an occupational health practitioner (including "Access to Work is not for people like you, it's for people in wheelchairs") amounted to harassment under s.26(4) Equality Act 2010. The EAT set out a two-stage test: (1) did the claimant subjectively perceive the conduct to have the proscribed effect; (2) if so, was it reasonable to regard the conduct as having that effect in all the circumstances. Applying that test, the EAT dismissed the claimant's appeal, holding the tribunal had not erred or acted perversely in finding the remark, read in the OH assessment context, was not objectively harassment; a claimant's mental ill‑health is a relevant circumstance but is not determinative.
- MRS V BAKER v THE GOVERNING BODY OF ST CHARLES RC SCHOOL [2026] EAT 158 9 October 2026 This appeal concerned a dismissed headteacher who argued the employment tribunal gave inadequate reasons and failed to separately address wrongful dismissal. The EAT upheld the tribunal: its investigation and findings that the employer genuinely and reasonably believed allegations were adequate to justify summary dismissal and the tribunal provided sufficient distinct reasoning that the conduct, taken cumulatively, amounted to a repudiatory breach. The appeal was dismissed.
- XYZ v BIRMINGHAM CITY COUNCIL [2026] EAT 152 5 October 2026 This EAT allowed parts of the claimant's appeal against an Employment Tribunal decision dismissing disability and some age-discrimination complaints, finding specific errors in the ET's treatment of whether the respondent acquired knowledge of the claimant's PTSD between June and October 2022, the justification for continuing disciplinary proceedings after that disclosure, and the ET's handling of late-presentation/time limits; those matters were remitted to the ET for reconsideration. The EAT dismissed the challenge to the ET's harassment "related to" finding and most age-discrimination grounds, and upheld the ET on burden of proof issues.
- MISS Z CHOWDHURY v THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR HEALTH AND SOCIAL CARE [2026] EAT 151 2 October 2026 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's "unless" order made after a part-heard hearing was adjourned for the claimant’s ill health and the Tribunal's later notice purporting to dismiss the remaining claim for non-compliance. The EAT allowed the appeal, set aside the unless order and the dismissal notice because the Tribunal had not assessed whether automatic dismissal of the whole claim was a proportionate sanction, and remitted the case for relisting with directions. The EAT accepted the claimant had been in material non‑compliance but held that finding has no continuing effect once the unless order is set aside.
- MISS ROSE SOUTHAM v BERKSHIRE HEALTHCARE NHS FOUNDATION TRUST [2026] EAT 150 1 October 2026 This appeal concerned whether the employment tribunal wrongly concluded that a litigant's 14 December 2017 note did not evidence two further protected disclosures (PD3 and PD9) and whether any such error could have affected the tribunal’s dismissal of related detriment complaints (D2 and D9.2). The Employment Appeal Tribunal found limited shortcomings in the tribunal’s reasoning about PD3 and PD9 but concluded those errors could not have changed the outcome on D2 and D9.2 because of the tribunal’s positive factual findings and pleading/timing constraints. Both the liability and reconsideration appeals were dismissed and no remittal was ordered.
- Bilal Miah v London Ambulance Service NHS Trust [2026] EAT 147 28 September 2026 This appeal concerned whether the claimant could rely on a new conversion argument on appeal when it had not been advanced in the Employment Tribunal in relation to disputed "disruption payments" for Christmas 2021 shifts. The EAT held the conversion argument had not been argued below and, absent exceptional circumstances and compliance with the Practice Direction, could not be raised for the first time on appeal; the appeal was dismissed and no preparation time order was made.
- MR K P McCONNELL v WM MORRISONS SUPERMARKETS LTD [2026] EAT 149 25 September 2026 This appeal concerned whether Mr McConnell was "assigned" for TUPE purposes after redeployment to a Returns & Recycling Unit (RRU), and whether the Employment Tribunal erred on indirect disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments, victimisation and time limits. The EAT held the ET was entitled to find assignment as a factual matter and that lawfulness of the prior redeployment was not part of the TUPE assignment inquiry, but it found legal errors in the ET's treatment of indirect discrimination and reasonable adjustments and remitted those complaints for rehearing; the appeal on victimisation was dismissed on its causation finding.
- KAREN STEEDMAN v EAST LOTHIAN COUNCIL [2026] EAT 142 24 September 2026 This appeal concerned whether a second Employment Tribunal (Decision 2) impermissibly recast an earlier finding that the respondent failed to make reasonable adjustments and whether the tribunal should have awarded loss reflecting a chance the claimant would have returned to work. The EAT refused the appeal, holding Decision 2 permissibly interpreted Decision 1 (including inferring the reasonable adjustment was a transfer within the East Lothian Works team between 12 October and 29 November 2016), that the duty to make the adjustment ceased once the claimant indicated she would not return, and that no financial loss flowed from the failure to make that adjustment. The EAT upheld the remedy of £15,250 plus £10,178 interest.
- MR R SHARMA v UNIVERSITY OF NOTTINGHAM [2026] EAT 145 24 September 2026 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in striking out the claimant’s employment claims without first determining his applications for reasonable adjustments after prolonged non-attendance. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the strike out, finding the judge had taken the claimant’s disabilities and medical evidence into account so far as the evidence permitted and that, given the claimant’s conduct, delay and prejudice to the respondent, strike out was a proportionate sanction. The appeal was dismissed.
- F v KING’S COLLEGE LONDON [2026] EAT 146 23 September 2026 This appeal concerned the employment tribunal's refusal to allow the claimant to amend his claim to plead breaches of section 47B ERA for protected disclosures and the tribunal's refusal to reconsider that decision. The EAT held the tribunal was entitled to refuse the amendment because the proposed amendment was insufficiently particularised about which facts were said to be protected disclosures and which were alleged detrimental treatment, and it was not obliged to invite clarification before deciding. The appeal was dismissed and the claimant's costs application regarding the respondent's bundle was refused.
- JK v LM [2026] EAT 144 21 September 2026 This appeal concerned claims of direct and indirect nationality/national‑origin discrimination after the claimant was refused security clearance and SVAP recommended maintaining the refusal on national security grounds. The Employment Tribunal refused to strike out the claims but made a deposit order concluding the claims had little reasonable prospect of success; both the claimant's appeal against the deposit order and the respondent's cross‑appeal against refusal to strike out were dismissed. The EAT held the Tribunal had properly assessed the s.192 national security defence, lawfully took SVAP's specialist findings into account without outsourcing its decision, and was entitled to conclude there was little prospect of success given the national security considerations and limited impact on the claimant.
- MRS MG HARKINS v MARKS AND SPENCER PLC [2026] EAT 131 21 September 2026 This appeal concerned claims by a visual‑merchandising manager with diagnosed mental health conditions that management comments and duties amounted to harassment, disability discrimination and failure to make reasonable adjustments. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the employment tribunal’s findings that the disputed comments and enquiries were not unwanted or not related to disability, that the 23 August enquiry was a proportionate management act, and that the employer lacked actual or constructive knowledge of a substantial disadvantage from shop‑floor duties; all grounds of appeal were dismissed.
- MR J KOFKIN v WARBURTONS LIMITED [2026] EAT 140 18 September 2026 The claimant appealed the Employment Tribunal's refusal to extend time for an out‑of‑time reasonable‑adjustment complaint arising from route changes after "Route Rationalisation." The tribunal found real forensic prejudice to the respondent from faded witness memories and gaps in contemporaneous records and refused the extension; HHJ Auerbach dismissed the appeal and upheld that decision. The claimant had succeeded on a separate discrimination complaint, but the late reasonable‑adjustment complaint was not allowed to proceed.
- Damien Burke v The Harrow Club [2026] EAT 141 17 September 2026 This is an appeal by a long‑serving youth worker, Damien Burke, against an Employment Tribunal finding that his summary dismissal was fair after an incident on 10 July 2023. The employer relied on a genuine belief that Burke breached safeguarding procedures, administered first aid without authorisation (by giving a tissue after a child lost a tooth), and was dishonest in his initial statement. The EAT rejected the appeal, upholding the Tribunal's conclusion that the employer genuinely held those beliefs and that dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses.
- Terence Hancox v Kenneth Sutherland & Ors [2026] EAT 139 17 September 2026 This is an EAT preliminary-hearing judgment in Hancox v Sutherland challenging an ET strike-out under rule 37; the EAT allowed one oral ground to proceed — that the ET erred by deciding the strike-out without giving fair notice and opportunity to respond — and dismissed the appellant's attempts to pursue additional grounds, to obtain disclosure, and to resile from his clear position at the hearing. The EAT gave detailed case-management directions for a full hearing, certified the disclosure application as totally without merit, and reprimanded extensive non‑compliant filings and use of generative AI without verification.
- Khans Solicitors v F Kaiser [2026] EAT 137 16 September 2026 This appeal concerned two remedial items in an Employment Tribunal award after findings of unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and sex-related harassment: (1) a £5,000 award for aggravated damages and (2) £672.56 awarded as the difference between statutory sick pay and full pay for part of a sickness absence. The EAT held the ET’s reasoning on both points legally deficient—finding the aggravated damages award lacked identification of additional aggravating factors and causation, and the SSP/full-pay differential lacked factual basis for entitlement and the four‑week period—and remitted those limited matters to the same Tribunal for redetermination. The remainder of the unappealed award stands subject to compliance/enforcement rules.
- NSL Ltd v Dean Bean [2026] EAT 132 15 September 2026 This appeal concerned the fairness of dismissal of a dyslexic civil enforcement officer accused of falsifying patrol records and related disability discrimination claims. The EAT upheld the Tribunal's conclusion that dismissal was unfair and that the employer failed to make reasonable adjustments, but allowed the employer's appeal in part by overturning the Tribunal's findings on indirect discrimination and harassment. The case was remitted for further disposal on remedies.
- John Grantham v Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole Council [2026] EAT 135 10 September 2026 This appeal concerned whether Employment Judge Cadney erred by failing to refer to a psychologist's letter diagnosing the claimant with autism when refusing reconsideration and striking out his unfair dismissal claim for repeated non‑compliance. The EAT held it was an error not to consider the letter, but the omission was immaterial because the letter did not explain the persistent defaults or identify practicable adjustments that would have enabled the case to proceed; the appeal was dismissed and the strike‑out and refusal to reconsider were upheld.
- Emmah Muchererah v Rushcliffe Independent Hospitals (Kegworth) Ltd [2026] EAT 134 9 September 2026 This appeal concerned a claimant dismissed after probation who alleged automatic unfair dismissal for protected disclosures, for raising health-and-safety/working-time complaints, and unlawful deduction from wages for unpaid overtime. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the employment tribunal’s core factual findings—that the two alleged protected disclosures were not made, that a health-and-safety concern was raised only once, that statutory working-time rights were not asserted, and that only one overtime timesheet was submitted and authorised—were not perverse. The EAT dismissed all grounds of appeal and upheld the tribunal’s decision.
- OLANREWAJU SANNI v REED SPECIALIST RECRUITMENT [2026] EAT 148 8 September 2026 This appeal concerned an application for an extension of time to file a Notice of Appeal to the EAT six days late after the claimant's employment tribunal claim was dismissed on withdrawal and a tribunal reconsideration was refused. HHJ Auerbach refused the extension, finding the primary cause of delay was the claimant's mistaken belief that the 42-day appeal period was suspended by the pending reconsideration, and that the claimant's medical and personal circumstances did not materially explain the delay on the evidence. The appeal was dismissed for want of punctuality.
- Jacqui McLean v Vallourec Oil & Gas UK Ltd [2026] EAT 133 7 September 2026 This appeal concerned a homeworker dismissed as redundant who alleged discrimination arising from disability (s.15 EqA) and unfair dismissal. The EAT held the Employment Tribunal erred in accepting the employer’s post‑dismissal belief about the claimant’s capability as discharging the s.15 burden, substituted a finding that the s.15 claim succeeded, and found the ET breached natural justice by deciding Polkey loss‑of‑chance issues at liability without notice, remitting Polkey to the quantum hearing before the same ET.
- Next Retail Limited & Anor v M Thandi and Ors [2026] EAT 130 7 September 2026 This EAT appeal concerned equal pay claims by retail sales consultants against warehouse operatives and whether Next's differing pay terms were justified under s.69 (material factor defence). The EAT upheld the ET’s finding of particular disadvantage from the statistics and other facts but allowed Next’s appeal in part, holding that the ET wrongly characterised Next’s legitimate aim (which included recruitment and retention benchmarking) and erred in parts of its proportionality analysis; the claimants’ cross‑appeal on direct discrimination was dismissed. The case was remitted for reconsideration of certain term‑specific proportionality issues and for further submissions on disposal.
- B Kristensen v Portman Healthcare Limited [2026] EAT 127 3 September 2026 This appeal concerned a dental hygienist dismissed after covert recordings, an allegation of forgery and a disciplinary process; the EAT found multiple legal errors in the Employment Tribunal’s treatment of the principal reason for dismissal and of protected-disclosure limitation/characterisation issues. The EAT held the Tribunal failed to identify a Meek‑compliant principal reason under s.98(1)(a), wrongly treated suspension as a one‑off act for s.48 limitation, and mischaracterised the scope of “the disciplinary investigation”; it substituted limited findings that suspension and the investigation were protected‑disclosure detriments, dismissed the wrongful dismissal claim, and remitted remaining issues for rehearing.
- M Jarosinski v Nestle UK Ltd [2026] EAT 129 28 August 2026 This appeal concerned whether Nestlé’s single consolidated ET3 response validly covered two consolidated claims and whether the Employment Tribunal was right to reduce both the basic and compensatory awards to nil (including a 100% Polkey reduction). The EAT held the single compendious response was permissible under the case management order and Rules 16–17, that the claimant had waived/estopped any objection by not raising it timely, and that there was no error in the ET’s factual or legal reasoning for applying 100% contributory-fault and 100% Polkey reductions. The permitted grounds of appeal were dismissed and the ET’s decision (no basic or compensatory award payable) was upheld.
- Paramjeet Singh Bhogal v National Education Union [2026] EAT 124 26 August 2026 This appeal concerns a union member's challenge to the Certification Officer's summary strike‑out of his complaint that National Officers lacked power under amended 2023 union rules to bring or suspend disciplinary proceedings. The EAT held the Certification Officer erred in law: the rule wording was ambiguous and the materials before her did not show the appellant's interpretation had no reasonable prospect of success, so the strike‑out was set aside and the original application remains live. The appellant's separate victimisation/discrimination arguments, raised anew on appeal, were dismissed as unrelated.
- MR HADI KHANAFER v SINGLE HOMELESS PROJECT [2026] EAT 138 20 August 2026 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal’s decision to reduce an unfair dismissal award to nil after finding the claimant had secretly taken full‑time work with Centrepoint while on special paid leave and was dismissed on 21 June 2022. The EAT held the tribunal erred in re‑characterising the reason for dismissal contrary to the employer’s concession and in failing to apply the correct causation and assessment steps for contributory fault, quashed the judgment and remitted the case for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal.
- Patrick Henry McAuley v Ethigen Ltd [2026] EAT 126 20 August 2026 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's strike‑out under rule 37(1)(b) of the claimant's detriment complaint (AWR reg 17(2)) after prolonged, intemperate correspondence by the claimant. The EAT held the ET lawfully considered correspondence authored by the claimant as part of his conduct of the proceedings and that he was given a reasonable opportunity to address the material, so no error of law was shown. The appeal was dismissed and the strike‑out upheld.
- Brandon Duffy v BXTR 3 Ltd T/A House of Gods [2026] EAT 119 10 August 2026 This appeal concerned a tribunal’s refusal of interim relief under ss.128–129 ERA after a claimant alleged a protected disclosure and summary dismissal. The EAT found the tribunal erred by treating mere factual disputes as determinative of the “pretty good chance” threshold and by failing to address a contemporaneous voice recording before it. The appeal was allowed and the matter remitted for the tribunal to make a proper summary assessment and give adequate reasons.
- A Bindi v Metropolitan Thames Valley [2026] EAT 136 6 August 2026 This is an application to extend time for an Employment Appeal Tribunal appeal that arrived two to three minutes late. The EAT refused the extension because the proposed appeal was effectively academic — the original tribunal order had been superseded by a fresh decision and the claimant’s substantive claims were later dismissed and unsuccessfully appealed — so extension was denied. The short delay and the claimant’s explanation were insufficient to outweigh the academic nature of the appeal.
- J Edward v North London NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 116 5 August 2026 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal could make a consent order reflecting terms earlier agreed when the claimant had subsequently revoked his consent and had told the tribunal he no longer agreed. The EAT held the October 2024 order was wrongly made because the tribunal proceeded to treat the order as “by consent” despite being informed the claimant opposed it; the EAT quashed that order and remitted the previously remitted remedy issues to the tribunal. The court also said that the mere fact a full‑and‑final settlement term would be unenforceable under section 144 Equality Act 2010 does not automatically prevent the tribunal from making a consent disposal under the rule.
- C Merriman v 1st Staff Limited & Ors [2026] EAT 128 4 August 2026 This Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed an appeal by Ms Merriman against a tribunal decision that had struck out her failure-to-make-reasonable-adjustments claims against four individual respondents. The EAT held the tribunal was wrong in law to rule that such claims cannot be brought against individuals and ordered the four respondents rejoined so particulars can be clarified and the claim returned to the tribunal. The matter will proceed to further case management and particularisation against those individuals.
- Fieldfisher LLP v Djamshid Rustambekov [2026] EAT 99 4 August 2026 This appeal concerned Fieldfisher's summary dismissal of a senior associate, Mr Rustambekov, for alleged sexual harassment and inappropriate conduct. The Employment Tribunal found the dismissal unfair, but the EAT held the Tribunal had unlawfully substituted its own view of witness credibility and evidence for the employer's in assessing whether the employer reasonably believed misconduct occurred, and set aside the Tribunal's judgment, remitting the case to a differently constituted Tribunal. The EAT found the Tribunal had also misapplied reasoning from MA (Somalia) to a Burchell s.98(4) assessment. Procedural and disclosure criticisms were recognised but the EAT concluded the identified errors materially affected the unfair dismissal finding.
- Johnson and Johnson Medical Limited v Tolulope Fayokun [2026] EAT 118 4 August 2026 The EAT dismissed the employer's appeal against findings of direct race discrimination: the Employment Tribunal's factual findings that a manager used a Nigerian profiling document to manage the claimant and attributed "Nigerian traits" to her were not perverse and were adequately reasoned, so no comparator needed to be constructed. The EAT allowed the employer's appeal against the Tribunal's extension of time, holding the Tribunal had failed to consider the extent of, and reasons for, the claimant's delay; that issue is remitted to the same Tribunal for reconsideration and both parties may adduce fresh evidence.
- University of Bristol v Dr David Miller [2026] EAT 84 4 August 2026 This appeal concerned Dr David Miller's summary dismissal by the University of Bristol for comments and tweets said to manifest anti‑Zionist beliefs. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal's findings that those pleaded beliefs satisfied the Grainger criteria as protected philosophical beliefs and that dismissal (and the appeal rejection) was directly discriminatory, unfair and wrongful, but allowed in part the employer's challenge to a 30% Polkey/Abbey National deduction. The EAT set aside paragraph 9 of the ET's remedy reasoning about the 30% chance the claimant would have been lawfully dismissed by October 2023 and remitted that issue for redetermination; other findings and a 50% contributory‑fault reduction remain intact.
- AB v GH Limited [2026] EAT 115 30 July 2026 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's dismissal of claims of sexual harassment, victimisation and constructive dismissal arising from workplace interactions at a Christmas party and later events. The EAT upheld the ET, finding the ET had properly considered consent and capacity (including intoxication) when applying the statutory test of whether conduct was "unwanted", and had lawfully refused to extend time for out‑of‑time complaints. The appeal was dismissed and anonymity orders remained in place.
- K Badham v Jaguar Land Rover Ltd [2026] EAT 94 29 July 2026 This appeal concerned a late application to amend Grounds of Appeal to adopt EAT Rule 3(7) observations and whether issue estoppel arising from a later Employment Tribunal (the Platt Tribunal) precluded the claimant's discrimination claim about refusal to fund CBT. The EAT exceptionally permitted the amendment but dismissed the appeal because the Platt Tribunal had necessarily found the decision to stop CBT funding was for reasons wholly unrelated to the claimant's health, creating issue estoppel; alternatively, the EAT upheld the original tribunal's finding that the claimant did not have a mental‑health disability on 7 March 2022.
- Gary Jeffery v Givaudan UK Ltd [2026] EAT 114 28 July 2026 This case concerns whether a valid request for written reasons under Employment Tribunals Rules 2013 rule 62 is extinguished by a subsequent settlement recorded by COT3. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the employment judge erred in refusing to provide written reasons after the claimant had timely requested them; settlement did not nullify that entitlement and the claimant's later notification was not a withdrawal. The EAT allowed the appeal and ordered the tribunal to provide written reasons for the remedy decision.
- Peter J Jackson v The Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police [2026] EAT 112 27 July 2026 This appeal by PC Jackson against findings by the Employment Tribunal in his whistleblowing and constructive dismissal claims was dismissed. The EAT held there was no procedural unfairness or legal error in the Tribunal's decision to treat closely related omitted passages from the original disclosure documents as part of the information disclosed, nor in its factual assessments on reasonable belief, delay, credibility, aggregation or the application of s.43F(1)(b)(ii). A late proposed amendment to narrow the statutory test was refused, and the Tribunal's conclusions (including on constructive dismissal) were upheld.
- Russell Cherrington v University of Derby [2026] EAT 107 27 July 2026 This is an appeal by a dismissed senior lecturer challenging an Employment Tribunal's finding that his summary dismissal for misconduct fell within the band of reasonable responses. The EAT held the Tribunal did not err in failing to raise Article 10 ECHR of its own motion, refused permission to raise Article 10 for the first time on appeal, and found any omission to refer to section 43(1) Education Act 1986 made no difference. The appeal was dismissed.
- Ray Joseph v The University of Aberdeen [2026] EAT 113 24 July 2026 This appeal concerned (1) whether the Employment Tribunal (ET) was right to strike out the claimant's whole discrimination claim after the respondent admitted one email had been deliberately altered, and (2) whether the ET erred in refusing to join the Lawn Tennis Association (LTA) as a respondent. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) upheld the concession that the ET erred in striking out the direct discrimination claim insofar as it related to circumstances in which any job offer was retracted or allowed to lapse and remitted that limited issue to the ET; the EAT refused the challenge to the ET's refusal to join the LTA.
- Dr Beena Kumari v Leicestershire Partnership NHS Trust [2026] EAT 111 23 July 2026 This appeal concerned Dr Beena Kumari’s challenge to the refusal to recuse a three‑member tribunal (judge plus two lay members) and to exclude a prior judgment in the linked Benaris proceedings that contained trenchant findings about two expert reports common to both cases. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding that the fair‑minded and informed observer would not perceive a real possibility of bias from the Benaris findings, that there was jurisdiction to exclude the earlier judgment if necessary but exclusion was not required, and that deciding the recusal application on paper with the reasons given was lawful.
- Z Pekacar v London Borough of Islington & Ors [2026] EAT 125 23 July 2026 This appeal concerned whether an employment judge wrongly excluded three allegations from the claimant's lists of issues at a preliminary hearing. The EAT allowed only one contested allegation (a threat to redeploy the claimant unless she worked five days in the office) to be added to the list of issues, and dismissed challenges to include the other two allegations (reporting to the ICO; failure to protect/retrieve personal documents). The EAT also concluded the employment judge's general approach to drafting the list of issues was not legally flawed.
- Lavinia Day v East and North Hertfordshire NHS Trust [2026] EAT 110 22 July 2026 This appeal concerned an ET costs order of £14,123.39 against a claimant who brought a hopeless companion‑rights claim. The EAT held the ET was entitled to order costs for the claimant’s unreasonable conduct but erred in (a) treating household/third‑party income as the claimant’s own ability to pay without analysing what part of that income was hers and (b) failing to carry out any summary assessment of the respondent’s claimed costs; those issues were remitted to a fresh tribunal.
- Leonardo Wolfe v Taka Mayfair Limited [2026] EAT 106 22 July 2026 This appeal concerned whether s10(1)(b) Employment Relations Act 1999 requires a worker actually to (reasonably) request to be accompanied before the statutory right to be accompanied arises, where the worker did not know the meeting’s purpose. The EAT held that s10(1)(b) unambiguously requires such a request; on the claimant’s pleaded case that no request was made, the tribunal correctly refused to allow an amendment adding a s10 complaint and the appeal was dismissed. The court also rejected the argument that the ACAS Code or other materials could displace the clear statutory requirement.
- Washington Waithaka v Barclays Execution Services Limited [2026] EAT 105 17 July 2026 This appeal concerned an ET decision striking out pre‑termination parts of Mr Waithaka’s race, victimisation and harassment claim as out of time and refusing an extension of time, and the ET’s 15‑month delay in issuing written reasons. The EAT rejected the Article 6/delay ground but allowed the appeal against strike‑out, holding a tribunal properly directing itself could not have concluded the claimant’s continuing‑act case had no reasonable prospect; the whole claim was remitted for a merits hearing. The EAT noted the extension‑of‑time point was academic but, if decided, would have been dismissed as within the ET’s discretion.
- E Saleh v Singletrack Systems Ltd [2026] EAT 104 16 July 2026 Mr Saleh appealed the Employment Judge’s dismissal of his constructive dismissal claim after resigning in July 2021, challenging refusals to order further disclosure of drafts/emails, to require unredacted Slack messages, and to consider complaints cumulatively. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, finding the Employment Judge’s case-management decisions were not perverse and that, on the facts found, there was no breach of the implied term of mutual trust and confidence.
- London North Eastern Railway Limited & Anor v Nimu Jiwanji & Ors [2026] EAT 102 16 July 2026 This appeal concerned whether a November 2017 workforce communication offering a pay award breached s.145 TULRCA by seeking to achieve a prohibited result (ending collective bargaining) under an unstructured collective bargaining agreement. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the employer's appeal, upholding the Tribunal's findings that collective bargaining had not been exhausted, that the employer had decided to stop using the agreed bargaining arrangements and impose terms, and that both the prohibited result and prohibited purpose under s.145 were therefore established. Awards to affected employees were upheld.
- M Shah v Home Office [2026] EAT 103 13 July 2026 This appeal concerned whether a Home Office disciplinary investigation and subsequent treatment of a claimant with depression amounted to disability discrimination under s.15 EA 2010 and whether the claimant's ticking of a disability box on a Guaranteed Interview Scheme (GIS) form amounted to a protected act for victimisation under s.27. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the ET erred in law by treating the employer's suspicion of dishonesty as excluding a causal link with the claimant's disability, substituted a finding that the investigation was something arising in consequence of the disability, and remitted questions of justification, whether ticking the GIS box was a protected act, and causation for victimisation back to the ET. The EAT dismissed the challenge that the ET’s finding on who commissioned the investigation was perverse.
- Chunxiu Zhao v Govia Thameslink Railway (GTR) Limited [2026] EAT 101 10 July 2026 This is the EAT’s dismissal of Ms Zhao’s appeal against an employment tribunal finding that her summary dismissal for misconduct (an HR email suggesting a colleague of Indian origin would form a “clique”) was fair. The EAT held that the tribunal reasonably found the operative reason for dismissal was the Rudman email, that managers were entitled to treat it as discriminatory, and that the investigatory and disciplinary process taken as a whole fell within the band of reasonable responses. The appeal grounds alleging procedural unfairness and mischaracterisation of motive were rejected and the tribunal’s decision was upheld.
- L Furbacher v London Borough of Barking and Dagenham Council [2026] EAT 117 9 July 2026 The claimant sought to amend an unfair dismissal claim to add termination of agency engagement; the Employment Judge refused, in part because the claimant had solicitors when the claim was presented and treated the change as a major new factual basis. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the judge mischaracterised the amendment (it was effectively a rebadging closely aligned with pleaded facts) and that refusing it for prejudice reasons was perverse given the early stage and overlapping evidence, so the EAT allowed the amendment.
- Patricia Kirkland v Caroline Mason t/a Hawthorn Education Services [2026] EAT 108 9 July 2026 This appeal concerned remedy awards after a finding of unfair dismissal: the Claimant challenged the ET's compensatory award (the mitigation finding) and a preparation time order (PTO). The EAT held the ET erred in law by misapplying the burden of proof on mitigation (failing to require the Respondent to prove the Claimant acted unreasonably in not mitigating) and by fixing a PTO as a bare sum without deciding and recording the number of hours as required by the Rules. The EAT set aside the compensatory award and the PTO and remitted those matters to a different Employment Judge for redetermination.
- SBH Windermere Ltd & Anor v S Nunns [2026] EAT 121 7 July 2026 This appeal concerned a tribunal’s reconsideration increasing compensation after the respondent said receipt of the award would put him above the Universal Credit £16,000 savings cap and reduce his benefits. The EAT held the tribunal was entitled to reopen the award but erred in not considering whether the respondent could have mitigated his loss by claiming New Style Jobseeker’s Allowance or New Style Employment and Support Allowance. The case was remitted to the same Employment Tribunal for a short rehearing limited to that mitigation issue. No wider rehearing was permitted.
- C M Day v Health Education England [2026] EAT 97 2 July 2026 Dr Day sought a wasted costs order (WACO) against HEE’s solicitors, Hill Dickinson, for failing to disclose certain Learning and Development Agreements (LDAs). The Employment Tribunal held, and the EAT upheld on appeal, that settlement agreements precluded the WACO and in any event HD’s non‑disclosure did not meet the high Rule 80 threshold because the materially same terms were already disclosed in the Gold Guide and no causative wasted costs were shown. The appeal was dismissed.
- M Mostafa v K Julier & Anor [2026] EAT 122 1 July 2026 This is a renewed permission-to-appeal application against a March 2025 Employment Tribunal decision dismissing race and religion discrimination claims, brought after the Employment Judge proceeded with a judge sitting alone because no non-legal members had been booked. The renewed application argued error in panel composition, lack of informed consent, inequality of arms, reliance on an unclear precedent, and failure to scrutinise evidence. The judge concluded there was no arguable error of law: the change in panel composition was a lawful case-management response to materially changed circumstances, the appellant had been asked and indicated willingness to proceed, the evidential complaint was unparticularised, and the cited authority could not be located. Permission to appeal was refused and no rehearing ordered.
- M Young v Royal Mail Group Limited [2026] EAT 93 29 June 2026 This appeal concerned whether posts Mr Young made in a CWU WhatsApp group during industrial action constituted participation in trade union activities under s.152 TULR(C)A 1992 and whether his dismissal for gross misconduct was therefore unlawful. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the Employment Tribunal applied the correct evaluative, fact‑sensitive approach and was entitled to find the posts separable from protected union activity and that dismissal was for misconduct. No legal error or identifiable flaw in the ET’s reasoning was found.
- Stephen Leighton v Renfrewshire Council [2026] EAT 95 26 June 2026 Leighton, an Autism Connections team leader, assisted a disabled tenant outside his normal duties and was later transferred to alternative duties after a complaint by the tenant's psychologist; the ET found the assistance was not a protected act under s 27(1)(c) Equality Act 2010 and that the transfer resulted from the subsequent complaint. The EAT held the ET erred in analysing whether the assistance was a protected act because it had not engaged with the specific factual basis relied on, but it found no error in the ET's causation finding that the transfer was motivated by the later complaint and separable from the assistance. The appeal was dismissed.
- G Laffy v Wkcic Group T/A Capital City College Group & Anor [2026] EAT 90 19 June 2026 This is an appeal by Mr Laffy against a Tribunal's dismissal of his direct discrimination claims (race, sex, age) against his employer arising from a breakdown with a colleague and four pleaded acts of alleged less favourable treatment. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the Tribunal's findings that the College had investigated many complaints, that a serious allegation by the colleague was withdrawn, and that there was no uncontested evidence amounting to a prima facie case of discrimination. The EAT found the Tribunal correctly applied the burden‑shifting framework and accepted the College's non‑discriminatory explanation (the complainant declined to pursue), so the appeal was dismissed.
- MR MATHIOS BERHANE v MR ADEBOWALE OLUJIMI [2026] EAT 109 18 June 2026 This EAT appeal challenged an ET preliminary decision that treated the claimant's effective date of termination as 30 April 2022, struck out several time‑barred claims, and allowed direct discrimination claims to proceed. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the ET did not err in relying on the finalised list of issues and in finding no mutuality of obligation after 1 May 2022, so the claimant lacked employee status for notice pay at 19 July 2022. Discrimination claims remain to proceed.
- Claire Jeffcoat v Hudson Business Centres Ltd [2026] EAT 91 16 June 2026 This appeal concerned whether a claimant's ET1 paper apart pleaded a claim of direct disability discrimination (s.13 EqA) as well as discrimination arising from disability (s.15). The EAT held that, read fairly and in context, paragraph F of the ET1 was capable of alleging a s.13 claim and the employment tribunal erred in refusing to treat it as such or to relabel it. The EAT substituted its own finding that the s.13 claim was pleaded, concluded no formal amendment was required, and remitted the case to the tribunal for further case management.
- Marguerite Andrea Cunningham v BBC [2026] EAT 92 16 June 2026 This appeal concerns a BBC announcer's claims under the Equality Act for discrimination arising from disability and failure to make reasonable adjustments after she disclosed Type 2 diabetes and fatigue and made a broadcast error on 7 June 2023. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the ET erred in law by finding the BBC did not and could not reasonably have known of the claimant's disability; that defence is rejected. The EAT also held the ET failed to consider whether removing the claimant from the Scotland Late shift (and giving greater shift stability) was a reasonable adjustment and remitted that issue for reconsideration; the EAT rejected the challenge that the ET's causation finding was perverse.
- S Stephens v The Health and Safety Executive [2026] EAT 88 16 June 2026 This is an EAT rehearing of four applications to extend time for appeals against ET decisions and the subsequent dismissal after the claimant withdrew her claim and concluded an ACAS COT3. The judge held the claimant did not show “exceptional circumstances” to justify extension: medical evidence did not establish incapacity at the relevant times, litigant-in-person status did not excuse delay, and the proposed appeals were weak or academic given the apparently binding COT3. All extensions were refused and the out-of-time appeals dismissed.
- XX v YY [2026] EAT 89 15 June 2026 This appeal concerned whether an employee's assertion that she acted under duress was relevant to the objective question of whether her conduct amounted to gross misconduct/repudiatory breach justifying summary dismissal. The EAT held the ET erred in treating duress as irrelevant and remitted the wrongful dismissal claim to the same tribunal to reconsider whether, in all the circumstances (including the accepted duress), the conduct so undermined trust and confidence as to justify dismissal. Most factual findings below were left undisturbed.
- Nicola Griffiths v Essex County Council [2026] EAT 86 12 June 2026 This appeal concerned remedies after findings that an employer's failure to permit the claimant to participate in an investigation was an indirect disability discrimination detriment and that cumulative breaches led to constructive unfair dismissal. The EAT dismissed the employer's cross-appeal that loss of earnings could not be attributed to the discriminatory detriment but allowed the claimant's appeal on valuation errors, finding the Tribunal had erred in awarding no future loss and in its approach to pension loss. The EAT remitted assessment of future loss of earnings and pension loss to the same Employment Tribunal for reassessment in accordance with its factual findings.
- Costco Wholesale UK Limited v Jaiden Nash [2026] EAT 85 11 June 2026 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in refusing the respondent an extension of time to file a defence to claims of race discrimination and harassment. The ET found the respondent had received and ignored correspondence and that the General Manager had deleted emails; it refused the late Rule 20 response after assessing explanation for delay, prejudice and merits. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the ET had properly applied the relevant principles and had not erred in law.
- Donna Harding v St George’s University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 100 10 June 2026 This EAT judgment concerns Ms Harding's late application to amend her Notice of Appeal to add a new ground challenging the Employment Tribunal's refusal to extend time for two reasonable adjustment claims. The EAT refused the very late amendment because it introduced a qualitatively different ground, was made without adequate explanation and would prejudice the respondent, and held that, with the amendment refused, the remainder of the appeal was academic and was dismissed.
- Zhuming Xu v Christian Action Research and Education & Ors [2026] EAT 98 10 June 2026 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal decision dismissing Ms Xu’s appeal against the Employment Tribunal’s refusal to revoke a settlement judgment or to award wasted costs. The EAT held that a late argument about the correct interpretation of the claimant’s conditional fee agreement (whether a 60% uplift would have been payable) was a new point not raised below and, even if considered, would not have changed the ET’s conclusion that there was no economic duress or solicitor/counsel impropriety. The ET’s findings that the solicitor and counsel did not act improperly were therefore upheld and no wasted costs order was made.
- C Di Fiore & Anor v Introhive UK Limited [2026] EAT 82 9 June 2026 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's refusal, on the fourth day of a nine-day hearing, to make a witness order compelling Mr Faisal Abassi after the claimants produced only topic headings and no draft statement. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the Tribunal was entitled to refuse the late application and was not required to assess the qualitative significance of evidence where no substantive content was provided. The EAT also found no perverse or unlawful exercise of discretion given timing, prejudice to the hearing timetable, and the claimants' procedural failures.
- London Borough of Ealing and Ors v Pauline Peace [2026] EAT 81 8 June 2026 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal erred by treating a worked-up "list of issues" at a case-management hearing as effectively amending the pleaded claim without applying the required balancing exercise. The EAT held the tribunal’s analysis was legally inadequate for failing to apply the Selkent-style balancing (injustice/hardship) to each contested matter and remitted the issue for rehearing by a different judge, with directions for the claimant to focus and justify any contested amendments.
- P Holmes v Kirklees Council [2026] EAT 80 2 June 2026 The claimant, a UNISON branch secretary, appealed the Employment Tribunal's dismissal of claims of unfair dismissal (including automatic unfair dismissal for trade union activities) and trade union detriment after being dismissed for threatening conduct and a pattern of bullying. The EAT rejected grounds that the Tribunal erred in law, was perversely silent on historical allegations, or that HR manipulation by Mrs Lucas vitiated the dismissal, finding the decision‑maker made an independent, reasonable decision that the principal reason for dismissal was conduct separable from protected union activity. The appeal was dismissed.
- P Chandrashekarappa v Wipro Ltd [2026] EAT 73 1 June 2026 This appeal concerned whether the claimant had acquired a legal entitlement to a "kitty bonus" of up to 1% of first‑year new‑logo invoicing for the JLP deal. The EAT held that when the Sector Lead approved 1% on 1 July 2020 in accordance with the March 2020 scheme parameters, the claimant's entitlement crystallised and the employer could not thereafter impose additional approval conditions or belatedly apply a $150,000 cap; the EAT substituted a finding that the claimant is entitled to 1% of JLP year‑one revenue less the sterling equivalent of the $150,000 already paid.
- H Rogers v Secretary of State for Justice [2026] EAT 78 29 May 2026 This appeal concerned a Registrar's refusal to extend time after a solicitor uploaded a covering letter instead of the reserved judgment and reasons, making the appeal institution 17 days late. The judge held the omission was not a "minor error" under rule 37(5) because the judgment and reasons are core documents, but nonetheless exercised discretion under rule 37(1) to grant an extension because the Notice of Appeal and compliant grounds had been lodged in time, the mistake was genuine and promptly corrected, and the balance of justice favoured extension. The appeal was allowed to proceed to sift in the usual way.
- London Ambulance Service NHS Trust v Ricky Garrett [2026] EAT 77 29 May 2026 This EAT appeal quashes a tribunal majority's findings that three disciplinary/investigatory acts amounted to direct discrimination because they were manifestations of the claimant's protected belief and quashes an overlapping finding of direct race discrimination. The EAT held the tribunal was wrong to treat the claimant's descriptive "no‑systemic‑racism" view as a manifestation of his normative "treatment belief" and failed to engage properly with non‑discriminatory explanations; the EAT substituted dismissals of those complaints and quashed the injury to feelings award.
- DHL Services Limited v Pawel Ignatowicz [2026] EAT 74 22 May 2026 This EAT appeal remitted parts of an ET decision that had found unfair dismissal for Facebook posts, reduced compensation by 10% for contributory fault and ordered reinstatement. The EAT held the ET erred in its analysis of contributory conduct (failing to consider all relevant posts and post‑dismissal/appeal‑stage conduct where relevant) and in framing the reinstatement question (failing to assess whether the employer genuinely and rationally believed trust and confidence were irretrievable). Both contribution and reinstatement issues were sent back to the ET for redetermination, with freedom of expression to be considered on remittal.
- Noel Deans v RBL Law Ltd (in liquidation) & Ors [2026] EAT 76 22 May 2026 This Preliminary Hearing considered whether the claimant could substitute wholly redrafted grounds of appeal and whether any amended grounds disclosed arguable errors of law. The judge accepted the explanation for the late amendment but found the substituted grounds non-compliant with Practice Direction requirements, and on merits concluded none of the proposed amended grounds raised arguable errors of law. Permission to amend to add a late harassment/time-extension ground was refused and the appeal was dismissed.
- E Komeng v National Highways Limited [2026] EAT 75 20 May 2026 This appeal concerned a fixed-term employee who alleged less favourable treatment after not being informed of an HRBP training course that permanent colleagues attended, and a related constructive unfair dismissal claim. The EAT held that, as a matter of law, denial of an opportunity to receive training under reg.3(2) of the Fixed-term Employees Regulations 2002 is treated as less favourable treatment under reg.3(1) without a separate detriment finding, but on the facts the employer’s reliance on cost and the employee’s anticipated departure made the treatment objectively justified and the tribunal was entitled to refuse an extension of time; the constructive unfair dismissal claim also failed. The tribunal’s legal error (importing a discrete detriment requirement) did not change the outcome and the appeal was dismissed.
- H Amin v Manchester Airport Group Plc & Anor [2026] EAT 63 19 May 2026 This appeal to the EAT challenged an Employment Tribunal's decision to strike out the claimant's claims for non-payment of ordered deposits, to refuse a postponement of a preliminary hearing, and to refuse relief from sanctions. The EAT dismissed the appeal, finding no error of law in treating the claims as struck out given lack of payment and the claimant's failure to attend or produce ordered originals, and no appearance of bias by the Employment Judge. The refusal of relief from sanctions was upheld because there was effectively no substantive application or evidential basis for relief once postponement was refused.
- The Government of the State of Kuwait v Dr Lyazid Fenniche [2026] EAT 83 19 May 2026 This appeal concerned extensions of time to appeal two state‑immunity judgments concerning whether the personal injury exception in s.5 of the State Immunity Act 1978 is qualified by ss.4 and 16 in respect of embassy employment and whether "personal injury" includes psychiatric injury. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed both appeals against the Registrar’s refusals, extended time to 12 March 2024 and sifted the appeals for a full hearing as raising arguable points of law. The EAT did not stay the appeals pending other proceedings but noted related higher‑court authorities bearing on the issues.
- Car Sales Solutions Limited v V Riekstins [2026] EAT 72 18 May 2026 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's refusal to reconsider a judgment that had found Car Sales Solutions Ltd to be the employer and awarded sums in default. The EAT held the Tribunal had failed to follow the mandatory stages when deciding the reconsideration application and had given inadequate reasons. The EAT allowed the appeal, remitted the reconsideration application to the Employment Tribunal to be determined by a different Employment Judge, and stayed the substantive appeal pending that reconsideration.
- G Leedham v Royal Mail Group Limited [2026] EAT 87 14 May 2026 This appeal concerned whether an employer satisfies the statutory duty to "give" an worker an itemised pay statement by providing electronic access rather than a paper document. The EAT held that "given" can be construed purposively to include electronic or constructive provision where the information is made available in a form the worker can in practice access and without material coercion or burden. On the facts (employee had a smartphone, no medical or practical impediment found, and no pleaded privacy claim), the tribunal was upheld and the appeal dismissed.
- Clifton Diocese v Janet Parker [2026] EAT 68 12 May 2026 This appeal concerned a non‑Catholic senior finance employee dismissed by the Clifton Diocese after an investigatory and disciplinary process; the Employment Tribunal had found the dismissal unfair and had also held certain investigative and disciplinary acts amounted to direct religion or belief discrimination and harassment. The EAT held the Tribunal erred in its application of the burden of proof under s136 Equality Act 2010 by using a blanket approach and relying improperly on lack of explanation at stage one, and remitted the discrimination (and, if appropriate, harassment) complaints for redetermination. The EAT left intact the Tribunal's findings of unfair and wrongful dismissal.
- Michele Robinson v Michael Harris & Ors [2026] EAT 71 12 May 2026 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal misapplied the Equality Act 2010 in claims brought by a self‑employed barrister who alleged discrimination, harassment and victimisation after a dispute over a returned fee and internal grievance process. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding that s.47 EqA is a jurisdictional gateway extending protection to self‑employed barristers but does not change the substantive tests in ss.13, 26 and 27, and that a stray quotation of s.39 in the Tribunal’s directions was harmless and did not vitiate its reasons. The Tribunal’s unanimous factual findings that there was no unlawful treatment were upheld.
- R Tedd v Surrey County Council [2026] EAT 66 12 May 2026 This appeal concerned the Employment Appeal Tribunal's review of an Employment Tribunal's strike‑out under rule 37(1)(d) for a claim said not to be actively pursued after the claimant deliberately misled the tribunal about medical reasons for non‑compliance with directions. The EAT found the ET had addressed both the threshold and discretionary stages in substance, took into account the overriding objective and proportionality, and was entitled to give little or no weight to very late partial compliance. The EAT dismissed the appeal and upheld strike‑out of the whole claim as an appropriate sanction in the exceptional circumstances.
- M G Harkins v Marks & Spencer PLC [2026] EAT 70 7 May 2026 This case concerns the proper role of respondents at Rule 3(10) sift hearings following permission refusals under Rule 3(7). The Employment Appeal Tribunal held that Rule 3(10) hearings are short, appellant-focused hearings in which respondents will not ordinarily be permitted to make submissions, save in very limited circumstances where a respondent can plainly and briefly demonstrate that a ground is unarguable. In the present case the respondent’s skeleton led to withdrawal of one ground but the judge declined further respondent participation and allowed other grounds to proceed.
- Jack Truman v SPL Powerlines UK Limited & Ors [2026] EAT 54 1 May 2026 This appeal concerns Mr Truman, who failed a rail industry drugs & alcohol test after disclosing prescribed medical cannabis and lost a conditional job offer when a testing provider recorded a "FAIL" on his Sentinel record. The EAT held Network Rail is a "qualifications body" and the Sentinel D&A pass requirement is a competence standard, dismissed the competence‑standard appeal, allowed Mr Truman's s.20 disability‑disadvantage appeal against Network Rail (remitting specific issues for rehearing) but not against Powerlines, and allowed Express Medicals' cross‑appeal on s.111(7) so it was not liable under ss.111/112 on that basis.
- A Ndow v University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 64 30 April 2026 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal erred in refusing to extend time for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims where the claimant had pursued an internal appeal that was later refused. The EAT held the Tribunal did not err: the claimant had not relied on the internal appeal below as causing delay nor pleaded that its refusal was a discriminatory act forming part of a course of conduct, and the Tribunal lawfully exercised its discretion to refuse an extension. The appeal was dismissed and the time‑barred claims upheld as out of time.
- H Lau v Dragon Cat Ltd t/a Dragon Cat Cafe & Ors [2026] EAT 65 30 April 2026 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Appeal Tribunal should apply the same strict approach to extensions of time for serving a Respondent's Answer as it does to time for instituting an appeal. The EAT held that stricter rules for institution of appeals do not automatically apply to lodging/delivering an Answer and, applying ordinary discretionary principles (length of delay, prejudice, overriding objective), granted a short, excusable 16-day extension to serve the Answer and refused the appeal from the Registrar's Order.
- Z Chowdhury v Secretary of State for Health and Social Care [2026] EAT 69 30 April 2026 The EAT allowed an appeal from the Registrar’s refusal to extend time for filing a notice of appeal where oral case management orders were made at a postponed ET hearing and a written record was not sent promptly; the claimant filed a revised Notice of Appeal deemed received 2 October 2024 and the Registrar had treated it as nine days late. The judge applied Rule 39 to permit the appeal to proceed (and said that, alternatively, an extension would have been granted if the tribunal’s later "Reasons for Case Management Orders" were treated as the written record). The appeal will proceed to be sifted.
- L Tarbuc v Martello Piling Limited [2026] EAT 58 28 April 2026 This appeal concerned whether a meeting treated as a s.111A "protected conversation" was rightly excluded from evidence across all of the claimant's claims and whether the ET should have identified an automatic unfair dismissal claim of its own motion or considered cumulative circumstances (ambush, lack of companion, timing) when assessing impropriety. The EAT held that s.111A protection was wrongly applied to the claimant's unlawful deduction and part-time worker claims (those documents must be disclosed), upheld the ET's refusal to raise an automatic unfair dismissal claim of its own motion, and found the ET erred in law by failing to assess cumulative circumstances and the ACAS Code when deciding whether conduct was improper; the case was remitted.
- Darron Foat v Department of Work and Pensions [2026] EAT 61 23 April 2026 This appeal concerns remedies after findings of disability‑related harassment and constructive dismissal; the Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the claimant's challenges to reductions for ACAS uplift, deduction of PIP, a 50% contingency discount on the future‑loss multiplier, and omission of an unpleaded small bonus, but allowed the respondent's cross‑appeal correcting an error in using a gross multiplicand for future loss. The EAT substituted a lower future‑loss figure and reduced the total award from £373,936.69 to £334,933.73.
- Isaac Bickley v John Lewis Plc [2026] EAT 59 22 April 2026 This appeal by consent concerned rejection of an ET1 because the name on the form did not match the EC certificate after the claimant changed his name by deed poll. The EAT held the Legal Officer erred by not considering whether the discrepancy was an "error in relation to a name" under Rule 12(2A) and substituted a decision treating the claim as validly presented on 9 July 2024. The tribunal also noted, alternatively, that Rule 6 could properly have been used to treat the name requirement as satisfied.
- MASTER TRADE NETWORK LTD v BASHIR AHMED [2026] EAT 143 22 April 2026
- QRS v London Borough of Tower Hamlets & Ors [2026] EAT 60 22 April 2026 The EAT refused an extension of time for the claimant to request a rule 3(10) hearing after a rule 3(7) sift letter was emailed to her, concluding she had no good excuse for missing the 28‑day deadline and that the underlying appeal was academic and had no realistic prospect of success. The appellant’s medical and therapy records showed genuine illness but did not demonstrate that her conditions materially caused her failure to act within time. The Registrar’s refusal to extend time was therefore upheld and the appeal dismissed.
- A Ikeji v Westminster City Council & Anor [2026] EAT 62 21 April 2026 This appeal concerns a victimisation claim under s.27 EqA where a conditional job offer was withdrawn after the employer discovered discrepancies about the claimant’s asserted continuing employment with ORR. The Employment Tribunal found the claimant knowingly misrepresented that he remained employed by ORR, dismissed the victimisation claim and ordered reduced costs of £3,000 under rule 76(1)(a); the Tribunal also refused reconsideration. The EAT’s preliminary handling indicated no arguable error in the Tribunal’s application of Arrowsmith or in treating the dishonesty finding as rendering pursuit of the claim unreasonable.
- Dr S Mokhammad v General Medical Council & Ors [2026] EAT 79 21 April 2026 This appeal concerned whether the publication and continued retention of a non‑sanctional warning on the GMC register amounted to "conduct extending over a period" for the purposes of section 123 Equality Act 2010, and whether the Employment Judge erred in refusing to extend time. HHJ Tucker allowed the appeal in part, holding the claimant had sufficiently pleaded ongoing conduct (publication plus retention), and that the Employment Judge wrongly treated publication as a single act and relied on prejudice findings relevant to another respondent; the race discrimination claim against the GMC was remitted to the Employment Tribunal for reconsideration.
- M Mulumba v Partners Group (UK) Ltd & Anor [2026] EAT 53 21 April 2026 This appeal concerned Employment Tribunal case‑management decisions in a discrimination/dismissal claim by an Associate who disputed whether a post‑August 2017 period was part of an MBA "Associate Program" or an "Accommodation Period". The EAT upheld the Tribunal's removal of a proposed "July 2018 meeting" issue and its exclusion of parts of the claimant's late reply witness statement as introducing new or marginal matters. The Tribunal's earlier territorial‑jurisdiction date (7 September 2017) and its substantive findings that dismissal resulted from expiry of the Accommodation Period (SOSR) but was procedurally unfair were recorded and applied.
- A Harper & Ors v Alliance Healthcare Management Services Ltd [2026] EAT 55 17 April 2026 Claimant LGV drivers appealed a tribunal decision that the 2017 Alloga Staff Handbook did not confer an entitlement to enhanced overtime for hours worked beyond prescribed daily hours and that drivers were excluded from the Handbook's substantive overtime provisions. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, holding the tribunal was entitled to decide only the pleaded issue and correctly interpreted the Staff Handbook; it declined to decide points about driver-specific handbooks because the claimants had not amended their pleadings to rely on them.
- John Halley v The Right Honourable Lady Smith & Anor [2026] EAT 56 17 April 2026 This appeal challenged an Employment Tribunal's preliminary ruling that John Halley was neither a "holder of public office" under s.50(2) Equality Act 2010 nor a "worker" for employment/discrimination jurisdiction. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding that the appointment as lead junior counsel was made by the inquiry chair (with ministerial role limited to remuneration) and that Halley acted as a self‑employed practising advocate rather than a worker. The EAT also found no procedural error in deciding the preliminary issue on the agreed documents.
- National Crime Agency v DP & Ors [2026] EAT 52 15 April 2026 This appeal concerned whether s56(1)(b) of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 requires Employment Tribunals to hold CLOSED proceedings merely because an employee's role involved intercepted material (an assumption made but neither proved nor denied). The Employment Appeal Tribunal rejected a literal, blanket application of s56(1)(b) in the employment-tribunal context, holding that s56(1)(b) should be read (so far as compatible with s3 HRA) to cover only "particular" interception-related conduct and that tribunals must balance national security, open justice and Article 6 rights using available procedural tools; CLOSED procedure is not automatically mandatory. The case was remitted for case management and further steps by the Employment Tribunal.
- Wirral University Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust v Moriarty [2026] EAT 48 8 April 2026 This appeal challenged a tribunal's refusal to strike out four factual particulars in a second unfair dismissal claim as an abuse of process under Henderson v Henderson. The EAT held the tribunal correctly applied the Henderson principle and had not misdirected itself or relied on irrelevant considerations. The appeal was dismissed and particulars 2, 7, 8 and 10 may proceed to trial; other particulars had previously been struck out as estopped.
- Anthony Boateng v Moss Bros Group Limited [2026] EAT 50 2 April 2026 This appeal concerned the tribunal's September 2023 strike-out of the claimant's multiple Equality Act complaints as no longer capable of a fair trial, and its February 2024 refusal to postpone/stay the merits hearing of the claimant's unfair dismissal and holiday-pay claims. The EAT upheld the tribunal's fact-sensitive evaluative judgment that delay, loss/unavailability of key witness evidence and documentary support made a fair trial impossible for the discrimination complaints, and it also upheld the refusal to postpone the hearing. Both appeals were dismissed and the tribunal's interlocutory decisions stood; the unfair dismissal and holiday-pay claims were later dismissed on their merits.
- S Alexander v St George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 67 31 March 2026 This appeal challenged an Employment Tribunal’s refusal to postpone a six‑day final hearing after the claimant’s trade union representative fell ill shortly before trial, arguing the ET ignored the representative’s fit note, fettered its discretion and lost jurisdiction once an appeal was lodged. The EAT (Bourne J) held the ET had considered the fit note, was entitled to conclude there were no exceptional circumstances under rule 30A and that the overriding objective did not require postponement, and rejected the submission that a pending appeal ousted the ET’s jurisdiction. The appeal was dismissed and the ET’s substantive dismissal and discrimination findings were upheld.
- Saidali Khakimov v Amova Asset Management UK Limited [2026] EAT 47 27 March 2026 This appeal concerned dismissal of claims under s.15 Equality Act 2010 and unfair dismissal after the claimant, suffering Functional Neurological Disorder, was dismissed following prolonged absence. The EAT held the Employment Tribunal correctly applied the Pnaiser framework, found no causal link between the agreed "something arising" (difficulty with multi‑layered thinking/unclear responsibilities) and the dismissal, and permissibly rejected the claimant's belated re‑formulation of that "something arising" at closing. The ET's alternative finding that dismissal was a proportionate means of achieving legitimate aims was upheld, and permission to add a late further ground of appeal was refused.
- Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Authority v Mark Hunt [2026] EAT 123 26 March 2026 This appeal concerns the Authority’s challenge to an Employment Tribunal finding that Mr Hunt’s dismissal was unfair and that he suffered direct sex discrimination arising from disciplinary proceedings about a 2017 video and related allegations. The EAT held the Tribunal had failed to make required clear findings on the employer’s reason (or principal reason) for dismissal under s.98(1)(a) ERA and had relied on unsuitable comparator evidence and speculation in finding direct discrimination. The EAT set aside the liability findings and remitted liability and remedy for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal; a secondary appeal about admitting reconsideration evidence was dismissed.
- KJ v British Council [2026] EAT 46 25 March 2026 This appeal concerned two limited errors alleged against an ET judgment in a claim by KJ for constructive unfair dismissal and sex discrimination/harassment. The EAT allowed the claimant's appeal on the 35% Chagger/Polkey deduction, finding the ET misdirected itself in constructing the counterfactual, but dismissed the respondent's cross-appeal on limitation/jurisdiction (the ET lawfully found a continuing state of affairs). The Chagger deduction was quashed and remedy/compensation issues were remitted; disposal was adjourned pending an outstanding remedies appeal.
- A Whitaker v White Rose Academies Trust & Anor [2026] EAT 43 20 March 2026 This is an appeal from an Employment Tribunal preliminary hearing which found the claimant was not an employee or worker of the sponsor (LEG) and dismissed claims against it. The claimant sought to advance for the first time on appeal a distinct statutory basis for worker status under s.43K(1)(a); the EAT held the ET did not err in declining to consider an unpleaded s.43K(1)(a) case and refused permission for the point to be run on appeal. The ET decision was therefore upheld and the appeal dismissed.
- Rukhsana Pasha v The Home Office [2026] EAT 42 17 March 2026 This appeal concerned a Home Office immigration officer dismissed for unauthorised CRS database searches between 2006 and 2017 and whether procedural defects rendered her dismissal unfair. The Employment Appeal Tribunal rejected all permitted grounds of appeal, holding the tribunal had not erred in its application of the ACAS Code, that disclosure failures did not prejudice the claimant, and that no adequate comparator evidence or bad faith was shown. The dismissal for gross misconduct was therefore upheld.
- Adamu Thomas v The Kingsdale Foundation [2026] EAT 40 12 March 2026 This appeal concerned whether a teacher who previously held U3 was entitled as of right to the maximum of the post‑2013 STPCD upper pay range and whether the school's lower pay constituted an unlawful deduction. The EAT upheld the tribunal's core finding that the 2013 STPCD converted fixed U1–U3 points into a performance‑determined upper pay range, so prior U3 status did not create an automatic right to the maximum, but the teacher was entitled to the minimum of the range and had suffered a shortfall of £902.67. The appeal was allowed only to correct the calculation and increase the award to £902.67; otherwise dismissed.
- L Capeling v TFX Group Limited [2026] EAT 57 10 March 2026 This appeal concerned whether a particular disclosure by the claimant about the absence of DAC contracts amounted to a "qualifying disclosure" under s.43B ERA (alleging endangerment of patient health/safety and concealment). The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the Employment Tribunal's factual findings that the claimant had only made a general, unexplained assertion of risk and that any belief linking missing contracts to patient-safety risk was not reasonable in light of her role and knowledge. The appeal was dismissed and the Tribunal's liability findings were left undisturbed.
- MacAusland Design Limited v A Portosi [2026] EAT 51 10 March 2026 This appeal concerns an Employment Appeal Tribunal decision upholding an Employment Judge's remedy award after a finding of unfair dismissal. The central issue was whether the judge erred in assessing the claimant's mitigation of loss, particularly when any failure to mitigate crystallised given an employment opportunity from the respondent in August 2021. The EAT dismissed the respondent's appeal and the claimant's cross‑appeal, finding no legal error or perversity in the judge's determination that any failure to mitigate crystallised in July 2022 and in her loss calculations.
- The Laurels Family Assessment Limited v M Y Kay [2026] EAT 39 10 March 2026 The EAT dismissed the employer's appeal against a majority ET finding that the claimant was automatically unfairly dismissed for making protected disclosures and that she suffered detriment in the handling of her appeal. The tribunal (majority) accepted the claimant's oral evidence about disclosures on 22 Aug and 13 Sep 2022, found those communications were qualifying and protected disclosures and the principal reason for summary dismissal, and held the employer’s handling of the appeal amounted to detrimental treatment. The EAT concluded the majority’s factual findings and reasoning were not perverse or inadequately explained.
- OE Olarewaju v Bupa Care Services Limited [2026] EAT 38 9 March 2026 This appeal to the EAT challenged an Employment Tribunal's refusal of interim relief in a s.103A ERA whistleblowing dismissal claim, arguing the tribunal gave inadequate reasons. The EAT held the judge's brief reasoning was sufficient to show refusal was because causation was unlikely—dismissal appeared attributable to alleged misconduct rather than protected disclosures—and dismissed the appeal. The decision confirms the tribunal can refuse interim relief on a summary assessment where the claimant does not have a "pretty good chance" of success.
- Daniel Matovu v The Chambers of Martin Porter KC & Ors [2026] EAT 36 5 March 2026 The case concerns an appeal by Mr Daniel Matovu against case-management decisions made by Employment Judge Hodgson at a preliminary hearing refusing an amendment to paragraph 32 of his Particulars and refusing a request for further information about allegations the Claimant acted in bad faith. The President held the EJ wrongly exercised his discretion in both refusals and, taken together with the EJ’s conduct at the hearing, there was a real possibility of apparent bias. The appeal was allowed and EJ Hodgson was ordered to be removed from further involvement in the Claimant’s case; substituted written reasons were provided overturning the refusals.
- Hypervolt Limited v S Jackson [2026] EAT 45 5 March 2026 This appeal concerned Hypervolt's challenge to a refusal by an employment judge (REJ Burgher) to extend time to file an ET3 and to reconsider a Rule 21 default judgment in Mr Jackson's claim. The EAT held the ET erred in law by failing to follow the two-stage Rule 72(1) process (first deciding whether there was any reasonable prospect of varying or revoking the original decision before seeking responses/hearing) and by giving inadequate reasons (not Meek-compliant). The appeal was allowed and the matter was remitted to the same REJ for fresh reconsideration and clearer findings; the listed remedy hearing remains pending.
- A v B, the Organisation & Ors [2026] EAT 35 4 March 2026 This case concerns an EAT review of its own RRO judgment varying a respondent regulation order. The EAT judge accepted he had failed to determine two self-contained sub‑grounds argued below — that there was a heightened need for freedom of expression and greater public interest — and concluded that omission warranted review and remission. The matter is remitted to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal to rehear those sub‑grounds; the RROs remain in force pending that rehearing.
- Attorney General v Sandra Messi [2026] EAT 34 3 March 2026 The Employment Appeal Tribunal considered an Attorney General application for a restriction of proceedings order against Sandra Messi as a vexatious litigant after she issued over 50 ET claims since 2017, none of which succeeded and many of which were struck out, withdrawn or dismissed for misconduct or lack of merit. The EAT found the statutory test under the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 satisfied (habitual, persistent and without reasonable ground), exercised its discretion to make an indefinite restriction order requiring EAT permission before instituting, continuing or making applications in ET or EAT proceedings, but declined to bar her from acting as a McKenzie friend and rejected her allegations of bias and fraud.
- Sujith Manuel v Netduma Limited [2026] EAT 44 3 March 2026 This Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the claimant's appeal against a refusal to permit an amendment to add a detriment claim for making a health and safety disclosure. The EAT held that the claimant's ET1 and particulars, objectively read, plainly asserted a health and safety detriment (it "shouted out"), so no leave to amend was required; alternatively, the Employment Judge erred in refusing amendment because the balance of prejudice favoured the claimant. The case was remitted for a further preliminary hearing and case management directions.
- Gemma Dobson v North Cumbria Integrated Care NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 32 27 February 2026 This appeal concerned whether a Tribunal had properly justified a provision, criterion or practice (PCP) requiring community nurses to work flexibly, including some weekends, after a part-time nurse who could not work weekends was dismissed. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, holding the Tribunal was entitled to weigh both group disadvantage and the claimant's individual hardship, to treat the claimant's consultation responses and lack of alternative proposals as relevant, and to extrapolate from team-level evidence to the wider workforce for proportionality purposes.
- Tesco Stores Limited v K Element & Ors [2026] EAT 33 26 February 2026 This appeal concerned procedural errors in how an Employment Tribunal handled Stage 2 equal value reconsideration applications in a long-running claim. The EAT held that the Tribunal wrongly dismissed some grounds as having "no reasonable prospect" where its own reasoning showed those grounds merited further consideration, and it substituted permission-to-proceed decisions for several grounds and remitted them for completion of the mandatory reconsideration stages once the stay is lifted. The EAT emphasised that factual questions relevant to Stage 2 must normally be resolved within the Stage 2 process, not deferred to the final hearing.
- Elena Bibescu v Clare Jenner Limited t/a Jenner’s [2026] EAT 30 24 February 2026 The claimant, an accountant dismissed in June 2020, alleged dismissal for making protected disclosures and detriment for protected disclosures. The EAT upheld the Tribunal's factual finding that the principal reason for dismissal was performance and inability to work with a colleague (so the s103A dismissal complaint fails) but found legal error in the Tribunal's handling of the s47B detriment issue and remitted that complaint to a differently constituted Tribunal. The EAT also criticised shortcomings in the Tribunal's written reasons.
- H Fullah v Medical Research Council & Ors [2026] EAT 28 20 February 2026 This is an EAT appeal about whether an Employment Tribunal properly answered a remitted victimisation causation question following the claimant's protected acts and the employer's finding of a breakdown in working relations leading to suspension and dismissal. The EAT held the ET erred by failing to address whether features relied on were "properly separable" from the protected acts and by asking the wrong causation question, allowed the appeal and remitted the specific causation issue for reconsideration to a differently constituted tribunal. The EAT also affirmed that suspension amounted to a detriment.
- F Ngole v Touchstone Leeds [2026] EAT 29 16 February 2026 This appeal concerned a claim of direct discrimination because of religious belief after a conditional job offer was withdrawn following media reports of the claimant's past social‑media posts opposing same‑sex marriage. The EAT found some legal errors in the Employment Tribunal's reasoning: the Tribunal was right that the initial withdrawal on 10 June 2022 was unlawful for not allowing the claimant an opportunity to address concerns, but erred in failing to identify and analyse separately each reason the respondent acted when assessing discrimination and justification. The appeal was therefore partly allowed and partly dismissed, with aspects of the case remitted to the same Employment Tribunal for further focused analysis.
- Ernest Milrine v DHL Services Limited [2026] EAT 31 13 February 2026 This case concerns dismissal for long-term medical incapacity after prolonged absence and a seriously flawed internal appeal process that never took place. The Employment Tribunal found the dismissal fair despite criticising appeal-stage failings; the Employment Appeal Tribunal held the ET erred in law by failing to treat a procedurally defective internal appeal as potentially rendering the dismissal unfair and substituted a finding of unfair dismissal. The EAT directed the parties to consider remedy, noting the appeal defects were striking and there was no finding that an appeal would have been futile.
- Bank of Africa United Kingdom Plc & Ors v N Tahri Hassani [2026] EAT 27 11 February 2026 This appeal concerned whether the claimant’s employment transferred from BMCE to the first respondent during a long-term secondment and related whistleblowing/detriment and automatic unfair dismissal findings. The EAT held the Tribunal was wrong to find a transfer on 8 January 2021 and set aside the automatic unfair dismissal holding against the first respondent, and it found procedural and legal errors in parts of the Tribunal’s whistleblowing detriment reasoning, remitting those parts for rehearing by a differently constituted Tribunal. The remaining original dismissals were left intact.
- Elizabeth Chand v EE Limited [2026] EAT 17 11 February 2026 This appeal concerned the fairness of a 2022 summary dismissal for alleged fraud and gross misconduct after four customer‑interaction incidents. The Employment Tribunal found only one incident could justify dismissal and that the employer had wrongly treated the conduct as fraudulent; the EAT held the Tribunal was right to dismiss the employer's cross‑appeal and further held that the Tribunal had erred in treating the dismissal as fair given the employer's composite reason included a fraud allegation not supported by reasonable grounds. The EAT substituted a finding that the unfair dismissal complaint succeeds and remitted remedy to the Tribunal.
- M Nowak v Evtec Aluminium Ltd [2026] EAT 26 6 February 2026 This appeal concerned claims by Mr Nowak (and colleagues) of direct race discrimination (by reference to Polish nationality) and victimisation, arising from workplace treatment and a 19 April 2022 letter about Friday breaks. The Employment Appeal Tribunal rejected challenges to the employment tribunal’s factual and legal reasoning on credibility, corroboration, detriment (including comparator assessment and burden under EqA s136) and refusal to allow a separate Working Time Regulations (WTR) claim to be pleaded. The EAT held the tribunal was entitled to find the claimants not credible, that there was no sufficient evidence of discriminatory motive or causation from protected acts, and that the letter did not amount to victimisation. The appeal was dismissed in full.
- Dr B Jones v Viiv Healthcare UK Limited [2026] EAT 24 30 January 2026 Dr B Jones, a Black woman dismissed after alleged breakdowns in working relationships, appealed a tribunal's rejection of her claims of direct race and sex discrimination and victimisation. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding that the tribunal had properly applied section 136 Equality Act 2010 in a fact-sensitive way, considered alleged stereotyping and victimisation, and reasonably concluded the dismissal resulted from an evidenced breakdown in relationships rather than protected characteristics or acts.
- The Advocate General for Scotland v Charles Milroy [2026] EAT 25 29 January 2026 This is an EAT appeal by the Advocate General for Scotland against an Employment Tribunal judgment in favour of reservist Charles Milroy under the Part-time Workers Regulations/Directive. The EAT upheld the Tribunal’s findings that Milroy qualified as a "worker", that his method of calculating daily pay treated him less favourably than a comparable regular, and that both the pay treatment and exclusion of pre‑1 April 2015 service from pension entitlement were "on the ground of" his part‑time/reservist status. The appeal was refused in its entirety.
- U Prasad v Epsom & St Helier Hospital NHS Trust & Anor [2026] EAT 23 29 January 2026 Dr Prasad appealed a Tribunal's order that she pay £20,000 costs after parts of her whistleblowing, discrimination and victimisation claims were found to have no reasonable prospect and to have been pursued unreasonably; the Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal. The EAT rejected challenges that the Tribunal misapplied r.76(1)(a) and (b), conflated rules, misdirected on causation, or wrongly proceeded in her absence, and upheld the Tribunal's exercise of discretion including refusal to admit late medical evidence.
- U Prasad v Epsom & St Helier Hospital NHS Trust & Anor [2026] EAT 22 29 January 2026 This appeal concerned whether Claim 6, brought by a former consultant cardiologist naming only the CEO, Ms Totterdell, could properly be struck out for disclosing no reasonable cause of action against her alone and whether consolidation or case management had made the Trust a respondent. The Employment Tribunal and the Deputy Judge found the ET1 and later particulars objectively showed the Claimant intended to sue Ms Totterdell personally, that consolidation did not convert the claim into one against the Trust, and that the Tribunal did not err in refusing to treat or substitute the Trust as respondent. The appeal was dismissed and the strike out of Claim 6 was upheld.
- M Anea v OCS UK & I Limited & Ors [2026] EAT 21 28 January 2026 This appeal challenged an Employment Tribunal's findings rejecting a cleaner's claims of sexual harassment and constructive/unfair dismissal and alleged the Tribunal had applied an impermissible, inflexible rule preferring the respondents' evidence. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held there was no legal error: the Tribunal had reached its conclusions on the totality of the evidence and its credibility findings were open to it. The claimant's appeal was dismissed.
- The Government of the State of Kuwait v S Mohamed [2026] EAT 20 28 January 2026 The EAT dismissed Kuwait's appeal against an ET decision that (i) s5 State Immunity Act 1978 disapplies state immunity for personal injury claims even where the State entered into a contract of employment in the exercise of sovereign authority, and (ii) "personal injury" in s5 includes psychiatric injury. The EAT followed its prior authorities on Ground 1 and held it was bound by the Court of Appeal in Shehabi on Ground 2, and indicated willingness to grant permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal for definitive resolution.
- Aman Khan v Novai Limited & Anor [2026] EAT 19 26 January 2026 This is an EAT appeal in which the claimant, a former CEO, alleged his January 2022 communications were protected public-interest disclosures and that a dismissal decision was made before those disclosures. The EAT found material legal and reasoning errors in the Employment Tribunal's assessment of whether qualifying/protected disclosures were made and in its reasoning on the timing of the dismissal decision. The EAT set aside the relevant parts of the liability judgment and remitted the matters to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal for full reconsideration. The EAT left questions about admission of a newly discovered transcript to the remitted tribunal.
- Besmir Pepkolaj v Barrett Steel Limited [2026] EAT 14 22 January 2026 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred by failing to identify a discrimination arising from disability (s.15) claim when the claimant's ET1 primarily pleaded unfair dismissal and denied being disabled. The EAT held that, on an objective analysis of the ET1, no s.15 claim was pleaded and the Tribunal was not obliged to probe or expand the unpleaded case; there was therefore no error of law and the appeal was dismissed.
- Alpha Anne and Ors v Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 15 21 January 2026 This appeal concerned 80 cleaners who transferred to Great Ormond Street Hospital and alleged indirect race discrimination for not receiving AfC pay before and after transfer. The EAT held pre-transfer claims failed because s.41 does not cover complaints about pay set by a contractor employer (following Royal Parks), but allowed the post-transfer claim in respect of PCP(d) (delay/refusal to apply AfC) on the basis that a prima facie indirect discrimination was made out and objective justification failed. The Tribunal’s errors on TUPE were immaterial because undisputed contract terms permitted the Trust to apply AfC from transfer. Pre-transfer dismissal upheld; post-transfer claim succeeded.
- R J Bryce v Active Security Solutions Limited & Anor [2026] EAT 16 21 January 2026 This appeal concerned strike-out and deposit orders after the claimant, a licensed door supervisor, was sent home following an incident and complained (among other things) of a s.44 ERA detriment. The Employment Appeal Tribunal rejected the claimant’s complaint that refusing leave to file written responses (as a requested reasonable adjustment for Asperger’s and dyslexia) caused material procedural unfairness, upheld the Tribunal’s reliance on Castano that incidental health-and-safety tasks do not make an employee “designated” under s.44(1)(a), and held any error on detriment was academic because the claimant was not within s.44(1). The appeal was refused in full.
- Sita Rama Swamy Kankanalapalli v Loesche Energy Systems Limited [2026] EAT 49 20 January 2026 The EAT allowed Mr Kankanalapalli's appeal against the ET's dismissal, holding that the employer's offer letter created a concluded contract subject to subsequent conditions rather than preventing formation. The tribunal implied a term requiring reasonable notice before termination and, on the facts, fixed that notice at three months; the employer breached the contract by withdrawing the offer without giving that notice. Claims for holiday pay and immediate payment of the relocation sum were rejected.
- S Pal v Accenture (UK) Ltd [2026] EAT 12 19 January 2026 This appeal concerned an employee dismissed under her employer's "progression/up or elsewhere" model after medical absences for endometriosis; the EAT found the Employment Tribunal erred in its Polkey analysis and in its handling of disability and related discrimination issues. The EAT held the ET had substituted its own counterfactual (what it would have done) for what the employer would have done if it had acted fairly, set aside the Polkey reduction and the disability/discrimination findings, and remitted the case to a differently constituted ET for fresh determination.
- M Odusanya v Pennine Care Foundation Trust & Ors [2026] EAT 5 16 January 2026 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's strike-out of the claimant's claims after she, while under oath, was warned not to discuss her evidence and later consulted a newly instructed representative; the ET treated those consultations as deliberate misconduct and struck out the case. The EAT allowed the appeal in part, holding that the ET unlawfully deprived the claimant of the ability to consult her representative and required her to give an account while under oath without permitting advice, set aside the strike-out and remitted the matter to a different panel; two grounds of appeal were upheld and three dismissed.
- D Leonard-Elmaz v Ocado Central Services Ltd [2026] EAT 41 15 January 2026 This appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal challenged an ET decision that struck out time‑barred recruitment/start‑date complaints, refused recusal for apparent bias, declined to extend time for those complaints, and found the claimant not disabled by depression for the relevant period. The EAT dismissed the appeal on all four grounds, holding there was no continuing act linking recruitment events to later dismissal, the ET properly exercised its discretion on extension of time, the ET correctly applied the long‑term disability test and was entitled to find the condition not likely to last 12 months, and there was no evidence of any undisclosed gift giving giving rise to apparent bias. No relief or remittal was ordered.
- Oluwafunto Dada v The Scottish Ministers [2026] EAT 13 15 January 2026 This is an EAT appeal challenging an Employment Tribunal's refusal to extend the Equality Act 2010 s.123(1) three-month time limit for two race discrimination claims and its refusal to allow an amendment. The EAT held the ET erred by relying on inappropriate authorities and misapplying the correct holistic "just and equitable" approach (as in Adedeji), and by failing to consider whether the proposed amendment was relevant to the limitation decision. The EAT set aside the ET's 19 September 2024 order and remitted the case for the original ET to reconsider.
- R Phullar v Ofsted [2026] EAT 10 14 January 2026 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment allowing parts of an appeal and cross-appeal from an employment tribunal decision concerning unfair dismissal and disability discrimination under the Equality Act 2010. The EAT held the ET applied the wrong legal test to the s.15 (arising-in-consequence) complaint and gave inadequate reasons on multiple issues (including failure to provide Access to Work equipment, consideration of alternative roles, and fairness of dismissal), and remitted those matters for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal; some original factual findings were left standing.
- A Darlington v London Borough of Islington [2026] EAT 11 13 January 2026 This appeal concerned whether an ACAS COT3 settlement signed in September 2021 between the appellant, Hargrave Park School governors and the London Borough of Islington barred a later whistleblowing detriment claim about non‑appointment at another council‑run school. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal's construction that, read objectively in its context, the COT3 released existing and future claims arising from the appellant's alleged protected disclosures at Hargrave and therefore precluded the later Westbourne claim. The appeal was dismissed.
- Guy’s & St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust v Nizam Mamode [2026] EAT 37 13 January 2026 This is an EAT appeal from an Employment Judge's finding that a consultant surgeon was constructively unfairly dismissed after alleged investigatory and managerial failings by Guy’s & St Thomas’. The EAT found the Employment Judge had misapplied the legal test for repudiatory breaches of the implied term of mutual trust and confidence, gave inadequate or perverse reasons on several pleaded allegations, and remitted the case for a de novo rehearing before a different Employment Judge.
- B Gurney v M Randall & Ors [2026] EAT 4 12 January 2026 This judgment concerns the respondent's application for costs under r.34A of the EAT Rules after dismissal of an appeal which had challenged an Employment Tribunal decision refusing wasted costs. The EAT held the respondent had not shown the high threshold of improper, vexatious, unnecessary or misconceived conduct (or equivalent unreasonable conduct/delay) required to justify a costs order, so the application was refused. The court noted that passing a sift or preliminary stage is a relevant factor but does not automatically prevent a costs award, and that wasted-costs liability for legal representatives requires conduct akin to an abuse of process.
- Craig Lamb v Teva UK Ltd [2026] EAT 8 12 January 2026 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal erred in finding a dismissal for alleged gross misconduct fair, given the investigator and note‑taker had some prior involvement, CCTV evidence was provided shortly before the disciplinary hearing, and managers were overheard making discouraging remarks. The EAT rejected challenges to the ET's application of s.98 ERA and relevant guidance, concluding the factual reason for dismissal was established and the overall investigation and disciplinary process were reasonable. The appeal was dismissed and the ET's decision upheld.
- London Ambulance Service NHS Trust v I Sodola (Debarred) [2026] EAT 6 9 January 2026 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal finding that an unexplained delay in providing written feedback after a failed promotion amounted to direct race discrimination under s.136 Equality Act 2010. The EAT held that, although the ET did not misdirect itself on law, the primary facts found could not reasonably support an inference that the delay was race‑motivated. The appeal was allowed and the ET’s discrimination finding as to the feedback delay was quashed.
- P McCrory v Healthwatch Stockport Limited [2026] EAT 3 8 January 2026 This appeal concerned whether a claimant's emails amounted to a clear, unequivocal and unambiguous withdrawal of his Employment Tribunal claims and whether a dismissal judgment signed by a Legal Officer was lawful. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the claimant's correspondence was equivocal, that the dismissal judgment was made in error of law, allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the Employment Tribunal for case management and any proper determination on withdrawal or dismissal.
- D Harding v St George's University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EAT 2 7 January 2026 This Employment Appeal Tribunal decision concerns two applications for extension of time to lodge appeals after an employment tribunal struck out one of the claimant's complaints and made a costs award following a separate liability trial. The EAT held that omitting to attach the strike-out judgment was a "minor error" under amended Rule 37(5) and, together with medical evidence of significant anxiety that substantially contributed to a short delay, justified treating the first appeal as instituted in time. The EAT refused to extend time for a freestanding late appeal against the costs judgment, so that second ARO was dismissed.
- J Mayanja v City of Bradford Metropolitan District Council [2026] EAT 7 7 January 2026 This appeal concerned whether the claimant had been offered a post in October 2021, new evidence (an email dated 18 Oct 2021) said to support that assertion, and whether the respondent should pay costs in the EAT. The EAT held that the Employment Tribunal had erred in not revisiting liability in light of the newly discovered email, set aside the liability and costs judgments below and remitted the claim to a differently constituted Tribunal. The EAT refused the claimant’s application for costs in the EAT under rule 34A, finding the respondent’s conduct did not meet the threshold for an adverse costs order.
- Mohammed Rashad v The Chief Constable of Cleveland Police [2026] EAT 1 2 January 2026 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's refusal to extend time for a victimisation claim (Complaint 9) brought by Mr Rashad, where the ET concluded that delay had impaired witness reliability and could cause reputational prejudice to a non-party witness. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the ET, finding its impressionistic assessment of weakened evidence over time was permissible and that potential reputational harm to a non-party witness could be relevant in the just-and-equitable exercise in the policing context. The ET’s reasons were held adequate and its discretion was not displaced.
- A Muda v Malaysia [2025] EAT 193 23 December 2025 This appeal concerns whether the Malaysian High Commission enjoyed state immunity from a locally recruited social secretary’s employment and related claims under ss.4 and 16(1)(aa) of the State Immunity Act 1978. The Employment Tribunal had dismissed the claim under s.4(2)(a) (an appeal on that point is stayed following Lorenzo) but found the employment and the acts complained of were not exercises of sovereign authority under s.16(1)(aa)(i) or (ii). The EAT upheld the Tribunal’s conclusions on s.16(1)(aa) and dismissed Grounds 2 and 3 of the respondent’s cross‑appeal; the s.4(2)(a) issue remains stayed pending the Government’s response to Lorenzo.
- Neil Duke v B & M Retail Ltd [2025] EAT 195 23 December 2025 This EAT appeal concerned claims of indirect disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments, unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal arising from the respondent employer’s COVID-era attendance requirements and refusal to furlough the disabled claimant. The EAT found multiple legal errors in the Employment Tribunal’s analysis — including on particular disadvantage, objective justification, burden of proof, reasonable adjustments and unfair dismissal reasoning — allowed the appeal and remitted the case to a differently constituted ET. No merits decision on the remitted issues was made.
- Donald Gormley v Phoenix Business Solutions (UK) Limited [2025] EAT 198 22 December 2025 This appeal concerned a legal director dismissed in a redundancy situation where the employment tribunal found there had been no consultation and therefore unfairness, but nonetheless dismissed the claimant's unfair dismissal claim and rejected a wrongful dismissal claim on grounds of a repudiatory breach. The EAT held the ET erred in law in dismissing the unfair dismissal claim and substituted a finding that the claim succeeds, but declined to remit the remedies: the ET’s two‑week compensatory award and statutory redundancy payment were left in place. The EAT also upheld the ET’s finding that the claimant’s post‑termination consultancy work amounted to a repudiatory breach defeating a claim for notice pay.
- L & Anor v Ministry of Defence [2025] EAT 197 22 December 2025 This appeal concerned whether paragraph 4(3) of Schedule 9 to the Equality Act 2010 can be read compatibly with Article 14 ECHR (taken with Articles 6 and/or 8) so as to permit disability-discrimination claims arising from armed forces service. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held paragraph 4(3) cannot be interpreted under section 3(1) HRA to confer such rights and dismissed both appeals. The tribunal assumed, without deciding, that Mr L’s complaint could fall within the ambit of Article 8 but left any justification/proportionality questions to be remitted if the interpretive issue were resolved for the appellants.
- R Jones v Ministry of Justice [2025] EAT 205 22 December 2025 This case concerns two long-delayed appeals by Ms Jones against Registrar refusals to extend time, and repeated efforts by the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) to provide reasonable adjustments for an asserted medical condition. The appellant failed to produce current medical evidence despite directions and repeatedly failed to co-operate with adjusted hearing arrangements, resulting in the EAT striking both appeals for lack of co-operation and unreasonable delay. The court held that the tribunal had made reasonable, pragmatic attempts to accommodate the appellant but was entitled to strike out the appeals to protect fairness and case management.
- Micro Focus Limited v James Mildenhall [2025] EAT 188 19 December 2025 This EAT appeal concerned whether Micro Focus triggered TULRCA s.188 collective consultation duties by "proposing" 20+ dismissals and whether the ET lawfully aggregated employees by treating the respondent as a "de facto" employer. The EAT held the ET erred in treating the CJEU decision in Marclean as authorising retrospective "look backwards and forwards" aggregation and erred in aggregating by reference to a purported "de facto" employer rather than contractual employers. The appeal was allowed in part and the two TULRCA issues were remitted to the ET for rehearing; other grounds were dismissed.
- T Turner v Western Mortgage Services Ltd [2025] EAT 191 19 December 2025 This appeal concerned whether an ACAS COT3 settlement, signed by the parties after a tribunal claim was struck out in part, objectively settled the struck-out PHI complaint and thus precluded the related EAT appeal. HHJ Auerbach held the COT3 was a binding contract, that its broad "any and all claims" language (subject to narrow exclusions) covered the struck-out complaint and the related appeal or at least rendered the appeal academic, and therefore ordered the appeal dismissed. The judge rejected claims of duress or other infirmity affecting the COT3's validity.
- D Kaur v Birmingham City Council [2025] EAT 190 18 December 2025 This appeal concerned a litigant-in-person who withdrew an employment tribunal (ET) claim and whose case was dismissed; she later sought to revisit the dismissal on grounds she had been ignorant of the consequences for a later civil personal injury (PI) claim. The Employment Judge and the Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the tribunal’s dismissal and refusal to reconsider, finding the tribunal had considered whether her continuing ignorance was reasonable and was entitled to conclude she should have informed her PI solicitors earlier. The appeal was dismissed and the earlier decisions were upheld.
- Emma Nunn v G and MJ Crouch and Son Ltd (t/a Crouch Recovery) [2025] EAT 187 17 December 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in finding that conduct complained of by Ms Nunn was not "unwanted" and did not have the proscribed effect of sexual harassment. The EAT upheld the ET’s factual findings that, given the close personal relationship, Ms Nunn’s participation in sexual "banter", her occasional laughter, and lack of contemporaneous complaint, the conduct was open to be regarded as not unwanted and not meeting the proscribed effect. The appeal was dismissed and the ET’s findings stand.
- Jen Nelson v Renfrewshire Council [2025] EAT 189 16 December 2025 This is an EAT judgment dismissing an appeal by a teacher who resigned for constructive dismissal after an incident with a headteacher and a flawed two‑stage grievance process. The EAT held the employment tribunal (on re‑hearing) correctly applied the objective Malik‑style test to the implied term of mutual trust and confidence and did not err in law in its factual and degree conclusions that the employer’s conduct, including grievance shortcomings, did not amount to a repudiatory breach. The EAT rejected arguments that the ET took irrelevant considerations into account or misdirected itself about the impact of the original incident on procedural obligations.
- S Brown v East Hanningfield Pre-School [2025] EAT 201 16 December 2025 This appeal challenged an Employment Tribunal Rule 21 paper judgment that awarded only a small unpaid wages sum while other potential claims (including disability, bullying, grievances and possible further claims) appeared in the claimant’s ET1 and supplementary material. The EAT found the scope of the claim was unclear on the material before the Tribunal and that the Employment Judge should have sought clarification or given reasonable assistance to the litigant in person before disposing of the claim on paper. The judge’s failure to do so was outside the reasonable exercise of discretion, the appeal was allowed and the matter was remitted to the Employment Tribunal for reconsideration under current Rule 22.
- A Singha v Lloyds Pharmacy Limited [2025] EAT 203 11 December 2025 This EAT judgment concerned two appeals from Employment Tribunal decisions: one about whether the claimant’s stress, anxiety and depression amounted to a disability, and one about victimisation. The EAT held the Tribunal erred when finding the mental impairment was neither substantial nor likely to be long term, remitting the disability question to a differently constituted tribunal. The EAT dismissed the appeal on victimisation, finding the Tribunal’s causation conclusions were open to it.
- Yovka Kisheva v Secure Frontline Services Limited [2025] EAT 194 11 December 2025 The claimant, a door supervisor, left part-way through a shift after an argument and notified her team leader but did not telephone the respondent's central number; she was summarily dismissed without a proper investigation. The ET found dismissal unfair but nonetheless labelled the conduct as gross misconduct and reduced awards by 100%; the EAT held the gross-misconduct finding was perverse on the evidence and remitted remedy to a differently constituted tribunal while upholding the unfair dismissal conclusion.
- Mohammed Shazan Chaudhry v Paperchase Products Limited & Anor [2025] EAT 181 10 December 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Secretary of State must pay a basic award for unfair dismissal from the National Insurance Fund where no employment tribunal (or equivalent) has made such an award because the employer became insolvent and the tribunal claim was stayed. The EAT held that, read naturally, Part XII of the Employment Rights Act 1996 requires a tribunal (or similar adjudication) to have made the basic award before the Secretary of State is obliged to pay, and dismissed the appeal. The court noted but did not disapply or resolve arguments that this regime may conflict with the Insolvency Directive and EU principles.
- Nalamolu Brahmaiah v Central and North West London NHS Foundation Trust [2025] EAT 192 10 December 2025 This appeal challenged an Employment Tribunal decision to extend time for the respondent to file an ET3 and to refuse default judgment, on the basis the claimant had not been given a proper opportunity to be heard. The EAT allowed the appeal, refused to grant substantive relief itself (including default judgment or employment remedies), and remitted the matter to the Employment Tribunal for rehearing with the claimant given a proper opportunity. The EAT ordered the claimant to pay the respondents' costs of the EAT hearing (£1,800) for misconceived and unreasonable conduct.
- Vesuvius Plc & Ors v Glenn Cowie [2025] EAT 183 9 December 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in grossing up a damages award to include UK National Insurance Contributions (NIC). The EAT accepted that including NIC was an error of law but treated the point as a new point on appeal and, exercising its discretion, refused to allow it because allowing the challenge would have caused the claimant substantial prejudice and undermined finality. The appeal was dismissed and the ET’s award of £3,171,723 remained in force.
- QR v The GI Group Limited [2025] EAT 178 8 December 2025 This appeal concerned whether an oral agreement reached on 6 December 2022 constituted a binding settlement and the correctness of an employment tribunal’s costs order of £10,100 against the claimant for unsuccessful procedural applications. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s finding that there was no binding contract because the parties reasonably understood a written agreement and independent legal advice were required, but allowed part of the appeal on costs, concluding the tribunal was entitled to make a costs order under rule 76(1)(a) yet erred in its assessment of the amount and reasons. The matter of the quantum of costs was remitted to the same employment judge for reconsideration focusing properly on the claimant’s ability to pay.
- Dr James Mullen v Melian Dialogue Research Limited [2025] EAT 179 5 December 2025 This appeal and cross‑appeal concerned remedy following findings that the claimant was unfairly dismissed for making protected disclosures and suffered protected‑disclosure detriment. The EAT found multiple legal errors in the Employment Tribunal's remedy reasoning — notably an inadequately reasoned 10% Polkey reduction, misapplication of the burden on mitigation, failure to determine claimed start‑up expenses, and errors on aggravated damages and injury to feelings — and remitted the case to a differently constituted ET to reconsider remedy. The ET had no jurisdiction to award injury to feelings for dismissal and must hear relevant evidence afresh on mitigation, Polkey, start‑up expenses and aggravated damages. No revised quantum was determined.
- Stay Safe East v Monique Francois [2025] EAT 199 5 December 2025 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal decision allowing an appeal by Stay Safe East from an employment tribunal finding that Miss Francois suffered direct race discrimination and remitting the claim for rehearing. The EAT held the ET erred in law by shifting the burden of proof without identifying the additional evidence required beyond a mere difference in treatment, and by drawing inferences of discrimination from a single comparator and unclear findings about decision‑maker involvement. The EAT also criticised procedural unfairness in the hearing (missing witness materials, unprepared/unrepresented respondent, and handling of an adjournment application).
- M v Northern, Eastern and Western Devon Clinical Commissioning Group (New Devon CCG) (Debarred) [2025] EAT 196 4 December 2025 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's refusal to anonymise and remove from the public Register a withdrawn 2017 judgment. The EAT held the ET proceeded on the incorrect premise that Article 8 was not relied on, so it failed to undertake the proportionality/balancing exercise required by Rule 50. The appeal was allowed and the matter remitted to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal to reconsider and carry out the balancing exercise.
- T Tamponi v Medequip Assistive Technology Ltd [2025] EAT 180 3 December 2025 This appeal concerned two claims of direct race discrimination arising from (1) employer communications about settled‑status and (2) disciplinary treatment after the claimant disposed of returned equipment. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, upholding the tribunal’s findings that the settled‑status communications did not amount to a detriment and that both discrimination complaints were out of time (with no just and equitable extension). The tribunal was also held to have been entitled to distinguish treatment prompted by a change in immigration status from treatment because of nationality/race.
- F Amedzo v Bidvest Noonan (UK) Limited [2025] EAT 202 2 December 2025 Mr Amedzo resigned alleging constructive dismissal after what he said was mishandling of a grievance about a manager; an Employment Tribunal found no breach of the implied term of trust and confidence and dismissed his claim. On limited grounds of appeal (seniority/suitability of the appeal manager, whether a defective grievance process could amount to constructive dismissal, and the role of Joe Boyle), the EAT found no error of law and dismissed the appeal. The Tribunal’s factual findings about who was appropriate to investigate and hear the appeal, and that any procedural defects did not cause prejudice, were held to be open to it. The ET decision therefore stands.
- A Perkins v Marston (Holdings) Limited [2025] EAT 170 28 November 2025 This appeal concerned whether three non-discriminatory material factors explained a sex pay gap and the correct approach to the s.69(2) material factor defence to indirect discrimination. The EAT held the ET was right to accept the factors on cogent, particularised evidence but erred as a matter of law by investigating why a factor disadvantaged women rather than simply whether it did; the matter of whether two factors were tainted by sex and whether reliance on them was proportionate was remitted for rehearing. Parts of the respondent's cross-appeal succeeded insofar as the ET’s proportionality analysis was insufficient and must be redone.
- G Mangwanya v National Association of Citizens Advice Bureaux [2025] EAT 175 27 November 2025 This appeal concerns the Registrar's refusal to extend the time to file an EAT appeal which was effectively 2 hours 24 minutes late. The Tribunal judge found the short delay was caused mainly by poor organisation and human error (with some medical difficulties affecting the appellant and her assistant), and that significant prejudice to the respondent from destruction of hearing notes made granting an extension inappropriate. The appeal from the Registrar's Order refusing the extension was dismissed.
- H Ahmed v Department of Work and Pensions [2025] EAT 176 26 November 2025 This consolidated EAT judgment concerns a disabled former Work Coach's discrimination and reasonable-adjustment claims arising from refusal or handling of entry to an employer "Employee Deal" and from tribunal hearing management. The EAT found the first tribunal erred in law by treating the 2020 refusal as not "unfavourable" under s.15 but dismissed that appeal on other findings; it allowed the second appeal, setting aside the strike-out of a reasonable-adjustment claim and restoring it; and it allowed the third appeal, finding the tribunal unlawfully varied hearing arrangements and unfairly dismissed a claim under rule 47, ordering relisting for an in-person trial before a different panel.
- Rohit Vikal & Anor v April Freke [2025] EAT 206 25 November 2025 This appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal challenged one of eight findings of sexual harassment made by an Employment Tribunal, focusing on an incident where the respondent allegedly refused to give the claimant her car keys and repeatedly asked her to chat. The appellants argued the Tribunal wrongly accepted the claimant's uncontradicted evidence without cross‑examination and impermissibly relied on other findings when assessing credibility. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the Tribunal was entitled to accept the unchallenged eyewitness evidence and to assess credibility in the context of the total course of conduct; the original findings and remedy therefore stand.
- Jerzy Lawrynowicz v Bidvest Noonan (UK) Limited [2025] EAT 177 24 November 2025 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's repeated refusal to allow a claimant to amend his claims and its indication it would strike out amended claims after an earlier EAT ruling had characterised the proposed amendments as amplifications rather than new claims. The EAT held the tribunal erred by re‑characterising the amendments contrary to the earlier ruling, by failing properly to assess delay and witness availability (including time consumed by the successful appeal), and by indicating strike out without permitting further specification. The EAT allowed the appeal, permitted the amendment, set aside the ET orders and remitted the matter to a differently constituted ET to determine time‑limit and other procedural steps.
- Dr Graeme Madden v Waracle Limited & Anor [2025] EAT 173 20 November 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal correctly held that Dr Madden was employed by Paystream (an umbrella company) rather than by Waracle. The EAT rejected Dr Madden’s challenge that the Paystream contract was a sham or that an employment contract should be implied with Waracle, finding the ET had applied the correct legal tests and given adequate reasons after looking beyond written documents. The EAT dismissed the appeal, refused late applications to expand grounds or admit fresh evidence, and remitted the matter to the ET to decide remaining issues including a disability discrimination claim against Waracle and a possible statutory notice issue under ERA s86(3) against Paystream.
- K Khan v The Cabinet Office [2025] EAT 163 18 November 2025 This is an appeal by Mr Khan against Judge Burns' strike-out of parts of a second ET1 challenging his 2019 suspension and dismissal after he inserted a personal USB into a work laptop. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld Judge Burns, adopting the earlier Stout tribunal's detailed factual findings and rejecting the permitted grounds (abuse of process/Henderson, issue estoppel/identity, and related victimisation complaints). The appeal was dismissed on the material before the court.
- A v B, the Organisation & Ors [2025] EAT 167 13 November 2025 This appeal concerned the claimant's applications to vary or set aside a permanent Restricted Reporting and Anonymisation Order (RRO) made in earlier Employment Tribunal proceedings. The Tribunal refused to vary or revoke the RRO, finding no cogent evidence of a material reduction in risk and that settlement did not eliminate the Article 8 privacy interests; the EAT treated most grounds as unarguable, upheld the need for the Tribunal orders to stand pending appeal, and made an EAT RRO to "hold the line." The EAT remitted one procedural question about whether a separate RRO was required for an unissued/withdrawn fourth claim.
- M Mettle v HCRG Care Limited [2025] EAT 204 13 November 2025 This appeal concerned Ms Mettle's claim of constructive dismissal and discrimination after three employer actions in 2022: changes to weekend rostering, suspension pending investigation of online comments, and a temporary relocation to Gravesend. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed all three grounds, finding no arguable implied amendment of express contractual terms on the rota point, that the ET's reasons for upholding the suspension were adequate to explain its decision, and that the express contract permitted the temporary workplace change and the ET properly found no breach of mutual trust and confidence. The claimant's appeal was therefore dismissed.
- The Attorney General v Dr Christian Mallon [2025] EAT 168 13 November 2025 The Attorney General obtained an indefinite Restriction of Proceedings Order (RPO) against Dr Christian Mallon after reviewing many Employment Tribunal claims he issued, finding he had habitually and persistently instituted vexatious proceedings without reasonable ground. The judge held an RPO was proportionate and Article 6‑compatible as a filter preserving access to justice for meritorious claims; Dr Mallon's proposed voluntary filter and his disabilities did not negate the need for the statutory RPO. Pending related appeals were stayed.
- A & Anor v C Limited & Ors [2025] EAT 165 12 November 2025 This appeal concerns two former employees who resigned after harassment, victimisation and other breaches; the liability tribunal upheld many complaints and a remedy tribunal awarded compensation but refused ACAS Code uplifts, limited loss periods, rejected personal injury awards for one claimant and miscalculated a quarterly bonus as annual. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found errors of principle in the remedy tribunal’s treatment of ACAS Code compliance, aspects of medical evidence and causation (notably for Ms B) and the bonus calculation, upheld other parts of the remedy decision, and remitted those discrete matters for rehearing by a differently constituted tribunal.
- Secretary of State for Business and Trade v Simran Sahonta & Ors [2025] EAT 166 10 November 2025 This appeal concerned (1) the correct date of a TUPE transfer following a conditional business sale of a bakery, and (2) whether regulation 8(7) TUPE disapplied regulations 4 and 7 because insolvency proceedings had been instituted. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal: the relevant transfer occurred on 21 March 2023 when responsibility as employer passed on Phoenix's restart of production, and regulation 8(7) applied because a provisional liquidator had been appointed on 7 March 2023. The appeal was dismissed and the matter was remitted to the Employment Tribunal to determine the claimants' applications to the national insurance fund under the Employment Rights Act 1996.
- K Taak v DPD Group UK Limited [2025] EAT 174 6 November 2025 This Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the claimant's appeal limited to the narrow ground that the employment judge had accepted the dismissing officer's written evidence that he had considered the claimant's 25 years' service but failed adequately to address apparently contradictory answers he gave in cross‑examination. The EAT held that omission was material to the fairness assessment, remitted the specific factual issue for rehearing before a different judge (permitting further evidence and cross‑examination of the decision‑maker), and left other tribunal findings undisturbed.
- The Scottish Ambulance Service Board v Andrew Chapman [2025] EAT 164 6 November 2025 The claimant submitted an ET1 that ticked "disability" but omitted the mandatory particulars, and the Employment Tribunal accepted and progressed the claim. The respondent argued the form was so devoid of detail that it could not sensibly respond and that staff should have referred the ET1 to an Employment Judge under Rule 12(1)(b). The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal on grounds 1 and 2, finding the ET erred by not referring the claim under Rule 12 and remitted the matter to the ET for Rule 12 consideration by a different Employment Judge.
- Ann Palmer v Surrey & Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust [2025] EAT 172 5 November 2025 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's strike‑out of a zero‑hours worker's holiday pay complaint where payslips and an offer letter described a "WTD pay" of 12.5%. The EAT held the Tribunal erred in law in striking out the claim because there was a core of disputed fact about whether the payments amounted to a transparent, comprehensible rolled‑up holiday pay arrangement capable of being set off. The appeal was allowed and the matter remitted to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal for redetermination.
- D Jallali v The Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis & Anor [2025] EAT 137 5 November 2025 This appeal concerned whether Annex F part 11(1) of the Police Regulations 2003 (pay) should be applied week-by-week or as an annualised cap for part‑time inspectors, and whether Annex O (annual leave) links days of leave to hours worked. The EAT held Annex F must be read consistently with a salaried, annualised regime (payment for hours actually worked up to a 2,080-hour annual cap), and that the employer’s week-by-week 40‑hour cap amounted to less favourable treatment under the PTWR and indirect sex discrimination under s.19 EqA; the ET’s dismissal of the annual-leave claim under Annex O was upheld. The case was remitted to the Employment Tribunal to determine remedy for the successful claims.
- J Mayanja v City of Bradford Metropolitan District Council [2025] EAT 160 4 November 2025 This EAT judgment allowed an appeal by Mr Mayanja after the Employment Tribunal admitted a late-discovered 18 October 2021 email for costs but refused to reopen liability findings. The EAT held the ET should have considered whether that email undermined its central credibility finding which underpinned dismissal of claims; the liability and costs judgments were set aside. The case was remitted to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal to rehear all complaints.
- Peter Sabourin v BT Group Plc [2025] EAT 171 4 November 2025 This EAT appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal properly addressed procedural issues in dismissing Mr Sabourin for capability after a PIP and final written warning. The EAT rejected two grounds but upheld one: the tribunal had failed to deal with a distinct, material contention that the decision-maker (Mr Dalby) had not considered the claimant’s performance after the final warning before deciding to dismiss. The EAT quashed the fairness finding and remitted the case to the same judge to make limited further findings and to re-determine fairness.
- H Thomas v Tindall Riley & Co Ltd [2025] EAT 182 30 October 2025 This appeal concerned an age discrimination claim where the claimant had rejected an offer of £110,000 and alleged less favourable treatment because a later comparator was engaged at a total employer cost of £115,000 (salary plus agency fee). Employment Judge Nicolle struck the claim out as having no reasonable prospect of success, finding the claimant could not show she was treated less favourably than the comparator. The EAT held there was no error of law in that decision and dismissed the appeal.
- D Carabott v London Borough of Newham [2025] EAT 155 29 October 2025 This appeal concerned whether an email of 10 July 2020 (with an attached dismissal letter) was sent, received and read by the claimant by 11 July 2020 for time‑bar purposes. The Employment Tribunal relied on three pieces of circumstantial documentary evidence and the claimant’s own accounts to find the email had been sent/received and that the claimant knew of or had a reasonable opportunity to read the dismissal by 11 July. The EAT held those factual conclusions were open to the Tribunal and not perverse, and dismissed the appeal.
- Zen Internet Limited v Paul Stobart [2025] EAT 153 27 October 2025 This case concerns the fairness of Zen Internet’s dismissal of its CEO, Mr Stobart, for capability (failure to restore profitability). The Employment Tribunal found procedural unfairness but, under Polkey, concluded a fair process would nevertheless have led to dismissal by 31 May 2023. The EAT dismissed Zen’s challenge to the finding of procedural unfairness but allowed the challenge to the Tribunal’s Polkey assessment, holding the Tribunal wrongly confined the counterfactual to events after 17 March 2023 and gave inadequate reasons for the 31 May 2023 timing; the Polkey issue was remitted for reconsideration.
- B Gurney v M Randall & Ors [2025] EAT 154 23 October 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in refusing a wasted costs order against the claimant's representative, Mr Sprack, after the Tribunal found the claimant was truly self‑employed and the claims lacked jurisdiction. The Tribunal accepted there were deficiencies in Mr Sprack’s conduct (failure to particularise an age claim, limited written advice on costs, poor explanation of settlement rationale, late withdrawal of a defendant) but held the high threshold for a wasted costs order was not met. The EAT dismissed the appeal and the Tribunal’s refusal to make a wasted costs order stood.
- J C Betancourt v United Kingdom Research and Innovation [2025] EAT 148 23 October 2025 The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed Mr Betancourt’s appeal, finding his immediate dismissal with payment of five weeks’ pay was wrongful because there was no contractual payment‑in‑lieu‑of‑notice clause. However, applying the "least burdensome" lawful method of termination, the judge concluded the employer would lawfully have dismissed with five weeks’ notice effective 15 March 2023 and paid the same amount, so no compensatory award was payable. The appeal therefore succeeded on liability but resulted in no damages or ACAS uplift.
- W Huntley v Siemens Healthcare Ltd [2025] EAT 152 23 October 2025 This appeal concerned a Tribunal costs order of £7,500 awarded to Siemens after a two-part liability hearing in claims brought by Mr Huntley, including disability discrimination and unfair dismissal. The principal legal issue was whether Rule 76(1)(b) requires that a claim must have had no reasonable prospect of success only at the outset of proceedings; the EAT held a Tribunal may assess that issue with reference to a particular past point after proceedings began. The EAT found no error of law in the Tribunal’s two-stage approach (threshold then discretion), its reasons, or its exercise of discretion and dismissed the appeal, upholding the costs order.
- J Ellard & Ors v Alliance Transport Technologies Limited UK [2025] EAT 169 22 October 2025 This appeal concerns whether an employer was "proposing to dismiss" 20 or more employees within 90 days, thereby triggering collective consultation under TULR(C)A 1992, following administrators' appointment and failed sale discussions in May 2023. The EAT held the ET applied the wrong test by focusing on a single fixed proposal instead of whether there was a proposal to dismiss the requisite number within the statutory period. The EAT substituted the ET’s decision, finding that on the available evidence there was a provisional intention to close unless a sale succeeded and awarded three appellants 90 days' protective pay from 2 May 2023.
- J Davidson v National Express Limited [2025] EAT 151 21 October 2025 This appeal concerned a coach driver dismissed after failing breath tests; the tribunal found dismissal unfair only because the employer’s internal appeal was procedurally flawed. The EAT rejected challenges to most of the tribunal’s findings and reductions (Polkey, contributory conduct, ACAS uplift) but held the tribunal erred by capping future loss at age 65 without properly evaluating the claimant’s evidence that he would have worked to age 70, and remitted past and future loss for fresh assessment.
- Tom Simpson v Unite the Union [2025] EAT 149 16 October 2025 This is an EAT appeal by Tom Simpson against the Certification Officer’s remitted decision that there was no breach of Unite’s disciplinary rules by reason of apparent predetermination by Mr Gillespie. The EAT rejected Simpson’s three grounds (misapplication of the apparent‑bias test; supposed attribution to the hypothetical observer of comparative practice about other unions; and alleged failure to take into account evidence or give adequate reasons) and dismissed the appeal, leaving the Certification Officer’s remitted decision intact.
- Tesco Stores Limited v K Element & Ors [2025] EAT 159 15 October 2025 This EAT disposal ruling deals with remitting parts of a Stage 2 equal value matter back to the same Employment Tribunal following appeal. The EAT limited remittal to the specific examples cited in the successful grounds of appeal, except where an error of principle or an "infecting" anchor-comparator error justified wider reconsideration, and directed use of a revised spreadsheet-style Record of Dispute/EVJD to assist Stage 2 fact-finding and independent experts. The EAT refused proposals that would widen remit beyond successful grounds or require verbatim insertion of training materials into the new format.
- DBP v Scottish Ambulance Service [2025] EAT 147 13 October 2025 This appeal concerned an Employment Judge's repeated on‑paper refusals to make a permanent anonymity order for a claimant who had disclosed prior self‑harm and an overdose in ET proceedings. The EAT held the judge was plainly wrong to refuse the post‑hearing application without giving the claimant a realistic, time‑limited opportunity to obtain and serve medical evidence or to list an oral hearing, and allowed the appeal. The matter was remitted to a different Employment Judge for reconsideration and a temporary anonymity order (cipher "DBP") was made pending that reconsideration.
- K Element & Ors v Tesco Stores Limited [2025] EAT 145 9 October 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal lawfully gave Tesco permission to call economist expert evidence in a large equal pay MFD hearing without sufficiently identifying the pleaded issues the experts would address. The EAT concluded the Tribunal's Second and Third Expert Evidence Decisions were wrong because the issues were not properly identified and the parameters of expert evidence were not firmly nailed down. The orders granting permission were set aside and the parties were directed to file further written submissions for disposal on paper (unless a hearing is requested).
- M Shubita v The University of Leeds Beckett & Ors [2025] EAT 157 9 October 2025 This appeal concerned the strike out of the claimant's consolidated claim against Warwick at a preliminary hearing and whether the Employment Tribunal gave him reasonable notice and opportunity to respond under rule 37(2). The EAT held the strike out was procedurally unfair for lack of reasonable notice, overturned the strike out, dismissed the submission that rule 54 required a fixed 14‑day notice, and remitted the matter to the Leeds Employment Tribunal for reallocation.
- O’Brien v Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Foundation Trust [2025] EAT 156 9 October 2025 This appeal concerned a disabled ward manager's claims of failure to make reasonable adjustments and unfair dismissal after disciplinary proceedings arising from alleged missed hours. The EAT found the tribunal erred by applying the time-extension test to the wrong reasonable-adjustment complaint and by failing properly to assess how the employer's delay affected the claimant's ability to defend the disciplinary charges. The EAT remitted both issues for reconsideration with directions about when time began to run and about giving proper weight to findings on delay; it did not substitute its own decision.
- Evans v Prospect & Ors [2025] EAT 143 8 October 2025 Evans appealed the Certification Officer's decisions to strike out his complaints about a precautionary suspension and an election statement and to refuse acceptance of a further application. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found no actual, automatic or real possibility of apparent bias, upheld strike-out of the suspension complaints, allowed the appeal on the election-code point and remitted that complaint to the CO, and allowed the challenge to non-acceptance of the 8 June 2022 application but proposed to strike that application out as apparently vexatious unless Evans shows cause.
- Partnership of East London Co-Operatives Ltd v Joanne MacLean [2025] EAT 142 7 October 2025 This appeal concerned whether a Clinical Streamer who invoiced via her limited company was contracted with the respondent personally and whether she was a worker or employee throughout 2018–2023. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s finding that the contract was with the claimant personally (PAD/MA signed by the individual) but quashed the tribunal’s conclusions on substitution/personal service and on mutuality of obligation as insufficiently reasoned. The tribunal’s findings that she was a worker/employee were therefore set aside insofar as they depended on those defective findings, and the EAT directed further steps.
- Ann Henderson v GCRM Limited & Ors [2025] EAT 136 6 October 2025 This appeal concerns an embryologist dismissed after disciplinary proceedings who claimed protection for whistleblowing under s103A and liability of managers under s47B(1A)/(1B) ERA. The EAT held the Tribunal failed to apply the Royal Mail v Jhuti analysis properly to the s103A principal‑reason question and remitted that complaint for reconsideration. The EAT also ruled it was unlawful to extend Jhuti to create personal liability under s47B(1A)/(1B) by attributing another employee’s motive to an innocent dismissing officer, and dismissed the s47B claims against the respondents on the Tribunal’s factual findings.
- J Alom v The Financial Conduct Authority [2025] EAT 138 30 September 2025 This is an appeal by J Alom challenging summary dismissal by the FCA for allegedly sending a harassing anonymous email (23 Jan 2020) and a later breach‑of‑confidence email. The Employment Tribunal found, on balance, the claimant authored the 23 January email and dismissed unfair dismissal and discrimination complaints; the EAT rejected multiple procedural grounds of appeal and dismissed the appeal. The EAT held the challenged procedural matters (non‑disclosure of wider interview transcripts, an Operation Orion IT search, an HR "script", and delay in reserved reasons) did not create a real risk of unfairness or vitiate the tribunal's decision.
- Dr Kate Barry v Upper Thames Medical Group & Ors [2025] EAT 146 25 September 2025 This appeal concerned whether a GP claimant had affirmed her employment contract before resigning in response to her employer stopping contractual sick pay. The Employment Tribunal found affirmation from delay and other conduct and dismissed her constructive unfair dismissal claim; the EAT held that finding was an error and substituted a conclusion that she had not affirmed and was unfairly dismissed, remitting remedy to the ET.
- Charles Vessey v Richmond Photography Limited [2025] EAT 135 23 September 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Judge was entitled to treat a counsel‑prepared Note of 24 March 2023, adopted at hearing, as the exhaustive statement of the discrimination complaints the Claimant sought to add rather than an earlier 11 January 2023 email. The EAT held the EJ was entitled to construe the Note as accurately and exhaustively summarising the amendments sought, to limit the direct discrimination claim to dismissal‑related matters and to treat other earlier complaints (e.g. WhatsApp exclusion, in‑employment reasonable‑adjustments complaints) as abandoned. The appeal was dismissed and directions for the substantive ET hearing remain.
- Yoosefinejad v East Space Ltd [2025] EAT 150 23 September 2025 The EAT allowed the claimant's appeal against an ET judgment that dismissed his claim for contractual notice pay. The ET had decided the case on an unpleaded basis — that the claimant committed a repudiatory breach accepted by the employer — which the EAT held was an error of law, and it substituted judgment that the claimant was entitled to his full contractual notice pay. Other grounds of appeal were not decided as unnecessary.
- Elaina Cohen v Khalid Mahmood MP [2025] EAT 134 18 September 2025 This appeal concerns whether a non‑party remote observer may obtain tribunal documents after observing a Rule 3(10) EAT hearing. The Employment Judge allowed remote attendance but refused repeated requests for ET1, ET3, notice of appeal and skeletons, concluding the applicant had not shown the documents were necessary to advance open justice and that disclosure posed disproportionate administrative and privacy risks. The appeal against refusal was dismissed.
- Liliana Vassallo v Mizuho International Plc & Anor [2025] EAT 131 17 September 2025 The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the Respondents' costs application under Rule 34A after finding that one ground of the Claimant's appeal was misconceived and that the Claimant acted unreasonably in several procedural respects (including failures to comply with Practice Direction requirements and disputing other parties' notes without providing her own). The EAT refused permission to extend time or to review, declined to make a wasted costs order against Counsel under Rule 34C, and awarded reduced costs of £1,000 overall against the Claimant in light of her limited means.
- N Ahmed v Capital Arches Group Limited [2025] EAT 133 17 September 2025 Mr Ahmed appealed against EJ Klimov’s preliminary decision that his race and religion/belief discrimination complaints were out of time and that it was not just and equitable to extend time. The EAT held the live complaints related to conduct ending in October 2018 (a one‑off change of duties) and did not constitute “conduct extending” to July 2021, upheld the tribunal’s assessment of prejudice to the respondent from extending time, and rejected the contention that the absence of the claimant’s manager as a witness made the PH unfair. The appeal was dismissed.
- Golam Chowdhury v Network Rail Infrastructure Limited [2025] EAT 132 16 September 2025 This Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed Mr Chowdhury’s appeal against a tribunal decision rejecting his claims of disability discrimination and failure to make reasonable adjustments after he was dismissed for capability. The EAT upheld findings that alternative roles (including helpdesk and receptionist) were not suitable adjustments because he lacked essential criteria and appropriate engagement, and that delay or additional training was not required. The EAT also refused late amendments to add new causes of action and found no error in treating proportionality under s.15 as materially aligned with the reasonable adjustments analysis on the facts.
- Sandra Ashley v Walk the Walk Family Support Service Community [2025] EAT 144 16 September 2025 This is an EAT appeal by a former CEO claiming disability discrimination under s.15 EA and unfair dismissal. The EAT rejected challenges that the ET should have reframed the s.15 complaint despite an agreed list of issues and that procedural overlap (investigators also making dismissal decision) rendered dismissal unfair when an independent appeal was offered but not pursued. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal’s findings upheld.
- Shane Maltby v Chestnut Inns Limited [2025] EAT 130 12 September 2025 This appeal concerned whether the employment tribunal should have identified or enquired about a previously unpleaded "claw syndrome" (ulnar nerve injury) as a distinct disability and whether it erred in refusing reconsideration to allow reliance on it or new evidence. The EAT held the tribunal had fairly elicited and recorded the claimant’s pleaded disabilities, was not required to identify an unpleaded impairment that did not plainly emerge from the case papers, and did not err in refusing reconsideration. Both grounds of appeal were dismissed and the tribunal’s substantive decision and refusal to reconsider were upheld.
- P Kirby v Royal Mail Group Limited [2025] EAT 141 11 September 2025 This appeal arises from the summary dismissal of Mr Kirby, a postman with an accepted mental health disability, after workplace incidents and abusive Facebook posts in October 2019. The Employment Tribunal found his misconduct did not "arise in consequence of" his disability under s.15 Equality Act 2010 and that dismissal was a proportionate response; the EAT dismissed the appeal, finding no error of law. The EAT also held that omission of the claimant's suicidal remark from the OH referral did not, as a matter of law, undermine the OH report.
- P Mallik v Arriva Kent and Surrey Limited [2025] EAT 139 9 September 2025 The EAT allowed Miss Mallik's appeal against the Employment Tribunal's strike‑out of her equal value equal pay claim, finding procedural and reasoning defects, and remitted that part of the claim for rehearing before a different tribunal. The EAT concluded the Tribunal failed to identify the correct statutory/regulatory basis, gave inadequate reasons and (appearing to act under Schedule 3) failed to give the required notice and opportunity to address s.131(6) matters. The separate complaint that a reasonable‑adjustments (toilet) issue was omitted from the list of issues was dismissed.
- BS Eaton Limited v A Hughes [2025] EAT 140 3 September 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal misdirected itself on who bore the burden of proof about an employee's readiness, willingness and ability to work following layoff, suspension and a failed mediation. The EAT held the Tribunal erred by requiring the employer to prove the employee was not ready, willing and able to return and remitted the case for a short rehearing on that single issue, with existing factual findings preserved. No other findings were disturbed.
- X v Y & Ors [2025] EAT 128 1 September 2025 This appeal concerned whether a claimant who filed a Notice of Appeal in time but omitted required documents could obtain an extension to treat the appeal as properly instituted. HHJ Tayler held the omission was a genuine, minor mistake, the claimant acted with reasonable dispatch once notified, and granted extensions under amended Rule 37(5) and Rule 37(1), treating the appeal as within time so it may proceed to sift. The judge noted respondents should reassess similar objections in light of the Rule 37(5) amendment.
- AB v Grafters Group Ltd (t/a CSI Catering Services International) [2025] EAT 126 28 August 2025 This appeal addressed whether sexual harassment by a colleague (CD) that occurred away from work was "in the course of employment" under s.109 Equality Act 2010. The Employment Tribunal found harassment occurred but held it was not in the course of employment and so dismissed the employer's liability. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the claimant's appeal, finding the ET failed to consider whether the out-of-work conduct was an extension of employment or had a sufficient nexus with work, and remitted the case for reconsideration on those questions.
- O Argence-Lafon v Ark Syndicate Management Limited [2025] EAT 124 22 August 2025 This is an appeal from an Employment Tribunal decision in which the claimant, a senior underwriter, was found to have made three protected disclosures (D1–D3) but not four later disclosures (D4–D7); two detriments were found but not to have been caused by the protected disclosures, and dismissal was held unfair on procedural grounds. The EAT rejected most challenges as impermissible re‑arguing of factual findings but found a legal error in the Tribunal’s failure to assess the fairness of the appeal stage when applying s.98(4), and remitted that limited issue for reconsideration. The ET’s refusal of the claimant’s reconsideration application was upheld.
- Dr Christopher Day v Lewisham and Greenwich NHS Trust [2025] EAT 123 19 August 2025 Dr Christopher Day appealed Employment Tribunal decisions dismissing his whistleblowing detriment claim arising from statements and letters published after settlement of earlier litigation, and the Tribunal’s refusal of his costs application. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) found two legal errors by the Tribunal (failure to decide one pleaded issue and an incorrect approach to whether detriments were "in employment") but held those errors immaterial and dismissed the appeals, upholding the Tribunal’s findings that most complained statements were true, causation was not established, and costs should not be awarded.
- J Samra v The London Borough of Islington [2025] EAT 162 19 August 2025 This appeal challenges a £15,000 Employment Tribunal costs order against the claimant after dismissal of his race discrimination claims. The EAT held the ET erred in law by failing to apply the required three‑part inquiry when concluding the claim had no reasonable prospect of success and remitted the costs application to a freshly constituted tribunal. The EAT also found the ET should have used the "in all the circumstances" discretionary test and given fuller analysis of the claimant's means.
- Mark Craven v Forrest Fresh Foods Limited [2025] EAT 121 14 August 2025 This appeal concerned whether payments labelled as dividends or director's loans meant an employee who was also appointed a director ceased to be entitled to PAYE salary and statutory sick pay. The Employment Tribunal found the claimant remained an employee but had acquiesced to payment in his capacity as a director and so lost entitlement; the EAT held that conclusion perverse. The EAT remitted the case for rehearing because the Tribunal failed to make necessary factual findings and misapplied legal principles about contracts, duties and the significance of payment labels.
- Andras Szucs v Greensquare Areaccord Ltd [2025] EAT 110 12 August 2025 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's striking out of the claimant's Second Claim (unsuccessful job applications) as an abuse of process under Henderson v Henderson because those matters could and should have been amended into the earlier First Claim (dismissal/victimisation) before its final hearing. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the Tribunal did not err in concluding the claimant should have applied to amend and that the lack of contemporaneous medical evidence or explanation supported that conclusion. It was unnecessary to decide separately whether the Second Claim lacked reasonable prospects or was out of time.
- L O Orrego v Clean Free Limited [2025] EAT 161 12 August 2025 This appeal concerned a £50 deposit order imposed by an Employment Tribunal on an amended indirect sex discrimination claim related to short‑notice sickness and childcare leave. The EAT held the ET erred by failing to construe the pleadings as a whole and by treating a potentially defective PCP in isolation, revoked the deposit order and allowed the claim to proceed on the existing amended particulars. The EAT did not remit for rehearing and left any further amendment or particulars to the tribunal to consider.
- CX v Secretary of State for Justice [2025] EAT 114 8 August 2025 This appeal concerns the Employment Appeal Tribunal's decision upholding a tribunal judge’s refusal to allow a claimant to amend her ET1, after disclosure, to add disability discrimination and failure-to-make-reasonable-adjustments claims based on depression and anxiety. The tribunal found the proposed amendment would introduce materially new legal and factual issues (including whether the claimant was “disabled”), raise time-limit and disclosure/witness/hearing-time prejudice, and that a four-month unexplained delay after disclosure weighed against allowing amendment. The EAT dismissed the appeal, finding no error in the tribunal’s balancing exercise.
- Martin Andrew & Anor v The Scottish Ministers [2025] EAT 117 8 August 2025 Two SPS prisoner management officers appealed an employment tribunal’s dismissal of their unfair dismissal claims after disciplinary findings they used inappropriate force. They argued the employer failed to investigate certain lines of inquiry and that the tribunal erred in law or made perverse factual findings. The EAT upheld the tribunal, finding the investigation, viewed as a whole, fell within the reasonable band and that unraised internal lines of inquiry were not necessarily material to the reasonableness of dismissal. The appeals were dismissed.
- NHS Education Scotland v Dr Hazel Hiram [2025] EAT 115 7 August 2025 This is an appeal by NHS Education Scotland against Employment Tribunal findings that a panel chair knew the full circumstances of a prior dispute and had been dishonest, findings which supported the claimant's successful discrimination and victimisation claims. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the ET reached factual conclusions unsupported by evidence and made a serious procedural error by concluding dishonesty without giving the witness an opportunity to address that allegation. The appeal was allowed and the ET's findings in the claimant's favour were set aside.
- Jamshid Aslam v Transport UK London Bus Ltd [2025] EAT 113 6 August 2025 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's immediate reconsideration which overturned its initial finding that Transport for London Bus Ltd (the respondent) victimised Jamshid Aslam by withdrawing a conditional job offer because it believed he might bring a discrimination complaint. The EAT held the Tribunal erred in treating that s.27(1)(b) (belief that the claimant may do a protected act) basis as outside the pleaded case and in failing to carry out the broader "interests of justice" assessment required on reconsideration. The EAT revoked the reconsideration decision, reinstated the original finding of victimisation, and remitted the matter for remedy.
- Mach Recruitment Ltd v Maria Oliveira [2025] EAT 107 1 August 2025 This appeal concerned whether, immediately before a change of supplier, there was an "organised grouping of employees" whose principal purpose was to carry out activities for a particular client (Butcher's) so as to trigger a TUPE service provision change. The Employment Judge found a settled group of Alutray operatives servicing Butcher's and that the respondent agency had assumed those activities; that finding was open on the evidence and not perverse. The appeal was dismissed, upholding the tribunal's conclusion that a service provision change occurred.
- A Bansal-McNulty v Queens Park Rangers Football and Athletic Club Limited & Ors [2025] EAT 120 31 July 2025 This appeal concerned an Employment Judge's refusal to order disclosure of documents from an FA disciplinary investigation ("FA bundle") in a race-discrimination/victimisation claim by a professional footballer. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Judge misapplied the specific-disclosure test by failing to first ask whether the documents were likely to assist or adversely affect any party's case and by treating the material as necessarily subject to CPR 31.22 collateral-use restrictions. The EAT allowed the appeal, set aside the refusal insofar as infected by legal error, and invited further submissions on disposal.
- L Akester & Ors v Burlington Care (Yorkshire) Ltd & Ors [2025] EAT 111 31 July 2025 This appeal concerned whether departmental Guidance and DHSC materials made the Secretary of State and DHSC co‑liable with care‑home employers for indirect discrimination under ss111–112 EA 2010 arising from vaccination entry regulations. The EAT upheld the ET’s strike‑out of claims against the SoS and DHSC, holding the Guidance did not narrow “clinical reasons”, did not instruct/induce/knowingly help unlawful discrimination, and that schedule 22 (and where relevant schedule 3) can exempt conduct done “pursuant to” the regulation. The claim against employers for unfair dismissal and indirect discrimination was left undetermined.
- Soufiane Amajane v Metroline Travel Limited [2025] EAT 122 31 July 2025 This appeal concerned whether the claimant was still employed when Metroline dismissed him on 27 January 2020, given an ambiguous resignation and events on 22 January 2020. The EAT held the Tribunal erred in failing to consider whether the parties agreed on 22 January to defer the effective date of the resignation and remitted that factual issue for the Tribunal to decide after hearing live evidence. The EAT refused the claimant's request for a differently constituted Tribunal.
- Tesco Stores Limited v K Element & Ors [2025] EAT 112 31 July 2025 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal decision on a Stage 2 equal value appeal by Tesco about how the tribunal defined "work" and the use of employer training materials in determining what employees were required to do. The EAT upheld some legal and factual errors identified in specific findings (e.g. treatment of productivity targets, time pressure, risks/hazards, faulty equipment, time of day/overtime, physical effort/monitoring/working environment/mental arithmetic) but rejected a broad challenge that the tribunal fundamentally misunderstood "work" or made training determinative. The appeal therefore succeeds in part; the EAT will decide disposal and further case management for Stage 3 at a separate hearing.
- The Executor or Personal Representative of Iqbal Khan v A Vijendran [2025] EAT 125 30 July 2025 This EAT allowed an appeal by the executor of Iqbal Khan against an Employment Tribunal award for redundancy and holiday pay because the Tribunal refused to give written reasons and refused to consider the respondent’s written submissions on remedy despite inconsistent/unexplained numerical calculations underpinning the award. The EAT found the Tribunal’s calculations for weeks’ pay and holiday pay were unexplained and could not be upheld, and remitted the matter for reconsideration and proper reasons/consideration of submissions rather than substituting its own decision.
- Raymond Saul & Co LLP v Billy Rashbrook [2025] EAT 129 29 July 2025 This appeal concerned the construction of an employment commission clause and whether the ET was wrong to reject the respondent's apportionment evidence. The EAT held the clause entitled commission only on profit costs in respect of work actually carried out by the employee (not colleagues' work) and that there was contemporaneous evidence permitting apportionment. Applying the corrected construction and the ET's factual findings about supervision and other contributors, the EAT concluded the claimant could not realistically meet the commission threshold and dismissed the claim.
- K Mesuria v Eurofins Forensic Services Ltd [2025] EAT 103 24 July 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in conducting a Preliminary Hearing on time points, dismissing an earlier claim as out of time and striking out a later claim without treating the issues properly as either a substantive preliminary issue or a strike out. The EAT held the Tribunal had procedurally and legally erred, failed to make necessary factual findings and balancing on just and equitable extension and on complaints said to extend over a period, and wrongly struck out matters not listed for strike out. The appeals were allowed and the case was remitted to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal.
- E Ewome v BMAT Education [2025] EAT 101 21 July 2025 This is an EAT appeal against an Employment Tribunal dismissal of a direct race discrimination claim about the claimant's 2019/20 PMR (initial pass → recorded fail on instruction from the Executive Headteacher → later recorded as pass). The ET found the claimant had not adduced facts from which discrimination could be inferred because a white comparator (Ms Viccars) was treated in materially the same way, and it upheld its case-management decision to admit an email from the comparator but refuse her live evidence. The EAT dismissed both grounds of appeal and upheld the ET's decision.
- L Chase v Northern Housing Consortium Ltd & Anor [2025] EAT 104 16 July 2025 This is an EAT appeal by Ms Chase against an Employment Tribunal judgment in her claims including whistleblowing detriment, reasonable-adjustment failures and disability discrimination. The EAT found the Tribunal’s long delay and poorly reasoned written decision contained errors of law and/or denied a fair hearing, allowed the appeal in part and remitted the case for a rehearing before a different tribunal; it upheld the tribunal’s factual findings on timing of disability and on direct discrimination but found legal error in the Tribunal’s approach to protection under s.43C(2) ERA and in its failure to address pleaded reasonable-adjustment allegations.
- Hafeez Ahmed v Department for Work and Pensions [2025] EAT 118 15 July 2025 This appeal concerned whether apparent bias arose from two intemperate emails by a lay Employment Tribunal member (Mrs Fox) combined with the Employment Judge's later recusal, and whether prior refusal of permission on bias estopped reliance on the emails. The EAT held that the emails together with the judge's recusal created an appearance of bias (including indirectly as to the other lay member) and that issue estoppel did not bar reliance on the emails in the changed circumstances. The appeal was allowed and the case remitted for rehearing before a newly constituted panel.
- Ladbrokes Betting & Gaming Limited v Wahida Omi [2025] EAT 99 14 July 2025 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal finding that Ladbrokes directly discriminated against Ms Omi by offering a colleague increased hours at the Watling Street site while not offering her the same increase, and that the treatment was linked to a perceived lack of flexibility as a proxy for her disability. The Tribunal also found Ms Omi resigned in response to repudiatory breaches and did not affirm the contract, amounting to constructive and unfair dismissal. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed Ladbrokes' appeal and upheld those findings.
- Swansea City & County Council v D Abraham & Ors [2025] EAT 93 11 July 2025 This appeal challenged an employment judge's refusal to recuse herself from case management in a large equal‑pay group claim on grounds of apparent bias arising from her prior work as a solicitor. The EAT held the judge applied the correct Porter "fair‑minded and informed observer" test, was entitled to rely on Locabail and to hear the application herself, and the appellant did not show a real possibility of bias; both appeals were dismissed and the case management orders stand.
- Y Chen v Coach Stores Ltd [2025] EAT 108 10 July 2025 This appeal concerned whether a tribunal legal officer wrongly rejected a claim because the respondent named on the ET1 did not match the prospective respondent on the ACAS early conciliation certificate. The EAT held the legal officer erred by failing to apply rule 12(2A)’s two-stage “error” and “interests of justice” test and concluded the misnaming was an error and it was not in the interests of justice to reject the claim. The EAT allowed the appeal and substituted a decision that the claim may proceed against Coach Stores Limited.
- Antony Savva v Leather Inside Out (in liquidation) & Ors [2025] EAT 96 9 July 2025 This appeal concerned multiple employment tribunal claims by Savva against his former employer and others, including whistleblowing (protected disclosure) complaints, unfair dismissal, discrimination and complaints about refusals/non-responses to subject access requests (SARs). The EAT upheld many pre-hearing time-limit findings but quashed a deposit order for two in-time SAR-related complaints, and remitted to a different tribunal the merits decisions on three identified PIDs (3, 10 and 11), the SAR-refusal detriment findings and the undetermined complaint about non-response to a later SAR. Other factual findings not challenged remain standing.
- James Marshall v McPherson Limited [2025] EAT 100 9 July 2025 This is an EAT appeal by James Marshall challenging an ET dismissal of his constructive unfair dismissal claim against McPherson Ltd, focusing on the "last straw" doctrine. The EAT found the ET had correctly stated the law but misdirected itself by saying a non‑repudiatory act cannot revive earlier breaches, which was a legal error undermining confidence in the ET's conclusion that there was no final straw. The EAT allowed that ground of appeal and remitted the case for rehearing before a freshly constituted tribunal. The EAT rejected a standalone perversity challenge and did not substitute its own findings.
- AYZ v BZA [2025] EAT 91 8 July 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 1992 required permanent anonymity for the Appellant who had made a police allegation of a sexual offence (April 2023; email June 2024) against the Respondent, and whether anonymity must extend to both ET and EAT judgments to prevent jigsaw identification. The EAT held the 1992 Act applied even though there had been no arrest or charge, that the Act’s protections can extend to judgments in non‑criminal proceedings, and that permanent anonymity in both ET and EAT was necessary; the Employment Judge’s refusal was not shown to be erroneous on the material before them.
- Syed Asim Raza Gillani & Ors v Veezu Limited & Ors [2025] EAT 97 8 July 2025 This appeal concerned a tribunal case management order requiring 509 claimants in a multi-claim drivers case to provide extensive particulars about “multi-apping” and availability. The EAT held the original order was irrational and disproportionate and set it aside, substituting a narrower regime: full particulars from 12 potential lead claimants and a verified questionnaire for 125 randomly selected claimants limited to a two‑year period. The EAT also held it may, in appropriate cases, substitute its own case management order under s.35(1)(a) rather than remit.
- J Logo v Payone GmbH & Ors [2025] EAT 95 7 July 2025 This appeal concerns three alleged acts of racial harassment at work and whether two substantiated acts were time‑barred and whether a circulated WhatsApp video was "related to" race or had the requisite harassing effect under s.26 Equality Act 2010. The EAT found legal errors in the Employment Tribunal's analysis of the s.26(1) "related to" and s.26(1)(b)/s.26(4) "effect" questions in relation to the Pure Blonde video, and in the Tribunal's exercise of the wide s.123 discretion to extend time for two substantiated incidents (black face and crude dinner remark). The EAT remitted those limited issues for redetermination by the original Tribunal, leaving most other factual findings intact.
- BCA Logistics Ltd v Brian Parker & Ors [2025] EAT 94 4 July 2025 This is an EAT appeal against an ET finding that 422+ drivers engaged as self‑employed by BCA Logistics were "workers" because a written substitution clause was not genuinely operable in practice. BCAL argued the ET erred by treating the absence of current/recent driver witnesses as a "striking gap" and by discounting substitution enquiries generated after litigation began. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the "striking gap" was a passing observation not amounting to adverse inference or legal misdirection, and that the ET was entitled to give little weight to late, litigation‑driven substitution evidence; the ET's finding that the drivers were workers was upheld.
- Philip Rush v Wilts & Dorset Bus Company Ltd [2025] EAT 119 1 July 2025 This appeal to the EAT challenged a Southampton Employment Tribunal's dismissal of discrimination claims and its small awards (£202.52) for unpaid sick pay, holiday pay and one 20‑minute overtime underpayment. The EAT dismissed all five grounds of appeal, holding the ET had not erred in refusing an uplift under s207A TULRCA for alleged ACAS Code non‑compliance, in refusing a statutory two–four week award for lack of written particulars, in its factual findings about overtime and Saturday enhancements, or in its holiday pay calculation. The ET’s findings and the original award were upheld.
- JP v Spelthorne Borough Council [2025] EAT 127 26 June 2025 The appeal challenged a preliminary Employment Judge decision that the claimant was not disabled under the Equality Act 2010 for the period December 2019 to 17 January 2021. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (Judge Keith) held the EJ had reasonably identified the relevant period from the pleadings and impact statement and was entitled to decide disability without first identifying every specific alleged act; the court also held the pleadings did not show that post-dismissal appeal conduct extended the relevant period. Both amended grounds of appeal were dismissed and the EJ’s preliminary decision that the appellant was not disabled stands.
- S Bailey v Aviva Employment Services Ltd [2025] EAT 109 24 June 2025 This appeal concerned a litigant-in-person who made repeated, unsubstantiated allegations of corruption, racism and collusion against the respondent and the tribunal during case management hearings. The employment tribunal found the conduct scandalous and unreasonable but decided, applying proportionality and Bolch-type considerations, that a fair trial remained possible and refused to strike out or to recuse; the EAT dismissed the claimant’s appeal and the merits hearing later dismissed the substantive claims.
- Gavin Granger v Scottish Fire & Rescue Service [2025] EAT 90 23 June 2025 This is an appeal by Gavin Granger against an ET finding that his dismissal following an IQMP ill‑health retirement assessment was fair for "some other substantial reason" rather than for capability. The EAT held the ET erred in law by treating the IQMP outcome as the substantive reason for dismissal instead of as an outcome of an ongoing capability process, and remitted the case to the ET to reassess fairness starting from incapability. Factual findings were not disturbed; the ET must also revisit the linked s.15 Equality Act claim if necessary.
- C Mileham v Zeus Limestone Ltd (T/A Rovic Tiles) (In Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation) & Anor [2025] EAT 105 19 June 2025 This appeal concerned the Employment Judge's refusal to allow the Claimant to amend proceedings to add "Mr Doe" as a second respondent in a disability discrimination and unfair dismissal claim. The EAT held the refusal was legally erroneous and unsafe because the Judge failed to identify and weigh the injustice or hardship to the Claimant and gave no adequate explanation of the asserted prejudice to Mr Doe. The EAT set aside the refusal and remitted the amendment application for rehearing by a different Employment Judge.
- Neelam Lal v Driving & Vehicle Standards Agency [2025] EAT 106 19 June 2025 This is an appeal by a driving examiner dismissed after a disciplinary hearing, challenging an Employment Tribunal's dismissal of her claims including direct race and disability discrimination, unfair dismissal and victimisation. The EAT rejected eleven grounds of appeal, holding the Tribunal correctly confined consideration to the pleaded comparator, that the Tribunal’s finding of a composite dismissal reason (belief in a data breach and undermining relationships) was open on the evidence, and that perversity, procedural and victimisation challenges failed. The appeal was refused in full.
- C Raison v DF Capital Bank Ltd & Ors [2025] EAT 86 17 June 2025 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal decision that an unfair dismissal claim was out of time because section 207B(3) ERA only discounts Early Conciliation (EC) days that fall after the effective date of termination (EDT). The EAT rejected the claimant's broader construction that the whole EC period extends the primary three‑month limitation and upheld the ET's finding that it was reasonably practicable to present the claim earlier. The appeal was dismissed and the claim was held to be three days late so the tribunal lacked jurisdiction.
- Harry Stedman v Haven Leisure Ltd [2025] EAT 82 16 June 2025 This is an EAT appeal by Mr Stedman against a tribunal finding that he was not disabled under s.6 Equality Act 2010 after being diagnosed with ASD and ADHD. The EAT found multiple legal errors in the tribunal's approach (including failure to compare functioning with and without the impairment, impermissible weighing of abilities, and misunderstanding that one affected day-to-day activity can suffice) and allowed the appeal, setting aside the decision and remitting the case to a fresh tribunal. One ground of appeal (that the tribunal was bound to accept Professor Fox’s report) was dismissed.
- K Hindmarch v North-East Ambulance NHS Foundation Trust [2025] EAT 87 16 June 2025 The EAT dismissed appeals by an ambulance driver who argued the Trust failed to make reasonable adjustments by refusing an FFP3 mask and that his subsequent dismissal was unfair. The Employment Tribunal had accepted he was disabled and known to the Trust but found there was no real prospect that providing an FFP3 mask would have removed the disadvantage (i.e. enabled his return to work), and the EAT held the ET made no legal error. Both the reasonable-adjustment and unfair-dismissal findings were upheld.
- JK v Ealing Council [2025] EAT 78 13 June 2025 This is an EAT appeal from an ET preliminary hearing about out-of-time unfair dismissal and discrimination/victimisation complaints, and about anonymity. The EAT held the Employment Judge erred in law by treating s.123 Equality Act extension questions as applications to amend rather than applying the statutory "just and equitable" test, made a material factual error about the claimant’s post-termination sickness absences, granted anonymity in the EAT on new medical evidence, allowed two grounds and remitted the time‑limit issues for rehearing before a different tribunal, and dismissed one ground. The ET is to reconsider anonymity in light of the new medical evidence.
- Shirley Okeze v Cygnet Health Care Limited [2025] EAT 88 13 June 2025 This appeal concerns whether an Employment Tribunal erred in deciding remedy at the same hearing as liability in Shirley Okeze’s discrimination and wrongful dismissal claim against Cygnet Health Care. The EAT dismissed the claimant’s challenge, finding no procedural irregularity or unfairness in the ET deciding remedy when parties had case management directions and the claimant had failed to plead or provide quantified evidence of financial loss. The ET’s refusal to reopen remedy and its rejection of the claimant’s reconsideration application were upheld.
- F Ntakibirora Mahoro v The Northern Care Alliance [2025] EAT 85 12 June 2025 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal appeal against an Employment Tribunal’s dismissal of a Band 6 Biomedical Scientist’s claims for disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments, harassment and unfair dismissal following long‑term sickness and dismissal for ill health. The EAT upheld the ET’s findings that the employer reasonably refused some adjustment requests (reduced hours, chair, digital microscope) given safety, workflow and recruitment considerations, that there was no discriminatory unfavourable treatment or harassment, and that dismissal was fair and proportionate. The ET’s finding that the employer’s failure to provide a further statutory written statement was not unreasonable was also upheld. The appeal was dismissed.
- Peder Prähl & Ors v Sebastian Lapinski [2025] EAT 77 12 June 2025 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal in England and Wales had international jurisdiction over three Sweden‑domiciled individual respondents in Equality Act claims brought by a former LLP member. The EAT upheld the tribunal: service in accordance with the Employment Tribunals Rules (or delivery under rule 91) was sufficient to subject overseas defendants to tribunal jurisdiction, and alternatively the amended Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982 s 15C could preserve the Brussels Recast‑style protections and apply on a good arguable case. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal’s jurisdictional decision was upheld.
- Kieron Dominic Scully v Northamptonshire County Council [2025] EAT 83 11 June 2025 This appeal concerned whether Northamptonshire County Council was the appellant's employer where the appellant provided care to his brother S and was paid via direct payments under the Care Act 2014. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the tribunal's factual finding that S (or his mother V acting for him) was the employer, and dismissed arguments that direct payments or S's alleged incapacity made the council the employer or required implying a contract with the council. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal's dismissal of the appellant's discrimination and pay claims was affirmed.
- Charlie Forrest v Amazon Web Services EMEA SARL UK Branch [2025] EAT 81 10 June 2025 This appeal concerned the Employment Judge's strike‑out of the claimant's disability and whistleblowing claims for non‑compliance with a case management order. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held it was an error of law to strike out without first considering whether a fair trial remained possible and without first trying the effect of an unless order, and reinstated the claims with directions for further case management.
- Kwabla Gad v UK Power Networks (Operations) Ltd [2025] EAT 84 10 June 2025 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal (ET) should have inferred victimisation from an internal email and whether three alleged detriments (a performance plan, refusal of a full-shift post, and refusal of 132kv training) were caused by protected acts. The EAT held the ET permissibly concluded the 21 February 2018 email did not support an inference that the protected act caused the detriments and that each detriment had non-discriminatory explanations. The appeal was dismissed and the ET’s dismissal of the victimisation claim was upheld.
- AR Wilson v Network Rail Infrastructure Limited [2025] EAT 80 6 June 2025 This case concerns extensions of time to institute appeals to the Employment Appeal Tribunal where a Notice of Appeal was lodged in time but with missing or incomplete documents. The EAT judge held that omissions which are promptly rectified can be treated as minor errors and granted extensions under rule 37(5), and also allowed an extension under the general discretion in rule 37(1) for a related consolidated claim. The Registrar's earlier refusal was overturned and the appeal was permitted to proceed to sift.
- Dr Nicholas Jones v The Secretary of State for Health and Social Care [2025] EAT 76 4 June 2025 Dr Nicholas Jones, an applicant of African‑Caribbean descent, challenged his non‑appointment after a two‑stage recruitment (paper sift and interview) as direct race discrimination. The EAT found the Employment Tribunal erred in its comparator analysis, including failing to treat Candidate B as an actual/evidential comparator and irrationally rejecting side‑by‑side comparison of interview responses, and remitted the complaint to a different Tribunal for redetermination. The EAT accepted that sift and interview can in principle be treated as separate stages but held the ET should have considered whether race‑influenced treatment at sift affected who reached interview.
- M Willis v GWB Harthills LLP & Ors [2025] EAT 79 3 June 2025 This appeal concerned a costs order made by an Employment Tribunal requiring a former managing partner (the claimant) to pay respondents' costs capped at £210,000 after the Tribunal found serious and dishonest conduct and made no award to the claimant. The claimant challenged the Tribunal's assessment of his ability to pay, its consideration of the impact on his wife and children, and reliance on an estimated profit share; the EAT rejected those grounds and dismissed the appeal. The EAT held the Tribunal lawfully considered ability to pay (at stage 2 and in quantum), was entitled to take the claimant's half‑share in a substantial family home and likely future profit share into account, and properly made a broad‑brush assessment while excluding belated evidence. The original capped costs order, with detailed assessment in the County Court, therefore stands.
- Home Office v Mohammed Shah [2025] EAT 75 29 May 2025 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment allowing the Home Office's appeal against an employment tribunal order requiring a "gist" be provided in closed (national-security) proceedings brought by an Immigration Officer whose security clearance was withdrawn. The EAT held the tribunal erred in its approach to gisting and overstepped by undertaking an evaluative scrutiny inappropriate for employment tribunals assessing Executive national-security assertions, and it failed adequately to have regard to the respondent's closed material. The appeal was allowed and further directions were given about whether the gisting issue should be remitted or decided by the EAT.
- Secretary of State for Business and Trade v V Karpavicius (Debarred) & Anor [2025] EAT 89 29 May 2025 The EAT allowed the Secretary of State's appeal against a tribunal finding that the sole director/shareholder of Prime Aquariums Ltd was an employee and awarded redundancy. The EAT held the tribunal erred in law by treating the claimant's sole shareholding and control as "an irrelevance" to employment status and remitted the limited issue of employment status for rehearing before a different judge. The EAT did not substitute its own factual conclusion and left other tribunal findings (eg effective date of termination and time limits) in place for the rehearing.
- Alastair Dobbie v Paula Felton t/a Feltons Solicitors [2025] EAT 71 28 May 2025 This appeal concerned whether a written Consultancy Agreement entitled Mr Dobbie to 40% of all fees paid to the practice for client A or only 40% of fees attributable to his own consultancy work, and whether an alleged oral retainer could vary the written contract. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal’s construction that clause 3 entitled the claimant to 40% only of fees attributable to his personal work (giving £5,000 per month) and treated the ET’s finding of an oral variation as legally erroneous but immaterial because the written contract produced the same monetary result. The appeal was dismissed and the ET's award for January–February 2016 was upheld.
- C Shawcross v SMG Europe Holdings Limited & Ors [2025] EAT 92 27 May 2025 This appeal challenged an order excluding an accidentally-received seven-email chain between employer and its solicitor as privileged legal advice, on the basis that the iniquity exception did not apply. The Employment Judge reviewed the emails and found they contained legal advice about dismissal risk and a suggestion to involve a senior manager, not advice to fabricate reasons or conceal decision-making. The appellant failed to show, on the balance of probabilities, that the communications contemplated dishonesty or a sham process, so the exclusion order was upheld and the appeal dismissed.
- The Scottish Ministers v James Blair [2025] EAT 74 27 May 2025 This appeal concerned a disability discrimination and reasonable‑adjustments claim by a fixed‑term team leader. The EAT held the ET erred in its direct discrimination analysis by not applying a proper non‑disabled comparator matching both attendance and the performance deficiencies relied on, and dismissed the direct discrimination claim; it also found the identified PCP (a seven‑day absence rule) did not causally put the claimant at a substantial disadvantage and dismissed the s.20(3) claim. The EAT further held the reasonable‑adjustment claims were time‑barred (not a continuing single course of conduct) but remitted a discrete issue to the tribunal because the ET gave insufficient Meek‑compliant reasons when exercising its discretion to extend time.
- AB v CD Ltd [2025] EAT 73 22 May 2025 This is an EAT appeal against an Employment Tribunal decision rejecting claims of disability discrimination and philosophical belief discrimination by a claimant who refused to wear a face mask. The Tribunal found no established impairment on the evidence and that the pleaded belief lacked the cogency required by Grainger; it also found no direct or indirect discrimination. The EAT (Choudhury J) dismissed the appeal and upheld the Tribunal's findings.
- Dr Vikas Chandra v The University and College Union [2025] EAT 70 20 May 2025 Dr Chandra challenged the Certification Officer’s refusal to accept multiple applications alleging unlawful disciplinary procedure by LSE UCU; the Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed his appeal, finding the CO acted beyond her powers by declining to accept applications as “not arguable” where internal procedures had been exhausted. The EAT held the CO could not effectively strike out applications on merits without following the show-cause/opportunity-to-be-heard safeguards in s256ZA and remitted the matters back to the CO for further handling, leaving the substantive numbered grounds undetermined.
- Heather Brady & Ors v North Lanarkshire Council & Ors [2025] EAT 69 15 May 2025 This appeal concerned multiple equal-value claims challenging a series of job evaluations carried out by North Lanarkshire Council under a local Red Book JES (2007–2019). The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, upholding the Employment Tribunal’s detailed factual and credibility findings that some individual evaluations were reasonably suspect but that most evaluations and subsequent re-evaluations were not, and rejecting a contention that one or a few unreliable evaluations tainted the whole local scheme.
- PP v GG Limited [2025] EAT 65 13 May 2025 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal's striking-out of a claimant's multi‑head employment claim after the Tribunal suggested to the respondent that it might apply to strike out, the respondent did so, and the Tribunal granted the application. The EAT held the Tribunal made legal errors by failing to consider relevant supporting material and the claimant's mental‑health/genuine‑belief matters, reached a perverse conclusion that a fair trial was impossible without attempting proportionate management steps, and created an appearance of bias or procedural unfairness by its conduct. The EAT allowed the appeal in part, set aside the strike‑out and remitted the case for further case management to a different panel.
- XY v AB [2025] EAT 66 13 May 2025 This appeal challenged a permanent anonymity order made under Rule 50 after the claimant withdrew her sex‑discrimination and harassment allegations but continued to publish and misrepresent them. The EAT held the Employment Judge had applied the correct two‑stage legal approach and carried out an appropriate fact‑specific balancing exercise, and dismissed the appeal. The permanent anonymity order for the respondent was continued and extended to the EAT proceedings; the EAT also granted permanent anonymity to the appellant for separate reasons.
- Dr Jayprakash Gosalakkal v University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust [2025] EAT 64 12 May 2025 This Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment concerns Dr Gosalakkal’s repeated attempts to reopen and vary a 2015 tribunal liability decision and a 2015 costs order, relying mainly on a 2012 Serious Untoward Incident (SUI) report said to be newly discovered and an allegation of apparent bias from a preliminary hearing remark. The EAT held the SUI report did not meet the test for new evidence that would probably have affected the 2015 outcome, rejected the bias complaint when the remark was read in context, and found no legal error in the tribunal’s extension of time; all appeals and the respondent’s cross‑appeal were dismissed.
- F Djalo v Secretary of State for Justice [2025] EAT 67 12 May 2025 This appeal concerned a strike-out of an indirect race-discrimination claim by a cleaner employed by a contractor (OCS) who sought to challenge pay disparities with Ministry of Justice direct staff, relying on clause 60.1(17) of the FM Contract and s.41 Equality Act 2010. The EAT upheld the ET: s.41 does not allow a contract worker to challenge remuneration payable under their employer’s contract with a principal; clause 60.1(17) was a compensation-event clause referring to governmental introduction of a living wage, not a power for the principal to require the contractor to pay the London Living Wage; the pleaded PCPs failed (one not a proper PCP, the other not shown to have been applied). The appeal was dismissed as bound to fail.
- S Mogane v Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (No 2) [2025] EAT 68 8 May 2025 This EAT judgment concerns how an enhanced redundancy payment already received should be treated when calculating compensation for unfair dismissal where a Polkey reduction applies. The claimant argued the enhanced payment should be included in loss before applying a 50% Polkey reduction and that the deduction for the enhanced payment should itself be pro‑rata; the EAT rejected both arguments and dismissed the appeal. The tribunal’s approach—apply the 50% Polkey reduction to the loss figure and then deduct the full excess of the enhanced payment over the basic award—was upheld, producing a compensatory award of £11,754.05.
- Cable News International Inc v Saima Bhatti [2025] EAT 63 6 May 2025 This case concerned whether a British journalist employed by a US broadcaster fell within the territorial scope of UK employment law and whether the Employment Tribunal had international jurisdiction. The tribunal found, and the EAT upheld, that the claimant became London‑based from 1 March 2017 so alleged wrongs from that date fell within UK territorial scope, and that the Employment Tribunal had international jurisdiction to hear those claims. The appeal was dismissed and the claims may proceed in the Employment Tribunal for acts from 1 March 2017; service via the London bureau did not vitiate jurisdiction.
- Neeraj Handa v The Station Hotel (Newcastle) Limited & Ors [2025] EAT 62 2 May 2025 This appeal concerned a tribunal’s strike‑out of a claimant’s whistleblowing/detriment claims against two external HR consultants (R4 and R5). The EAT held it was arguable that R4 and R5 could be agents when carrying out their investigative/disciplinary remits, but there was no arguable basis to treat them as agents liable for the claimant’s dismissal itself. The tribunal’s strike‑out of the dismissal‑related claims against R4 and R5 was therefore upheld and the appeal dismissed; the claimant may continue claims against the employer and other respondents.
- J Mireku v London Underground Limited [2025] EAT 57 29 April 2025 This is an appeal by a part‑time Customer Service Supervisor, Mr Mireku, against an Employment Tribunal's dismissal of his claim under Regulation 5 of the Part‑Time Workers Regulations alleging cancellation of overtime due to his part‑time status. The EAT held it would follow its prior decision in Augustine and treat Regulation 5(2)(a) as requiring the worker’s part‑time status to be the sole ground of the less favourable treatment until a higher court decides otherwise. Applying that test, and on the Tribunal’s factual findings that the cancellation was caused by administrative confusion and the claimant’s atypical budgeting/managerial arrangements (and that no comparable full‑time worker existed), the appeal was dismissed.
- Brake Bros Ltd v S Hudek [2025] EAT 53 28 April 2025 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal rightly implied a contractual term that the claimant driver should be paid for hours worked in excess of his intended average weekly hours if averaging did not occur. The EAT set aside the tribunal’s implication, holding that the written contract entitled the claimant only to basic pay for five variable-length shifts and to overtime solely where the contract expressly provided for additional half- or full-shifts. The tribunal’s implied term was inconsistent with the express overtime regime and was therefore not permitted; the claim was dismissed.
- Paul Thompson v Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Service [2025] EAT 59 28 April 2025 This is an EAT appeal against an Employment Judge’s refusal to permit the claimant to amend his ET1. The EAT held the judge erred by treating alleged non-compliance with a case management order as determinative and failing to apply the Selkent balancing exercise of injustice and hardship, allowed the appeal in part and remitted the amendment application to a different Employment Tribunal for rehearing. The EAT did not find the judge’s robust language alone showed apparent bias.
- The London Borough of Southwark & Anor v Ayodele Martin [2025] EAT 60 28 April 2025 This is an EAT rehearing of appeals about six whistleblowing detriment findings made by an Employment Tribunal after a fresh hearing. The EAT dismissed the respondents' appeal except that it allowed the claimant's cross-appeal: the Tribunal perversely failed to treat a change to the school's opening hours as a possible detriment without addressing the claimant's particular case, so that issue (including causation for detriment 5(b)) is remitted for reconsideration; the other detriment findings and causation conclusions were upheld as open to the ET on the evidence.
- Glaucia Pereira v Methods Business And Digital Technology Limited [2025] EAT 55 17 April 2025 This is an EAT appeal against an Employment Judge's refusal to permit the claimant to amend her ET1 to add protected disclosure detriment and dismissal claims arising from October 2021 onboarding events. The EAT held the Employment Judge had erred in law in key aspects of her approach to the amendment application, allowed the appeal in part, and remitted the matter to the Employment Tribunal for reconsideration and case management (save for one discrete procedural issue).
- A E Madu v Loughborough College [2025] EAT 52 16 April 2025 This appeal concerned a £20,000 costs order made against a claimant in a race discrimination employment claim who began as a litigant in person and later obtained representation. The EAT held that the Employment Tribunal applied the ordinary legal test for costs but made key errors: it illegitimately inferred the content of privileged legal advice and failed to properly account for the period the claimant was unrepresented and the particular difficulties of discrimination claims. The appeal was allowed, the costs order set aside, and the matter remitted to a differently constituted tribunal to reconsider costs if pursued.
- L. Marshall v East & North Hertfordshire NHS Trust [2025] EAT 46 16 April 2025 This is an EAT appeal by L. Marshall against a Watford employment tribunal judgment dismissing multiple discrimination and redundancy-related complaints after her redundancy in January 2021. The EAT found the tribunal had failed to address one pleaded element of her s.15 Equality Act claim (whether conduct on 21 September 2019 arose from her disability) and remitted that discrete issue to the same tribunal for consideration. The EAT dismissed the remainder of the appeal, upholding the tribunal's conclusion that the redundancy dismissal was fair and that two IPC vacancies in 2020 were not suitable alternatives.
- Gold Panda Limited & Anor v H O'Keefe [2025] EAT 47 15 April 2025 The appellants (two companies) appealed a tribunal costs order under Employment Tribunals Rules r.76(1)(a) after the tribunal found they sought strike-off/dissolution to avoid liability following successful complaints by the claimant. The Employment Appeal Tribunal refused the appeal, holding that acts aimed at making continuation or enforcement of proceedings impossible can amount to "the way that the proceedings...have been conducted" and that the tribunal had not erred in finding intention to avoid liability. The tribunal's award of £8,370.98 jointly and severally against the appellants was upheld.
- Islanders Vets v Gemma Mortland [2025] EAT 72 15 April 2025 This appeal concerned the tribunal's award of notice pay after the claimant resigned on 7 October 2019 and the employer communicated alternative last working dates on 7 and 9 October. The EAT held the tribunal erred by treating those communications as wrongful dismissal rather than acceptance of the resignation and by ignoring the contract term (one week during probation) governing the employer's notice. The notice-pay award beyond one week's pay was set aside; awards for unauthorised deduction and holiday pay remain.
- Katerina Rainwood v Pemberton Capital Advisors LLP [2025] EAT 51 11 April 2025 The EAT dealt with two interlocutory matters in Rainwood v Pemberton Capital Advisors LLP: a consent appeal on LPP/s.43B(4) rulings and an appeal against striking out five whistleblowing-detriment complaints. By consent the ET's LPP conclusions were quashed and remitted to a different judge; the EAT also upheld that permitting witness evidence at the preliminary hearing was not unlawful but found the tribunal erred in striking out the five detriment complaints without first considering or requiring amendment/particularisation, and substituted a refusal to strike out with directions for amendment and case management.
- J Biddulph v Eastern Counties Leather (In Partnerships) [2025] EAT 56 10 April 2025 This is an EAT appeal by J Biddulph against a tribunal finding that a £10,000 December 2019 payment was an interest-free loan, not commission, and that the employer could deduct the outstanding loan from final pay, leaving a respondent counterclaim. The appellant sought to raise a new Consumer Credit Act (CCA 1974) argument on appeal; the EAT refused to permit the new point, admitted limited fresh medical evidence about a respondent witness, and upheld the tribunal’s deductions and calculations. The appeal was dismissed.
- L Barbosa Dethling v Metropolitan Police Service [2025] EAT 58 8 April 2025 This is an EAT appeal concerning a refused in-time amendment to add a post-termination victimisation complaint based on two solicitor emails about the claimant’s warrant card. The tribunal was held to have erred by assessing detriment through its own view of the emails rather than whether the claimant’s subjective reaction was reasonably open, and by applying an unduly binary test on causation. The EAT quashed the tribunal’s refusal and allowed the claimant’s amendment to add the victimisation complaint against the respondent.
- T Duncan v Fujitsu Services Ltd [2025] EAT 44 8 April 2025 This is an appeal from an ET finding that dismissal for offensive Slack messages did not amount to discrimination arising from disability under s.15 EqA. The EAT dismissed the appeal, concluding the claimant had not pleaded or evidenced a direct causal link between his ADHD/ASD and the misconduct, so the ET correctly treated the case as alleging an indirect (Risby-type) link and lawfully carried out the objective proportionality balancing under s.15(1)(b). The ET permissibly found dismissal proportionate given the seriousness of the conduct and consideration of less discriminatory alternatives.
- Tesco Stores Limited v K Element & Ors [2025] EAT 43 28 March 2025 Tesco sought to amend its Notice of Appeal in large stage 2 equal value proceedings to add a long schedule of alleged factual errors (para 52) and a clarification that findings about one comparator applied to others (paras 53–55). The Employment Appeal Tribunal refused para 52 as excessively late, vague and likely to cause delay and prejudice, and allowed paras 53–55 as a permissible clarification subject to respondents' challenge at the final hearing.
- John J Campbell v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust & Anor [2025] EAT 42 27 March 2025 This is an appeal against an employment tribunal’s dismissal of a race harassment claim after a colleague called the claimant a "fucking monkey". The EAT refused the appeal, holding the tribunal had properly assessed whether the remark was made "in the course of" employment by weighing contextual factors and had correctly applied the section 109(4) defence that the employer took all reasonable steps to prevent harassment. The tribunal’s factual findings were treated as matters for its judgment and were not disturbed.
- Helen Kinch v Compassion in World Farming International [2025] EAT 41 26 March 2025 This appeal concerned a tribunal’s decision to strike out a constructive unfair dismissal claim under rule 37 on the basis that the claimant had affirmed the contract by agreeing multiple extensions of her notice period. The EAT found the judge made factual errors and that the question of affirmation depended on disputed or unclear contemporaneous material, so it could not properly be decided on the papers. The strike-out was set aside and the case remitted to a differently constituted tribunal for a full evidential hearing on constructive dismissal, affirmation and related factual issues.
- N Bari v Richmond & Wandsworth Councils [2025] EAT 54 25 March 2025 This appeal concerns a litigant-in-person claimant who sought an order requiring the respondents to answer eight questions about colleagues and reasonable adjustments in a disability-discrimination claim. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held that tribunals do have power under Rule 29 to order parties to provide information (distinct from document disclosure) and that the tribunal below gave inadequate reasons, particularly by failing to consider relevance to the claimant’s direct discrimination and victimisation claims. The appeal was allowed and the information application was remitted for fresh determination by a different judge.
- Alexandru Bucur v The Soho Sandwich Company Ltd [2025] EAT 40 21 March 2025 This EAT judgment dismisses the claimant’s appeals against an ET decision rejecting claims that payments for bank holidays and denial of days off in lieu amounted to unlawful deductions from wages and breaches of the Working Time Regulations. The tribunal had found the claimant was paid his normal salary plus an explicit day-rate for each bank holiday (constituting "double pay") and that a day off in lieu is not "wages", so no unlawful deduction arose. A late argument about contractual carryover of extra holiday under s.13A(7) WTR, raised for the first time on appeal, was disallowed because it would require fresh evidence. The appeals were therefore dismissed in full.
- London United Busways Limited v Sener [2025] EAT 37 20 March 2025 This appeal concerned whether repeated questioning and comments about a bus driver's need for frequent toilet breaks amounted to disability-related harassment. The EAT upheld findings of harassment as to communications by controllers (which were sufficiently explained and in time) but remitted two manager-related incidents (May and June 2018 meetings) for the tribunal to give fuller reasons and excluded a January 2019 meeting it had wrongly included. The overall complaint remains in time because conduct after the limitation cut-off survived the appeal.
- E Kamphues v Venator Materials UK Ltd [2025] EAT 30 19 March 2025 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's striking out of a litigant-in-person claimant's multiple complaints for non‑compliance and not actively pursuing the claim. The EAT held the Tribunal erred in law by moving from finding threshold conduct to strike-out without first exercising the required discretion (including assessing proportionality and whether a fair trial remained possible). The EAT allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the Employment Tribunal, refusing the claimant's requests for postponement and remote attendance of the EAT hearing.
- F v J [2025] EAT 34 19 March 2025 This EAT appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal applied the correct test in refusing a claimant with Asperger's syndrome anonymity under rule 50, where he said publicity would harm his future employability. The EAT held the tribunal set the evidential bar too high by requiring objective proof of harm, found the claimant's fears had an objective/reasonable foundation on the material before it, and substituted a decision anonymising both parties because publishing the respondent’s identity would likely identify the claimant.
- Kostrova v McDermott International Inc & Anor [2025] EAT 35 13 March 2025 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's strike-out of a litigant-in-person's sex and age discrimination complaints and an allegation of judicial bias. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the bias ground failed for lack of particularity but found the Tribunal erred in law by misconstruing the pleaded case, treating disputed material facts as undisputed, and making an informal credibility assessment when deciding strike-out. The EAT set aside that part of the ET judgment and remitted the remaining discrimination complaints to a different tribunal for a merits hearing.
- M Griffiths v Scarista Limited & Ors [2025] EAT 36 13 March 2025 This appeal concerned whether the claimant's email withdrawing her tribunal claims on 18 December 2022 brought the proceedings to an end before a reserved judgment was promulgated on 19 December 2022. The Employment Judge erred in treating the claims as live, promulgating and publishing a substantive judgment, and refusing reconsideration; the appellate judge set the substantive judgment aside and ordered the claim dismissed on withdrawal. No copy of a dismissal judgment need be entered on the Register under the applicable rule.
- Dr Kevin Connaughton v Greater Glasgow Health Board [2025] EAT 32 12 March 2025 This appeal concerned whether Dr Connaughton, a GP partner in a practice holding a GMS contract with NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde, was a “worker” under s.230 ERA, reg.2 WTR or the Working Time Directive for unpaid holiday claims. The Employment Tribunal found the 2018 GMS contract was between the Board and the partnership, not the individual GP, and that the Board lacked the requisite power of direction or control over the individual; the EAT found no error of law and dismissed the appeal.
- Wealmoor Limited v R Poniatowski [2025] EAT 48 12 March 2025 Wealmoor Limited appealed parts of a remedy decision after the claimant succeeded in claims including discrimination and unfair dismissal. The EAT allowed the appeal, finding two legal errors: the Employment Tribunal grossed up the whole injury-to-feelings award without apportioning the element attributable to the dismissal, and it gave inadequate reasoning on mitigation of loss. The EAT remitted the case to the same Employment Tribunal to reconsider apportionment of the injury-to-feelings award and to give proper reasons on mitigation. Sums not challenged on appeal remain payable.
- David Fong v David Montgomery & Ors [2025] EAT 31 11 March 2025 This appeal concerns the Employment Tribunal's refusal to allow a litigant-in-person claimant to amend his claim to plead automatic unfair dismissal for asserting a statutory right and/or making a protected disclosure. The EAT held the tribunal erred in law by failing to give the ET1 a fair reading, wrongly treating the proposed pleading as a new complaint rather than re-labelling of matters already pleaded, and by making unsupported factual findings and taking irrelevant considerations into account. The EAT remitted the amendment application to the Employment Tribunal for reconsideration by a different tribunal and directed the change be treated as re-labelling.
- M Kokomane v Boots Management Services Ltd [2025] EAT 38 11 March 2025 The claimant appealed an Employment Tribunal decision that her grievance letters were not protected acts under the Equality Act because they did not expressly allege race discrimination. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the ET applied too narrow a test by focusing on the absence of the word "race" and remitted the matter to the ET for reconsideration of whether, in context, the grievances were capable of amounting to race discrimination. The appeal was allowed and the case sent back for rehearing or reconsideration.
- Robinson v Nottingham Healthcare NHS [2025] EAT 39 11 March 2025 This Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the claimant's appeal against an Employment Tribunal's finding that she was not disabled and remitted the disability issue for full redetermination by a new tribunal. The EAT held the ET made legal errors including treating uncorroborated claimant evidence as insufficient without assessing credibility, irrationally averaging fluctuating CBT self-report scores instead of considering periods of peak severity, and misassessing effects on sleep and driving. The ET's approach to face‑mask wearing as a day‑to‑day activity was rejected.
- Brian Gourlay v West Dunbartonshire Council [2025] EAT 29 10 March 2025 This appeal concerned the tribunal's 80% reduction of a large award for past and future wage and pension loss after findings that the respondent's discrimination caused the claimant to develop a chronic severe depressive episode leaving him permanently unfit for work. The EAT found legal error and perversity in that reduction, set aside the economic loss award (paragraph 2 of the remedy judgment) and remitted quantum for reassessment by a differently constituted tribunal. The respondent's cross‑appeal to limit loss to the date of a hypothetical lawful dismissal was refused.
- Dr Mark Ter-Berg v Parul Malde & Anor [2025] EAT 23 28 February 2025 This appeal concerned whether a dentist who sold his practices and entered an Associate Agreement was a "worker" under s.230(3) Employment Rights Act 1996; the tribunal had found he was not. HHJ Auerbach held the tribunal erred in treating a substitution/locum clause (clause 36) and prior findings on employee status as automatically precluding worker status, quashed the worker finding and remitted the limited issue of whether the company was a client/customer of any business/profession carried on by the claimant for rehearing.
- Rafiqul Islam v Loomis UK Ltd [2025] EAT 49 28 February 2025 This is an EAT appeal from a tribunal dismissal of a driver/custodian's claims that he was selected for redundancy because of his Islamic faith and that the tribunal misapplied the Equality Act 2010 burden of proof. The EAT held the tribunal, read fairly, had considered whether a prima facie case of discrimination was made and did not err in law by not expressly citing statutory burden provisions; the numerical/statistical evidence relied on was not sufficient to shift the burden of proof. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal's findings that redundancies were genuine and dismissal fair were upheld.
- Tesco Stores Limited v K Element & Ors [2025] EAT 26 27 February 2025 Tesco appealed an Employment Tribunal refusal to permit economist evidence in large equal value litigation. The EAT held the ET applied the wrong test (an improper "relevance"/strike‑out approach and misunderstood the "Consequences Issue") and remitted the application for fresh determination under the correct statutory test. The matter is to be reheard by the same judge, who may seek further submissions.
- Alcian Roofe-Stewart v MacIntyre Care Ltd [2025] EAT 24 26 February 2025 This is an EAT appeal against a tribunal finding that the claimant (with MCTD) was not disabled under the Equality Act 2010 at the time of her 2021 dismissal. The EAT held the tribunal’s rejection of schedule 1 paragraph 2(2) (treating ceased effects as continuing if likely to recur) was insufficiently reasoned given the low threshold for "likely to recur" and the medical evidence of a fluctuating chronic condition. The EAT quashed the disability finding, allowed the appeal in part, and remitted the paragraph 2(2) issue to the tribunal with directions for refreshed case management and consideration of bespoke medical evidence.
- Marston (Holdings) LTD v A Perkins [2025] EAT 20 19 February 2025 This appeal concerns an employee's claims of indirect sex discrimination (PCP: requirement to travel significant distances) and unfair dismissal for redundancy after she said such travel conflicted with childcare. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the Employment Tribunal's reasoning on group disadvantage and justification was unclear and legally inadequate, and that the ET wrongly re-opened the claimant’s earlier concession on redundancy without proper process. The EAT allowed most of the employer’s grounds of appeal, set aside the ET’s relevant findings and remitted the matter for further directions.
- Equans Services Ltd v Cameron Bennett [2025] EAT 33 18 February 2025 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal decision to extend time for an out-of-time age discrimination claim. The EAT held the Tribunal had failed to apply or consider established authorities and key factors (notably the length/reasons for delay and forensic prejudice from unavailable witnesses), such that its decision was perverse. The EAT substituted its own decision that it was not just and equitable to extend time and dismissed the age discrimination claims.
- R Peposhi v Go Crisis Limited & Anor [2025] EAT 27 18 February 2025 This appeal concerns whether the claimant complied with an Employment Tribunal "Unless Order" after failing to rejoin a CVP final hearing. The Employment Judge dismissed the claim for non‑compliance, but the Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Order required a written statement explaining why the claimant could not rejoin by CVP or telephone and any relevant documentary evidence, and that the claimant had, objectively and in time, provided such a statement and documents. The dismissal was set aside because the Judge applied a qualitative assessment of the explanation and resolved ambiguity against the claimant.
- W v Highways England & Ors [2025] EAT 18 18 February 2025 This appeal concerned whether KPMG could be liable to a Highways England employee who alleged whistleblowing detriment, direct sex discrimination and victimisation, where she had no express contract with KPMG. The EAT substituted the tribunal's factual finding that there was no implied contract with KPMG, held the tribunal had erred in treating absence of a contract as determinative of the ERA s.43K extended employer question, upheld that s.111(7) prevented a s.111 Equality Act claim in the circumstances, and remitted fact-sensitive issues (agency, aiding liability, and s.43K) for further tribunal consideration.
- Amanuel Ghebrehiwt v Wilson James Ltd [2025] EAT 50 12 February 2025 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal erred in law in finding Mr Ghebrehiwt was fairly dismissed for unauthorised prolonged absence while caring for his vulnerable mother during early Covid-19. The EAT dismissed the appeal, upholding the ET's findings that the claimant admitted unauthorised absence, was unreliable as a witness, had been warned and dismissed for unauthorised absence, and that late emails refused admission were immaterial. The EAT also held there was no procedural unfairness or bias in the disciplinary/dismissal process and that the conduct found amounted to gross misconduct justifying summary dismissal.
- M Miller v Greggs PLC [2025] EAT 21 12 February 2025 This appeal concerned a Notice of Dismissal and related Rule 38(2) and reconsideration decisions. After review of IT evidence, the Respondent accepted that allegations and any Tribunal findings of dishonesty/scandalous conduct were incorrect, the parties settled, and the appeals were allowed by consent with the claims dismissed. No remedy or prior findings of dishonesty were upheld.
- Impact Recruitment Services Ltd v Korpysa [2025] EAT 22 11 February 2025 This appeal concerned whether an employer’s genuine but mistaken belief that an employee had resigned can constitute a potentially fair reason for dismissal and whether the tribunal properly applied the s.98(4) ERA 1996 fairness inquiry. The EAT held the tribunal majority was wrong to treat such a mistaken-belief reason as intrinsically incapable of being a substantial reason and to omit the s.98(4) fairness assessment; the appeal was allowed and the case remitted for rehearing on those issues.
- P Easton v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2025] EAT 15 7 February 2025 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal erred in finding that the Home Office fairly dismissed Mr Easton for dishonesty in a 2019 Border Force application. The EAT held the tribunal properly applied the Burchell test (belief, reasonable grounds, reasonable investigation), rejected the claimant's argument that the unstructured "employment history" box was ambiguous, and found dismissal fell within the band of reasonable responses. The appeal was dismissed and no remittal was ordered.
- R Smith v John Raymond Transport Ltd [2025] EAT 13 7 February 2025 The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed Mr Smith’s appeal against the Employment Tribunal’s dismissal of his harassment and direct discrimination claims (race and age). The central challenge—that the Tribunal’s finding that a witness (Woodward) communicated concerns to another (Harrison) was perverse or non‑compliant with Meek—failed because the Tribunal’s factual findings were adequately explained and supported by evidence (including a message). No error of law or procedural unfairness was identified sufficient to disturb the Tribunal’s decision.
- Tesco Stores Limited v K Element & Ors [2025] EAT 45 5 February 2025 Tesco appealed parts of Employment Tribunal decisions in large equal value litigation concerning stage 2 hearings under the EV Rules; the EAT held multiple grounds of Tesco’s appeal to be reasonably arguable and allowed them to proceed to full hearing. Central issues were whether the Tribunal correctly identified its fact‑finding role under the EV Rules and whether it erred by prioritising training materials and avoiding determination of particular factual matters. The EAT expressed concern about case management in very large litigation and directed progression to a full hearing on the permitted grounds.
- Dr K Sharma v University of Portsmouth [2025] EAT 19 4 February 2025 Dr Sharma, an academic, brought direct race discrimination and victimisation claims after not being reappointed to an Associate Head role; the ET found multiple acts of discrimination and awarded damages. The EAT allowed the employer's appeal in part, concluding the ET had failed to address losses flowing from two specific liability findings and had erred on the ACAS uplift and non-disclosure inferences, and remitted those limited issues to the same ET for rehearing; other grounds were dismissed.
- Victormills Iyieke v Bearing Point Limited [2025] EAT 25 4 February 2025 This appeal concerned two costs orders made against a dismissed employee after his direct race discrimination claim failed. The EAT (Auerbach J) held the tribunal erred in finding the claimant acted unreasonably in continuing to trial after disclosure and erred in assessing his means and in summarily fixing the maximum capped costs; the costs application was dismissed and the original orders set aside. No remittal was made—Auerbach J substituted the decision that the Rule 76(1)(a) threshold was not met.
- L Ramos v Wolf Data Systems Limited (debarred) & Ors [2025] EAT 16 31 January 2025 This is an EAT decision on nine appeals by L Ramos challenging Employment Tribunal transfers of multiple, similar discrimination claims into the Watford case-management office. The President found that when a transfer stems from active judicial case-management intervention made without a hearing, the Tribunal should in writing identify the judge and give reasons, but that most confirmation letters in these cases lacked those formalities. Despite those procedural defects, the panel concluded no substantive injustice arose (having regard to an earlier explanatory letter of REJ Foxwell) and confirmed the transfers under the Tribunal’s s.35 power; one appeal (Wolf Data Systems) was dismissed on its merits. Applications to reinstate grounds, for further disclosure, and for recusal were refused.
- R Olyazadeh v Newcastle University [2025] EAT 17 30 January 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in finding Dr Olyazadeh’s Second Claim (for unfair dismissal and notice pay) was out of time. The EAT held the tribunal made an error of law by failing properly to consider and give reasons about the claimant’s explanation that the history of earlier proceedings affected whether it was reasonably practicable to present the Second Claim in time, and remitted that narrow issue for reconsideration. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s factual finding that the effective date of termination was 18 April 2023 and rejected the claimant’s argument that silence about notice in resignation correspondence creates a presumption of dismissal on notice.
- Eddie Stobart Limited v Caitlin Graham [2025] EAT 14 29 January 2025 Eddie Stobart Ltd appealed an Employment Tribunal award of £10,000 for injury to feelings after finding the employer had failed to deal with a maternity-related grievance; the Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal as to quantum, finding the award manifestly excessive and inadequately reasoned, and substituted a reduced award of £2,000 plus £169 interest. The EAT emphasised that where evidence of upset is sparse tribunals may cautiously consider the manner of discrimination to infer severity, but must focus on compensation for the injury actually suffered and give adequate reasons for selecting a sum within the Vento bands.
- Akhigbe v St Edward Thomas Homes Ltd (SEH) [2024] EAT 142 23 January 2025 This judgment concerns whether an appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal was properly instituted where the appellant failed to lodge required ET pleadings for some claims within 42 days. The EAT President held the earlier EAT erred in treating the appeal as properly instituted, refused to extend time for omissions relating to the 2018 SEH claim (deliberate omission, not a minor error), but accepted that withdrawn challenges to the 2019 Niblock claims could excuse those particular omissions. The 2 February 2024 order permitting the appeal to proceed was revoked insofar as it rested on the appeal being properly instituted; the extension of time was refused for the 2018 claims.
- Carol McMahon v AXA ICAS Ltd [2025] EAT 8 22 January 2025 This EAT decision concerns three linked appeals by Carol McMahon against AXA ICAS Ltd about payment of permanent health insurance (PHI) benefits and a struck-out disability discrimination claim. The tribunal was upheld that the employer’s PHI scheme gave rise to contractual payments that constituted "wages" while employment subsisted, and that "normal earnings" meant basic contractual salary excluding overtime and speculative increases; the tribunal’s approach to the scheme’s 5% annual uplift was held to be legally flawed (the uplift applies year‑by‑year to the amount being paid) but did not change liability. An application to amend to claim post‑termination PHI payments was properly refused, while the strike‑out of the discrimination claim was set aside and remitted for reconsideration because the tribunal should have allowed focusing of pleadings and taken evidence about witness cogency before striking out.
- Abel Estate Agent Ltd & Ors v Elizabeth Reynolds [2025] EAT 6 20 January 2025 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal loses jurisdiction where a claimant presented part of her claim without an ACAS early conciliation certificate. The EAT held the Tribunal erred in rejecting the claim under rule 12 and that failure to obtain a certificate does not automatically oust the Tribunal's competence; the correct approach is to consider enforcement, waiver or disposal under rules 27 or 37. On the facts the EAT refused the respondents' applications under rules 27 and 37, set aside the rule 12 rejection and remitted the claims for determination on the merits.
- Sivanandan v Independent Office for Police Conduct & Anor [2025] EAT 7 20 January 2025 This appeal challenged a tribunal's decisions granting relief from sanction under rule 38(2) after Penna missed an unless-order deadline for serving a costs schedule by about four hours, and refusing the claimant's requests for reconsideration and recusal. The EAT held that an unless order under rule 38 can validly apply to a costs application, that a party may apply for relief under rule 38(2) without waiting for a separate rule 38(1) notice, and that deciding the relief application on paper where no hearing was requested did not deny the claimant a fair opportunity to be heard. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal's decisions were upheld, with unresolved substantive matters (including the deposit) remitted to the tribunal.
- Bazgha Anwar v Boots Management Services Ltd [2025] EAT 9 14 January 2025 This appeal concerned the Employment Judge's decision at a private preliminary hearing to strike out the claimant's automatic unfair dismissal claim and to record it as struck out "by consent". The EAT concluded the Employment Judge erred in treating the litigant in person as having consented and that the manner of strike‑out was unfair and an error of law. The appeal was allowed, the strike‑out set aside and the matter remitted to the Regional Employment Judge for further directions and determination.
- Smirnov v Ramboll UK Limited & Anor [2025] EAT 12 14 January 2025 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal wrongly decided who employed the claimant without witness evidence or directions for witness statements, and whether absence of an ACAS early conciliation certificate naming the Danish employer at presentation invalidated the claim. The EAT allowed the claimant's appeal on procedural‑fairness grounds, remitted the employment‑status issue for fresh tribunal determination with appropriate case management and directions for witness evidence, and dismissed the employer's cross‑appeal on the ACAS point.
- B Sritharan v Deloitte LLP & Anor [2025] EAT 5 9 January 2025 This appeal concerned multiple discrimination and unfair dismissal findings by an Employment Tribunal after the claimant, a technical director dismissed while absent sick with disability-related stress, failed to get an internal CPO role. The EAT upheld most factual findings but identified legal errors (notably failure to consider justification for alleged indirect disability discrimination, failure to consider whether the burden of proof had shifted given a named comparator and no respondent evidence, and an internal inconsistency where the ET purported to dismiss a claim it had accepted) and remitted specified issues for rehearing by a differently constituted tribunal.
- Danny Duployen v Whyte & Mackay Limited [2025] EAT 3 7 January 2025 This appeal arose from an employment tribunal decision finding constructive dismissal and disability discrimination and awarding basic and compensatory awards. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed most grounds of appeal, upholding the tribunal's refusal to order reinstatement or re‑engagement (on the evidence), its lower‑band Vento award of £7,500 for injury to feelings, and its mitigation finding limiting loss to six months. The EAT varied the tribunal's decision only to add interest at 8% per annum on the discrimination awards from 14 February 2022 until payment.
- Dr Craig John Bennoch v Scottish Power Ltd & Ors [2025] EAT 61 7 January 2025 This appeal concerns repeated challenges by Dr Bennoch to an Employment Tribunal judgment dismissing his unfair dismissal claim, focusing on a nearly four‑year‑late reconsideration application and a request under rule 69 to correct the ET judgment. The EAT refused to extend time or grant reconsideration, and held the rule 69 request sought substantive amendment not a clerical correction, so both the fifth and sixth appeals were dismissed at the rule 3(10) stage. The judge treated the ongoing serial applications as abusive and refused to allow further proceedings.
- East Lancashire NHS Trust v Imran Akram [2025] EAT 2 7 January 2025 This case concerns how to calculate holiday pay for a phlebotomist on irregular shifts; the Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the employer’s appeal as premature because the Employment Tribunal had selected a divisor (working days per year) but not completed the complementary part of the calculation. The EAT held that tribunals must apply the Working Time Regulations’ statutory method—starting with the correct weekly pay and then deriving daily/hourly rates—and remitted the matter for remedy once the multiplicand evidence is fixed.
- The British Council v Sellers [2025] EAT 1 3 January 2025 The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the British Council's appeal against an employment tribunal re‑engagement order made after a finding of unfair dismissal for alleged gross misconduct. The EAT held that, once the employer withdrew any positive case of contributory fault, s.116(3)(c) did not require the tribunal to make a fresh inquisitorial factual finding that the claimant committed the misconduct, and it was perverse for the ET to conclude the employer could not rationally rely on an independent investigator's report. The re‑engagement order was set aside.
- Rico Quitongo v Airdrieonians Football Club Limited & Anor [2024] EAT 201 20 December 2024 This appeal concerned a professional footballer’s claims of harassment and victimisation under the Equality Act 2010 after an alleged racist incident; the Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal on two grounds, substituted a finding of victimisation for the club’s refusal to communicate with the player’s agent after 16 October, and remitted remedy. The EAT also remitted factual findings and remedy on one harassment complaint (that the chairman suggested the player had sought publicity) but refused the appeal on four other harassment grounds, concluding the tribunal’s findings on those were permissible.
- S Fox v South Essex Academy Trust [2024] EAT 199 20 December 2024 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's refusal to postpone and its striking-out (and purported dismissal) of the claimant's application for a costs/preparation-time order for alleged persistent non-compliance. The EAT found legal error: the ET failed to assess whether non-compliance was deliberate or wilful, whether a fair hearing remained possible, and did not consider less draconian sanctions or the impact of the claimant's recognised disabilities and reasonable adjustments. The ET's decision was set aside and the costs application is remitted to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal for determination.
- Walsall Metropolitan Borough Council v Christine Oliver [2024] EAT 193 20 December 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's decision to find automatic unfair dismissal under section 99 ERA based on a supposed breach of regulation 10 of the Maternity and Parental Leave etc. Regulations 1999, where that regulation‑10 claim had not been properly pleaded or identified earlier. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the employer's appeal, holding the ET erred by deciding a new cause of action without treating it as an amendment, failing to consider jurisdiction/time‑limit issues, and by not making the factual findings required by regulation 10; the EAT invited further submissions before final orders.
- P Mefful v Citizens Advice Merton and Lambeth Ltd [2024] EAT 198 19 December 2024 This appeal concerned whether a January 2012 email from the claimant put the employer on actual or constructive notice of a shoulder disability by 19 March 2012, and whether the dismissal in March 2012 was because of something arising in consequence of that disability under s.15. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s unanimous finding that the primary reason for dismissal was perceived lack of capability/engagement, not something arising from disability, and the majority finding that the January email did not give actual or constructive knowledge by 19 March; the claimant’s appeal was dismissed.
- M Bogdan v The Cabinet Office - Government Digital Services [2024] EAT 177 17 December 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal gave adequate reasons and addressed the Claimant's allegations that she had repeatedly requested job re-evaluation before February 2020 and had been wrongly graded for about five years. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the Tribunal omitted to deal with issues 6.1 and 6.2 (the earlier/requested re-evaluations) and that this omission was a serious procedural irregularity, so those issues were remitted to a differently constituted tribunal; the Tribunal's reasoning on the five-year wrongful grading complaint (issue 6.13 / Ground 2) was held to be adequate and that ground was dismissed.
- Metroline Travel Ltd v Justin Taylor [2025] EAT 4 17 December 2024 This appeal concerns Metroline's challenge to an Employment Tribunal's finding of ordinary unfair dismissal after a depot altercation; the EAT held the ET repeatedly substituted its own view for the employer's and failed to apply the required "range of reasonable responses" test to investigation, disciplinary and appeal stages. The EAT set aside the ET's decision on ordinary unfair dismissal as fundamentally flawed and remitted the matter for rehearing by a different Employment Judge; the ET's decision on automatic unfair dismissal was left undisturbed.
- K Kaler v Insights ESC Limited [2024] EAT 195 12 December 2024 This is an appeal by a teacher dismissed for abusive/threatening emails who alleged disability discrimination (ASD) and other complaints. The Employment Appeal Tribunal rejected challenges to the tribunal’s refusal to further adjourn the resumed hearing and to its handling of procedural adjustments, upheld the tribunal’s finding that the claimant’s misconduct was not shown to arise from ASD and that dismissal was justified, and dismissed the appeal. The EAT did find one narrow error on the tribunal’s conclusion about constructive knowledge of the claimant’s ASD but held that error did not affect the outcome.
- Malcolm Ford v The Scottish Ministers [2024] EAT 197 12 December 2024 This appeal concerned whether two employer actions — a March 2017 unrequested secondment and a Feb–May 2019 disciplinary investigation — amounted to detriments because the employee had made protected disclosures, and whether dismissal was automatically unfair. The EAT found legal error in the tribunal’s reasoning on the two detriment claims, quashed those parts of the decision and remitted them (and related time‑bar and remedy questions) for reconsideration. The EAT rejected the challenge to the tribunal’s unfair‑dismissal conclusion, finding no error in treating conduct as the principal reason for dismissal.
- Sadia Shakil v Samsons Limited [2024] EAT 192 11 December 2024 This is an EAT appeal about whether an Employment Tribunal correctly assessed injury to feelings in a pregnancy discrimination claim and properly applied the Vento bands and Presidential Guidance. The EAT held the Tribunal erred by failing to identify and assess evidence of injury to feelings, state the applicable Vento band or explain the award’s placement within it, and therefore allowed the appeal. The EAT remitted the injury-to-feelings assessment to a different Employment Tribunal and refused to substitute an award itself.
- London United Busways Limited v V De Marchi & Anor [2024] EAT 191 10 December 2024 This case concerned whether a bus driver who objected to a TUPE transfer under regulation 4(7) but did not elect to treat his contract as terminated under regulation 4(9) remained employed by the transferor or transferred to the transferee. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held that where reg 4(9) applies an employee has a choice to treat the contract as terminated, and where the employee objects under reg 4(7) that objection prevents transfer so the transferor, not the transferee, is treated as having dismissed the employee. The appeal and cross‑appeal were dismissed and the tribunal’s conclusion that the claimant was dismissed by the transferor was upheld, with remaining factual issues remitted to the Employment Tribunal.
- Paul Douglas v North Lanarkshire Council [2024] EAT 194 10 December 2024 This appeal concerned whether an ET's allowance of a late amendment to add protected-disclosure (s.47B/103A) claims precluded the tribunal from later deciding time-bar and whether the tribunal erred in law in finding the claimant's dismissal fair. The EAT held that where time-bar was not addressed at amendment because the proposed pleadings were unclear, the jurisdictional point remains open and may be revisited at the merits hearing; and that there was no legal error in concluding the dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses given the attendance record and occupational health evidence. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal's findings on time-bar and fairness were upheld.
- D Ireland v University College London [2024] EAT 190 30 November 2024 Mr Ireland challenged UCL’s withdrawal of a conditional job offer as racially motivated; the Employment Tribunal accepted evidence that the offer was withdrawn because referees had not provided satisfactory references and dismissed the discrimination claim. The EAT judge held that the ET’s factual finding on liability is not susceptible to interference absent perversity, but directed that appeals concerning costs decisions and procedural handling of costs applications proceed to a full hearing.
- Frank Aliyu v Tesco Stores Limited [2024] EAT 185 28 November 2024 This appeal concerned claims by Mr Aliyu that various acts by Tesco (including comments by a People Partner, a lengthy investigation, suspension and dismissal) amounted to victimisation, harassment, protected-disclosure detriment and unfair dismissal. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the Employment Tribunal’s findings: the alleged Hitler salute was rejected, some comments were inappropriate but did not amount to detriment or harassment on the facts, suspension and delay were detriments but were not caused by protected acts, investigation flaws did not change the outcome, and dismissal for misconduct was not materially influenced by protected acts. The appeal was dismissed.
- Samuel Utere v Huxlow Science Academy [2025] EAT 28 26 November 2024 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's refusal to allow a Claimant to amend his ET1 to add direct discrimination claims for sex and philosophical belief late in proceedings. The EAT dismissed the sole ground of appeal, holding the Employment Judge had correctly applied the law and permissibly found the proposed sex claim would substantially change the factual and legal scope, was out of time, and that the balance of prejudice and delay justified refusal. The Judge’s exercise of discretion was upheld.
- Marina Saveka v General Mills UK Ltd [2024] EAT 186 22 November 2024 This appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal challenged refusal of an extension of time to appeal several case-management rulings (including anonymity and other reporting/attendance restrictions) and sought procedural relief about the appeal bundle. The EAT refused the extension and the anonymity/restrictions, upheld directions requiring inclusion of ET1/particulars/ET3 and the tribunal strike-out reasons in the bundle, and dismissed the appeal. The judge found the appellant’s partly redacted medical evidence insufficiently independent to establish incapacity affecting decision‑making and that caring/homelessness claims were inadequately evidenced. Normal reporting and publication (including naming parties) was permitted.
- N Hall v Paragon Finance PLC [2024] EAT 181 21 November 2024 This is an EAT decision on an interim relief application in a whistleblowing/automatic unfair dismissal claim where the ET had refused interim relief. The EAT held the ET had failed adequately to engage with the parties' cases on whether three alleged disclosures (PD1–PD3) were qualifying disclosures and allowed the respondent's cross‑appeal on PD3, but it upheld the ET's interim conclusion that pre‑existing employer concerns about the claimant's conduct meant causation was not established. The claimant's appeal was dismissed, the respondent's cross‑appeal succeeded in part, and the refusal of interim relief stands.
- Kemsley v Cambridgeshire County Council [2024] EAT 180 20 November 2024 This Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the employee's appeal and set aside the Employment Tribunal's dismissal of claims for unfair dismissal, victimisation, age discrimination and sexual harassment, on grounds the ET's written reasons largely copied the respondent's material and failed to engage with or independently evaluate the appellant's evidence and submissions. The EAT found the ET gave inadequate or no reasons on key issues (detriment, causation/"tainted information", whether the appellant saw an offensive email, and age/disposition contentions) and remitted the case for rehearing before a differently constituted ET.
- The Advocate General for Scotland v Koren Brown & Anor [2024] EAT 189 20 November 2024 This case concerns an Employment Appeal Tribunal appeal by the Ministry of Defence Police against an ET finding that a 7.6 MSFT fitness requirement for authorised firearms officers was a PCP causing indirect sex discrimination and that the claimant was not offered a formal Chester treadmill alternative or adequate assistance. The EAT upheld the ET’s findings on group and individual disadvantage and on failure to offer the alternative/assistance, but allowed the appeal in part because the ET’s proportionality reasoning—particularly whether a less discriminatory alternative could have achieved the MDP’s legitimate aims in the claimant’s specific case—was inadequately explained. The EAT remitted the proportionality issue to the same ET (if practicable) for reconsideration.
- Wangtian Xie v E'Quipe Japan Ltd [2024] EAT 176 14 November 2024 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal's strike‑out of a litigant‑in‑person's race discrimination claim arising from her employment at Harrods, limited to acts by two managers and later expanded to include an alleged "anti‑Chinese culture". The EAT found the Tribunal erred in concluding there were no reasonable prospects of proving an "anti‑Chinese culture" when the claimant's pleaded facts were taken at their highest and that the Tribunal mischaracterised the tea‑break complaint; the strike‑out was set aside and the claim remitted for further progress. The EAT dismissed the ground that the Tribunal failed to consider amendment, and directed any renewed strike‑out or deposit application be heard by a different judge.
- Anne-Marie Alexis v Westminster Drug Project [2024] EAT 188 12 November 2024 This appeal concerned a receptionist reduced from three to two posts who was unsuccessful at interview, had declared dyslexia and pursued grievances and appeals, and was later dismissed for "some other substantial reason" after an HR consultant found trust and confidence had irretrievably broken down. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed her appeal, holding that the employer reasonably concluded breakdown of mutual trust and confidence made length of service irrelevant and that alternatives (including a warning) had been considered and reasonably rejected. The EAT also refused to admit new factual complaints outside the limited grounds of appeal and upheld the ET’s factual findings.
- F Laloui v Parks (London) Limited & Anor [2024] EAT 196 12 November 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal decision dismissing a claimant's sex discrimination, harassment, victimisation and unfair dismissal claims. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the ET erred by failing to consider specific evidential comparators the claimant had properly identified for several direct discrimination allegations and remitted those issues (issues 1(a), 1(k), 1(m), 1(n) and 1(o)) to the original ET for reconsideration; most other grounds, including the comparison of terms with a male candidate (ground 2), were dismissed and the ET's remaining findings largely stand.
- Steven Connor v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [2024] EAT 175 12 November 2024 This appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in finding the claimant’s depression did not amount to a disability before 8 February 2019, whether there was a procedural irregularity in denying evidence in chief/re‑examination, and whether the misconduct was caused by the disability. The EAT rejected the procedural irregularity claim, upheld the ET’s approach that recurrence requires recurrence of substantial adverse effects on day‑to‑day activities (not merely recurrence of the impairment), accepted that a non‑litigation medical letter can carry evidential weight and that an opinion that something “appears” connected can meet the balance of probabilities, and held any identified evidential criticisms did not change the outcome. The appeal was dismissed.
- Declan Durey v South Central Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust [2024] EAT 173 8 November 2024 This appeal concerns a whistleblowing claimant (a former student/then registered paramedic) who alleged protected disclosures and consequential detriments, constructive/unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the claimant’s appeal and the Trust’s cross-appeal, upholding the tribunal’s finding that one disclosed email (disclosure 2) was not a protected disclosure because the claimant lacked a reasonable belief that it tended to show danger to patient safety, and that the tribunal’s findings on detriment and causation (including for disclosure 9) were not perverse. The EAT declined to decide a broader preliminary legal issue about tribunals’ power to award non‑pecuniary loss.
- N Orban v Rohan Designs Ltd [2024] EAT 187 7 November 2024 This Employment Appeal Tribunal decision concerned two case-management appeals in an unfair dismissal/hybrid-hearing context. The EAT dismissed the first appeal, finding no error in a tribunal directing compliance with Presidential Guidance to allow a witness in Canada to give evidence remotely. The EAT allowed the second appeal, holding that a refusal to order specific disclosure was legally flawed because the judge did not adequately explain why documents that were prima facie relevant were nonetheless irrelevant, but declined to order further disclosure because the respondent had voluntarily produced the material.
- Nkechi Leeks v Royal Marsden NHS Foundation Trust [2024] EAT 178 7 November 2024 This appeal concerned time limits for Mrs Leeks’ Equality Act discrimination claims and a whistleblowing detriment claim under the NHS (Recruitment – Protected Disclosure) Regulations 2018. The EAT held the Employment Judge erred by failing to identify which sub‑paragraph of regulation 5(3) applied to the whistleblowing complaint and remitted that timing issue to the tribunal, but upheld the judge’s discretionary refusal to extend time on the facts as treated for the other claims.
- Christopher Rodger v Forestry and Land Scotland [2024] EAT 172 6 November 2024 This appeal challenged an employment tribunal’s finding that Mr Rodger was not disabled and that it lacked jurisdiction because he lacked title/interest, relying on episodic absences and CBT referrals. The EAT (Lord Colbeck) rejected grounds that the tribunal erred by treating January 2021 and March 2022 absences as unconnected and by failing to reason about CBT evidence, holding the tribunal considered the evidence and reached conclusions open to it. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal’s decision upheld.
- Tracey Smith v The Restaurant Group (UK) Ltd [2024] EAT 168 1 November 2024 This appeal concerns whether Tracey Smith's discrimination and unlawful deduction claims were time-barred where two early conciliation certificates existed. The EAT held the earlier mandatory certificate governed limitation (following Sera Garau), the subsequent certificate did not revive time, and the tribunal properly refused to exercise its discretion to extend time. The claimant's appeal was dismissed.
- CJ v PC [2024] EAT 182 22 October 2024 This is an EAT appeal from an Employment Tribunal remedy award to a claimant who succeeded in discrimination and victimisation and was ill‑health retired. The EAT held the Tribunal erred in law by not applying the Parry v Cleaver "insurance" exception (such pensions can, in principle, be excluded from deduction) but refused permission to run that point on appeal because it had not been argued below and would require reopening factual issues; the EAT upheld the Tribunal’s deduction of earnings from alternative work for mitigation and dismissed the appeal.
- Dr Maclennan v The British Psychological Society [2024] EAT 166 21 October 2024 This case concerned whether a charity trustee elected President‑Elect was a "worker" protected from detriment for making protected disclosures, and whether Article 10 read with Article 14 ECHR required extending protection where statutory worker status was absent. The Employment Tribunal found no contract/worker status and rejected the Convention claim; the EAT upheld the Tribunal’s factual finding on contract but remitted the Article 10/14 issue for fuller consideration and held that a worker is protected for disclosures made to an employer before employment begins. The claimant’s contractual grounds were dismissed, the Convention ground was allowed and remitted, and the pre‑commencement‑disclosure point was allowed.
- Nkechi Leeks v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] EAT 184 17 October 2024 This is an EAT appeal against a reconsideration decision that upheld the ET's strike‑out of the claimant's employment claims for failure to comply with an Unless Order and a £750 costs order. The EAT dismissed the appeal, finding there was no compliance with the Unless Order, the non‑compliance was deliberate, serious and prejudicial, and reconsideration would amount to an impermissible second attempt to re‑argue the substantive decision. The original strike‑out and costs order were therefore upheld.
- Governing Body of Windsor Clive Primary School & Anor v Stephanie Forsbrook & Anor [2024] EAT 183 16 October 2024 This EAT judgment allowed in part an appeal from an Employment Tribunal's finding of disability-related harassment arising from an administrative error that triggered a stage 2 absence meeting. The EAT held the ET gave insufficient reasoning about how the conduct was "related to" the claimant's disability and which aspect of the absence process constituted "unwanted conduct." The case was remitted to the ET to decide, on argument only (no new evidence), whether the conduct was related to disability and whether it was separate from or additional to the ordinary absence process.
- Deksne v Ambitions Ltd [2024] EAT 171 15 October 2024 This is an EAT appeal by Ms Deksne concerning unlawful deductions from wages in the form of underpaid holiday pay arising from a single calculation error by her employer. The Tribunal had held many earlier underpayments were time‑barred by treating gaps over three months (and a single corrected payment) as breaking a "series" of deductions; the EAT allowed the appeal, held the underpayments constituted a series back to 11 August 2019, and substituted a judgment awarding £496.75.
- Ministry of Defence v Anne Rubery [2024] EAT 165 14 October 2024 The EAT allowed the MOD's appeal, holding that the Employment Tribunal had erred in reading words into s.121 Equality Act 2010 to permit ET claims about the service‑complaints process. The exclusion of challenges to the internal service complaints procedure was found objectively justified under Article 14 read with Article 6 ECHR and proportionate, and the proposed s.3 HRA "read‑down" would have gone against the grain of the statutory scheme and amounted to disapplication of reg.3(2). The cross‑appeal failed: EU(W)A 2018 Schedule 1 para 3 prevented disapplication of an enactment at the material time. The claimant’s ET claims so far as they challenge the service‑complaints process were struck out; other claims remain unaffected.
- Carozzi v University of Hertfordshire & Anor [2024] EAT 169 9 October 2024 This appeal to the EAT concerned harassment and victimisation claims under the Equality Act 2010 brought by an employee who resigned during probation. The EAT held the Employment Tribunal erred by treating "related to" in s.26 as requiring a mental element equivalent to "because of" in direct discrimination, allowed the appeal on harassment complaints insofar as they concerned comments about the claimant's accent, and remitted one victimisation complaint for re‑determination; allegations of bias or procedural unfairness were rejected.
- K Pilgrim v Jasmine Care (Holdings) Ltd [2024] EAT 179 8 October 2024 This appeal concerned Ms Pilgrim’s challenge to an Employment Tribunal’s refusal to award her legal costs after she succeeded on liability; the EAT (Deputy Judge Caspar Glyn KC) dismissed the appeal. The EAT held the Tribunal did not err in law or in its discretion in refusing a costs order, and that the earlier preparation time order of £420 remained effective. The EAT also held that “proceedings” in the Rules means the whole claim from issue to final determination, so a preparation time order in respect of those proceedings precludes a subsequent costs order for the same proceedings.
- Patrick Arthur-Badoo v Guy’s & St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust [2024] EAT 163 1 October 2024 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment allowing an appeal by Mr Patrick Arthur-Badoo against Guy’s & St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust. The EAT found the Employment Tribunal’s reasoning unsafe and remitted claims of unauthorised deduction from wages and indirect (race) and direct (marriage) discrimination for re-determination by a differently constituted tribunal. The EAT directed the parties to consider alternative dispute resolution and to seek advice on the viability of the discrimination claims.
- University of Exeter v Dr Annette Plaut [2024] EAT 159 1 October 2024 This EAT decision concerned appeals from findings by an Employment Tribunal in a dismissal and discrimination dispute between University of Exeter and Dr Annette Plaut. The EAT set aside the Tribunal's harassment and victimisation findings relating to the April 2019 suspension for analytical and case‑management errors, upheld the Tribunal's overall finding of unfair dismissal, and remitted limited issues (a particular victimisation point and the ACAS uplift) for rehearing by a different tribunal.
- Dr A Moghaddam v Chancellor, Masters and Scholars of the University of Oxford & Ors [2024] EAT 156 30 September 2024 This appeal concerned multiple employment claims by Dr Moghaddam against the University of Oxford and two professors arising from successive fixed‑term research contracts and a dispute in 2018; the EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal’s (ET) decision that the 2016–2019 fixed‑term renewal was objectively justified and did not create permanency and also upheld the ET’s finding that the claimant was not disabled. However the EAT allowed the appeal in part, concluding the ET gave inadequate reasons on whistleblowing detriment causation and applied Polkey principles incorrectly on procedural unfair dismissal, and remitted those limited issues to a fresh tribunal for further findings and remedy.
- Dr. Bernadette McInerney v Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust [2024] EAT 158 30 September 2024 This appeal concerned remedy awards after findings of constructive unfair dismissal and victimisation by the claimant, a former consultant forensic psychiatrist, who sought about £2.11m mainly for lost future medico‑legal earnings. The Employment Tribunal awarded injury to feelings, aggravated damages and limited loss of earnings (£23,344.30) but rejected the large future medico‑legal loss for lack of independent medical and corroborative evidence and on mitigation; the EAT dismissed the appeal in full. The EAT upheld the Tribunal’s choice of a retirement age of 67 and its refusal to apply a percentage‑chance approach to the speculative medico‑legal loss.
- H Curtis v Ministry of Defence [2024] EAT 161 30 September 2024 This is an appeal from an Employment Tribunal Preliminary Hearing in which parts of a pregnancy/maternity discrimination claim (complaint about cancellation of a medical board) were struck out for lack of jurisdiction on the basis the Claimant had not pursued or appealed an omission in a Service Complaint. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Specified Officer had not complied with the Service Complaints Regulations' mandatory requirement to notify and give reasons where a complaint (or part) is not admissible, so the deemed‑withdrawal/notice‑triggering provisions did not operate. The EAT allowed the appeal, concluded the only proper decision was that the medical‑board discrimination complaint was admissible, and held the Tribunal has jurisdiction.
- AB v The University of East London [2024] EAT 157 27 September 2024 This case concerns five appeals where Notices of Appeal were filed within the 42‑day limit but omitted required documents; each appellant later sought an extension after rectifying the omission. The EAT applied existing guidance on whether omissions are "minor errors" under amended rule 37(5) and, if not, whether an extension should be granted under rule 37(1). Three appeals (AB, Shina, Adams) succeeded and time was extended; two (Rehman, Samuels) failed and extensions were refused.
- Sameena Bashir v The London Borough Of Barking & Dagenham & Ors [2024] EAT 154 26 September 2024 The claimant, an agency-supplied tutor, alleged breaches of the Agency Workers Regulations and the Equality Act (including race discrimination and harassment) and an ERA-related complaint after work supplied via an employment business. Employment Judge Drake struck out most Equality Act and the AWR complaints as out of time or unarguable; the EAT held that the Tribunal erred in law by failing to analyse whether an individual (R4) might have acted as agent of the end‑user (R1) for s.109 Equality Act liability and by dismissing without analysis whether a 2 March 2022 email could form part of a course of conduct for time‑aggregation. The EAT set aside the strike‑out of the AWR and Equality Act complaints and remitted them for rehearing and fresh case management; the ERA/time dismissal strike‑out remained undisturbed on appeal.
- Kevin Gallagher v McKinnon’s Auto and Tyres Ltd [2024] EAT 174 25 September 2024 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal was perverse to find that pre-termination negotiations between Mr Gallagher and his employer were inadmissible under s.111A ERA because there was no impropriety. The EAT rejected the claimant’s grounds of appeal, held the ET was entitled to find the discussions (meeting and messages) were pre-termination negotiations, and that its factual findings of no impropriety were not perverse. The appeal was dismissed and the ET must now decide the substantive unfair dismissal claim without the excluded evidence.
- M Dowding v The Character Group PLC [2024] EAT 153 24 September 2024 This EAT judgment upheld the employment tribunal's liability findings in a dismissal case brought by a former Group Finance Director alleging whistleblowing and ordinary unfair dismissal, concluding the tribunal properly applied a Burchell-type approach and its reasons were sufficient to find the dismissal fair for conduct causing loss of trust. The EAT allowed parts of the claimant's costs appeal: it quashed the tribunal's direction that detailed assessment be on the indemnity basis because the tribunal had not applied or explained the higher Howman-type threshold, and it quashed and remitted the £20,000 summary "costs of costs" award for inadequate explanation of that amount. The remainder of the costs decision was upheld and the case was remitted to the same three-person tribunal panel for reconsideration on those points.
- F Amedzo v Bidvest Noonan (UK) Limited [2024] EAT 148 20 September 2024 This appeal concerned the Registrar's refusal to extend time for an EAT appeal when the appellant filed a notice of appeal without the ET1 and ET3 forms. The EAT judge reheard the Registrar's decision, held the omission was a "minor error" because the substantive information was otherwise before the court and was promptly rectified, and allowed the appeal, granting extensions under Rule 37(5) and, for the same reasons, Rule 37(1).
- J Edwards v Unite the Union & Ors [2024] EAT 151 20 September 2024 This EAT decision concerned two appeals from an Employment Tribunal judgment in a discrimination/victimisation claim by a disabled union member. The EAT held the ET erred in applying the s.136 EqA 2010 burden‑shifting test to the victimisation complaint about Ms Formby's investigation and that the Claimant's 9 October 2017 email did amount to a protected act alleging failure to make a reasonable adjustment (disability). The EAT substituted findings on those points, concluded the burden had shifted and was not discharged by the Respondent, and remitted remaining issues (consequences and remedy) to a freshly constituted ET.
- Christopher Zagorski v North West Anglia NHS Foundation Trust [2024] EAT 164 12 September 2024 This appeal concerned whether the claimant's recurrent migraines met the Equality Act 2010 definition of disability. The EAT held the Employment Tribunal erred in law by relying on potential behaviour modification to discount the effects of the migraines and, applying the correct approach, substituted a finding that the claimant was disabled at the relevant times. The EAT therefore allowed the appeal and set aside the Tribunal's contrary disability finding.
- Paul Morley v UNISON The Public Service Union [2024] EAT 143 12 September 2024 This appeal concerned (1) strike out of two complaints about the February 2021 Lancashire branch secretary election and (2) refusal of jurisdiction over a complaint that the appellant's membership was ceased shortly before a 2022 election. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the Certification Officer's strike out of the two 2021 complaints as lacking any reasonable prospect of success. The Tribunal accepted the respondent's concession on jurisdiction for the membership-cessation complaint and remitted that complaint to the Certification Officer for full consideration.
- R Moon v Slater & Gordon UK Ltd [2024] EAT 144 12 September 2024 This appeal concerned claims by Mr Moon for unpaid discretionary bonuses, disability-related harassment and unfair dismissal following a redundancy. The EAT held the ET erred in treating the bonus claim as if it gave rise to an unlawful deduction from wages under s.27(1) ERA but that error was academic because no identifiable/crystallised sum was pleaded for the discretionary bonuses; the harassment finding was not perverse; and dismissal was for redundancy but unfair because no appeal was offered. The claimant’s appeal was dismissed; the employer’s cross-appeal succeeded on jurisdiction/definition grounds without changing the substantive outcome.
- S Thomas v Surrey and Borders Partnership NHS Foundation Trust & Anor [2024] EAT 141 5 September 2024 This appeal concerned whether the claimant’s “English nationalism” (including public anti‑Islamic advocacy) qualified as a protected philosophical belief under s.10 Equality Act 2010. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s use of the Grainger framework (with Forstater consistent) and agreed that the claimant’s expressed advocacy — including calls to ban or forcibly remove Islam/Muslims — fell within the exceptional Article 17(2) exclusion and so was not protected. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal’s preliminary finding stands.
- South Gloucestershire Council v Pavandeep Hundal [2024] EAT 140 5 September 2024 This appeal concerned whether the claimant, an agency social worker with endometriosis, was discriminated against when her engagement was terminated because of disability‑related sickness absences. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Tribunal erred in treating the conduct as direct discrimination under s.13 EqA 2010 but upheld the finding of discrimination arising from disability under s.15. The EAT also upheld the Tribunal's conclusion that the respondent failed to justify the termination as a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
- C Johnson v GT Gettaxi (UK) Ltd [2024] EAT 162 28 August 2024 This EAT appeal concerned whether a licensed Hackney Carriage driver who used the respondent’s booking app was a limb (b) "worker" under s.230(3)(b) ERA. The tribunal found the driver was in business on his own account, because drivers remained free to ply for hire and the external regulatory regime (TfL/Hackney rules) and the factual matrix showed the app was ancillary; the EAT dismissed the appeal, finding no error of law or perversity. The tribunal therefore lacked jurisdiction to hear the claimant’s asserted worker claims.
- R Thomas v Brandpath UK LTD [2024] EAT 150 22 August 2024 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal erred in law in assessing the fairness of a dismissal when it identified but did not decide whether a prior final written warning was manifestly unfair, and when it failed properly to consider whether the employer's investigation fell within the band of reasonable responses. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal on those grounds, substituted a finding of unfair dismissal by consent, and remitted remedy issues to the original Tribunal.
- Erhard-Jensen Ontological/Phenomenological Initiative Limited v Daniel Rogerson [2024] EAT 135 20 August 2024 The EAT allowed the employer's appeal, holding the ET was wrong to reject judicial proceedings immunity (JPI) in respect of the claimant’s pleaded post‑employment detriment that the respondent had commenced a groundless ICC arbitration in Singapore (para 16(g)). The EAT found the detriment was founded on the content of the arbitration initiating documents and therefore fell within established JPI principles, and that the Singapore seat did not, as a matter of law, prevent the immunity applying. The EAT substituted a finding that JPI applied to paragraph 16(g), struck that part of the claim out, and remitted remaining issues to the Employment Tribunal.
- Ian Escudier v Coca-Cola Europacific Partners Great Britain Limited [2024] EAT 145 20 August 2024 This is an EAT appeal where the tribunal held the claimant was not disabled by cough syncope or anxiety/depression; the EAT found the tribunal's conclusion that cough syncope did not have a substantial adverse effect and was not likely to last more than 12 months was perverse and remitted that issue for redetermination, while upholding the tribunal's finding that anxiety/depression was not a disability.
- Nkechi Leeks v University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2024] EAT 134 16 August 2024 This is an EAT decision overturning an Employment Tribunal's strike-out of two linked discrimination claims where the Judge had treated a respondent witness leaving employment as making that witness "lost" and thus justified strike-out. The EAT held departure from employment is not automatically fatal and remitted the strike-out and associated costs decisions for redetermination after fuller assessment; it also held that refusal to engage in voluntary judicial mediation/assessment can, in principle, be unreasonable conduct attracting a costs order.
- Andras Szucs v Greensquare Group Ltd [2024] EAT 160 15 August 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal gave adequate, Meek‑compliant reasons when rejecting that the claimant’s protected acts were a cause of his dismissal and when treating some complaints as separable from protected acts. The EAT held the ET had applied the correct legal test but used inconsistent language, failed to identify clearly the actual reason(s) for dismissal, and did not explain why it preferred some contemporaneous documentary inferences over others. The appeal was allowed and the matter remitted to the same Employment Tribunal for rehearing; no substantive findings were substituted.
- British Airways PLC v B Rollett & Ors [2024] EAT 131 15 August 2024 This appeal concerned whether section 19 of the Equality Act 2010 can be read to permit indirect discrimination claims by persons who do not share the protected characteristic of the disadvantaged group but suffer the same disadvantage. The EAT upheld the ET's preliminary ruling that, consistent with CJEU authority in CHEZ and the Marleasing interpretative obligation, section 19 may be read to allow such "same disadvantage" claims and dismissed British Airways' appeal. The court directed parties to propose precise wording to give effect to that interpretation if necessary.
- Carnival PLC (t/a Carnival UK) v Laura Hunter [2024] EAT 167 15 August 2024 The employer appealed findings that a claimant on maternity leave had been both automatically and ordinarily unfairly dismissed after team‑leader posts were reduced from 21 to 16. The EAT held the Tribunal erred in treating the remaining pre‑existing posts as "suitable alternative vacancies" under Regulation 10 MAPLE and also found the Tribunal had not properly handled errors in the redundancy scoring/selection. The EAT quashed both unfair dismissal findings and remitted the case for rehearing.
- M Hewer & Anor v HCT Group & Ors [2024] EAT 133 14 August 2024 This appeal to the EAT concerned whether an appeal was properly instituted when the appellant filed written reasons but failed to file the Employment Tribunal's short written judgment as required by Rule 3(1). The EAT held the appeal was not properly instituted by that omission but, exercising its discretion and having regard to the explanation and timeliness of rectification, granted an extension of time so the appeal could proceed to sift.
- T Amber v West Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service [2024] EAT 146 14 August 2024 This appeal challenges an employment judge's preliminary decisions striking out whistleblowing detriment complaints as out of time and ordering deposit payments on alleged harassment/discrimination incidents. The EAT found the judge erred by not taking the claimant's pleaded case at its highest, failing to apply the Cox v Adecco approach, and making deposit orders where factual disputes required resolution at a merits hearing. The appeals on strike out and contested deposit orders were allowed and the matter was remitted for case management and rehearing.
- Trevor Farley v Sunderland City Council [2024] EAT 115 14 August 2024 This appeal concerned Trevor Farley's disability discrimination claims arising from three April 2020 incidents and the Employment Tribunal's (ET) dismissal and refusal to extend time. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) dismissed Farley's appeal, upholding the ET's findings that he was not disabled at the material time, the employer lacked requisite knowledge, no PCP was applied, and no extension of time should be granted. Procedural challenges about the hearing bundles and the Registrar's directions were also dismissed.
- J Parnell v Royal Mail Group Ltd [2024] EAT 130 12 August 2024 This is an EAT appeal by J Parnell against dismissal of post‑Jan 2020 claims by the Shotter ET, including disability discrimination (s.15 EqA), reasonable adjustments (s.20/21) and unfair dismissal. The EAT found a limited legal error in the Shotter ET's s.15 causation analysis (failing to consider chains of causal links and to explain unfavourable treatment reasoning adequately) but dismissed the appeal overall because the ET's conclusions on justification and lack of any effective adjustment by the dismissal date were open on the evidence. The Shotter ET's dismissal of the claims therefore stands.
- Jen Nelson v Renfrewshire Council [2024] EAT 132 12 August 2024 This is an appeal by a teacher who resigned alleging constructive unfair dismissal after an aggressive incident by her head teacher and flawed stage 1 and 2 grievance handling. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed parts of the appeal, finding legal errors in the Tribunal's reliance on the claimant's failure to pursue stage 3, misapplication of the Malik objective test, and failure to consider cumulative conduct, and remitted the case to the same Tribunal for reconsideration on those points; the Tribunal's factual findings in the claimant's favour were left undisturbed. The appeal was otherwise dismissed.
- G Treadwell v Barton Turns Development Ltd [2024] EAT 137 7 August 2024 This case concerns an appeal about whether late amendments to an ET1 that characterised the claimant's dismissal by a director as a "detriment" under section 47B ERA should have been permitted. The EAT, applying the Court of Appeal decision in Timis and Sage v Osipov, held the employment judge erred in refusing the amendment treating dismissal as a detriment, ordered that amendment (paragraph 13) to be allowed, and dismissed the respondent's cross‑appeal. The EAT treated the other allowed amendments as permissible re‑labelling of existing pleaded facts and noted practical case‑management issues, including deferring remedy questions pending related appeals.
- Hesham Elhalabi v Avis Budget UK Ltd [2025] EAT 11 7 August 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred by (1) not considering that the claimant had not been warned he faced an allegation of dishonesty before dismissal and (2) failing to consider or explain the relevance of out-of-time background race discrimination complaints. The EAT dismissed both grounds, holding the Tribunal could treat the background complaints as immaterial to the in‑time claims and that the procedural point about lack of warning was a new argument not raised below and not an obvious issue the Tribunal had to raise of its own motion.
- Artem Limited v K Edwins [2024] EAT 136 6 August 2024 This appeal concerned an employee's constructive dismissal, unfair dismissal and sex and race discrimination claims after her employer said it had "lost confidence" in her. The ET found repudiatory conduct causing constructive dismissal and (by majority) shifted the burden of proof to the employer and found discrimination; the EAT held the ET majority erred at stage one of the Equality Act burden‑shifting and overturned the discrimination findings, remitting those claims to the same ET for redetermination. The unfair dismissal finding was not disturbed on the appeal as it was treated as academic for remedy reasons.
- Nigel Midgley v Vossloh Cogifer UK Ltd [2024] EAT 149 6 August 2024 This EAT appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's order that the claimant pay the respondent's costs after an unsuccessful unfair dismissal/protected disclosure claim. The respondent had relied on a solicitor's "Without Prejudice" letter supplied to the tribunal with the "Without Prejudice" heading and surrounding passages redacted, and the tribunal treated the unredacted parts as a costs warning. The EAT held the tribunal had been inadvertently misled and made an error of law in relying on the redacted material, quashed the costs order, and declined to remit the matter.
- Quorous Slater v Allen Ford UK Ltd [2024] EAT 139 6 August 2024 This appeal concerned strike‑out orders that dismissed all of the claimant's employment complaints after summary dismissal for alleged misuse of a police fuel card. HHJ Auerbach held the tribunal erred in three specific strike‑out decisions: the protected‑disclosure unfair‑dismissal complaint was wrongly characterised and not taken at its highest (refused to be struck out), and the direct sex discrimination and "forced overtime" (breach of contract) complaints were improperly resolved at a preliminary stage and were remitted for fresh consideration by a different judge. The appeal was allowed in respect of those three strike‑out orders.
- Melanie Carroll-Cliffe v Pembrey and Burry Port Town Council [2024] EAT 125 2 August 2024 This appeal concerned an ET costs decision under rule 76 after the claimant (former Town Clerk) succeeded on constructive unfair and wrongful dismissal but the ET refused most of her claimed costs, awarding £1,000 for unreasonable conduct in disclosure/hearing bundle preparation. The claimant argued the ET misapplied the objective "no reasonable prospect" threshold and treated pre‑claim conduct as conduct "of the proceedings"; the EAT rejected those arguments and dismissed the appeal. The EAT held the ET had applied the two‑stage threshold-and-discretion approach correctly and was entitled to refuse the remainder of the costs claimed.
- N Notaro Homes Ltd v C Keirle & Ors [2024] EAT 122 31 July 2024 This EAT decision concerned whether a tribunal must always reduce a compensatory award under s.123(6) ERA where it finds the claimant's culpable conduct contributed to dismissal. The tribunal found four dismissals were in truth for protected disclosures although the claimants had made culpable social-media posts; it made no reduction and the EAT dismissed the employer’s appeal. The EAT held that while tribunals must consider reduction, there is no legal rule requiring some reduction in every case; on these facts a decision of zero reduction was not unlawful.
- Mansfield Care Limited v Leah Newman & Ors [2024] EAT 128 30 July 2024 This appeal concerned whether the June 2021 closure/move of Adamwood Nursing Home gave rise to TUPE protections (both a business transfer and a service provision change), whether a collective consultation duty under TULRCA arose, and whether staff described as "bank staff" were employees. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal's finding that the lead claimant (Ms Smith) was an employee, allowed the employer's and council's appeals in part, found the ET's reasoning on TUPE and on TULRCA consultation defective, and remitted the limited TUPE issues for reconsideration by the ET.
- Leicester City Council v John Gibbin [2024] EAT 138 25 July 2024 This EAT judgment concerned claims that Leicester City Council discriminated against an employee with longstanding depression by investigatory and disciplinary steps and failed to make reasonable adjustments. The tribunal had found some "something arising" and s.20–21 failures, but the EAT upheld the tribunal's factual findings that certain conduct arose from the claimant's disability while allowing appeal in part because the tribunal applied an incorrect causation test and erred in parts of its reasonable‑adjustments and justification reasoning. The EAT set aside several of the tribunal's findings (claims 4(b), 4(c), 5 and related s.20/8, and 7(b),(c),(d)) while leaving other unchallenged findings intact.
- The Scottish Ministers v Johanna Johnston [2024] EAT 121 25 July 2024 This case concerns whether a salaried full‑time Sheriff who was also appointed and sat as a Temporary Judge became a part‑time worker for purposes of the Part‑Time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations. The Employment Tribunal had found two concurrent part‑time appointments arose by conduct; the Employment Appeal Tribunal set that finding aside, construed section 20B of the Judiciary and Courts (Scotland) Act 2008 as preserving the terms of the shrieval appointment, held there was insufficient evidence to infer two separate employment relationships, and declared the claimant was not a part‑time worker under the Regulations, dismissing her claim.
- Allison Bailey v Stonewall Equality Limited & Ors [2024] EAT 119 24 July 2024 This appeal concerned whether Stonewall (through an employee's complaint) had "caused" or "induced" Garden Court Chambers' (GCC) direct discrimination against Allison Bailey for her gender-critical beliefs. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the Employment Tribunal's findings that GCC directly discriminated but that Stonewall's complaint was a protest and did not instruct, induce or cause GCC's discriminatory outcome. The EAT found no error of law and dismissed the appeal on liability against Stonewall; Ms Bailey's successful claim against GCC and its service company was unaffected.
- Commissioners for Revenue and Customs v Lees of Scotland Limited [2024] EAT 120 23 July 2024 This case concerns whether employee deductions placed into Lees of Scotland Ltd's main trading account under a voluntary holiday savings scheme were made for the employer's "own use and benefit" for National Minimum Wage (NMW) purposes, and whether subsequent refunds could be treated as "additional remuneration" to discharge NMW arrears. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) held the Employment Tribunal erred: because the deducted sums were held in the employer's main account and at its disposal they were for the employer's use and benefit, so HMRC's notice of underpayment was restored. The EAT also found refunds from the scheme could not be treated as extinguishing NMW arrears absent a link to specific pay reference periods and appropriate uplift.
- Raymond Cairns v The Royal Mail Group Limited [2024] EAT 129 23 July 2024 This appeal concerned Mr Cairns' Equality Act claims (s.15 and s.20) after he was retired on ill‑health and his appeal against dismissal was rejected. The EAT held the tribunal failed to determine essential factual and evaluative aspects of his case as it stood at the appeal decision—notably whether an imminent depot merger would have created suitable indoor roles and whether postponing dismissal until that merger was a reasonable adjustment. The appeal was allowed in part and the Equality Act findings set aside and remitted to a differently constituted tribunal limited to fresh consideration of those appeal‑stage issues; unchallenged findings (including the unfair dismissal decision) remain binding.
- AEL v Flight Centre (UK) Ltd [2024] EAT 116 22 July 2024 This appeal concerned two Rule 50 anonymity applications by the claimant and the Employment Tribunal's failure to consider the second application (4 August 2021) on its merits, instead treating a reconsideration as relating to the earlier refused application and as a Rule 70 matter. The EAT held that the ET erred in that approach, allowed the appeal, and exercised its powers to grant an anonymity order substituting the claimant's initials "AEL" and directing revision of public judgments.
- Heidi Bennet v London Borough of Islington [2024] EAT 118 19 July 2024 This appeal concerns the Employment Appeal Tribunal's review of a tribunal's refusal to postpone a ten‑day unfair dismissal and disability discrimination hearing after the claimant's volunteer representative confirmed he would not attend due to ill health. The EAT found the tribunal erred by not treating the renewed postponement application as involving a material change (loss of representative supported by medical evidence) and by failing to consider a short adjournment to obtain further medical evidence about the claimant's ability to represent herself given her diagnosed mental health conditions. The EAT allowed the appeal and remitted the case for a fresh hearing before a differently constituted tribunal.
- Addison Lee v H Afshar & Ors [2024] EAT 114 18 July 2024 This appeal concerned Employment Tribunal Rule 39 deposit orders made against hundreds of claimants in mass claims after earlier "Lange" litigation had found similar claims likely to succeed. The EAT dismissed Addison Lee's appeals, holding the tribunal could rely on the prior, closely connected decisions when making a Rule 39 assessment, that refusal to strike out did not preclude making deposit orders, and that the staged procedure (first setting caps in principle, later naming beneficiaries and apportioning amounts) was a permissible case‑management approach; the deposit orders were upheld as proportionate.
- L. Oyebisi v Hyde Housing Association Ltd [2024] EAT 124 16 July 2024 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal’s strike‑out of a claimant’s claims under rule 37 after misconduct by her lay representative and non‑compliance with tribunal orders. The EAT held the ET acted unfairly because the claimant and her representative were not given a reasonable opportunity or adequate notice to respond to the respondent’s strike‑out application, allowed the appeal and remitted the case to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal. The EAT refused the claimant’s application for costs and made no costs order against the respondent.
- Leslie Easton & Co Ltd & Anor v Tina Donlon [2024] EAT 126 16 July 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal should have adjourned to obtain up‑to‑date medical evidence about a respondent’s fitness/capacity to give evidence after that respondent had suffered a severe stroke. The EAT held there was legitimate doubt about the respondent’s capacity and that the Tribunal erred in refusing an adjournment and in treating the respondent as having deliberately chosen not to give evidence. The EAT allowed the appeal on that ground and remitted the main liability issues (sexual harassment and victimisation) for rehearing by a different Employment Tribunal, leaving the earlier time‑limit decision intact.
- W Augustine v Data Cars Ltd [2024] EAT 117 15 July 2024 This appeal under the Part-Time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2000 concerned whether a flat weekly "circuit fee" charged equally to all drivers amounted to less favourable treatment of a part-time driver when assessed pro rata, and the correct causal test under regulation 5(2)(a). The EAT held that a pro rata/time-and-proportion analysis is appropriate and upheld the appeal on that ground, and further held that part-time status must be the effective and predominant (but not necessarily sole) cause of the treatment; the ET was wrong to rely on employer intention. The appeal was therefore upheld on ground 1 and in part on ground 2, with the parties invited to make submissions on disposal.
- G Masiero & Ors v Barchester Healthcare Limited [2024] EAT 112 11 July 2024 This is an EAT appeal upholding Employment Tribunal findings that dismissals of care‑home staff who refused COVID‑19 vaccination were fair. The EAT rejected challenges that the Tribunal misapplied the SOSR/Catamaran test, failed to balance Article 8 rights properly, or treated the policy as forced medical treatment; it found interference with Article 8 justified (including by Article 2-related protection of life). The appeal was dismissed and the Tribunal's substantive and procedural conclusions, including in respect of Mrs Hussain, were upheld.
- Minis Childcare Ltd v Z Hilton-Webb [2024] EAT 108 10 July 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal’s finding of indirect disability discrimination arising from the respondent providing documents in a "small" font to an employee with Apert syndrome and impaired vision. The EAT held the ET’s brief conclusion that there was "no legitimate aim" was legally inadequate, allowed the appeal and remitted the single complaint for redetermination with directions to clarify factual matters (including exact font sizes) and to conduct a proper proportionality analysis. The EAT accepted that "efficient management" can, in principle, be a legitimate aim for standard-format documentation but emphasised that justification requires a reasoned assessment.
- D Bangura v OCS UK & I Ltd [2024] EAT 155 9 July 2024 This appeal to the EAT challenged an Employment Tribunal finding that the claimant, after a workplace fall, had not proved a physical impairment causing a substantial and long-term adverse effect on standing/moving and so was not disabled for Equality Act purposes. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the Tribunal's factual conclusion was open on the evidence, including inconsistent accounts, limited objective findings, and the claimant's failure to produce an ordered medical report. The consequence is that there was no duty on the employer to make reasonable adjustments.
- D Chumbu v The Disabilities Trust [2024] EAT 113 9 July 2024 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal's refusal to grant relief from sanction after the claimant failed to comply with an unless order requiring service of an updated witness statement and payment of a costs award. The EAT upheld the ET's refusal of relief in respect of the witness statement as reasonable and proportionate, but found it was unlawful to make the costs award the functional equivalent of a deposit in an unless order without the safeguards of the deposit regime. The appeal was dismissed overall because the correct refusal on the witness‑statement ground meant the claim would have been dismissed in any event.
- HSBC European Works Council v HSBC Continental Europe [2024] EAT 104 4 July 2024 This case concerned challenges by the HSBC European Works Council to HSBC Continental Europe's post‑Brexit designation of an Irish representative agent and amendments to their 2015 EWC Agreement that excluded UK operations and changed the implementing law. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeals, holding the Agreement unambiguously covered only "EEA Member States" so UK operations fell outside its scope post‑Brexit, and that the designation and consequential amendments were lawful and did not breach the Agreement or Article 18.5. The tribunal also rejected the EWC's arguments about Regulation 40 and procedural unfairness.
- Christopher Watson v Wallwork Nelson Johnson & Anor [2024] EAT 105 28 June 2024 The claimant, a senior tax accountant, was found by an Employment Tribunal to have become an associate partner (a de facto partnership under the Partnership Act 1890) and therefore not an "employee" under s.230 ERA, although the Tribunal also found he qualified as a "worker" under s.230(3)(b). The EAT dismissed the claimant's appeal, holding the ET lawfully applied a multifactorial assessment and permissibly inferred a partnership from conduct and agreed essential terms despite the absence of a signed deed; the ET's credibility and weight findings were for it to make. The ET's finding that the claimant was a worker was not inconsistent with the partnership conclusion and was left undisturbed. The claimant's claim for unauthorised deductions upheld below was not disturbed.
- Mathy Jorine Matondo v Kingsland Nursery Limited [2024] EAT 123 27 June 2024 This Employment Appeal Tribunal decision allowed an appeal by a former nursery worker who had sued for unpaid overtime, finding the original tribunal had erred by effectively treating uncorroborated oral recollection as insufficient as a matter of law and by failing to consider contemporaneous communications and other evidence. The EAT remitted the wages claim for rehearing with directions on case management, disclosure and the proper appraisal of all evidence. The holiday pay claim had previously succeeded and that part of the decision was not disturbed.
- Taylors Service Ltd (Dissolved) & Ors v The Commissioners for HMRC [2024] EAT 102 26 June 2024 This appeal concerned whether time spent by poultry workers travelling in employer‑provided minibuses between home and their first or last farm assignment counted as "time work" under regs 30 and 34 of the National Minimum Wage Regulations 2015. The Employment Tribunal found the journeys were not "work" in the ordinary sense but nonetheless treated them as time work under reg 30; the EAT applied the Supreme Court's approach in Royal Mencap Society v Tomlinson‑Blake, read regs 30 and 34 together, and concluded ordinary travel is not time work absent deeming by reg 34. The EAT allowed the appeal, set aside and remade the Tribunal's decision, and quashed the Notices of Underpayment.
- Buildmaster Construction Services Ltd v Ghada Al-Naimi [2024] EAT 101 25 June 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal award of £9,750 for unlawful deductions from wages where the employer claimed an oral variation of pay linked to workload/profits. The EAT held the ET had correctly applied the two-stage s.13 ERA approach (identifying what was properly payable and then considering authorisation) without conflating the stages, and that the ET gave adequate reasons for rejecting the employer’s oral variation evidence. The employer’s appeal was dismissed and the ET award upheld.
- Dr Marcul Bicknell & Anor v NHS Nottingham and Nottinghamshire Integrated Commissioning Board [2024] EAT 103 25 June 2024 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal decision that the dissolution of Nottingham City CCG and transfer of functions to Nottingham and Nottinghamshire CCG did not amount to a TUPE "relevant transfer" because the CCG's core activity was commissioning (purchasing) rather than supplying goods or services on a market. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the Tribunal's reliance on Nicholls and CJEU authorities to hold that commissioning, standing alone, is not an "economic activity" for TUPE purposes, so no relevant transfer occurred and the TUPE claims failed. The appeal was dismissed and the Tribunal's findings and reasoning were held sufficient.
- J Wharton v Sheehan Haulage and Plant Hire Ltd [2024] EAT 127 25 June 2024 This appeal concerned whether an unlawful deduction claim was out of time. The EAT held the employment judge erred by treating time as running from termination (9 Sept 2020) rather than from the date of the payment alleged to be the deduction (18 Sept 2020), and found the claimant had contacted ACAS within three months and presented his claim in time. The appeal was allowed and the claim was remitted to the ET for determination.
- His Honour Timothy Clayson & Ors v Ministry of Justice & Anor [2024] EAT 99 24 June 2024 Three former fee‑paid recorders who later became salaried circuit judges challenged less favourable pension treatment under JUPRA compared with earlier JPA terms, arguing it derived from prior part‑time recording service. The Employment Tribunal found recorder and circuit judge offices distinct, that the part‑time discrimination affecting recorder service had been remedied, and that the ongoing difference in pension treatment resulted from their appointment/timing under JUPRA after 31 March 1995 rather than their prior part‑time status. The EAT dismissed the appeal and upheld the ET's decision, leaving the claimants' salaried circuit judge service on JUPRA terms.
- Helen Ballerino v The Racecourse Association Ltd [2024] EAT 98 20 June 2024 The EAT allowed Ms Ballerino's appeal against the ET's dismissal of her claims, holding the ET failed to engage with the statutory redundancy test in section 139 ERA and remitting the issues of redundancy, direct sex/pregnancy and maternity discrimination, and automatic unfair dismissal to the ET for reconsideration. The EAT declined to order a rehearing before a fresh panel and directed remission to the same ET panel where practicable.
- Ronnie Blair v George Burr [2024] EAT 100 20 June 2024 This appeal concerns an Employment Tribunal's dismissal of an unlawful deduction from wages claim by Mr Blair after he resigned in November 2022. The ET treated the claim as limited to notice pay and a defamation allegation and did not address an asserted separate claim for unpaid wages for the period 1–18 November 2022. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found that to be an error and remitted only the discrete issue of unpaid wages for 1–18 November 2022 back to the same ET for determination. Other grounds advanced but not pleaded in the ET1 were not treated as errors of law.
- Liliana Vassallo v Mizuho International PLC & Anor [2024] EAT 170 19 June 2024 This appeal concerned the Employment Judge's refusal to allow the Claimant to amend her ET claim to add whistleblowing, automatic unfair dismissal and indirect associative sex discrimination claims. The Employment Judge found, on the materials and submissions, that earlier drafts and counsel's submissions showed an informed decision had been taken not to plead whistleblowing and that the Claimant had not adduced evidence or waived privilege to contradict that. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding no error of law in the refusal to permit the amendments.
- Thorney Golf Centre Limited v Andrew Reed & Anor [2024] EAT 96 19 June 2024 This appeal concerned a tribunal's refusal to extend time for a late response and the consequential substantive judgment reached with the respondent largely precluded from contesting the case. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the tribunal erred by failing to begin its delay analysis with the prejudice caused by the original lateness and by not properly weighing the prejudice to the respondent of being prevented from contesting the merits. The EAT allowed the appeal against the refusal of the extension and consequentially allowed the appeal against the December 2021 substantive decision, directing that any fresh rule 20 decision must be taken by an Employment Judge sitting alone.
- B Knight v Off Broadway Limited [2024] EAT 109 18 June 2024 This appeal concerned whether a claimant could carry over holiday under the Working Time (Coronavirus) (Amendment) Regulations 2020 after Covid-related business disruption. The EAT held the tribunal was correct on some factual points but erred by failing to apply and record the specific Shimizu guidance on whether the employer had taken steps to enable or inform the worker to take leave; the appeal was allowed in part and two issues were remitted for further factual determination. The questions remitted were whether the respondent complied with its duty under Shimizu/Reg 13(10) and precisely how much holiday the claimant took in 2019/20.
- C v Grampian Health Board & Ors [2024] EAT 97 18 June 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal should have applied the narrow exception in Royal Mail v Jhuti (and Uddin) to attribute a third respondent’s mindset to the employer when assessing fairness of dismissal. The tribunal found dismissal was for a substantial reason (loss of a national training number) and fair, and the Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld that conclusion, rejecting application of Jhuti/Uddin because there was no evidence of a superior hiding the true reason and the facts involved distinct entities. The appeal was dismissed.
- Cheryl Lobo v University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2024] EAT 91 18 June 2024 This is an appeal by Cheryl Lobo challenging an Employment Tribunal’s finding that successive fixed‑term locum contracts did not convert into a permanent post under the Fixed‑term Employees (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2002 because the last renewal was objectively justified. The ET found the claimant’s 6‑PA locum role was genuinely different from the substantive 10‑PA consultant post the Trust created, and that the Trust’s ring‑fencing, encouragement and coaching showed no lack of good faith. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, finding no error of law and that the ET’s factual conclusions were open to it.
- M Birkett v Integral UK Ltd [2024] EAT 107 18 June 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal made sufficient findings about (a) the employer's search for suitable alternative vacancies and (b) why the claimant was not appointed to a Manchester vacancy for which he was interviewed. The EAT allowed the claimant's limited appeal, holding the ET's factual findings on those two points were insufficient for the purposes of section 98(4) ERA and remitted those narrow issues to the same ET (if practicable) for redetermination, while leaving the ET's findings that dismissal was for redundancy and that there was no discrimination intact.
- The British Council v Ana-Maria Beldica [2024] EAT 92 17 June 2024 The claimant, employed by the British Council in Dubai, brought UK employment claims after being unable to pursue them in the UAE. The ET had found that a hypothetical plea of diplomatic/state immunity by the respondent in UAE proceedings would sever the territorial pull of UAE law and engage Article 6 ECHR, giving the UK tribunal jurisdiction. The EAT allowed the respondent’s appeal, holding that a hypothetical or unexercised plea of immunity does not itself amount to acts of state authority sufficient to establish extra‑territorial ECHR jurisdiction and that the ET could not assume such a plea would breach customary international law without factual assessment. The ET’s jurisdictional decision was set aside.
- Staffordshire County Council v Desna Lowers [2024] EAT 110 14 June 2024 This appeal concerned the Employment Judge's decision to strike out the respondent's defence after repeated non‑compliance, late and voluminous disclosure, and failure to comply with orders for further particulars, which the EJ concluded made a fair trial on liability impossible. The EAT upheld the strike‑out as proportionate and within the EJ's discretion, but found a narrow error in that the EJ did not expressly consider the consequences of strike‑out for the respondent’s participation in any remedy hearing; that error did not undermine the strike‑out and no further directions were required because the respondent has since been permitted to attend a remedy hearing.
- Hafeez Ahmed v Department for Work and Pensions [2024] EAT 84 10 June 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Judge erred in assessing whether the claimant was disabled by depression for Equality Act purposes, where the EJ treated 22–25 September 2020 as the "Relevant Period" and found no disability then. The EAT allowed the appeal on Ground 1, holding the EJ wrongly selected and relied on that limited period without ensuring the litigant in person appreciated the consequences, remitting the question of disability at the correct relevant times to a different judge; all other grounds of appeal were dismissed.
- Ian Clifford v IBM United Kingdom Ltd [2024] EAT 90 10 June 2024 This appeal concerned whether a 2013 compromise agreement precluded the claimant's later disability discrimination claims and whether those claims had any reasonable prospects of success. The EAT upheld the ET's strike‑out, holding the settlement met s.147(3)(b) Equality Act requirements because it sufficiently identified the types of future claims it covered, and alternatively that the pleaded discrimination claims were plainly unarguable. The appeal was dismissed and the claims remain struck out.
- Adrian Ikeji v Office of Rail and Road & Ors [2024] EAT 87 5 June 2024 This appeal concerned whether Rule 3(1)(b) of the EAT Rules 1993 (as then worded) required service of every ET1/ET3 from multiple tribunal claims heard together in order to properly institute an EAT appeal. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held that Rule 3(1)(b) should be read to require service of the claim and response relevant to the specific judgment under appeal, not all claims in the broader proceedings, and that the appellant had properly instituted the appeal in respect of the second claim. The court also treated the appeal against the Registrar’s refusal to extend time on that basis.
- NSL Ltd v P Zaluski [2024] EAT 86 5 June 2024 This case concerned claims of indirect race discrimination and harassment arising from an employer's leave/quarantine policies and a manager's threatening emails after a Polish employee overstayed authorised leave for bereavement and quarantine. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the employer's appeal on justification, finding the tribunal had materially erred in its proportionality analysis and remitted that issue for fresh consideration, but upheld the tribunal's finding that the manager's repeated threat emails amounted to race-related harassment. The EAT quashed aggravated damages and two recommendations, leaving injury-to-feelings liability intact subject to reconsideration of remedy after justification is re-decided.
- Leicester City Council v B Parmar [2024] EAT 85 4 June 2024 This is an employment tribunal race discrimination claim by a long‑serving Head of Service of Indian origin who was temporarily transferred and investigated after complaints in January 2021. The ET found facts supporting an inference of race discrimination because similar complaints about white staff were handled informally while the claimant was formally investigated, shifted the burden of proof to the respondent, and concluded the respondent failed to rebut that inference; the EAT upheld those central findings and dismissed major grounds of appeal. The claimant's separate allegation of false allegations was dismissed by the ET.
- Ian Bugden v The Royal Mail Group Limited [2024] EAT 80 28 May 2024 This appeal concerns Mr Bugden’s challenge to Employment Tribunal findings dismissing his unfair dismissal and failure-to-make-reasonable-adjustments claims after dismissal under Royal Mail’s attendance policy. The EAT rejected the complaint that the tribunal should have raised a specific redeployment adjustment (Ground 1) but allowed the complaint that the tribunal erred in not considering redeployment as an alternative to dismissal when assessing fairness (Ground 3). The unfair dismissal decision was set aside and remitted to the Employment Tribunal for reconsideration limited to whether redeployment was considered as an alternative to dismissal.
- First Greater Western Limited v Ahmed Moses Moussa [2024] EAT 82 24 May 2024 This appeal concerned whether First Greater Western (FGW) had subjected Mr Moussa to whistleblowing detriments and victimisation arising from protected disclosures/acts in 2012–13, where later decision‑makers in 2018–19 lacked direct knowledge of those earlier matters. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal’s findings that FGW had inflicted detriments because an institutional “collective memory” within management (notably via HR adviser Ms Czechowicz) perpetuated prejudice against the claimant, and dismissed FGW’s challenges on perversity, adequacy of reasons and procedural unfairness. The Employment Tribunal’s causation analysis and factual findings were held to be open to it and not flawed in law.
- R Godfrey v Natwest Markets Plc [2024] EAT 81 24 May 2024 This is an appeal from an ET decision rejecting claims of disability discrimination under ss.13 and 15 EqA by a claimant diagnosed with Asperger's. The EAT held the ET correctly found no actual knowledge by the respondent and, despite a slip in reasoning by the majority focusing on diagnosis, upheld the ET's counterfactual factual finding that the claimant would have refused assessment and therefore the respondent lacked constructive knowledge. The appeal was dismissed and the ET's decision upheld without remit.
- Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd v Lee Loverseed & Ors [2024] EAT 79 24 May 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal order requiring Virgin Atlantic to disclose unredacted internal management documents (April–July 2020) showing financial figures redacted from materials about a redundancy exercise. The EAT held the redactions were relevant under CPR 31.6 to pleaded issues (causation, fairness/transparency of selection, whether cost‑saving drove selection, and proportionality in indirect discrimination defences) and dismissed the employer's appeal, directing production of clean copies (excluding payroll identifiers). The EAT also held that Hancock does not impose a separate attestation requirement for routine redactions in disclosure.
- Tesco Stores Ltd v K Element & Ors [2024] EAT 83 23 May 2024 This is an appeal by Tesco against Employment Tribunal case management orders in large multi-claimant equal pay litigation, principally challenging a standard disclosure order (order 5) and an issues-based disclosure order (order 13.1), and the sequencing of an MFD hearing before the final equal value hearing. The EAT dismissed the appeal against orders 5 and 13.1, upheld the tribunal's discretion to order staged disclosure and to list the MFD hearing first, refused to require immediate pleading of discrimination by claimants, and dismissed Tesco's stay application as academic.
- Jessica Anderson v CAE Crewing Services Limited [2024] EAT 78 22 May 2024 This appeal concerned whether two AME doctors were agents of CAE Crewing Services for the purposes of s.109 Equality Act 2010 and whether the Employment Tribunal correctly analysed disability discrimination and timeliness. The EAT held the Tribunal had erred by conflating agency with vicarious liability and remitted the agency issue and incomplete substantive discrimination reasoning for redetermination before a different Tribunal; limited complaints about disciplinary proceedings and a final written warning were remitted to the same Tribunal, while most timeliness findings were upheld.
- Wendy Drake v Churchill Contract Services Ltd [2024] EAT 88 22 May 2024 This appeal concerned whether the ET should have considered an automatic unfair dismissal claim under TUPE regulation 7 where the claimant was dismissed after a service transfer and re-engaged on reduced terms. The EAT found the tribunal erred by failing to explore whether a regulation 7 claim was being advanced, given the claimant’s pleadings, emails and PH papers that raised a real possibility the dismissal was by reason of the transfer. The appeal was allowed and the case remitted for further case management and, if necessary, a fresh substantive hearing on any regulation 7 claim.
- Colin Smith v Nottingham City Transport [2024] EAT 94 21 May 2024 This appeal concerned a discrimination claim where the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) allowed one ground: the employment tribunal erred in treating a particular allegation (allegation 6, harassment by SS on 19 October) as no longer live. The EAT dismissed the claimant’s other grounds challenging the tribunal’s handling of harassment law, section 15 findings, the injury-to-feelings award, and refusal of interest. The case was remitted for further steps consistent with allowing ground 1.
- Alexander Pady & Ors v HMRC & Ors [2024] EAT 73 20 May 2024 This EAT judgment concerns an appeal against a Bristol Employment Tribunal decision striking out 20 FDA-supported direct age discrimination claims as an abuse of process after a linked sample hearing (Newby) resolved the common justification issue. The ET found the FDA claimants had unreasonably failed to engage with the sample-case process and belatedly sought to rely on fresh expert evidence; the EAT upheld that evaluative conclusion, dismissing the appeal. The decision affirms that in case-managed multiples strike-out under rule 37 may be appropriate where relitigation would be manifestly unfair and would undermine the administration of justice.
- Justin Lawes v Fleet Maritime Services (Bermuda) Ltd [2024] EAT 77 17 May 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Judge's reserved case management decision to stay determination of whether the Employment Tribunal had territorial jurisdiction under the Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) Order 1994 to hear a ship's captain's breach of contract claim against a Bermuda company. The EAT held the stay was a case management order under rule 1(3)(a) and, given the complexity of international service and jurisdiction issues and differences between court and ET procedures, was not "certainly wrong". The appeal was dismissed; the claimant may pursue court proceedings on jurisdiction and, if successful, return to the tribunal.
- Mohammed Ayub v Ministry of Defence [2024] EAT 93 17 May 2024 This is an appeal by Mr Ayub against an Employment Tribunal refusal to allow an amendment adding two post‑discharge discrimination allegations (delay in re‑joining and being required to take a fitness test). The EAT found the Employment Judge erred in law by failing to take into account material matters relied on by the claimant—notably disclosure obtained in 2023 and the claimant's case that the new allegations linked to existing pleaded matters—and allowed the appeal. The EAT remitted the amendment application for redetermination by a different Employment Judge rather than substituting a decision to grant the amendment.
- J Abbey & Ors v Tesco Stores Limited & Anor [2024] EAT 76 16 May 2024 This appeal concerned about 6,000 claimants in a large Tesco equal pay multiple who challenged Employment Judge Hyams' case management orders: (1) refusing to require Tesco to file ET3 responses to the stayed KP claims pending sample determinations, and (2) limiting disclosure/attendance to documents put before the tribunal. The EAT dismissed both appeals, holding the ET's decisions fell within its wide case-management discretion, were proportionate, and did not involve error of law or perversity.
- Hayley Young v Commissioner of Police and the Metropolis [2024] EAT 55 15 May 2024 This case concerned whether Hayley Young was disabled under the Equality Act 2010 at the material time, her dismissal having followed repeated sickness absences she attributed to fibromyalgia. The employment tribunal found her symptoms were substantial but not shown to be attributable to fibromyalgia (or any single underlying condition) before August 2020, gave reduced weight to a GP's July 2019 letter, accepted a specialist diagnosis only from August 2020, and concluded she was not disabled at the material time. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal and upheld the tribunal's findings.
- James Johnstone & Anor v Glasgow City Council [2024] EAT 75 13 May 2024 This is an appeal by foster‑carer claimants against parts of an Employment Judge’s refusal to allow certain amendments to their ET1 pleadings. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Employment Judge applied the correct legal test, properly considered delay, prejudice and relevant factors, and did not err in refusing parts of "Amendment 1"; the appeal was dismissed.
- Craig Waites v Bilfinger Salamis UK Ltd [2024] EAT 74 10 May 2024 This is an appeal by Mr Craig Waites against an Employment Tribunal's dismissal of his unfair dismissal claim after he was dismissed for breaching rope access safety "Golden Rules". The appeal argued the tribunal impermissibly substituted its own view for the employer's and that the appeal decision maker unfairly relied on a technical authority's views without giving the claimant an opportunity to respond. The EAT rejected both grounds and refused the appeal, upholding the tribunal's decision.
- Martin Groom v Maritime and Coastguard Agency [2024] EAT 71 9 May 2024 This appeal concerned whether a long‑serving volunteer Coastguard Rescue Officer was a "worker" entitled to be accompanied at a disciplinary hearing. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Tribunal erred: the published documents created a right to remuneration for specified activities and that right gives rise to a contract when the CRO attends such remunerated activity. The EAT substituted a decision that the Claimant was a worker for activities attracting payment, leaving worker status for non‑remunerated activities undecided.
- Vusi Mathebula v Time 4 U Limited [2024] EAT 89 9 May 2024 This appeal concerned a race discrimination complaint by Mr Mathebula that his manager called staff "monkey(s)" at a meeting on 15 June 2020. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the employment tribunal failed to make necessary, specific findings about whether the word was used at that meeting or in what context and should have considered treating the allegation as harassment related to race (alternatively direct discrimination), particularly because the claimant was unrepresented. The EAT allowed the appeal in part and remitted the meeting-related complaint to a differently constituted tribunal for reconsideration; other complaints were left undisturbed.
- C Baldwin v Cleves School & Ors [2024] EAT 66 3 May 2024 This appeal concerned whether Employment Tribunal had discretion under section 110 Equality Act 2010 to decline to find personal liability against individuals when an employer was found liable. The EAT held s.110(1)(a)–(c) gives no such discretion and substituted findings that the headteacher and mentor personally contravened s.110 in respect of acts for which the school was liable, while dismissing the claimant’s procedural complaint on victimisation and rejecting a perversity challenge to the tribunal’s harassment conclusion. Remedies were remitted to the ET for consideration and allocation.
- D Ireland v University College London [2024] EAT 68 3 May 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal (ET) award of costs of £14,000 against a claimant after dismissal of his race discrimination claim and the ET's dismissal of the claimant's wasted costs application against the respondent's lawyers. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) dismissed both appeals, holding the ET did not err in principle or exercise of discretion in hearing the respondent's costs application at the end of the liability hearing and that the wasted costs claim was properly dismissed.
- Ian Ritson v Milan Babic Architects Limited [2024] EAT 95 2 May 2024 The EAT dismissed Ian Ritson’s appeal against an Employment Tribunal decision that texts he sent in April 2020 did not amount to qualifying protected disclosures and that his dismissal on 10 April 2020 was for redundancy. The ET had found the claimant lacked a reasonable belief that the texts were public-interest disclosures and that selection for redundancy was driven by objective cost-saving decisions (highest earners), not by any protected disclosure. The EAT held the ET applied correct legal tests, gave adequate reasons, and made permissible findings of fact.
- N Bodis v Lindfield Christian Care Home Ltd [2024] EAT 65 1 May 2024 This is an EAT appeal about s.15 disability discrimination and unfair dismissal after an employee was investigated and summarily dismissed following incidents at a care home. The EAT found the Tribunal erred in law to the extent it treated the claimant's investigatory demeanour as merely trivial when it had contributed to referral/dismissal, but dismissed the s.15 appeal because the Tribunal's alternative justification finding was not challenged. The unfair dismissal appeal was also dismissed.
- Lorenzo Ramos v Nottinghamshire Women's Aid Limited & Anor [2024] EAT 67 30 April 2024 This appeal concerned a deposit order imposed by Employment Judge Welch against Mr Lorenzo Ramos (aka Lorenzo Garcia), a serial litigant who brings sex discrimination claims based on online job adverts without applying. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (HHJ Tayler) upheld the deposit order, finding the Rule 39 test was correctly applied, the claimant’s prospects of success were rightly assessed as low (including because he had no genuine interest in the role), and prior similar litigation could permissibly inform that assessment. Appeals challenging bias, procedural error, and the refusal to make a reciprocal deposit order against the respondent were dismissed as unarguable or without merit.
- Lorenzo Ramos v Nottinghamshire Women's Aid Limited & Anor [2024] EAT 69 30 April 2024 This appeal concerns Mr Lorenzo Ramos' late recusal request made shortly before judgment was handed down in relation to his Rule 3(10) applications; HHJ Tayler considered the request and refused it. The judge held there was no basis for recusal, finding delay in arriving and prior dismissed complaints did not establish apparent bias, and the order and judgment were handed down unchanged.
- Z v Y [2024] EAT 63 26 April 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's failure to decide a pleaded claim of discriminatory constructive dismissal, instead relying on an agreed list of issues and treating most Equality Act claims as out of time. The EAT held the ET erred in law by not addressing the pleaded discriminatory constructive dismissal, substituted a finding that that claim (under ss 15, 21 and 39(2)(c) EqA) was in time and upheld, and remitted factual questions about earlier acts amounting to conduct "extending over a period" and remedy to the ET.
- Dr Therese Mary William v Lewisham and Greenwich NHS Trust [2024] EAT 58 24 April 2024 This appeal concerned a consultant neonatologist who alleged whistleblowing protection and causation for detriments after raising concerns about a colleague, feeding guidelines and NEC rates. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal's findings that only the handover complaint was a protected disclosure, that the guideline and NEC-rate complaints were not reasonably believed to show a health/safety risk, and that the protected disclosure did not materially influence the respondent's detrimental decisions. The EAT also refused to admit an external April 2023 review report as fresh evidence.
- Solomon Demba v Care UK Community Partnerships Ltd [2024] EAT 60 24 April 2024 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal correctly refused reconsideration of its merits decision after finding a conditional job offer withdrawn following delays and a grievance. The EAT held the tribunal erred by failing to apply the distinct legal test for victimisation (separate from direct race discrimination) and that it was not inevitable a correct application would have produced the same outcome. The EAT allowed the appeal and remitted the victimisation point for fresh reconsideration under rule 72(1).
- Dr V Powell v University of Portsmouth & Anor [2024] EAT 56 23 April 2024 This is an appeal by Dr Powell against an ET dismissal of claims for disability discrimination (ss.15, 20, 21 Equality Act 2010) and constructive dismissal arising from his inability, during Sept–Oct 2018, to undertake unpredictable face-to-face teaching due to syncope/blackouts. The ET found the university lawfully required fitness to carry out core teaching duties as a proportionate means to achieve a legitimate aim and that the proposed adjustments were impracticable or would not have removed the substantial disadvantage; the EAT dismissed the appeal and upheld the ET’s findings. The ET also rejected constructive dismissal, finding no repudiatory breach or cumulative course of conduct by the employer.
- British Airways Plc v De Mello & Ors [2024] EAT 53 19 April 2024 This EAT judgment concerns whether various British Airways cabin‑crew allowances (meal allowance, duty‑free commission, Back‑to‑Back allowance) form part of "normal pay" for statutory holiday pay and whether repeated underpayments form a time‑barred "series" under s.23(3) ERA. The EAT found several tribunal errors (including on burden allocation, designation of statutory leave and use of reference periods), allowed some grounds of appeal, substituted a finding that the deductions were sufficiently similar to potentially form a series, and remitted multiple issues (including inclusion of the allowances and quantum) for rehearing by a different judge. Directions for reassessment and case management were given.
- Stena Drilling PTE Limited v Tristan Smith [2024] EAT 57 18 April 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal had jurisdiction to hear a seafarer's claims under the Employment Rights Act (ERA) and the Equality Act (EqA) against a Singapore company, given the claimant's links to UK payroll/HR and contractual choice of Singapore law. The EAT held the Employment Judge erred by conflating international/forum jurisdiction under ss.15C/15D of the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982 (as amended) with territorial jurisdiction and by relying on s.199(7) ERA and reg.3 of the 2011 Regulations to found international jurisdiction for the EqA claim. The tribunal's decision was set aside and remitted for reconsideration of international jurisdiction under ss.15C/15D, and, if needed, further factual inquiry into territorial jurisdiction for the EqA claim; the Lawson/Ravat territorial analysis for the ERA claim was upheld.
- Verifone (UK) Ltd v K Zena [2024] EAT 54 18 April 2024 The claimant, a Black female financial controller, was dismissed purportedly for redundancy after the ET found a pre-determined plan to retain a more junior Polish employee; the ET found unfair dismissal, rejected direct race discrimination, and a majority found victimisation. The EAT allowed the respondent’s appeal on victimisation, holding the ET majority had failed to take into account the ET’s unanimous finding that the appeal investigation and outcome were pre-determined, and therefore set aside the victimisation finding and dismissed that claim. The claimant’s cross-appeal on direct race discrimination was dismissed and the ET’s original discrimination decision was upheld.
- Brian Carver v London Borough of Newham & Anor [2024] EAT 64 17 April 2024 This appeal concerned the Employment Judge's decision to strike out Mr Carver's claims. The EAT found the strike-out judgment gave inadequate reasons—failing to explain why a fair hearing was impossible or why lesser sanctions were inappropriate—and likely did not take into account the claimant's 25 November 2022 correspondence providing late compliance. The appeal was allowed and the matter was remitted to the Employment Tribunal with directions about how to proceed.
- Adefunke Adekoya & Ors v Heathrow Express Operating Company Ltd [2024] EAT 72 16 April 2024 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal decision allowing in part an appeal by redundant Heathrow Express employees who sought to enforce ongoing 75% leisure travel discounts. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s finding that ATOC travel terms were incorporated into the employees’ contracts but overturned the tribunal’s reliance on a Reciprocal Agreement’s withdrawal provisions and findings of implied agreement to vary rights; those issues were remitted for rehearing, including whether Regulation 3(c) gave the tribunal jurisdiction and whether £750 settlement payments compromised the claims.
- E Aird & Ors v Asda Stores Ltd & Ors [2024] EAT 52 16 April 2024 This appeal concerned a case-management order in large-scale multi-claimant equal pay litigation against Asda, where Keller Postman sought attendance at private preliminary hearings and copies of all inter-party documents. The Employment Judge allowed attendance and hearing bundles but refused full production of inter-party documents; the EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the judge acted within her broad case-management discretion. The order was only slightly amended after Keller Postman gave a confidentiality undertaking.
- The Home Office v J Oxley [2024] EAT 44 16 April 2024 This appeal concerned whether a 2021 complaint about annualised hours, pleaded as indirect disability discrimination, was barred by a withdrawn 2017 claim by cause of action estoppel, Rule 52 ET Rules (judgment on withdrawal), or as an abuse of process. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the Employment Tribunal had misidentified and misconstrued the causes of action in the 2017 and 2021 claim forms, made fundamental errors of analysis and reached perverse conclusions on preclusion and abuse. The EAT allowed the appeal in part, set aside the ET’s decision and remitted the matter to a different Employment Tribunal for redetermination with directions for further case management.
- Gary Lewis v Dow Silicones UK Limited [2024] EAT 51 12 April 2024 This appeal concerned whether a claimant's resignation after a TUPE transfer was an automatically unfair dismissal because the dismissal was for the transfer. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the ET erred in treating "safety" as the respondent's sole or principal reason when that reason had not been pleaded or evidenced; on the pleaded case the principal reason was the TUPE transfer and the dismissal was therefore automatically unfair. The EAT substituted a decision to that effect and remitted the matter to a fresh tribunal for remedy.
- TwistDX Limited & Ors v Dr N Armes & Ors [2024] EAT 45 12 April 2024 This appeal concerns whether an Employment Tribunal correctly refused to strike out claims against US and UK respondents in dismissal/whistleblowing proceedings, including whether the Recast Brussels Regulation gives the Tribunal international jurisdiction over a US parent (Abbott) and US individuals, and whether domestic ET Rule 8 can confer jurisdiction. The EAT held the Employment Judge was entitled to find the claimants' jurisdictional case reasonably arguable and so not suitable for strike-out at that stage, but allowed the appeal in part because the judge gave insufficient reasoning on the agency case against two UK individuals and remitted that point for reconsideration; the remaining international jurisdiction issues are to be determined at a substantive hearing.
- Alexander Barnett v H & H Gelato Limited & Ors [2024] EAT 62 11 April 2024 This appeal challenges an Employment Judge’s Rule 39 preliminary deposit order requiring Mr Barnett to pay £100 per claim to continue protected disclosure detriment, victimisation and automatic unfair dismissal claims. The EAT found the judge had given insufficient reasons for dismissing two discrete claim-strands based on alleged comments by a manager (Mr Dhanili) and remitted those strands for reconsideration, but upheld the deposit order as to the strands based on an alleged failure to investigate and the automatic unfair dismissal strand. The overall result: partial success for Mr Barnett and remittal to the Employment Judge to reconsider the order limited to the affected strands.
- Gillian Philip v Working Partners Limited & Anor [2024] EAT 43 8 April 2024 This appeal concerned whether the claimant, a freelance writer engaged by a book packager and publisher, was a "worker" under ERA 1996 s.230(3)(b) (and thus an "employee" for Equality Act 2010 purposes). Employment Judge Kemp found she carried on a profession/business and the packager was her client, so limb (b) did not apply; the EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the judge applied the correct law and reached a conclusion open on the facts.
- Donna Edinboro v Jamma Umoja (Residential Services) Ltd [2024] EAT 61 28 March 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Judge's decision at a preliminary hearing striking out multiple claims (including breach of contract and detriment for alleged protected disclosure). The EAT found material procedural and analytical errors: the EJ failed to apply Rule 37 properly, did not take the claimant's case at its highest, made substantive findings at the preliminary stage, and failed to give reasonable notice and opportunity to address strike-out of claims other than unfair dismissal. The strike-out decision was set aside and remitted for rehearing before a different Employment Judge; permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal on a narrow point was refused.
- M Jasim v LHR Airports Limited [2024] EAT 59 28 March 2024 The claimant appealed two tribunal decisions heard together but initially filed full paperwork for one claim only; the ET1/ET3 for the second claim were omitted and supplied after the appeal period. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the appeal was properly instituted in time for the first claim, found the omission for the second claim to be a "minor error" under Rule 37(5), and granted an extension so that the second claim could proceed. The judge would not have extended time under Rule 37(1) but allowed the more forgiving exercise of discretion under Rule 37(5).
- K Ciochon v Mark Kempe t/a Neville Arms & Neville Arms Inn [2024] EAT 48 27 March 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal wrongly applied the Burden of Proof in a pregnancy discrimination/redudancy claim after the claimant notified her pregnancy and was dismissed shortly afterwards. The EAT held the Tribunal erred by considering the respondent’s explanatory evidence at the first (stage‑one) assessment of whether the burden of proof shifted and by failing to explain why its factual findings did not shift the burden; the appeal was allowed and the case remitted for rehearing before a different Employment Tribunal.
- W v Interserve Group Ltd & Ors [2024] EAT 70 26 March 2024 This appeal concerned whether a tribunal wrongly refused to include alleged earlier protected disclosures (from 2018 onwards) in the list of issues for a whistleblowing and unfair dismissal claim. The EAT held the tribunal erred: read fairly (and with allowance for a litigant in person) the claimant’s original particulars, together with further particulars supplied before the hearing, did sufficiently raise those prior disclosures. The EAT directed that the claimed disclosures and related factual and legal issues be added to the list of issues for the merits hearing; no substantive findings on protection or causation were made.
- Guy Matthews v CGI IT UK Ltd [2024] EAT 38 25 March 2024 This is an EAT appeal against an ET decision dismissing multiple claims by Mr Matthews arising from his 2021 dismissal by CGI for an irretrievable breakdown of trust and confidence. The EAT rejected all grounds of appeal, holding that dismissal without prior warning or right of appeal was within the range of reasonable responses on the facts, that the Turner principle was properly applied (reasonable, not exhaustive, remedial steps were taken), and that findings on victimisation, burden of proof, the OMF policy and refusal to extend time for an Equality Act claim involved no legal error. The ET’s decision was therefore upheld.
- Toby Nicol v World Travel and Tourism Council & Ors [2024] EAT 42 25 March 2024 This appeal concerned Mr Nicol’s whistleblowing claims after dismissal, focusing on whether six alleged disclosures were protected and whether those disclosures influenced the dismissal. The EAT held the ET erred in concluding PD3 had not been made and erred in finding Mr Nicol had made sexualised comments (unfairly decided), but rejected the challenge that onward transmission to a decision‑maker requires no knowledge of content. The EAT allowed parts of the appeal but found the identified errors immaterial to the outcome and did not remit the case.
- Ramandeep Kaur v Sun Mark Ltd & Ors [2024] EAT 41 21 March 2024 This case concerns a claimant who succeeded in part on liability for discrimination, harassment and some victimisation but whose remedy claim was struck out after the employment tribunal found she either destroyed or lied about destruction of a notebook and a second mobile phone. The ET concluded that the conduct occurred in late October 2022, was dishonest or deliberate, and made a fair trial of remedy impossible, so it struck out the remedy claim under rule 37(1)(b). The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the claimant’s appeal, upholding the ET’s findings and conclusion that strike-out was proportionate.
- S Wakeman v Boys and Maughan Solicitors & Anor [2024] EAT 39 20 March 2024 This appeal concerns the Employment Tribunal’s use of Unless Orders and strike‑out for the claimant’s non‑compliance with directions on disclosure and witness statements. The EAT found procedural error—especially in failing to take account of significant respondent correspondence that was not copied to the claimant and in the tribunal’s handling of relief from sanction—and allowed the appeal in part, remitting the case to a different Employment Tribunal for redetermination.
- M Rajput & Anor v Sky Retail Stores Limited [2024] EAT 46 19 March 2024 This appeal concerned Store Managers whose managerial role and store manager allowance (SMA) were abolished in a 2018 restructure; the employment tribunal found the change terminated their contracts and dismissed unlawful deduction and consultation claims. The appellants sought permission to raise a new Geys-based legal point at the EAT (arguing termination should be treated as elective, not automatic), but the EAT refused permission because the point was not run below, was substantive, and would likely require further factual inquiry or remission. The appeal was dismissed.
- Worcestershire Health and Care NHS Trust v Angela Allen [2024] EAT 40 19 March 2024 This appeal concerned multiple age and disability discrimination complaints after a restructuring and dismissal. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal's finding that a manager ticking "retirement due to ill health" on an occupational‑health referral was unwanted conduct related to age and therefore age‑related harassment, but disallowed treating the same act also as direct discrimination. The EAT overturned the Tribunal's finding that a predetermined grievance outcome was age‑related harassment, held the two age‑related incidents did not form conduct extending over a period, and remitted time‑limit (just and equitable) issues to the Tribunal.
- Abraham Goldstein v Marie-Pierre Herve [2024] EAT 35 14 March 2024 This appeal concerned whether a personal assistant's emails and her refusal to return to her employer's home during the second COVID‑19 lockdown fell within the health‑and‑safety protections in s.44(1)(c),(d),(e) ERA and whether her subsequent constructive dismissal was automatically unfair under s.100(1)(d). The Employment Tribunal found the claimant's concerns about commuting and attending the home were "connected with" her work, that her 4 November email amounted to a protected refusal to return and her steps were appropriate, and that the employer breached the implied term of trust and confidence; the EAT dismissed the employer's appeal and upheld those findings.
- Rentokil Initial UK Ltd v M Miller [2024] EAT 37 14 March 2024 This appeal concerned whether the employer should have offered a four‑week trial in a different (service administrator) role as a reasonable adjustment for a field technician with multiple sclerosis who could no longer work at height. The EAT held that a trial period can, depending on circumstances, amount to a reasonable adjustment and that once the claimant shows a PCP, substantial disadvantage and an apparently reasonable adjustment the burden may shift to the employer to show it was not reasonable. The tribunal’s factual findings that the trial should have been offered and that dismissal was unfair were upheld; the appeal was dismissed.
- R Melki v Bouygues E and S Contracting UK Ltd [2024] EAT 36 13 March 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Appeal Tribunal's new rule 37(5) (effective 30 Sept 2023) applies to appeals already pending and whether omission of the respondent's Grounds of Resistance from a Notice of Appeal was a "minor error" allowing extension of time. The EAT held rule 37(5) does apply to pending appeals but the omission of the whole Grounds of Resistance was not a minor error (being an omission of an essential document), so no extension under rule 37(5) was available; no extension was justified under rule 37(1) either and the appellant's application was dismissed.
- B King v Thales DIS UK Ltd [2024] EAT 34 8 March 2024 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal decision allowing Mr King's appeal against parts of a Preliminary Hearing decision that had dismissed his sex discrimination claim as an abuse of process and refused an amendment to add disability discrimination. The EAT found the judge correctly construed the ET1 as not already pleading disability (so amendment was required) but erred in law on abuse of process by failing to undertake a broad, merits-based assessment and by not giving adequate weight to Mr King's vulnerability. The case was remitted to a fresh Employment Tribunal to reconsider the abuse of process issue and the proposed amendment, with directions on matters to be considered.
- F Atif v Dolce & Gabbana UK Ltd [2024] EAT 47 7 March 2024 This is an appeal by Mrs Atif against an ET finding that her dismissal for alleged abuse of a sickness absence policy was not race discrimination. The EAT reviewed whether the burden of proof had shifted and whether proper comparators were identified, and concluded the Tribunal had engaged with the relevant evidence and its conclusion of no race discrimination was open to it. The appeal was dismissed.
- Hilton Foods Solutions Ltd v Andrew Wright [2024] EAT 28 7 March 2024 This appeal concerned whether an employee must have complied with the formal Schedule 2 notice requirements of the MPLR to be treated as having "sought to take" parental leave for the purposes of protection from dismissal. The EAT upheld the employment judge's refusal to strike out the claim, holding that there is no absolute legal requirement of strict compliance with Schedule 2 and that whether an employee has "sought" to take parental leave is a factual question for the tribunal; formal compliance is usually strong evidence but not conclusive. The claimant may therefore pursue an automatic unfair dismissal claim to a fact-finding hearing.
- Scottish Water v Lynne Edgar [2024] EAT 32 6 March 2024 This EAT appeal concerned whether Scottish Water had proved a material factor defence to an equal pay claim where a male comparator, appointed after the claimant, was paid higher in the same band. The Employment Tribunal had required proof of the identity and subjective state of mind of the specific pay decision‑maker and excluded comparative evidence of skills and performance after appointment; the EAT held those were legal errors. The Tribunal's preliminary ruling was set aside and the preliminary issue remitted to a differently constituted Tribunal for rehearing.
- Seyi Omooba v Michael Garrett Associates Ltd & Anor [2024] EAT 30 6 March 2024 This appeal concerned an actor who was removed from a lead role after a 2014 Facebook post expressing religious views was re‑publicised and generated adverse publicity; she brought claims of religion/belief discrimination, harassment and breach of contract. The EAT upheld the ET’s factual findings that the respondents acted for commercial/artistic reasons related to the adverse publicity (not because of her protected belief), rejected the harassment claims, found the claimant in repudiatory breach of the theatre contract and upheld the ET’s costs order and its removal order for hearing documents.
- Yacht Management Company Limited v Lindsay Gordon & Anor [2024] EAT 33 6 March 2024 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal had territorial jurisdiction under the ERA and EqA to hear a seafarer's claims where the vessel never entered UK waters and an agreed fact stated her "tours of duty" began and ended outside Great Britain. The EAT upheld the Tribunal's finding that the claimant's contractual duties began and ended at her home in Aberdeen and that the Tribunal therefore had territorial jurisdiction. The appellant's arguments about the meaning of "tours of duty" and reliance on Windstar and Fleet Maritime Services were rejected.
- Donald Gabel v The Health and Safety Executive [2024] EAT 31 5 March 2024 This appeal challenged an ET finding that the HSE was not a "qualifications body" in respect of the post of diving supervisor, that the supervisor role was not a "personal office", and that the HSE's refusal to recognise the claimant's claimed "grandfather rights" did not involve legal error. The EAT dismissed the appeal, upholding the ET's factual findings and conclusion that the HSE was not a qualifications body for that specific role, that the role was part of a trade/profession rather than a personal office, and that the ET's brief treatment of justification and reasonable adjustments was adequate (and would, if necessary, have accepted the HSE's proportionality defence).
- P Patel v DPD Group UK Limited [2024] EAT 202 5 March 2024 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal decision striking out a delivery driver’s claim as having no reasonable prospect of success under Rule 37(1). The central issue was whether the franchise agreement’s genuine contractual right of substitution meant the Claimant was not contractually obliged to perform services personally (and so could not be a "worker"). The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the agreement genuinely allowed substitution, the case was indistinguishable from Stojsavljevic and Turner, and dismissed the appeal, upholding strike-out.
- Patti-Merne Edwards v Ministry of Defence [2024] EAT 18 5 March 2024 This EAT appeal concerned whether a service complaint under s.121(1) Equality Act 2010 must sufficiently indicate allegations of discrimination, harassment or victimisation and the protected characteristic(s) relied on so that an employment tribunal has jurisdiction. The court endorsed a non‑technical but substantive test: the service complaint must, read reasonably as a whole, indicate it is complaining of discrimination/harassment and identify the relevant protected characteristic(s) (or for victimisation that it arose from a protected act). Applying that test, the claimant’s 14‑page service complaint did not, in substance, amount to allegations of race or sex discrimination or victimisation, and the appeal was dismissed.
- Wicked Vision Ltd v I Rice [2024] EAT 29 4 March 2024 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal wrongly allowed an amendment to plead that the employer was vicariously liable under s47(1B) ERA for a co‑worker/owner's act that "subjected the claimant to the detriment of dismissal". The EAT held the Employment Judge erred: s47(2) disapplies Part V and bars a s47(1B) vicarious liability claim against an employer where the alleged detriment "amounts to dismissal (within the meaning of Part X)". The appeal was allowed and the claimant's application to amend was dismissed; the time‑limit issue was left for trial or further hearing.
- Philip Hall v Transport for London [2024] EAT 26 1 March 2024 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal's refusal to grant a third postponement of a part‑heard merits hearing and to appoint a litigation friend for the claimant. The ET treated the application under rule 30A(3), concluded the medical evidence was outdated and did not show "exceptional circumstances", and proceeded in the claimant's absence; the EAT dismissed the appeal and upheld the ET's decision. No challenge was made to the ET's substantive merits findings.
- Emelia Donkor-Baah v University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Trust & Ors [2024] EAT 23 29 February 2024 This is an appeal by an agency worker who was sent home during a shift and whose Regulation 5 AWR suspension-pay claim was struck out by the Employment Tribunal. The EAT rejected the new contention that Regulations 5, 7 and 8 create an overarching "Agency Relationship" that persists between assignments, holding instead that Regulation 5 rights apply during an active assignment and not as an umbrella status between assignments. The tribunal's factual finding that the assignment ended at 02:30 on 10 February 2019 was upheld and the appeal was dismissed.
- Francesco Accattatis v Fortuna Group (London) Limited [2024] EAT 25 29 February 2024 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal erred in a s.100(1)(e) Employment Rights Act 1996 claim after the claimant was dismissed for requesting furlough or to work from home during COVID-19. The EAT held the tribunal failed to apply s.100(2) when deciding if those steps were "appropriate" and did not clearly identify whether the protected demand was the principal reason for dismissal. The appeal was allowed in part and the case remitted to the original tribunal judge for rehearing only on those narrow issues; other factual findings stand.
- Dr M Tattersall v Mersey and West Lancashire Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust (formerly Southport & Ormskirk Hospital NHS Trust) [2024] EAT 24 28 February 2024 This is an appeal against a Rule 38(1) confirmation notice dismissing the claimant's employment claims for failure to comply with an unless order to produce GP records. The EAT held that at stage 2 (Rule 38(1)) the tribunal's task is limited to determining whether the unless order was complied with and that materiality of any non-compliance is for stage 3 (Rule 38(2)); the REJ was entitled to issue the confirmation notice on the written materials and the appeal was dismissed.
- D Martin v The Board of Governors of St Francis Xavier 6th Form College [2024] EAT 22 27 February 2024 This is an EAT appeal by Mr Martin challenging an Employment Tribunal majority decision that dismissed his claims of direct race discrimination and constructive unfair dismissal after an investigation and disciplinary hearing following late arrival at exams. The EAT held the Tribunal did not err in law, did not reach a perverse conclusion and gave adequate reasons: the Tribunal rightly treated Mr White as a comparator (or evidential comparator), rejected Spindler and McQuitty as actual comparators because of material differences, and upheld the finding of no less favourable treatment on racial grounds and no constructive dismissal. The appeal was dismissed.
- Christian Abanda Bella v Barclays Execution Services Limited & Ors [2024] EAT 16 23 February 2024 This appeal challenged an employment judge’s refusal to allow Mr Abanda Bella to audio-record a three‑day preliminary (strikeout) hearing as a disability-related reasonable adjustment. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the judge’s 16 July 2022 decision was unlawful because she failed to take into account material factors and was unduly dismissive of the psychotherapist’s evidence; the appeal was allowed and a declaration of unlawfulness made. The appellant did not seek to overturn the substantive preliminary-hearing outcome and no further order was made.
- L Humby v Barts Health NHS Trust [2024] EAT 17 21 February 2024 This appeal concerned claims by Mr Humby of constructive unfair dismissal and victimisation after a restructuring that reassigned him from Band 6 to Band 5 and his subsequent resignation. The EAT found multiple material errors at both the preliminary stage (wrongly refusing amendments and striking out earlier detriments as time‑barred) and at the final hearing (misordering issues by deciding constructive dismissal before properly addressing victimisation, misapplying burden and detriment tests, and unfair cross‑examination), and remitted the matter for a complete re‑hearing.
- James Linton v The Athelstan Trust [2024] EAT 14 19 February 2024 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal properly found the claimant not disabled under the Equality Act 2010 where his PTSD arose about 25 years earlier and whether the Tribunal properly imposed a £500 rule 39 deposit order on his unfair dismissal claim. The EAT allowed both appeals, holding the ET had failed to engage properly with the consultant psychiatrist’s report (including on likelihood of recurrence) and had not given adequate reasons for doubting the claimant could prove essential facts underpinning the unfair dismissal claim. Both the disability finding and the deposit order were set aside and remitted for redetermination.
- V Barnard v Hampshire and Isle of Wight Fire and Rescue Authority [2024] EAT 12 14 February 2024 This is an appeal by a Green Book employee alleging equal pay and constructive unfair dismissal after comparators on Grey Book terms seconded to non‑operational roles were paid more. The Employment Appeal Tribunal rejected challenges to the tribunal's findings that the contractual requirement on comparators to maintain operational competence was a genuine material factor, that the respondent's justification and proportionality analysis (including consideration of a short-lived HOST experiment) was lawful, and that no implied equality clause arose because the equal pay claim failed. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal's dismissal of both claims was restored.
- Damilare Ajao v Commerzbank AG & Ors [2024] EAT 11 12 February 2024 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal decision upholding a first‑instance tribunal's revocation of the claimant's anonymity and restricted reporting orders, dismissal of his small holiday‑pay claim, and a costs contribution order against him. The EAT accepted that the tribunal could revisit and revoke privacy orders once the underlying allegations were found to be fabricated, found the claimant's evidence about converting three leave days to sick leave to be false, and reduced but upheld a costs contribution of £5,362 for the appeal. The appeal was dismissed in full.
- Carmen Chevalier-Firescu v HSBC Bank PLC [2024] EAT 6 9 February 2024 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal’s strike‑out and time‑limit decisions in two discrimination and victimisation claims by Ms Chevalier‑Firescu against HSBC arising from 2018–2021 recruitment events. The EAT found procedural and legal errors in the Tribunal’s handling—notably in striking out the Second Claim that had not been properly before the OPH and in the exercise of the s.123(1)(b) Equality Act 2010 time‑extension discretion—and allowed grounds of appeal. The EAT did not decide the merits but remitted the matters to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal for reconsideration.
- Jerzy Lawrynowicz v Bidvest Noonan (UK) Limited [2024] EAT 13 9 February 2024 This is an EAT judgment allowing an appeal from an Employment Tribunal order of 28 April 2022 that refused an application to amend and struck out the claimant's claim. The EAT held the ET erred in law by characterising the claimant's further pleaded materials as entirely new claims (thereby distorting the Selkent balancing exercise) and by failing to apply or record the correct Rule 37 strike-out test. The ET orders were set aside and the matter remitted for further case management and reconsideration (including disability/discrimination and any fresh strike-out application).
- J Logo v Payone GmbH & Ors [2024] EAT 9 8 February 2024 This case concerns an appeal from an Employment Tribunal decision striking out three indirect race discrimination complaints (about the respondent's German-only website, a German-language job advert, and largely German-language meetings). The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Tribunal’s justification assessment was superficial and that strike out was inappropriate where detailed factual and business-economics issues were involved. The appeal was allowed and the indirect discrimination claims were remitted for substantive consideration by a different Employment Tribunal.
- B Pawlicka v Gregory Park Holdings Ltd t/a Four Seasons Hotel [2024] EAT 27 6 February 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal should have treated proceedings as including an unpleaded whistleblowing (protected-disclosure) claim after finding the claimant was a worker and striking out her pleaded s44/s100 ERA health-and-safety claims. The EAT held the Tribunal did not err: the claimant had not sufficiently pleaded or signposted a whistleblowing claim before dismissal, and the Tribunal was not required to raise or develop such an unpleaded claim or re-open proceedings. The appeal was dismissed.
- A Fasano v Reckitt Benckiser Group PLC & Anor [2024] EAT 7 31 January 2024 This is an EAT judgment in Mr Fasano’s appeal against the ET’s dismissal of an indirect age discrimination claim arising from Remco’s 18 September 2019 change to the 2017 LTIP which limited vesting to those employed on that date. The EAT held the employment-on-18-September requirement was a PCP that put over-57s (including Mr Fasano) at a particular disadvantage and was not a proportionate means of achieving the legitimate aim of retaining staff. However, the EAT also held there was no basis to treat RB Group as agent for RB Health, so RB Health could not be held liable on that agency basis; the EAT therefore dismissed the appeal in outcome terms while substituting findings on justification and agency and permitted the respondents to run the agency argument despite no formal cross-appeal.
- Sean Pong Tyres Limited v Barry Moore (debarred) [2024] EAT 1 29 January 2024 This appeal concerned whether alleged employer liabilities for constructive unfair dismissal and discrimination could transfer under TUPE to a putative transferee when the claimant had resigned before the transfer, and whether the Tribunal erred in refusing a very late amendment to plead a post-claim TUPE transfer. The EAT dismissed the appeal: liabilities for the unfair dismissal claim did not transfer because the claimant was not employed at the time of the putative transfer, the employer’s primary statutory liability under the EA 2010 did not transfer merely because an alleged tortfeasor employee may have moved, and the Tribunal did not unlawfully refuse the late amendment under Selkent principles.
- G Kikwera-Akaka v Salvation Army Trading Company Limited [2024] EAT 49 25 January 2024 This EAT appeal dismissed the claimant’s challenge to an Employment Tribunal ruling that his dismissal for capability/performance was fair. The Tribunal had found a final written warning and a short PIP had together put the claimant on notice that his role was at risk, and that dismissal fell within the band of reasonable responses; the EAT found no error of law. The EAT also upheld the Tribunal’s Polkey assessment reducing compensation to nil on the balance of probabilities.
- Vaultex UK Ltd v Robert Bialas [2024] EAT 19 25 January 2024 Vaultex dismissed Mr Bialas after he posted a racist joke on the company intranet; an employment tribunal found the dismissal outside the band of reasonable responses and unfair. The employer appealed to the EAT, which held the tribunal had substituted its own view of sanction and misapplied the band of reasonable responses test. The EAT allowed the appeal and substituted a decision that the dismissal was fair.
- Dr Nicholas Jones v The Secretary of State for Health and Social Care [2024] EAT 2 23 January 2024 Dr Nicholas Jones, a Black Caribbean applicant, brought a direct race discrimination claim after not being appointed to a Public Health England role; the Employment Tribunal found his claim was out of time and dismissed it on the merits. The central issue on appeal was whether the ET was perverse in refusing to extend the three-month limitation period as just and equitable; the Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, holding the ET did not err in refusing an extension. The EAT limited its decision to the time point and did not decide other substantive grounds of appeal.
- Hendy Group Ltd v Daniel Kennedy [2024] EAT 106 23 January 2024 This case concerns a redundancy dismissal where the Tribunal found the employer failed to take reasonable, proactive steps to consider the at‑risk employee for alternative posts and therefore dismissed him unfairly. The Tribunal awarded compensation of £19,566.73 and made no Polkey reduction, concluding the employer’s procedural failings caused the Claimant’s non‑selection. The Employment Appeal Tribunal refused permission to appeal and upheld the Tribunal’s approach and decision at this stage.
- Omar Ayche v The Hop Box Limited (t/a Peddler Market) [2024] EAT 10 23 January 2024 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal was correct to find that the respondent had made a reasonable adjustment by permitting the claimant to wear a face mask below his nose. The EAT held the ET had wrongly proceeded on an incorrect understanding of undisputed facts—specifically that the respondent knew of and consented to that practice when the claimant had in fact adopted it unilaterally. The EAT allowed the appeal and remitted the reasonable adjustments claim to the ET for rehearing.
- S Glasson v The Insolvency Service [2024] EAT 5 23 January 2024 This appeal concerned a claimant with a stammer who said videoconference interview procedures and emphasis on oral answers put him at a substantial disadvantage and that the employer should have adjusted or justified that practice. The tribunal found the claimant did enter a "restrictive mode" affecting some answers but that the employer had neither actual nor constructive knowledge of that specific disadvantage and that the videoconference oral interview was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. The EAT dismissed the appeal, upholding the tribunal's rejection of both the section 20 reasonable adjustment claim and the discrimination arising from disability claim.
- Lancashire and South Cumbria NHS Foundation Trust v R Moon [2024] EAT 4 22 January 2024 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment upholding an Employment Tribunal finding that an Associate Hospital Manager (AHM) engaged by Lancashire and South Cumbria NHS Foundation Trust was party to a contract and was a "worker" (limb (b)) and thereby "employed" for certain statutory protections. The Trust argued that appointment under section 23(6) Mental Health Act and the requirement of independence for AHMs precluded worker or employment status; the EAT rejected that contention. The EAT held the Tribunal was entitled to find mutual obligations, consideration, and a contractual arrangement in practice, and that independence at the point of statutory decision-making did not automatically negate worker status. The Trust’s appeal was dismissed and the claim may proceed to a final hearing.
- P Sullivan v Isle of Wight Council [2024] EAT 3 22 January 2024 This appeal concerned whether an unsuccessful external job applicant could bring a whistleblowing/detriment complaint under Part IVA of the Employment Rights Act 1996 and under Article 14 ECHR (with Article 10 ambit conceded). The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the claimant was not in an analogous position to protected employees/workers (or to NHS applicants), that "job applicant" did not amount to "other status" under Article 14, and that a proposed s.43K amendment could not be read into the ERA as it would not "go with the grain" of the statute. A narrower error in the tribunal’s proportionality analysis was immaterial to the outcome.
- M Shah v Home Office [2024] EAT 21 19 January 2024 This appeal concerned an application for extension of time to lodge a notice of appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal where not all ET1/ET3 forms from a multi-claim tribunal hearing had been included within the 42-day limit. The EAT held the appeal was not properly constituted in time but, although there was no “good excuse” for the delay, exceptional circumstances justified granting an extension; the Registrar’s refusal was overturned and time was extended to 25 July 2022.
- Viktor Kiseliov & Ors v Alpha Vehicles Limited [2024] EAT 8 17 January 2024 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Judge erred in refusing to set aside dismissal under Employment Tribunal Rules r.38(2) after Claimants missed a case management deadline. The EAT held the Judge mis-exercised his discretion by failing to consider relevant matters (including significant compliance, proportionality and whether a fair trial was possible) and concluded the sanction was disproportionate. The EAT allowed the appeal, set aside the dismissal and remitted the case for rehearing by a different judge.
- J Holbrook v Tom Cosgrove KC & Ors [2023] EAT 168 10 January 2024 This is an EAT appeal in which the claimant sought to challenge a London Central Employment Tribunal’s refusal to extend time for an out-of-time discrimination claim. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the tribunal had applied the correct just-and-equitable/reasonableness test, was entitled to reject the claimant’s account (including his reliance on a non-binding first-instance decision and his preoccupation with concurrent BSB proceedings), and had properly balanced prejudice between the parties. The original refusal to extend time was upheld and the claim remains out of time.
- Jacqueline Cross v NHS Somerset Clinical Commissioning Group [2024] EAT 20 3 January 2024 This appeal concerns Mrs Cross who, after contacting ACAS, believed she could wait for a grievance outcome and so missed the time limit for an unfair dismissal claim. The Employment Judge found her belief genuine but unreasonable; the EAT allowed the appeal, finding errors in the Judge's reasoning and remitted the question of reasonableness to a differently constituted tribunal for rehearing.
- Blanc de Provence Ltd v Thu Lieu Ha [2023] EAT 160 21 December 2023 This EAT allowed the respondent's appeal and remitted the claimant's sex-related harassment claim to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal for redetermination. The EAT found the original ET made a legal error by substantially relying on an unestablished inference that the managers would not have acted the same towards a man, without putting that proposition to the manager or making an express finding. Primary findings of fact were left intact but the harassment issue must be re-decided (and any necessary additional findings made) by a new tribunal.
- Ionel Ion v Citu Manufacturing Ltd & Anor [2023] EAT 151 14 December 2023 This appeal arose from Mr Ion’s claims of race discrimination, whistleblowing detriment/dismissal, and indirect disability discrimination following his redundancy; the Employment Tribunal dismissed all claims but the Employment Appeal Tribunal found material legal and procedural errors. The EAT held the ET failed to apply the burden‑shifting approach properly on race, made inadequate findings on alleged protected disclosures and their causal effect, mis‑applied the law on indirect disability discrimination, and conducted a hearing undermined by poor interpretation and undue restriction of cross‑examination. The EAT allowed the appeal in full and remitted the whole case to a freshly constituted employment tribunal for rehearing.
- Haziz Rahim v The Big Word & Anor [2023] EAT 171 12 December 2023 This is an appeal from an Employment Tribunal striking out multiple claims as out of time and refusing to extend time. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed two grounds: the Employment Judge failed to identify the substance of poorly-pleaded claims and failed to consider a written amendment application dated 2 September 2021 before striking out; it dismissed the perversity challenge to the Judge’s identification of the correct respondent. The case is remitted to the Employment Tribunal for rehearing so amendment/application issues can be addressed; two grounds were not determined on appeal.
- The Kingdom of Spain v L Lorenzo [2023] EAT 153 12 December 2023 This appeal concerned whether the Kingdom of Spain could rely on diplomatic or state immunity to strike out race discrimination and harassment claims brought by a locally‑recruited employee of its London embassy. The EAT held Article 31 diplomatic immunity attaches to the individual diplomatic agent and not to the State as defendant, the ET's factual finding that the employment and complained‑of acts were non‑sovereign was not perverse, and section 4(2)(a) of the State Immunity Act 1978 was correctly disapplied in respect of the Equality Act claims. The ET's preliminary judgment was upheld and the EqA claims may proceed against the State.
- Dr S Hassane v GlaxoSmithKline Services Unlimited [2023] EAT 150 7 December 2023 This appeal concerned a redundancy dismissal and consolidated discrimination claims by Dr Hassane after he unsuccessfully applied for an internal SPO Director role; he argued that the appointment of Ms Adele Cheli after his exit demonstrated differential treatment and shifted the burden of proof. The Employment Tribunal allowed limited disclosure, heard evidence, found the claimant’s case vague and unparticularised, and dismissed his claims. The EAT upheld the ET, concluding the ET did not err in refusing to treat Ms Cheli as an unpleaded comparator or to expand the claimant’s case, and that the claimant had not adduced sufficient factual material to shift the burden of proof or to show unfair dismissal or discrimination.
- D Carryl v Governing Body of Manford Primary School [2023] EAT 167 6 December 2023 This appeal concerns a claimant who was ordered to pay a £250 per-complaint deposit under Rule 39(2), failed to pay, and had her claims struck out; she appealed late. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the Employment Tribunal had not made reasonable enquiries into disposable income or given reasons for the specific quantum, and that administrative failings and the claimant’s diligence amounted to exceptional circumstances justifying extension of time. The EAT upheld grounds on Rule 39(2), extended the time for appeal to when the claimant filed in February 2022, and recalculated the deposit at £30 per complaint.
- Edge Hill University v E Glasby [2023] EAT 162 6 December 2023 This appeal concerned an employment tribunal’s upholding of several reasonable‑adjustment claims and section 15 disability discrimination complaints following dismissal for sickness absence. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the tribunal’s reasons were deficient on essential elements (timing, substantial disadvantage, knowledge, and reasonable steps) for three reasonable‑adjustment complaints and failed to address causation/timing and justification for a section 15 complaint. The EAT allowed the employer’s appeal, quashed those decisions and remitted them for rehearing by a differently constituted panel.
- Margaret Gallacher v T&C Bars Limited & Anor [2024] EAT 15 6 December 2023 This appeal concerns the Registrar's refusal to extend time to lodge an EAT appeal that was instituted 412 days late. The President found the appellant failed to give a full, honest and acceptable explanation for the entire period of delay and that there were no exceptional circumstances to justify extending time. The Registrar's refusal was upheld and the appeal dismissed.
- SPI Spirits (UK) Limited & Anor v Vladislav Zabelin [2023] EAT 147 6 December 2023 This appeal concerned remedy issues after a tribunal found SPI Spirits (UK) Limited and Mr Zabelin liable for detriment and unfair dismissal following protected disclosures. The respondents argued contractual clauses limited compensation to £270,000, that the ACAS Code uplift required a written grievance and could not apply to an individual; the EAT rejected those points. The EAT held the clauses did not operate as a tribunal‑award cap (and would be void if they purported to limit statutory compensation), upheld the tribunal’s finding that the grievance history engaged the Code so a 20% uplift was justified, and confirmed the uplift could be applied to the individual respondent. The appeal was dismissed.
- The Royal Embassy of Saudi Arabia (Cultural Bureau) v A Alhayali [2023] EAT 149 5 December 2023 This is an EAT appeal by the Royal Embassy of Saudi Arabia (Cultural Bureau) against Employment Tribunal findings on state immunity under the State Immunity Act 1978. The EAT allowed grounds challenging the tribunal’s treatment of an unsigned Embassy statement and its conclusion that the claimant’s duties were not sovereign, holding some weight should have been given to the statement and on the correct test the claimant participated in the public service so immunity applied. The EAT dismissed challenges to the construction of the SIA personal injury exception and confirmed psychiatric injury falls within “personal injury.”
- Astha Limited & Anor v S Grewal [2023] EAT 170 30 November 2023 This Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment concerned an appeal against an Employment Tribunal remedy decision after the claimant succeeded in unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims and was awarded about £41,046.82. The EAT rejected appeals that the tribunal should have made a further contributory-conduct deduction and that the claimant’s interim lower-paid employment broke causation, but allowed the appeal that the second respondent was incorrectly made personally liable for awards payable only against an employer, removing the basic award and s.38 particulars award from her personal liability.
- Bauhaus Educational Services Limited v Oluwaseyi Elemide [2023] EAT 161 30 November 2023 The EAT held that the claimant did not comply with an unless order requiring service of his witness statement on the respondent by a specified date, because lodging the statement with the Tribunal without serving the respondent did not meet the order. The Employment Judge was wrong to treat the lodging as compliance, so the claim stood dismissed on expiry of the order; the EAT directed the Tribunal to serve a Rule 38(1) notice so the claimant may apply under Rule 38(2) for relief from sanction.
- Ryanair DAC & Anor v Jason Lutz [2023] EAT 146 30 November 2023 The EAT dismissed appeals by Ryanair DAC and Storm Global Limited against an Employment Tribunal finding that Mr Lutz, a contracted pilot supplied to Ryanair, was employed by MCG for CAWR purposes, was a "worker" under EU law/AVD, and was an "agency worker" under the AWR. The EAT upheld factual findings that the service‑company interposition was a fiction, substitution rights were sham or fettered, and the five‑year supply was temporary, and it endorsed the ET’s legal reasoning on tripartite employment, personal service despite regulatory fetters, and the meaning of "temporarily". Appeals were therefore dismissed.
- British Bung Manufacturing Company Ltd & Anor v Mr A Finn [2023] EAT 165 28 November 2023 This EAT judgment dismissed the employer's permitted appeal and upheld a tribunal finding that the claimant was harassed related to sex, unfairly dismissed and wrongfully dismissed after summary dismissal for presenting a police‑headed witness statement. The tribunal found the "bald cunt" remark amounted to harassment related to sex, the employer acted in bad faith by purporting to await police enquiries then dismissing shortly after without proper process, and the claimant did not commit a repudiatory breach; awards were reduced for claimant culpability.
- Joseph De Bank Haycocks v ADP RPO UK Ltd [2023] EAT 129 28 November 2023 The EAT allowed Mr De Bank Haycocks' appeal, holding that the Employment Tribunal had failed to address absence of workforce-level consultation at a formative stage and that the dismissal for redundancy was procedurally unfair. The EAT remitted the case to the ET to determine remedy, directing the same Employment Judge to hear that remit.
- Nicholas Toure v Ken Wilkins Print Limited [2023] EAT 163 28 November 2023 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal was entitled to find the claimant’s racial-abuse grievance was fictional and to treat his subsequent statements to managers (threatening to drop the appeal in return for promotion/pay) as separable misconduct leading to dismissal rather than victimisation for making a protected act. The EAT upheld the ET’s credibility findings, accepted that hearsay reliance was permissible on the facts, and concluded the victimisation claim could not succeed because the grievance was false/made in bad faith and the statements amounted to tantamount blackmail. The EAT dismissed the appeal and affirmed dismissal for misconduct.
- Dr Sara Ajaz v Homerton University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2023] EAT 142 24 November 2023 This appeal concerned whether a 2018 COT3 and the Rule 52 dismissal of a 2017 detriment claim barred new 2021 detriment claims based on the same nine alleged protected disclosures. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Employment Judge erred in treating Rule 52 as automatically giving rise to issue estoppel, but nonetheless dismissed the appeal overall because the COT3, properly construed, had settled the contested issue that the disclosures were protected and the 2021 claims were an abuse of process. The strike-out therefore stands.
- Karen Shanks v Lothian Health Board [2023] EAT 148 24 November 2023 This appeal challenged whether regulations requiring facemasks were ultra vires because paragraph 3 of Schedule 19 to the Coronavirus Act 2020 forbids regulations requiring "medical treatment", and whether the Employment Tribunal erred in finding dismissal for refusing to wear a mask fair. The EAT held that "medical treatment" does not, in its plain meaning, cover general infection-control measures like mask-wearing, and found no error in the Tribunal's application of the range-of-reasonable-responses test. The appeal was refused and the Tribunal's dismissal of the unfair dismissal and breach of contract claims was upheld.
- Brian Rowe v Ashmore Group PLC & Ors [2023] EAT 172 23 November 2023 This is an EAT appeal against a £1,000 deposit order made by an Employment Judge at a preliminary hearing in respect of nine claims brought by Mr Rowe against his employer. The EAT allowed the appeal in part, quashing the deposit order in respect of the complaints about the investigation and suspension because the Tribunal had failed to focus on how the claimant actually put his case and had relied on irrelevant matters; the order is set aside and any sums paid must be repaid. Other grounds were not upheld in substance.
- Dr Paul Leaney v Loughborough University [2023] EAT 155 23 November 2023 This appeal concerned whether the employment tribunal misapplied the law on affirmation after Dr Leaney resigned claiming constructive unfair dismissal. The EAT found the tribunal erred by treating nearly three months' delay as dispositive rather than identifying conduct or circumstances between 29 June and 28 September 2020 from which affirmation could be inferred, allowed the appeal on that point and remitted affirmation for fresh decision on the existing evidence.
- Roua Al Taweel v Stichting Female Journalists Network [2023] EAT 159 22 November 2023 This appeal concerned the claimant's employment status while working for the respondent from March 2018 to April 2020 and related dismissal claims. The EAT held the Employment Tribunal had erred in treating the claimant as an employee of her own limited company in 2020 without applying ordinary employment‑status analysis, remitting the 2020 status question to the ET; other grounds were dismissed and earlier findings that she was self‑employed in 2018 but an employee in 2019 were upheld.
- L Fry v Kingswood Learning & Leisure Group Ltd [2023] EAT 166 21 November 2023 This appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal challenged an Employment Tribunal's finding that the dismissing manager did not know of the claimant's protected disclosures before she was dismissed and that the real reason for dismissal was redundancy linked to pandemic-related business pressures. The EAT rejected the appeal, holding the ET's finding on timing of knowledge was not perverse and that the ET had given adequate reasons. The ET decision that the dismissal was for redundancy and not whistleblowing was therefore upheld.
- J Olatunde v Viewber Ltd [2023] EAT 158 17 November 2023 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal properly refused late amendments to add national minimum wage and holiday‑pay claims and its strike‑out of discrimination claims. The EAT upheld refusal of the NMW amendment and a broad holiday‑pay claim based on key‑holding time but found error in the tribunal’s failure to consider a narrower holiday‑pay amendment limited to time spent on actual viewings. That narrower claim was remitted to the tribunal for reconsideration by a different judge.
- Stuart Harris Associates Limited v A Gobudhun [2023] EAT 145 17 November 2023 This appeal concerned a tribunal's finding that an employee had been constructively and unfairly dismissed after refusing to follow an employer's practice of entering "estimated" expenses. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the constructive dismissal outcome but set aside the tribunal's findings of dishonesty (and related competence findings) because the tribunal failed to put the allegation of dishonesty to the employee and misapplied the subjective limb of the Ivey test. The EAT rejected complaints that the judge's provisional case summary and limited judicial research amounted to prejudgment or impermissible descent into the arena.
- Rev Dr James George Hargreaves v Evolve Housing & Support & Anor [2023] EAT 154 16 November 2023 The claimant, dismissed for gross misconduct, had his discrimination, victimisation and unfair dismissal claims struck out by an Employment Tribunal as scandalous, vexatious and unreasonable under Rule 37(1)(b). The EAT upheld the finding of abusive conduct but held the Tribunal was wrong to conclude the conduct made a fair trial impossible and that strike-out was proportionate. The EAT allowed one ground of appeal, set aside the strike-out, reinstated the claims and remitted the case for an open preliminary hearing to give directions for a substantive hearing.
- Dr Gueorgui Kolev v Middlesex University [2023] EAT 173 14 November 2023 Dr Kolev, a former senior lecturer, appealed an Employment Judge’s strike-out of parts of his sex discrimination, harassment and victimisation claims as time-barred following a Preliminary Hearing listed for strike-out/deposit. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal, finding legal and procedural error because the Preliminary Hearing was effectively used to decide substantive limitation issues without proper notice, case identification or consideration of evidence, and remitted the case for further case management before a differently constituted tribunal.
- Blackdown Hill Management Limited & Anor v Anastasia Tuchkova [2023] EAT 156 9 November 2023 This is an EAT judgment on an appeal against an Employment Tribunal (ET) decision where the ET had found the claimant unfairly dismissed for redundancy and had upheld four discrimination complaints related to maternity/sex. The EAT upheld the ET's unfair dismissal findings (procedural unfairness) but allowed parts of the respondents' appeal on the discrimination findings, concluding the ET erred in its legal reasoning on causation and in addressing timeliness, and remitted those discrimination complaints for reconsideration while leaving the ET's factual findings as binding background. Remedy-related findings including the Polkey reduction largely stand.
- S Bharaj v Santander UK Plc & Ors [2023] EAT 152 9 November 2023 This appeal concerned the Employment Judge's decision to strike out Miss Bharaj's whistleblowing, sex discrimination and harassment claims for deliberate non-compliance with a Davidson order requiring exchange of witness statements before a 20‑day trial listing. The EAT upheld the strike out and refusal to reconsider, finding the judge lawfully applied rule 37(1)(c) and proportionality (including Article 6) and that, because the delayed exchange made the scheduled trial unworkable, no less drastic sanction would have avoided prejudice. The appeals were dismissed and the claims remain struck out.
- Elaina Cohen v Khalid Mahmood MP [2023] EAT 144 8 November 2023 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal correctly extended time for a claim after the claimant filed an ET1 with an entirely wrong ACAS early conciliation number, and whether parts of the Tribunal's detriment findings were perverse. The EAT held the proper inquiry is whether the claimant reasonably believed the claim had been validly presented (the nature of the original error is relevant but not determinative), dismissed the employer's appeal against the extension of time, allowed the claimant's limited appeal on a finding denying a threatened dismissal, and remitted related factual issues to the ET.
- Sandra Brooks v Brooks v Leisure Employment Services Ltd. [2023] EAT 137 8 November 2023 This appeal concerned whether the employer’s removal of the claimant from a work WhatsApp group amounted to a fundamental breach of the implied term of mutual trust and confidence, and whether the claimant had affirmed the contract before resigning. The EAT agreed the removal (in context) was a breach but found the ET erred in law in concluding the claimant had affirmed the contract; the affirmation issue was remitted to the same Employment Tribunal for rehearing. Disability discrimination was not pursued on appeal.
- The No 8 Partnership v Maxine Simmons [2023] EAT 140 8 November 2023 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal’s findings that the claimant was constructively unfairly dismissed and directly discriminated against by association after her employer refused extended unpaid time off to care for her father. The EAT allowed the employer’s appeal, holding the ET unfairly relied on hypothetical comparators without permitting the parties to address them, concluding the discrimination finding was perverse on the ET’s own findings and dismissing the s.13 claim, and remitting the constructive dismissal complaint for rehearing because the ET misapplied the Malik test and gave inadequate reasons. The ET judgment was set aside; the s.13 claim was dismissed and the constructive dismissal claim remitted to a differently constituted ET.
- Claudio Costagliola Di Fiore & Anor v Introhive UK Limited [2023] EAT 139 7 November 2023 This appeal concerned whether the 42‑day time limit for an EAT appeal ran from promulgation of the tribunal’s written judgment and reasons or from a later separate set of case‑management reasons, and whether time could be extended for exceptional circumstances. The judge held time ran from the written judgment and reasons (8/11 Nov 2021), the appeal was out of time because required ET1/ET3 were not filed within time, and no exceptional circumstances (including Article 6 considerations) justified an extension.
- Anglian Windows Ltd (t/a Anglican Home Improvements) v Allister Webb [2023] EAT 138 3 November 2023 The case concerned whether an individual partner in a genuine two-person partnership could bring an unfair dismissal claim as an employee where services were provided and paid through the partnership. The Employment Tribunal refused to strike out the claim, distinguishing Firthglow v Descombes, but the EAT allowed the employer's appeal. The EAT held that, on the agreed facts, the contract was with the partnership so there was no realistic prospect of an individual contract of employment and the claim was properly struck out.
- Gina Gannon v Teuta Bicaku & Anor t/a Ivory Dental Clinic [2023] EAT 143 2 November 2023 This is an appeal by Ms Gannon against an Employment Tribunal’s dismissal of her TUPE inform-and-consult claim after a practice sale on 9 March 2021. The EAT held the Tribunal failed to analyse or apply specific pleaded provisions of Regulations 13, 13A and 15 (including 13(9), 13(2)(b)–(d), 13(5), 13(6) and 15(2)) and omitted necessary factual findings about events on 9 March, so the appeal was allowed and the claim remitted for rehearing. No substantive determination on the merits was made by the EAT. The judge urged parties to consider settlement given the modest capped compensation.
- R Omar v Epping Forest District Citizens Advice [2023] EAT 132 2 November 2023 This appeal concerned whether the claimant's words during an altercation on 19 February 2020 objectively amounted to an effective resignation, or whether subsequent events showed the employer had dismissed him. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the Employment Tribunal erred in law and fact by misstating the legal position on "special circumstances" and by failing to make necessary findings, allowed the appeal and remitted the case for rehearing.
- P Embery v Fire Brigades Union [2023] EAT 134 25 October 2023 This is an appeal against the Certification Officer’s decision to strike out an FBU member’s complaint under rule C13 as having no reasonable prospect of success or being misconceived. The central issue was whether C13 required referral to the Standing Orders Committee whenever a member remained dissatisfied with an Executive Council (or sub‑committee) decision. The EAT upheld the Certification Officer’s construction of C13 — that the Executive Council (or its sub‑committees) may “settle” disputes by decision, and the Standing Orders Committee is empowered to adjudicate only where the EC/sub‑committee cannot satisfactorily do so — and dismissed the appeal.
- M Jarosinski v Nestle UK Ltd [2023] EAT 157 24 October 2023 This appeal challenged an Employment Judge's reconsideration decision refusing the Claimant's application under Rule 72. The EAT held the EJ erred procedurally by skipping the mandatory Rule 72(1) "sift" and by conducting a Rule 72(2)-style rehearing alone rather than by the original full tribunal, rendering the decision unsafe; the EAT remitted the matter for a Rule 72(1) consideration by a differently allocated judge. The EAT rejected the complaint that reliance on the long and complex litigation history was an impermissible time-based reason.
- Chief Constable of Derbyshire Constabulary & Ors v N Clark & Anor [2023] EAT 135 23 October 2023 This Employment Appeal Tribunal considered whether regulation 12 of the Police Injury Benefit Regulations 2006 (a disablement gratuity) forms part of an "occupational pension scheme" for the purposes of section 61 Equality Act 2010, and so whether the Employment Tribunal had jurisdiction to hear disability discrimination claims. The EAT held regulation 12 is not part of an occupational pension scheme because entitlement does not arise "on" retirement or termination as those words are naturally understood, and also concluded the gratuity is not clearly "pay" under the Framework Directive. The respondents' appeal on section 61 succeeded and the claimants' cross-appeal on section 108 was dismissed.
- R Sandhu v Enterprise Rent-A-Car Ltd [2023] EAT 169 19 October 2023 This is an EAT appeal against an Employment Tribunal judgment dismissing claims of unfair dismissal, direct disability discrimination and harassment by a long‑serving payroll employee. The ET found the principal reason for dismissal was the claimant’s sustained refusal to accept the 2016 reporting lines and breakdown in working relations, and that alleged harassment incidents were minor and not shown to be linked to the father’s disability. The EAT rejected challenges to the ET’s reasons and perversity arguments and dismissed the appeal, upholding that dismissal was for some other substantial reason and within the band of reasonable responses.
- Virgin Active Limited v C Hughes [2023] EAT 130 16 October 2023 This EAT decision concerned claims by C Hughes that Virgin Active dismissed her for making protected disclosures and because of race discrimination. The EAT upheld the Tribunal's findings that qualifying protected disclosures were made and motivated the dismissal, and rejected challenges on perversity and delay. However it found legal error in the Tribunal's burden‑shifting analysis for the race claim (treating comparators as actual without assessing material differences), set the race findings aside and remitted that issue for rehearing.
- Z Valimulla v Al-Khair Foundation [2023] EAT 131 10 October 2023 This is an EAT appeal by a Masjid Liaison Officer dismissed for redundancy after being placed in a pool of one. The EAT found the Employment Tribunal erred in accepting without adequate reasons that the role was unique and substituted a finding that there had been no meaningful consultation about the decision to place the claimant in a solo pool, making the dismissal procedurally unfair. The pooling issue was remitted for rehearing by a different judge and remedy (including any Polkey reduction) was left to be determined.
- Dr Glaucia Pereira v GFT Financial Limited [2023] EAT 124 6 October 2023 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's refusal at the sift stage to reconsider an out‑of‑time application to amend claims to add pregnancy‑related automatic unfair dismissal and statutory rights. The EAT held the ET erred as it addressed time limits before first asking whether the proposed pregnancy‑related allegations were already pleaded in the ET1 and attachments, and it failed to consider the balance of prejudice and relevant medical evidence about the claimant's cognitive difficulties. The EAT allowed the appeal and remitted the case to a fresh ET to determine whether a reconsideration hearing is required and how to proceed.
- R Meshram v Entserv UK Limited [2023] EAT 126 28 September 2023 This is an EAT appeal by Mr Meshram against an ET dismissal of his victimisation complaints against Entserv arising from his quick dismissal and the handling of his internal appeal. The EAT upheld the ET's conclusion that the protected act did not materially influence the dismissal but found the tribunal's reasoning on the limited sub-issue of whether Mr Nagra failed to action the claimant's 14 June 2019 appeal email was procedurally inadequate (not Meek-compliant) and remitted that sub-issue for reconsideration. No new evidence was permitted; the same tribunal may receive further submissions and must reconsider any consequential effects on the dismissal finding if necessary.
- J Williams v Newport City Council [2023] EAT 136 27 September 2023 This EAT appeal concerned whether the tribunal erred in finding the claimant was not disabled under the Equality Act 2010. The tribunal had accepted a continuing mental impairment and that the claimant could not return to work while a potential court-attendance requirement remained, but treated court attendance as not a "normal day-to-day activity" and so concluded there was no substantial adverse effect. The EAT held the tribunal should have treated the preventing effect on return to work as capable of amounting to a substantial adverse effect and substituted a decision that the claimant was disabled throughout the relevant period.
- Lindsay Anne McNicholas v Care And Learning Alliance & Anor [2023] EAT 127 26 September 2023 This employment appeal concerned whether a joint referral by the respondents to the General Teaching Council for Scotland (GTCS) following the appellant's protected disclosures constituted a novus actus interveniens breaking causation for whistleblowing detriments. The EAT held the remedies tribunal erred in treating the GTCS decision to investigate as a supervening cause; on the tribunal's findings the referral and its consequences were a natural and reasonable consequence of the respondents' wrongful conduct. The appeal was allowed and the case remitted for reassessment of remedies, certain costs and ACAS/tax adjustments.
- M Fernandes v Department for Work and Pensions [2023] EAT 114 14 September 2023 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal correctly fixed the notional date from which time ran for claims of failure to make reasonable adjustments and indirect disability discrimination, and whether it misapplied the just-and-equitable discretion. The EAT held the ET misdirected itself by failing to ask when a reasonable employee, based on facts known to them, would have concluded the employer would not comply; Grounds 1 and 2 were allowed, Grounds 3 and 4 dismissed, and the case was remitted for further factual findings and determination.
- Greater Glasgow Health Board v Stephen Mullen [2023] EAT 122 12 September 2023 The EAT allowed the employer's appeal and substituted judgment that Mr Mullen's dismissal for gross misconduct was fair. The Tribunal had found the employer genuinely believed, after reasonable investigation, that he shouted/threatened on 11 March 2021, but had nevertheless based unfairness on a contrary "real reason" hypothesis and some procedural defects; the EAT held the Tribunal should have assessed fairness by reference to the established reason and genuine belief and that the procedural departures did not make the dismissal outside the range of reasonable responses.
- T v Royal Bank of Scotland Plc [2023] EAT 119 11 September 2023 The claimant, dismissed after an extended sickness absence and alleging unfair dismissal and disability discrimination, had his claims struck out by an ET in February 2019 for non‑compliance and/or because a fair trial was said to be impossible. The EAT (HHJ Auerbach) held the tribunal erred to the extent it struck out the whole claim, quashed that decision and substituted a decision declining to strike out as at February 2019, remitting case management back to the ET.
- Edenbeck Limited v E Stevenson [2023] EAT 128 7 September 2023 This appeal concerned a costs and remedy decision after an employment tribunal found sex discrimination, disability discrimination arising from PTSD, and constructive unfair dismissal by Edenbeck Limited against E Stevenson. The EAT upheld the tribunal's substantive remedy awards but found legal error in parts of its costs reasoning: wrongly treating ordinary cross-examination as unreasonable conduct, and failing to proceed from finding the costs threshold crossed to a discrete exercise of discretion as to whether to award costs and in what proportion. The matter of costs was remitted for rehearing consistent with those rulings.
- Matthew Riley v Direct Line Insurance Group PLC [2023] EAT 118 6 September 2023 This appeal concerned whether the employment tribunal failed to provide reasonable adjustments for Mr Riley's cross‑examination, whether his contract terminated by mutual consent on 19 September 2018 rather than by dismissal, and whether time should have been extended for his adjustments claims. The EAT dismissed the appeal, upholding the ET's findings that the tribunal did not unlawfully withhold reasonable adjustments or render the hearing substantively unfair, that the contract terminated by free mutual consent on 19 September 2018 despite a later letter describing dismissal, and that it was not just and equitable to extend time for the adjustments claims.
- London United Busways Limited v Kamal Hamid Dankali [2023] EAT 123 1 September 2023 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal should have struck out or further investigated a claim after the union representative said the absent claimant had given blanket oral authority to continue proceedings while overseas. The EAT held the tribunal was not required to probe maintenance or champerty on the facts before it but erred in accepting the representative’s untested oral assertion of authority and relisting the case without taking further investigative steps. The EAT quashed the refusal to strike out and remitted the matter for the tribunal to determine appropriate further steps.
- Mid and South Essex NHS Foundation Trust v Catriona Stevenson & Ors [2023] EAT 115 31 August 2023 The EAT dismissed the employer's appeal and upheld the ET's finding that the claimants validly refused offered suitable alternative roles and therefore remained entitled to redundancy pay. The central issues were (a) whether the judge misdirected himself by treating suitability findings as irrelevant to reasonableness and (b) whether he failed to consider how the facts "ought to have appeared" to the claimants. The EAT held there was no error: suitability was taken into account but did not automatically determine reasonableness, and it was open to find that the claimants' perceptions made refusal reasonable from their point of view.
- W Davey v Harrods Ltd [2023] EAT 133 31 August 2023 This appeal concerned an Employment Judge's strike‑out of Mr Davey's unfair dismissal and protected disclosure claims for alleged non‑compliance with an "unless" order. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the judge erred by failing to assess whether a fair trial remained possible and by not applying the overriding objective and proportionality, including not taking account of the claimant's unacknowledged extension requests. The EAT allowed the appeal, set aside the strike‑out and remitted the case for further directions and trial.
- D Cox v Adecco UK Limited & Ors [2023] EAT 105 30 August 2023 This is an appeal against an Employment Tribunal’s refusal to allow six late amendments to a whistleblowing/detriment claim by Mr D Cox. The EAT allowed two amendments (an oral disclosure on 2 July 2018 and a broadened lock‑out/second‑respondent detriment) but dismissed the appeal as to the remaining proposed amendments, finding those refusals were within the ET’s case‑management discretion. The case was remitted to the ET for further case management and determination in light of the permitted amendments.
- Jagruti Rajput v Commerzbank AG & Anor [2023] EAT 116 29 August 2023 This appeal concerned the date of a TUPE transfer of Commerzbank’s EMC business to SocGen, where the sale was implemented by a series of transactions and part of the business (Flow) was predominantly outside the UK. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held that a transfer effected by a series of transactions is dated by reference to when responsibility as employer for the economic unit passes, and that the tribunal did not err in using the "essential nature" formulation to identify that point. The EAT allowed the appeal only to the extent that the tribunal had wrongly excluded the Flow (non‑UK) component from its assessment and remitted the question of the correct transfer date for rehearing.
- Brian Kristensen v Portman Healthcare Limited [2023] EAT 121 25 August 2023 This appeal concerned whether disclosures about an alleged forgery of the claimant's employment contract were protected as made in the public interest. The EAT held the Employment Tribunal was perverse to find the police were "not interested" and fixed that the claimant had reported a fraud and that police attended his workplace; the question whether the disclosure was objectively reasonably in the public interest was remitted to the ET for determination. Other dismissal claims proceed to hearing.
- Dr Oleg Iourin v The Chancellor, Masters and Scholars of the University of Oxford [2023] EAT 108 24 August 2023 This Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment concerns Dr Oleg Iourin’s claims of direct sex discrimination, victimisation and disability discrimination against the University of Oxford. The EAT upheld the Tribunal’s approach to the burden of proof and its finding that the claimant was not disabled, but found a material legal error where the Tribunal wrongly recorded that a grievance committee had found harassment and relied on that misstatement in dismissing two allegations about compulsory harassment training. The EAT remitted those two allegations for rehearing by a differently constituted Employment Tribunal and dismissed the remainder of the appeal.
- F Habib v Dave Whelan Sports Limited t/a DW Fitness First [2023] EAT 113 23 August 2023 This Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the claimant’s appeal on ground 8, finding the Employment Tribunal’s adverse credibility findings were unsafe because they failed to engage with guidance on vulnerable witnesses (the Equal Treatment Bench Book and Presidential Guidance) despite the claimant being dyslexic. The ET had refused several reasonable adjustments and did not warn or give the claimant an opportunity to address concerns about her dyslexia, rendering the hearing substantively unfair. The EAT set aside the ET’s decision and ordered a full retrial before a different panel, and did not decide the remaining grounds which depended on the impugned factual findings.
- E Macfarlane v Commissioners of Police of the Metropolis [2023] EAT 111 22 August 2023 This appeal concerned Mrs Macfarlane’s challenge to an employment judge’s refusal to allow amendment of her ET1 to add whistleblowing (s.47B) detriment and automatic unfair dismissal claims. The EJ concluded the proposed amendments would materially change the factual and legal basis of the pleaded claim (not merely relabelling), and that on balance of hardship the prejudice to the respondent and the claimant’s earlier disavowal at a case management hearing justified refusal. The EAT dismissed the appeal.
- Aecom Limited v C Mallon [2023] EAT 104 10 August 2023 This appeal concerned a dyspraxic job applicant who claimed the employer failed to make reasonable adjustments by insisting on an online application form. The EAT found one factual finding of the tribunal to be perverse (that the 2018 role was in a different team to the claimant’s prior post) and allowed that ground, but dismissed grounds on knowledge, enquiries and reasonableness of expecting an email explanation, upholding that the employer ought to have telephoned and would thereby have constructive knowledge. The case was remitted to the same Employment Tribunal to reconsider whether the claimant was a genuine applicant.
- A Hewston v Ofsted [2023] EAT 109 4 August 2023 This case concerns a long‑serving social care inspector who touched a pupil during an inspection, was investigated and summarily dismissed for gross misconduct, and whose claim of unfair dismissal was upheld on appeal to the EAT. The EAT found the employment tribunal erred by failing to give sufficient weight to the absence of any policy, training or other forewarning that a single uninvited touch could lead to summary dismissal and by noting that key documents relied on by the employer had not been disclosed, and substituted a finding that the dismissal was unfair. The EAT also quashed the tribunal’s wrongful dismissal decision for lack of a clear independent finding and remitted remedy and the wrongful dismissal claim for rehearing.
- Rowena Owen v Network Rail Infrastructure Limited [2023] EAT 106 1 August 2023 This is an appeal by a signaller, Ms Owen, against an employment tribunal’s refusal to grant a just and equitable extension of time under section 123 of the Equality Act 2010 for sex-related discrimination/harassment complaints arising around Wimbledon (Nov 2015–May 2017). The EAT held the tribunal erred in law by treating the absence of an explanation for delay as an automatic bar to extension and found the tribunal’s reasoning on prejudice unsatisfactory in part. The EAT quashed the time decision and remitted the matter to the same tribunal for reconsideration, leaving certain factual findings (items 1–25) intact.
- B Garcha-Singh v British Airways Plc [2023] EAT 97 26 July 2023 This appeal concerned whether British Airways breached its incorporated Absence Management Policy (AMP) by repeatedly postponing a termination date and whether the claimant was denied a contractual right of appeal to his detriment. The EAT dismissed the claimant's appeal, holding the AMP did not prohibit a reasonable managerial postponement of a termination date, the claimant had already been given a full and fair appeal against the substantive decision to dismiss, and the overall procedure fell within the band of reasonable responses.
- Clare Jackson v The University Hospitals of North Midlands NHS Trust [2023] EAT 102 19 July 2023 This appeal concerned whether the unilateral imposition on 3 December 2018 of a band 5 contract on a band 6 NHS research nurse amounted to a Hogg v Dover College dismissal for purposes of entitlement to an enhanced Agenda for Change (AfC) contractual redundancy payment. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the employment tribunal erred in law by conflating the Hogg dismissal test with constructive dismissal, giving inadequate reasons and failing to carry out a proper before-and-after comparison of terms. The EAT allowed the appeal and remitted the limited issue of entitlement to the AfC contractual redundancy payment to a differently constituted tribunal.
- Polystar Plastic Limited v M Liepa [2023] EAT 100 19 July 2023 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal properly extended time under Equality Act s.123(1) for a race discrimination claim where the claimant's first ET1 lacked an ACAS early conciliation number. The EAT held the ET erred in treating the respondent as bearing a burden to disprove the claimant's asserted belief that ACAS had been contacted and failed adequately to explain how it weighed the reason for delay; on the facts the claimant had not shown his belief was reasonable nor that there was a good reason for delay up to 12 May 2022. The EAT allowed the appeal, substituted those findings, and remitted the just-and-equitable exercise to the ET to decide at the merits hearing.
- A Chauhan v University of Leicester [2023] EAT 112 18 July 2023 This appeal concerned an unless order requiring the claimant to provide further and better particulars in response to a respondent's October 2019 grid and the sanction that "the claim" would be struck out for non‑compliance. The Employment Tribunal found the claimant's largely handwritten responses did not amount to substantial or qualitative compliance, refused relief from sanctions, and struck out the whole claim; the Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal and upheld that decision.
- Lorenzo Ramos v Lady Coco Limited T/A Shamela's Fresh Hot and Cold Food [2023] EAT 99 13 July 2023 This is an application under Employment Appeal Tribunal rule 3(10) by Lorenzo Ramos seeking permission to appeal an Employment Tribunal's dismissal of his sex-discrimination claim and its award of a Preparation Time Order (PTO) in favour of Lady Coco Limited T/A Shamela's. The EAT judge refused permission, holding the proposed appeals raised no arguable question of law, upholding the ET's factual findings that the claimant lacked genuine intention to apply for the advertised job and was not credible, and finding the claimant's conduct vexatious. Both appeals were dismissed as totally without merit and the judge referred the claimant's conduct to the Registrar for possible further action.
- Ionut Cosmin Onea v Contingent and Future Technologies Ltd [2023] EAT 125 11 July 2023 This appeal concerned whether Employment Tribunal proceedings should have been stayed because of concurrent High Court proceedings (a breach of confidence claim and an unfair prejudice petition). The EAT held the Employment Judge erred by treating potential "embarrassment" to the High Court as a threshold requirement rather than one factor in a balancing exercise. Applying the correct test, the EAT found considerable overlap between the forums and directed that the ET claim be stayed pending resolution of the High Court matters.
- R Kealy v Westfield Community Development Association [2023] EAT 96 11 July 2023 This appeal concerned Ms Kealy's whistleblowing, unfair/constructive dismissal and health-and-safety claims against Westfield Community Development Association and whether the employment tribunal correctly identified qualifying and protected disclosures and their causal consequences. The EAT found multiple legal and reasoning defects, notably conflation of the s.43B qualifying-disclosure test with the ss.43C/43G protection tests and unsafe credibility-based findings, and remitted all claims for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal. The EAT upheld several grounds of appeal and concluded the tribunal's findings were unsafe.
- Pilkington UK Limited v A Jones [2023] EAT 90 6 July 2023 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in finding under s.15 Equality Act 2010 that the employer’s belief that the claimant had undertaken physical activity while off sick was the “something arising” from his disability which led to dismissal for gross misconduct. The EAT held the ET had not departed from the pleaded case and had correctly applied the causation analysis, endorsing that the respondent’s subjective belief (together with the claimant’s sickness absence) could objectively qualify as the “something arising” from disability. The appeal was dismissed and the ET’s discrimination finding under s.15 was upheld.
- The Sports PR Company Limited v Valentina Londono Cardona [2023] EAT 110 4 July 2023 This appeal concerned whether the employment tribunal erred in extending time under section 23 after earlier rule 12/13 paper decisions had treated the claim as presented out of time, and related issues about a wages award and costs. The EAT dismissed the respondent’s challenge to the tribunal’s extension of time, allowed a late amendment to contend that three days’ SSP should have been deducted, remitted recalculation on that point, and refused the claimant’s pro bono costs application.
- Leslie Butler v Synergy Health UK Limited [2022] EAT 205 29 June 2023 This case concerns the fairness of the dismissal of Mr Butler for misconduct after he refused a new instruction requiring staff to remain at their workstation until shift end and to clock out before changing out of PPE. The Employment Tribunal was entitled to reject an implied contractual right and to find the instruction reasonable, but the Employment Appeal Tribunal held that the Tribunal’s conclusions on procedure and that the dismissal fell within the band of reasonable responses were perverse in light of its own factual findings, and allowed the appeal on those grounds. The EAT invited written submissions on disposal.
- United Taxis Limited v R Comolly & Anor [2023] EAT 93 28 June 2023 This EAT judgment concerned whether Mr Comolly, a taxi driver who registered with United Taxis and worked via shareholder drivers, was a worker or employee of United Taxis and/or of shareholder Mr Tidman. The tribunal's finding that there was an implied contract making him a worker of United Taxis was overturned as unnecessary; the EAT substituted a finding that Mr Comolly was not a worker/employee of United Taxis but was a worker of Mr Tidman for the periods he drove Mr Tidman’s taxi. The tribunal was also wrong to treat him as simultaneously employed/worker of both United Taxis and Mr Tidman for the same work.
- A v Carers Trust South East Wales [2023] EAT 80 27 June 2023 This appeal concerned multiple employment claims (protected disclosures/whistleblowing, direct disability discrimination, harassment/victimisation and unfair dismissal) arising from the claimant's dismissal after internal complaints and an investigation. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal's factual findings that the alleged verbal disclosures lacked sufficient factual content to be qualifying disclosures and that the real reason for dismissal was complaints arising from the investigation, not protected disclosures or disability-related acts. The EAT dismissed all grounds of appeal and upheld the ET's judgment (the claimant's holiday pay claim remained the only successful claim below).
- A Wainwright v Cennox PLC [2023] EAT 101 20 June 2023 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal erred in dismissing Ms Wainwright’s constructive unfair and discriminatory dismissal claims after finding certain acts amounted to disability-related discrimination. The EAT held the ET had failed to analyse whether those discriminatory acts also amounted to repudiatory breaches of contract or materially contributed to her resignation, and remitted the unresolved dismissal claims to a differently constituted Employment Tribunal while preserving other factual findings.
- Kristie Higgs v Farmor’s School [2023] EAT 89 16 June 2023 This is an appeal by a school employee dismissed after reposting Facebook material opposing relationships education; the Employment Tribunal had rejected her discrimination and harassment claims on the basis the school acted because readers might perceive her as homophobic/transphobic. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal, finding the ET failed to assess whether the posts had a sufficiently close/direct nexus to the claimant’s protected beliefs and then to carry out the required proportionality (articles 9 and 10) assessment. The matter was remitted to the ET for rehearing limited to the nexus and proportionality question, with the ET’s primary factual findings preserved.
- CSC Computer Science Limited v CL Hampson [2023] EAT 88 15 June 2023 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal made the necessary factual findings to decide a "like work" claim under s.65 Equality Act 2010. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the tribunal's written reasons mainly recited evidence without making the specific factual determinations required about the claimant's and comparators' actual duties, differences between them and the frequency/nature of those differences. The EAT allowed the appeal and remitted the case for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal.
- N Moustache v Chelsea and Westminster NHS Foundation Trust [2022] EAT 204 15 June 2023 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in failing to identify and determine a disability discrimination claim arising from the Claimant's dismissal and in failing to have adequate regard to her asserted mental‑health impairment when assessing fairness of dismissal. The EAT held the ET should have clarified and considered the Claimant’s assertion that her dismissal was connected to a mental‑health disability, allowed the appeal and remitted both the unfair dismissal and discrimination claims for reconsideration. The EAT invited submissions on whether remittal should be to a different Tribunal.
- General Medical Council v Karim [2023] EAT 87 12 June 2023 This EAT judgment allowed the GMC's appeal in part against an ET decision that had found direct race discrimination by the GMC in investigatory and fitness-to-practise processes concerning a Black African/European Muslim doctor, and remitted four specified race-discrimination complaints for rehearing by a differently constituted tribunal. The EAT held the tribunal’s reasons were Meek‑deficient, internally inconsistent, and failed to engage adequately with material parts of the GMC’s case and research relied on to rebut the statistical evidence. The remitted issues relate to (1) a second IOP referral (Feb 2015), (2) the failure to progress an allegation against Mr Laniado (circa 16 Jan 2014), (3) proceeding with an AR allegation despite finding Rao unreliable on Mr Laniado, and (4) delay in handling the claimant’s case.
- L Brown v General Vending Services Ltd [2023] EAT 98 9 June 2023 This is an EAT appeal in which Mrs Brown challenged an employment tribunal’s finding that she was not disabled at the time of her dismissal for a shoulder impairment. The EAT found the tribunal had given insufficient and unclear reasons for discounting a consultant’s July 2019 letter and had misapplied guidance on distinguishing coping strategies from avoidance and on identifying normal day-to-day activities (notably computer/mouse use). The EAT quashed the tribunal’s decision and remitted the case for rehearing by a different tribunal, refusing to substitute a finding of disability.
- Adam Greasley-Adams v Royal Mail Group Limited [2023] EAT 86 7 June 2023 This appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal challenged an Employment Tribunal's dismissal of claims under s47B ERA and ss26–27 EqA arising from workplace complaints and an internal bullying and harassment investigation. The EAT held the ET had not erred in law: s26(4) requires consideration of the claimant's perception (and that awareness is necessary for that limb), the ET's objective reasonableness assessment (including the investigatory context) was open to it, the time extension was properly addressed, and the perversity challenge failed. The appeal was dismissed.
- Daniel Tanase v Barchester Healthcare Limited [2023] EAT 84 1 June 2023 This EAT decision sets aside an Employment Tribunal’s 10 November 2022 dismissal of the claimant’s unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims for alleged non‑compliance with a 3 October 2022 order. The EAT held the 3 October order was a Rule 29 case management order (not a Rule 38 unless order) and that the Tribunal failed to afford the appellant the Rule 37(2) oral hearing he had requested before striking out, so the dismissal was procedurally incompetent. The matter was remitted to the Employment Tribunal and the 3 October order directed to be reconsidered because parts obliged the claimant to do things effectively for others to perform.
- F v J [2023] EAT 92 1 June 2023 The EAT allowed a claimant's appeal against an employment tribunal's refusal to grant an anonymity order, finding the tribunal wrongly assumed that lodging a claim placed its existence and contents into the public domain and failed to give the litigant in person a fair, proactive opportunity to adduce evidence about likely harm to future employability. The tribunal's decision was quashed and the anonymity application was remitted for fresh consideration by a different judge (not EJ Brewer).
- K Kohli v Department for International Trade [2023] EAT 82 1 June 2023 This appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal challenged an Employment Tribunal’s rejection of the claimant’s direct race discrimination complaints, including an argument that the ET failed to consider subconscious (unconscious) discrimination. The EAT found the ET had made clear factual findings explaining the non‑discriminatory reasons for the contested role decisions and appraisal, leaving no room for an inference of subconscious race discrimination, and dismissed the appeal.
- Lycatel Services Limited v Robin Schneider [2023] EAT 81 26 May 2023 This case concerned whether an Employment Tribunal should have stayed proceedings for an alleged unpaid bonus of £7,995,124.89 because the employer had concurrent High Court proceedings seeking negative declaratory relief denying entitlement. The EAT found the ET applied the wrong test and misunderstood the nature and complexity of the High Court claim, and on a de novo balancing exercise held the High Court was the more appropriate forum. The EAT allowed the employer's appeal and ordered the ET proceedings stayed pending determination of the High Court claim.
- Jagbir Sidhu v Our Place Schools Limited [2023] EAT 70 23 May 2023 This is an appeal from an Employment Tribunal’s rejection of two Equality Act 2010 harassment complaints by Mr Sidhu (allegations about a sawing/chopping gesture and use of the phrase “coloured people”). The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the tribunal did not err in law in applying the s.26 test (perception, circumstances, reasonableness) and accepted the tribunal’s credibility and contextual findings that the conduct lacked the requisite purpose or effect. The appeal was dismissed.
- Lovingangels Care Ltd v B Mhindurwa [2023] EAT 65 12 May 2023 This is an unfair dismissal appeal where a live-in carer was made redundant after her client went into hospital during early COVID-19; the tribunal found the dismissal unfair because the employer failed properly to consider furlough as an alternative and the internal appeal was a rubber-stamp. The EAT dismissed the employer’s appeal, holding no change to unfair dismissal law was required by the pandemic and upholding the tribunal’s findings that alternatives had not been properly considered and the appeal procedure was ineffective.
- Institute and Faculty of Actuaries v R Davda [2023] EAT 63 11 May 2023 The claimant, a UK student member of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries, alleged direct and indirect race discrimination arising from the number of exam opportunities available to him and from the Institute recognising exemptions from the Indian Actuarial Institute (IAI). The Employment Appeal Tribunal set aside the tribunal's finding of direct discrimination (no direct discrimination on number of opportunities) and remitted the s.112 Equality Act claim and related factual issues about any agreement with the IAI to a newly constituted tribunal for reconsideration. The cross-appeal on the Fellowship PCP was dismissed.
- S Sually v HMRC [2023] EAT 83 11 May 2023 This appeal concerned an Employment Judge's preliminary decision striking out parts of the claimant's discrimination, harassment and victimisation complaints and making a deposit order. The EAT held the tribunal erred in striking out certain post‑termination allegations because they formed part of a sequence requiring contextual assessment, and erred in making a deposit order without adequate reasoning and without properly assessing the claimant's means. The appeal upheld grounds 1, 2, 3 and 5 and remitted remaining case management to the regional judge.
- The Royal Parks Ltd v G Boohene & Ors [2023] EAT 69 5 May 2023 This appeal concerned outsourced toilet/cleaning workers who claimed indirect racial discrimination because the principal (The Royal Parks) applied a lower pay practice to contractor-employed workers than to its own staff. The EAT held that section 41 Equality Act 2010 can cover principals who in practice determine pay terms for contract workers, but it allowed the employer’s appeal because the Employment Tribunal had wrongly identified the PCP and so used an indefensible comparison pool; the ET’s decision was set aside and the indirect discrimination claims were dismissed.
- A Booth v Delstar International Ltd [2023] EAT 22 4 May 2023 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal correctly applied causation under s.15 Equality Act 2010 and assessed group disadvantage for an indirect discrimination claim arising from an employer's delay in applying for income protection and an attempted dismissal. The EAT held the ET had made legal errors: it misapplied the two-stage causation test (failing to analyse multiple causes and using inconsistent definitions of the "something arising") and erred in its PCP/comparator approach by comparing disabled v non‑disabled rather than persons who share the claimant's specific disability. The EAT allowed both the claimant's appeal and the employer's cross‑appeal on these points and remitted the issues to the ET for rehearing.
- Sinead Campbell v Tesco Personal Finance PLC [2023] EAT 68 2 May 2023 This appeal concerned whether a genuine redundancy arose when Tesco consolidated three risk teams into two and created a Centralised Controls Testing Team with a Lead Risk Manager and a Risk Manager. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Employment Tribunal erred by failing to apply the section 139 Employment Rights Act 1996 test—there was no factual finding that the employer’s requirement for risk-management employees had ceased or diminished. The EAT allowed the appeal, set aside the unfair dismissal decision and remitted the claim for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal.
- A McDermott v Sellafield Ltd & Ors. [2023] EAT 60 28 April 2023 This appeal arose from a whistleblowing/victimisation claim by an EDI consultant whose contract was terminated after she ran focus groups and produced a critical HR report following an anonymous Safecall allegation. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s overall dismissal of the substantive complaints, finding the report did not, on balance, disclose information tending to show wrongdoing and that termination was for perceived lack of balance, poor value and cost. The EAT did find limited legal errors (notably in treating one oral remark as mere opinion and failing to address whether it was a protected act) but held those did not undermine the tribunal’s core factual conclusions on causation. The EAT allowed the claimant’s costs appeal, quashed the prior costs awards and remitted costs for rehearing by a fresh panel.
- Darrell Miles v Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency [2023] EAT 62 28 April 2023 This appeal arose from a DVSA driving examiner who refused to return to work during the COVID-19 pandemic and brought ERA and EQA claims. The EAT upheld the tribunal's findings that (i) a recognised safety representative covering the place where he worked defeated the s.44(1)(c)/s.100(1)(c) claim and (ii) his belief in a serious and imminent danger was not objectively reasonable under s.44(1)(d)/(e), but it found an error in the tribunal's reasoning on disability causation and remitted disability and related constructive dismissal/detriment issues for rehearing.
- P Louis v Network Homes Limited [2023] EAT 76 25 April 2023 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Judge erred by effectively striking out a litigant in person’s pleaded indirect race discrimination claim at a preliminary hearing without reasonable notice or opportunity to be heard, and whether the pleaded facts could disclose a viable indirect race claim. The EAT held there was a procedural error in not giving reasonable notice or a chance to make representations, but on substantive analysis the pleaded PCPs could not, as a matter of law, establish indirect race discrimination (either because the PCP applied equally to all fixed‑term staff or because the claimant alleged loss of a positive advantage rather than a disadvantage). The appeal was therefore dismissed because the outcome would have been the same.
- Daniel Matovu v 2 Temple Gardens Chambers & Ors [2023] EAT 58 20 April 2023 This is an appeal by Mr Daniel Matovu against an Employment Tribunal’s dismissal of his claims of direct and indirect race discrimination, race‑related harassment and victimisation by 2 Temple Gardens Chambers and two individuals. The EAT rejected all four grounds of appeal, finding no unfair hearing or apparent bias and upholding the ET’s primary findings that the respondents’ actions (including the proposed speaker, the Azib investigation and interim clerking arrangements) were not race‑related detriments. The appeal was dismissed in full.
- Despina Charalambous v National Bank of Greece [2023] EAT 75 19 April 2023 This case concerned whether dismissal for gross misconduct was fair where the person who decided to dismiss had not personally conducted the disciplinary hearings. The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal's finding that dismissal was within the range of reasonable responses and that any procedural shortcomings were cured by a substantive internal appeal. The EAT rejected a rigid rule requiring the eventual decision‑maker to have personally heard the employee.
- Fire Brigades Union v P Embery [2023] EAT 51 14 April 2023 This is an EAT judgment allowing the FBU's appeal against an Employment Tribunal finding that Mr Embery, seconded from the London Fire Brigade, was employed by the union and had been unfairly dismissed. The EAT held the ET failed to give adequate reasons under rule 62(3) by not addressing the central submission that one person cannot generally have two employers for the same work, and on the facts found the relationship with the FBU was not one of employment because payments could be expense-related and there was insufficient evidence of control. The EAT substituted a decision dismissing the unfair dismissal claim.
- Aspect Windows (Western) Limited v Adam Retter [2023] EAT 95 13 April 2023 This EAT appeal challenged apparent bias after a lay tribunal member posted a Daily Mail link about the ET’s decision on her LinkedIn and engaged briefly with others. Applying the fair‑minded and informed observer test, the tribunal judge concluded the posts, read in context, did not give rise to a real possibility of bias. The EAT dismissed the appeal and the original ET award was left intact.
- Topps Tiles PLC v G Hardy [2023] EAT 56 13 April 2023 This EAT appeal arises from an ET finding that a long‑serving store manager with depression was unfairly dismissed and suffered discrimination arising from his disability; the EAT dismissed most grounds of appeal but remitted the question of contributory conduct under ERA ss 123(6) (and s122(2) if intended) because the ET applied the wrong legal test. The EAT upheld the ET's causation and proportionality findings under EqA s15, but directed the ET to reconsider whether the claimant's own blameworthy conduct caused or contributed to dismissal using the correct legal approach.
- Debra Lingard v Leading Learners Multi Academy Trust [2023] EAT 52 12 April 2023 This is an Employment Appeal Tribunal decision upholding an Employment Tribunal's findings in a claim by Ms Lingard for constructive dismissal (successful) and disability discrimination (unsuccessful). The EAT rejected appeals that the ET misapplied legal tests for actual or constructive knowledge of disability and that its factual findings were perverse, and it dismissed a cross-appeal about alleged forgery of appraisal signatures. The ET’s reliance on contemporaneous medical and occupational health evidence to find the employer lacked knowledge of a long-term disabling condition was held to be open on the evidence.
- Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council v K Bonsu [2023] EAT 74 11 April 2023 This appeal concerned whether the employment tribunal was entitled to find direct race discrimination in the way Stockport Council conducted an internal investigation into a support worker’s alleged misconduct, thereby shifting the burden of proof under s.136 Equality Act 2010. The EAT held that, although the tribunal majority could properly treat the overall factual matrix (failures to take witness statements, not checking CCTV, not following up a race complaint) as amounting to "something more", that part of the tribunal’s decision was inconsistent with its reasoning on dismissal and was not sufficiently Meek‑compliant. The EAT quashed the finding of direct race discrimination as to the conduct of the investigation and remitted that complaint for rehearing by a differently constituted panel; the tribunal’s unanimous factual findings and its other dismissed complaints remain intact.
- B.L.I.S.S Residential Care Ltd v Teresa Eileen Fellows [2023] EAT 59 5 April 2023 The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the employer's appeal and substituted a dismissal of the claimant's unfair dismissal claim as out of time, concluding it was not reasonably practicable to present within the primary time limit. The EAT held it had power to award costs for both the employment tribunal and EAT proceedings, found the claimant’s attempts to extend time and resist the appeal were misconceived, and ordered modest costs of £1,000 against the claimant after considering her means.
- Santosh Alexander Thukalil & Anor v Kamalammal Poonnamamnal Kattuvila Puthenveettil & Anor [2023] EAT 47 5 April 2023 This appeal concerned a live‑in domestic worker who successfully challenged regulation 2(2) of the National Minimum Wage Regulations 1999 as indirectly discriminatory and unjustified, and the Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the tribunal’s disapplication of that regulation and declaration that she was entitled to the national minimum wage for 2005–2013. The EAT held that article 157 TFEU applies to unjustified indirect pay discrimination, can be relied on directly in domestic courts under the former s.2(1) ECA 1972, and therefore required disapplication of the regulation; arguments that a male comparator or a single‑source employer was required were rejected. The appeal was dismissed.
- H Hassan v BBC [2023] EAT 48 4 April 2023 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal wrongly narrowed the claimant’s pleaded discrimination and victimisation claims by limiting the issues to the BBC’s 13 September 2019 instruction not to allow the claimant to move teams. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the tribunal was entitled to focus the case on that decision because the particulars of claim, read properly and in context, supported that narrower formulation and earlier events did not clearly "shout out" as pleaded claims. Allowing belated expansion to include 2017/2018 complaints would have been inconsistent with prior case management and unfair to the respondent.
- Alcedo Orange Limited v G Ferridge-Gunn [2023] EAT 78 30 March 2023 This appeal concerned a finding of pregnancy discrimination after the claimant was dismissed about one month into employment. The EAT held the tribunal's discrimination finding unsafe because it did not identify who actually made the dismissal decision and failed to apply the Reynolds "tainted information"/separate-acts analysis to determine whether that decision-maker was influenced by the claimant's pregnancy. The EAT remitted the equality claim to the same employment tribunal for re-determination.
- Ebury Partners UK Limited v M Acton Davis [2023] EAT 40 29 March 2023 This appeal concerned an employment tribunal judge’s rehearing of a claimant’s complaint after an earlier judgment on whether commissions payable during a one‑year secondment had expired and whether there was a breach of the implied term of trust and confidence. The EJ’s original judgment held any contractual commission entitlement ended after 12 months and there was no breach; on reconsideration the EJ upheld the 12‑month construction but then, on a new basis not argued at reconsideration, found a breach and unlawful dismissal. The EAT allowed the employer’s appeal, holding the EJ should not have conducted the broad reconsideration or decided the case on a new unpleaded basis, reinstating the original judgment and setting aside the reconsideration decision.
- Dr S Bi v E-ACT [2023] EAT 43 28 March 2023 This appeal concerned Employment Tribunal decisions refusing to set aside an unless order requiring the claimant's consent to full disclosure of medical records and refusing an out‑of‑time application to reconsider that refusal after the claimant obtained an autism diagnosis. The EAT held the ET did not err in deciding the rule 38(2) and rule 72(1) applications on the papers, found no requirement to hold oral hearings absent evidence of prejudice, and upheld the ET's substantive findings that full medical disclosure was necessary and that the respondent would be prejudiced, so the claimant's remedy hearing was not reinstated. The claimant's appeals and the respondent's cross‑appeal were dismissed.
- N Mendy v Motorola Solutions UK Limited & Ors [2023] EAT 71 28 March 2023 Mr Mendy appealed Employment Judge Grewal’s private case management decisions striking out certain breach of contract/unlawful deduction claims and refusing amendments to add indirect race discrimination and post‑termination victimisation. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal, setting aside the strike‑outs and the refusals, holding that the strike‑outs were unlawful at a private preliminary hearing, that indirect race discrimination had already been pleaded so did not require leave, and that permission to amend to include a mortgage‑insurance post‑termination victimisation allegation should be granted. Late attempts to add further grounds to the notice of appeal were refused.
- G Thom v Hobart Real Estate Partners Limited [2023] EAT 37 24 March 2023 The EAT upheld the employment judge's decision that the tribunal lacked jurisdiction to hear the claimant's unlawful deduction from wages claim arising from a discretionary "performance fee" clause. Clause 6.2 gave the employer a discretion to pay a minimum 10% of the Company's performance fee, but the parties never agreed the terms or a method to calculate any payable sum for the Worship Square transaction, so no identifiable or quantifiable sum was "properly payable." The claim and subsequent appeal were dismissed for want of jurisdiction; no substantive determination on entitlement was made.
- Moving Brands Limited & Ors v Matheus Heinl & Anor [2023] EAT 34 22 March 2023 The EAT allowed in part an appeal against an ET case management order for specific disclosure in proceedings by Moving Brands Ltd and others. The EAT rejected most respondent challenges but held the CMO must be amended to (a) except from disclosure documents that disclose the substance or nature of privileged legal communications and (b) permit claims of legal advice privilege (not only litigation privilege) for communications on or after 17 February 2021. The remainder of the ET order was upheld.
- J Edward v Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust [2023] EAT 33 17 March 2023 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal’s approach to mitigation of loss after the Claimant’s dismissal and related remedial calculations. The EAT held the tribunal erred by not directing itself on the correct legal test for mitigation and by applying a 50% blanket reduction to past loss instead of making balance‑of‑probabilities findings as to when and at what rate the Claimant would have obtained alternative employment; the mitigation issue was remitted for rehearing. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s future loss assessment, and by consent corrected awards for injury to feelings and pension/tax/interest calculations.
- S Khakimov v Nikko Asset Management Europe Limited [2023] EAT 38 16 March 2023 This appeal by Mr Khakimov challenged Employment Tribunal decisions on interim relief, costs, disclosure and the list of issues; the EAT dismissed all five grounds. The EAT held the tribunal was entitled to treat a 21 April 2021 witness statement (not a 23 March email) as the operative implicit amendment attempt and to refuse permission to add a s.103A claim, lawfully made a £7,500 costs order under rule 76 without cross‑examination, and acted within its case‑management discretion in refusing broad access to employer email/calendar and in finalising the list of issues.
- A Minnoch & Ors v InterserveFM Ltd & Ors [2023] EAT 35 15 March 2023 This appeal concerned whether an employment judge wrongly struck out 37 claimants’ claims for non‑compliance with an unless order without first assessing whether the claimants had materially complied. The EAT held the judge erred by applying a formalistic/punitive approach, failing to direct himself to the material‑compliance test and to resolve ambiguities in the order in the claimants’ favour. The strike‑outs were set aside and the case was remitted to a different employment judge to consider material compliance and any relief from sanction.
- HHJ Kalyany Kaul KC v Ministry of Justice & Ors. [2023] EAT 41 15 March 2023 The claimant, a Circuit Judge, appealed the Employment Judge's Rule 37(1)(a) strike-out of most discrimination-related claims about how two grievances were handled. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the Judge was entitled to strike out claims that had no reasonable prospect of success because they rested on undisputed, ordinary events and contained no plausible alternative facts or inferences; the only surviving claim related to the substantive non-determination of the staff grievance.
- Bibi Adilah Rojha v Zinc Media Group Plc [2023] EAT 39 14 March 2023 This case concerns appeals to the EAT against an Employment Tribunal's unless order (leading to automatic strike-out for non-compliance) and a deposit order relating to a sex/pregnancy/maternity discrimination complaint. The claimant failed to attend preliminary hearings and to provide further particulars or pay the deposit; the ET struck out the claim and ordered the deposit. The EAT dismissed both appeals, concluding the ET acted within its case-management discretion.
- Philip McQueen v General Optical Council [2023] EAT 36 10 March 2023 This is an appeal against an employment tribunal’s finding that the claimant’s confrontational conduct did not arise in consequence of his disabilities under s.15(1) Equality Act 2010. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, finding no error of law: the tribunal permissibly concluded the disabilities had limited effects and that the claimant’s "meltdowns" arose from temperament rather than those effects. The tribunal’s poor drafting did not make its decision unlawful and its factual findings were not perverse.
- A Achi v GMB & Anor [2023] EAT 29 9 March 2023 This case concerns a GMB union official who raised a grievance of bullying and race discrimination while off sick and later alleged victimisation and constructive dismissal after investigatory/disciplinary steps and an early termination of sick pay. The Employment Tribunal dismissed the discrimination, victimisation and constructive dismissal claims (but awarded unpaid sick pay for 1–13 March 2018). The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the tribunal’s factual findings and dismissed the appeal in full.
- Ministry of Justice & Anor v R Dodds & Ors [2023] EAT 31 7 March 2023 The EAT allowed the Ministry of Justice's appeal, holding that the Employment Tribunal erred in law by focusing narrowly on specific "part‑time" periods and by drawing a core/non‑core duties distinction when determining whether four judges were part‑time workers under the Part‑Time Workers Regulations (and relatedly under PTWD). The EAT found further legal errors in the ET's causation and justification reasoning, permitted claimants to amend to rely on PTWD points, and remitted the specified issues for fresh fact‑finding and re‑determination (before a differently constituted ET).
- S Palihakkara v The English Sport Council [2023] EAT 27 3 March 2023 This is an appeal against the Registrar’s refusal to extend time for an appeal filed 675 days late. The claimant relied on diagnosed depression and other personal difficulties to explain the delay, but the judge found those factors did not provide a good explanation given the claimant’s other timely litigation activity and engagement with proceedings. The application to extend time was refused and the appeal dismissed as unarguable and academic in light of subsequent merits proceedings.
- Dr Stephen John Watkins v British Medical Association [2023] EAT 23 2 March 2023 This appeal concerns Dr Watkins' challenges to the Certification Officer's handling of complaints arising from his August 2017 posts, including refusals to amend earlier, finally determined complaints, a second out-of-time appeal, and a remitted complaint under Principle 17. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeals, holding that res judicata and finality barred reopening complaints not remitted by the court, that the second appeal was out of time and abusive, and that the Certification Officer's factual findings on Principle 17 were open to her and not vitiated by error of law.
- A Mohammed v Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust [2023] EAT 16 24 February 2023 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal "unless" order requiring the claimant to provide further particulars of multiple discrimination claims, on pain of dismissal of her entire claim for non‑compliance. The EAT held the employment judge erred in law by failing to engage with Rule 38 and relevant authorities and by making an order that would automatically dismiss complaints that had not been the subject of any request. The appeal was allowed and the matter was remitted to the tribunal with directions to proceed more narrowly and to facilitate a preliminary hearing.
- James Thorp & Anor v Shuhdi Ali [2023] EAT 21 22 February 2023 This appeal concerned whether UK employment law applied to a claimant who worked for Qatari companies while based in the UK and whether an oral contract of employment had been formed. The EAT allowed the respondents' appeal on the territorial (sufficient connection) issue because the ET had not adequately explained or applied the required comparative test, and remitted that issue to the ET for rehearing. The EAT dismissed the appeal on contract formation, upholding the ET’s factual finding that an oral binding contract existed.
- G Meaker v Cyxtera Technology UK Limited [2023] EAT 17 21 February 2023 This appeal concerned whether a 5 February 2020 employer letter amounted to a dismissal and, if so, whether the effective date of termination (EDT) was 7 February 2020 for an unfair dismissal claim. The Employment Tribunal found the letter communicated a dismissal with EDT 7 February, making the unfair dismissal claim out of time; the EAT dismissed the claimant's appeal. The EAT held that, for statutory purposes, the EDT can be the date a dismissal is communicated even if the employer’s communication amounted to a repudiatory breach not accepted at common law. The EAT also upheld the ET’s refusal to extend time for the unfair dismissal claim.
- Daniel Johnston v Veritas Technologies (UK) Limited [2023] EAT 15 20 February 2023 This case concerns a dispute over commission under Johnston's FY20 compensation Plan where he claimed unpaid sums but was paid a lesser amount. The Employment Tribunal found an error in quota-setting but held the employer validly relied on Plan provisions (including an approval requirement for earnings above 250% of OTC) and that amounts above that threshold never became payable. The EAT refused the appeal and dismissed the cross-appeal, concluding no unlawful deduction occurred because the additional sums were not legally due.
- A v Choice Support (formerly MCCH Ltd) [2023] EAT 18 16 February 2023 This appeal considered whether a temporary Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) anonymity and restricted reporting order should be made permanent after an Employment Tribunal (ET) had found that sexual activity became non-consensual. The EAT admitted limited medical records from an intervenor (EA) but excluded a late witness statement that sought to collaterally challenge ET findings, refused the Claimant's adjournment, and upheld a lifetime anonymity order for the Claimant, EA and EA’s parents while narrowing the restricted reporting order to what was necessary to prevent identification. The judge emphasised the need to identify which statutory or rule power (ETA s.11, ET Rule 50 or EAT Rule 23) is being relied on and tailored reporting restrictions to avoid unnecessary breadth.
- K Cook v Gentoo Group Limited [2023] EAT 12 15 February 2023 Mr Cook challenged his dismissal by Gentoo Group as unfair and as direct age discrimination after the employer expedited redundancy to avoid an enhanced pension payment. The EAT held the tribunal had erred in its justification analysis for the direct age discrimination finding because it had not properly identified and explained the legitimate aim or applied the required proportionality analysis, and remitted that issue to a differently constituted tribunal; a previously imposed 15% compensation reduction was by consent revoked so the total reduction stands at 75%.
- A Alston & Ors v The Doctors Laboratory Limited & Ors [2023] EAT 13 13 February 2023 The EAT allowed part of an appeal in a group claim by couriers for unpaid annual leave, setting aside the Employment Tribunal’s finding that carried-over rights were subject to limitation when leave had been taken. The EAT declared that untaken paid annual leave (including leave taken without pay due to lack of facility) may be carried over until termination or until the employer provides a facility to take it, and remitted factual issues (worker status, continuity, periods of work) to the ET for directions.
- T Smith v Tesco Stores Limited [2023] EAT 11 10 February 2023 This appeal challenges an employment tribunal’s decision to strike out a litigant-in-person’s prolix and repeatedly amended claims against Tesco under Rule 37(1)(b) and (e). The tribunal concluded the claimant’s persistent refusal to engage with extensive case management made a fair hearing impossible and that striking out the entire claim was proportionate in the exceptional circumstances. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal and upheld the strike-out.
- Henna Jaleel v Southend University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2023] EAT 10 3 February 2023 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in law about the evidential burden under section 136 Equality Act 2010 in race discrimination and race-related harassment claims arising from a readvertisement of a DME post and conduct at the DME interview. The tribunal found constructive dismissal (unfair dismissal) but dismissed the Equality Act claims, concluding the claimant had not adduced the "something more" necessary to shift the burden to the respondent. The EAT held the tribunal had correctly applied the law, its fact-driven conclusions were not perverse, and dismissed the appeal.
- M Glover v Lacoste UK Ltd & Anor [2023] EAT 4 2 February 2023 This EAT judgment concerns an appeal against a tribunal's rejection of an indirect sex-discrimination claim arising from a rejected flexible‑working request. The EAT held the tribunal misapplied authority (Little) by treating a PCP as only applied when implemented, and remitted the case for redetermination on whether the employer's determination of the flexible‑working application amounted to the application of a PCP and whether the claimant suffered detriment or group disadvantage; it also found the tribunal's group‑disadvantage and injury‑to‑feelings findings unsafe and removed the second respondent.
- D v E [2023] EAT 66 1 February 2023 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's strike-out of an indirect sex discrimination claim after reformulating the PCP as suspension pending investigation with consideration of "further action." The EAT held the ET materially erred in concluding dismissal could not be the particular disadvantage arising from that PCP and allowed the appeal, setting aside the strike-out and remitting the claim for further case management (including consideration of a deposit order).
- O Rahman v Ford Retail Limited t/a Trustford [2023] EAT 55 1 February 2023 This case concerned whether a claimant's later "further information" to his ET1 had in substance pleaded protected acts for a victimisation complaint so that formal amendment of the claim form was unnecessary. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the ET1 alone did not plead protected acts and permission to amend was required in principle, but the tribunal below erred by failing to state whether paragraph 63 of the further information did, in substance, allege protected acts. The EAT found paragraph 63 (read with the ET1) did substantively allege that the claimant told HR and pursued a grievance/appeal about race discrimination, and remitted the amendment application for reconsideration on that basis.
- Alexander Hawkes v Oxford Economics Limited [2022] EAT 179 31 January 2023 This case concerned an application by Mr Hawkes to extend the time for appealing to the EAT after a crucial email sent on the deadline day failed to be received due to an apparent EE internet-provider fault. The EAT accepted the technical failure and Mr Hawkes's explanation as a "good excuse", rejected allegations of dishonesty and prejudice to the respondent, and granted an extension of time to 19 February 2021. The Registrar's prior refusal was overturned and the judge undertook to proceed to sift the appeal.
- Earl Shilton Town Council v K Miller [2023] EAT 5 31 January 2023 This was an employment appeal about whether a female office clerk was directly sex-discriminated against by inadequate toilet arrangements at premises shared with a playgroup. The tribunal found the women’s facilities (in the playgroup area, requiring staff to be summoned, lacking a sanitary bin and external lock) were less favourable than the men’s and that the disadvantage was inherently because of sex. The EAT dismissed the employer’s appeal, finding no error of law in those conclusions.
- D Gibbons v K Chinambu & Anor [2023] EAT 50 26 January 2023 This employment appeal concerned whether the tribunal wrongly applied a "principal reason" test to Equality Act claims after finding two reasons contributed to the claimant's dismissal (breakdown of workplace relationships and inability to work elsewhere because of ill‑health). The EAT held the tribunal erred in treating the principal‑reason approach as definitive for s.15 and substituted a finding that the dismissal was in part because of something arising in consequence of disability. The EAT remitted the questions of justification under s.15 and the s.26 harassment complaint for reconsideration by the (preferably same) tribunal.
- London United Busways Limited v Steven Harry [2023] EAT 67 25 January 2023 This appeal concerns an Employment Tribunal’s finding that the claimant was unfairly dismissed over his handling of a defective bus tyre. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the employer’s appeal because the Employment Judge relied on two matters—the asserted limited scope of the disciplinary charge and alleged inadequate training—that had not been put in evidence or argued, depriving the employer of an opportunity to respond. The Tribunal’s judgment was set aside and the unfair dismissal claim remitted for rehearing before a different judge; earlier findings on Polkey, contributory fault and remedy were removed.
- Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust & Anor v N Matar [2023] EAT 1 24 January 2023 This appeal concerned a late‑50s locum consultant who was treated less favourably than a younger comparator after a regulatory issue about lack of specialist registration arose alongside a clinical investigation. The Employment Tribunal found direct age discrimination and constructive dismissal and awarded past pecuniary losses on the basis that, but for the discrimination, the claimant would have continued on an extended locum arrangement until his planned retirement; the EAT dismissed both respondents’ appeals, upholding the liability findings (save for a limited error pre‑December 2017) and the remedy award. The EAT held respondents had not discharged the burden of proof and that the counterfactual award did not offend public policy despite the technically ultra vires nature of the locum arrangement.
- L Lloyd v Elmhurst School Limited [2022] EAT 169 24 January 2023 This EAT judgment concerned whether a part-time teaching assistant's "basic hours" for national minimum wage purposes are determined by hours actually worked or by the hours to which she was contractually entitled (including paid school holidays). The EAT held the tribunal erred by focusing on hours actually worked and by excluding contractual paid holidays; it allowed the appeal on those grounds and remitted the case to a different employment tribunal to determine basic hours and related factual matters. One ground about misstating statutory holiday entitlement was dismissed as immaterial.
- Denise Ondowa Boesi v Asda Stores Limited [2023] EAT 49 20 January 2023 This appeal concerned a claim of direct disability discrimination under the Equality Act 2010 by a warehouse operative dismissed for incapability after long-term absence due to degenerative disc disease. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the employment tribunal had correctly constructed a hypothetical non-disabled comparator by imputing the claimant's relevant circumstances (long-term absence and incapacity) and properly found the employer's reason for dismissal was incapability (a consequence of the disability) rather than treatment "because of" the disability. The ET's finding that the claimant would have been treated the same if non-disabled was upheld.
- Kite et al v Madeline Clark [2022] EAT 194 19 January 2023 The EAT dismissed the respondents' appeal against Employment Judge Norris's refusal to grant costs without a hearing, holding the tribunal did not err in law in dismissing a succinct costs application that failed to plead specific grounds. The court accepted the judge was entitled to take the application at face value, determine the matter on paper and refuse costs where the applicant had not shown what additional material would be advanced at a hearing. Amendments to party names were permissible and no rehearing was ordered.
- Lydia Edwards v Pick Everard [2023] EAT 61 18 January 2023 This case concerns a former senior health and safety consultant with dyslexia who challenged her employer's criticisms about filing practices, mobile phone use and circulating NHS dyslexia material for her children, alleging disability discrimination and failure to make reasonable adjustments. The Employment Tribunal found the claimant unreliable in parts, that the contested conduct did not arise in consequence of her disability, and that she was not placed at a substantial disadvantage by the employer's document-upload requirement. The EAT dismissed the appeal, concluding the tribunal did not err in law on the limited grounds advanced.
- B.L.I.S.S Residential Care Ltd v Teresa Eileen Fellows [2023] EAT 8 12 January 2023 This is an EAT judgment allowing an employer’s appeal against an Employment Tribunal’s decision to extend time for an unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal had found it was not reasonably practicable to present the claim within the three‑month primary limit because the claimant’s solicitor miscalculated the deadline and mailed the claim to the wrong address; the EAT held those errors were unreasonable and attributable to the claimant and that it was reasonably practicable to have presented the claim in time (including by electronic filing). The ET’s extension was set aside and the claim was dismissed as out of time.
- K Preston v E.ON Energy Solutions Limited [2022] EAT 192 6 January 2023 This appeal concerned whether the employer knew (or ought to have known) of the claimant’s disability and the likely substantial disadvantage from it, when the employer’s duty to make reasonable adjustments arose, and whether dismissal was a proportionate response. The EAT dismissed the claimant’s appeal, upholding the ET’s findings that the employer had sufficient awareness of the impairment but only became aware of the relevant substantial disadvantage on 18 October 2017, that reasonable adjustments had been arranged before any return date, and that dismissal for continued unauthorised absence was a proportionate means of pursuing a legitimate aim. No breach of ss.20/21 EqA or s.15 discrimination in dismissal was found.
- Dr Vivienne Lyfar-Cissé v Western Sussex University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust & Ors. [2022] EAT 193 30 December 2022 This appeal concerns Dr Lyfar‑Cissé’s challenge to an Employment Tribunal’s dismissal of her claims that re‑opening a prior disciplinary process and dismissing her was unfair and amounted to victimisation for protected disclosures. The EAT upheld the ET, finding the dismissal could be characterised as conduct or SOSR but was fair within the band of reasonable responses, protected acts/disclosures were not shown to have motivated the dismissal, and a late HSJ newspaper article did not justify reconsideration. Both the principal appeal and the appeal against refusal to reopen were dismissed.
- J Davies v EE Limited [2022] EAT 191 23 December 2022 This appeal concerned whether the employer applied a provision, criterion or practice (PCP) — namely the claimant’s contractual 40‑hour per week requirement — to a disabled employee and whether the tribunal erred in concluding no PCP was applied. The EAT held the tribunal was wrong to treat the PCP as not applied: the contractual 40‑hour week was a PCP applied to the claimant from 24 September 2019 to 27 February 2020, and remitted the reasonable adjustments and related constructive dismissal issues to a newly constituted tribunal. The EAT also indicated that the existence of part‑time roles or a temporary phased return did not negate that underlying PCP.
- H Elhalabi v Avis Budget UK Limited [2022] EAT 185 19 December 2022 This Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment addressed timeliness and extensions for a claimant’s substantive appeal and two Registrar orders after the claimant filed an appeal before receiving written reasons but had timely requested them. The EAT held that the Abdelghafar approach to extending time applies to appeals from Registrar interim orders about institution, treated the substantive appeal as properly instituted (or alternatively extended time), and allowed both appeals against the Registrar’s orders so the substantive appeal may proceed.
- Olsten (UK) Holdings Limited v Adecco Group European Works Council [2022] EAT 183 13 December 2022 This appeal concerned whether Adecco breached its EWC agreement by failing to convene an Extraordinary Meeting about collective redundancies affecting multiple EEA countries and by refusing to supply country‑by‑country sales data. The EAT upheld the CAC’s findings that the matters were "transnational" because the redundancies significantly affected employees in at least two EEA countries, dismissed Olsten’s appeal and the EWC’s cross‑appeal on time limits, and confirmed penalties totalling £25,000.
- A Chaudhry v Cerberus Security and Monitoring Services Limited [2022] EAT 172 9 December 2022 The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed an employee's appeal against a judge's refusal to permit amendments to his ET1, finding legal errors in the judge's approach. The EAT held the judge should have required the proposed amendments in writing and expressly balanced the injustice or hardship to both parties, and it remitted the amendment application for rehearing by a different judge.
- Leicester City Council v A Chapman [2022] EAT 178 9 December 2022 Leicester City Council appealed an employment tribunal's findings that a claimant's dismissal was unfair and that wrongful dismissal was not proved. The EAT allowed the appeal, finding the ET had impermissibly substituted its own view for the employer’s reasoning about a pivotal remark and had wrongly treated the employer as having called no relevant evidence for the wrongful dismissal claim. The EAT set aside the ET's determinations and remitted the matter for further proceedings.
- S Garrod v Riverstone Management Limited [2022] EAT 177 9 December 2022 This case concerns appeals by Mrs Garrod against Employment Tribunal decisions that (1) removed "without prejudice" protections from parts of a pre-claim grievance meeting record and (2) ordered her to pay costs. The EAT upheld the ET's findings that a dispute existed when the meeting occurred, that the meeting was a genuine attempt to settle so without‑prejudice privilege applied, that the "unambiguous impropriety" exception did not apply to a consensual termination proposal, and that a costs award of £3,400 was justified because of materially untruthful evidence. Both appeals were dismissed.
- Lucy Griffiths v Gloucestershire County Council [2022] EAT 195 8 December 2022 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Judge gave adequate reasons when dismissing a constructive unfair dismissal claim by Ms Griffiths, a social worker and manager who resigned alleging breaches of the implied term of mutual trust and confidence. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Judge's reasons were deficient: he failed to make necessary factual findings or explain how disputed facts led to his conclusion, relied on an unargued inference about the timing of the grievance, and did not analyse material post‑resignation evidence; the appeal was allowed and the case remitted for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal.
- R Thorpe v Sainsbury's Supermarket Limited [2023] EAT 20 6 December 2022 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal should have extended time for Ms Thorpe to bring unfair dismissal, wages and discrimination claims after her dismissal on 7 June 2019, given her ET1 dated 20 August 2019 lacked an ACAS certificate until 11 November 2019. The Employment Judge refused to extend time, finding Ms Thorpe had engaged with her employer, could have completed the ET1 in time and had assistance, and therefore it was not just and equitable to extend time; the EAT dismissed the appeal. A factual error about a hospitalization date was held immaterial and did not make the decision perverse.
- Stephanie Morris v Lauren Richards Ltd [2023] EAT 19 6 December 2022 The claimant appealed an Employment Tribunal (ET) finding that her anxiety, though substantial, was not a disability because it was not likely to last 12 months. The EAT held the ET erred in law by treating post‑dismissal events (and the likely effect of leaving the workplace) as showing the condition would not persist, and remitted the limited issue of duration/likelihood for rehearing. The ET's finding that the impairment had not already lasted 12 months at dismissal was left undisturbed.
- A Anghel v Middlesex University [2022] EAT 176 5 December 2022 This case concerns a litigant in person who sought an extension of time to institute an appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal after failing to attach the required grounds of claim; the grounds document was provided one day late. The Registrar refused to extend time and Judge Auerbach dismissed the claimant’s appeal, holding the appeal was not properly instituted until the grounds were filed and that the claimant’s explanations (mistake, distress, alleged misleading correspondence) did not amount to a good reason or exceptional circumstances to justify an extension.
- Archie Teixeira v Zaika Restaurant Limited & Anor [2022] EAT 171 2 December 2022 This is an appeal against a tribunal’s finding in an unfair dismissal case where the claimant, a tandoor chef, was dismissed without any procedure during the COVID-19 downturn. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held that the tribunal erred in law by concluding there was a 100% chance the claimant would nevertheless have been fairly dismissed at the same time without adequately considering warning or consultation. The EAT allowed the employer’s appeal on those Polkey-related grounds and remitted the matter to the original tribunal to reconsider whether and to what extent a fair process would have affected timing, pool or outcome.
- R Richardson v Extreme Roofing Limited [2022] EAT 173 1 December 2022 This case concerns two appeals to the EAT that were not properly instituted because required documents (a signed ET judgment and ET3) were missing; the appellant later supplied those documents out of time. The Employment Appeal Tribunal refused extensions of time because the appellant gave an inadequate explanation for the delay and had failed to comply with the Practice Direction; the appeals were dismissed. The judge declined to strike out for lack of bundle/skeleton as disproportionate and found no binding agreement to withdraw the appeal.
- Unilever De Centroamerica SA de CV v A Pirie [2022] EAT 170 1 December 2022 This appeal concerned an unfair dismissal finding where the tribunal held the employer acted unreasonably by not discussing UK "BFS" role options and visa issues with an employee at the end of an international fixed-term assignment. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the employer to contest at remedy whether a UK BFS post in fact would have been available and remitted the case for the tribunal to make fresh findings on whether the claimant would, if she had sought a UK post and obtained a visa, have been placed into such a post and to reassess compensation accordingly.
- Anjum Sarah v Aetos Capital Group (UK) Ltd [2022] EAT 187 24 November 2022 This appeal addressed an Employment Tribunal's reduction of unfair dismissal compensation by exactly 50% after finding the claimant had "at least a 50% chance" of obtaining a single post created by a sham redundancy exercise. The EAT held the tribunal erred in law by adopting the 50% reduction without explaining why it did not adopt a higher probability and remitted the case for reassessment of the appropriate percentage reduction under Polkey principles.
- G Kalu & Anor v University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust (formerly Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust) [2022] EAT 168 24 November 2022 This case concerned two consultant claimants who signed a collective grievance and were later disciplined and dismissed after refusing to cooperate with an external investigation; the ET rejected most discrimination and victimisation claims but found the collective grievance was false and made in bad faith, and found a procedural failing in the dismissal. On appeal the EAT held the respondent had put bad faith sufficiently on notice but ruled it was unfair for the ET to make a bad‑faith (dishonesty) finding about the January 2015 grievance without allowing specific cross‑examination on dishonesty, so that part of the ET’s decision cannot stand; the EAT otherwise upheld the ET’s dismissal of victimisation complaints linked to the external investigator’s report and left the remainder of the ET’s decision intact.
- J Hilaire v Luton Borough Council [2022] EAT 166 23 November 2022 This appeal concerned whether Luton Borough Council failed to make reasonable adjustments under s.20 of the Equality Act 2010 by requiring a disabled employee (depression and arthritis) to attend and participate in a ring‑fenced redundancy interview (a PCP). The Employment Judge found the claimant would not have attended regardless of his disabilities, that only a short delay was offered and that more intrusive adjustments (e.g. "slotting") were not reasonable in the collective redundancy process. The EAT dismissed the appeal, upholding the ET’s factual findings and conclusions that no breach of the duty to make reasonable adjustments had been shown.
- D McGonagle v Jaguar Land Rover Limited [2023] EAT 24 22 November 2022 This appeal concerned the Employment Judge's refusal to reconsider an ET's decision that an age-based 55‑year criterion for access to a Retired Managers Loan Agreement Plan was directly discriminatory but justified. The EAT held the Judge erred in treating the claimant's reconsideration request as merely re‑arguing when the ET's justification rested on a legitimate‑aim (intergenerational fairness / parity between legacy DB and newer DC pension members) that was not plainly pleaded or supported by evidence. The EAT allowed the appeal and directed reconsideration under rule 72(2), with an opportunity for the parties to address the point (by hearing or representations).
- Graham Ellis v K Bacon & Anor [2022] EAT 188 22 November 2022 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal erred in law by finding direct discrimination because the claimant was married. The EAT allowed the appeal, concluding the ET had applied the wrong legal test and failed to construct the correct comparator, even though the ET’s factual findings of mistreatment by the employer stood. The case was remitted because the ET’s reasoning conflated acting on a spouse’s instructions or the spouse’s identity with discrimination "because of" being married.
- Melissa Mones v Lisa Franklin Limited [2022] EAT 199 18 November 2022 This appeal concerned whether the CJRS Treasury Directions gave employees a right to require employers to calculate furlough pay by the CJRS formula and whether an implied contractual term could do so. The EAT dismissed the claimant's appeal, holding the Directions created obligations between HMRC and employers, not enforceable rights for employees, and that the claimant had accepted an express contractual variation (the 30 March 2020 Furlough Letter) which governed her furlough pay. No unauthorised deduction under s.13 ERA was found.
- Jennifer Benjamin v The Markfield Project [2022] EAT 167 17 November 2022 This appeal concerned the claimant's challenge to an Employment Tribunal's refusal to reconsider its remedy decision after she relied on further mitigation documents and argued her disability affected her evidence on injury to feelings. The EAT dismissed the claimant's complaint insofar as it was in substance an attack on the original remedy decision but allowed and remitted the matter for reconsideration to the ET only on the point that the ET had failed to address the claimant's contention that her disability affected her ability to give evidence on injury to feelings. The respondent's cross-appeal was dismissed.
- M Humed v Sight and Sound Security [2023] EAT 53 16 November 2022 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Judge wrongly struck out all of Mr Humed's claims as out of time, particularly an Equality Act victimisation claim. The EAT found the judge had misconstrued the victimisation pleading and erred in striking it out; that claim was in time and reinstated for further case management and hearing. All other heads of claim were properly struck out.
- Sokratis Lasdas v Vanquis Bank PLC & Anor. [2022] EAT 198 15 November 2022 This appeal concerned whether the claimant's pleaded discrimination claim was direct or indirect race discrimination after an employment tribunal treated it as direct and made deposit orders, which led to strike-out for non-payment. The EAT held the claimant's pleading, fairly read, alleged indirect race discrimination via a provision, criterion or practice (PCP) requiring Experian checks; the tribunal erred in law by characterising it as direct discrimination and by ordering deposits on that basis. The deposit orders (aggregate £500) were quashed, the claims were reinstated and the matter remitted for a closed preliminary hearing and listing for a final hearing.
- JT Edwards Ltd v Isaac Seopane [2023] EAT 54 9 November 2022 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal’s finding that the claimant, dismissed after requesting furlough in May 2020, had been unfairly dismissed and suffered unlawful deductions from wages. The EAT upheld the Tribunal’s liability findings and its entitlement to apply the maximum 25% ACAS uplift where no procedure was followed, but found the Tribunal’s reasoning on several remedial issues (the pay rate to be used for compensation, the timing/effect of the claimant’s eczema, and a late award for loss of a company car) inadequate and remitted those remedy issues to a freshly constituted Tribunal. The unlawful‑deduction figures were agreed to be gross and not to be grossed‑up; further evidence or submissions may be required on eczema and car loss.
- easyJet PLC v easyJet European Works Council [2022] EAT 162 4 November 2022 This appeal concerned whether amended TICER Regulation 4(1) applies only where central management is treated as situated in the UK by Regulation 5, or also where central management is actually situated in the UK. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held that the ordinary meaning of Regulation 4(1) covers both actual UK central management and situations where central management is deemed to be in the UK by Regulation 5, so the CAC had jurisdiction. The appellant's restrictive construction was rejected and the appeal was dismissed.
- K Marangakis v Iceland Foods Limited [2022] EAT 161 2 November 2022 This appeal concerned whether a claimant had withdrawn an internal disciplinary appeal and whether a successful appeal restores employment so the original dismissal "vanishes." The EAT upheld the tribunal's finding that the claimant had not objectively withdrawn the appeal and that allowing the appeal legally reinstated her (so the prior dismissal had no effect), despite her subjective unwillingness to return. The claimant's subsequent dismissal for non-attendance did not revive the original dismissal, and the EAT dismissed her appeal.
- W Balcerzak v George Birchall Service Limited & Anor [2022] EAT 202 2 November 2022 The appellant claimants appealed the Employment Tribunal's rejection of their protective award claims on the ground of an alleged discrepancy between the respondent name on the ACAS Early Conciliation (EC) certificate and the ET1. HHJ Tucker held the names were the same (George Birchall Service Limited) and allowed the appeal, concluding the Tribunal was wrong to reject the claims on that basis and that Tribunals must consider Rule 12(2A) before rejecting for minor name/address errors.
- K Element & Ors. v Tesco Stores Limited [2022] EAT 165 31 October 2022 The EAT considered whether Tesco's 2014 "Exercise" amounted to a statutory "job evaluation study" (JES) for equal pay purposes and when the s.136 Equality Act 2010 burden of proof shifts at a preliminary hearing. The tribunal's finding that the 2014 Exercise was exploratory, omitted material job demands and lacked quality‑assurance was upheld, and the appeal was dismissed. The EAT also held that the burden under s.136 shifts only once a claimant has made a prima facie case on all elements of the claim. The claimants' substantive equal value claims were not resolved here and proceed.
- M Morgan v Buckinghamshire Council [2022] EAT 160 28 October 2022 The EAT dismissed the claimant's appeal and the respondent's cross‑appeal concerning the dismissal of a supervising social worker for unauthorised gift‑giving to a child and an inappropriate case note, holding the tribunal's findings on conduct and the range of reasonable responses were open to it. The tribunal also upheld the respondent's reliance on section 15(1)(b) Equality Act 2010, finding dismissal a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. One harassment‑by‑effect complaint succeeded in relation to the appeal officer's remark that the claimant had "chosen" to mask her autism; the cross‑appeal against that finding failed.
- The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v D Beattie & Ors [2022] EAT 163 27 October 2022 The case concerned whether an Employment Tribunal correctly disapplied article 3(b) of the Equality Act (Age Exceptions for Pension Schemes) Order 2010 to remedy age discrimination in PPF-assessed pension payments, and whether that remedy rested on direct effect of the Framework Directive or on general EU law principles and was affected by the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. The EAT held the ET had based its decision on general EU principles of equal treatment (not on horizontal direct effect of the Directive), that the trustee was not an emanation of the state on these facts, that the “future effects” principle could apply, but that the Withdrawal Act prevents claimants who started proceedings after IP completion day relying on disapplication via those general EU principles. Two claimants who commenced before IP completion day may proceed; the rest are dismissed insofar as dependent on disapplication through retained EU principles.
- Tom Simpson v Unite the Union [2022] EAT 154 12 October 2022 This case concerns Mr Simpson's challenge to Unite the Union's handling of complaints and disciplinary proceedings that led to his expulsion, alleging breach of natural justice because John Gillespie repeatedly participated in investigatory and decision‑making stages and then chaired the disciplinary panel without disclosing Simpson's request for recusal. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Certification Officer erred in law by failing to apply the correct test for apparent predetermination — whether a fair‑minded and informed observer would conclude there was a real possibility of predetermination — and invited submissions on disposal.
- Charles Melvin Bathgate v Technip UK Limited & Ors [2022] EAT 155 7 October 2022 This appeal concerned whether a redundancy settlement validly waived an age‑discrimination claim that had not yet arisen and whether the Employment Tribunal (ET) had jurisdiction given seafarer/territorial exclusions. The EAT held the settlement failed s.147 Equality Act 2010 because it attempted to extinguish a claim that had not crystallised or been identifiable at the time. The EAT also held the claimant remained a "seafarer" for s.81 purposes (despite recent periods ashore) and that s.108 could not confer broader post‑employment discrimination rights than existed during employment, so the ET lacked jurisdiction; the claimant’s appeal succeeded on the settlement point but the respondent’s cross‑appeal on jurisdiction succeeded.
- T Penicela v Sanctuary Care Ltd [2022] EAT 181 6 October 2022 This is an EAT decision allowing in part an appeal from a tribunal's unfair dismissal finding by a regional manager dismissed after a probation review. The tribunal found one protected disclosure (13 Sept 2017) and that the dismissing officer genuinely believed the dismissal was for lack of capability, but failed to address the claimant's central case that an earlier manager's report (Cranfield's) was tainted by motive arising from her disclosures. The EAT remitted the case for limited further consideration on whether Cranfield was influenced by protected disclosures and, if so, the effect on the later decision-maker; the challenge on multiple other disclosures was dismissed.
- Dr Mark Ter-Berg v Simply Smile Manor House Ltd & Ors [2023] EAT 2 4 October 2022 This appeal concerned whether a dentist who sold his practices and signed an Associate Agreement was an employee. The EAT held the Autoclenz/Uber purposive approach to written terms applies but upheld the tribunal's overall reliance on the written agreement except that the ET misinterpreted clause 36's "other cause" (substitution) so as to treat substitution as unfettered. The ET's finding of no employment was quashed and the matter was remitted for rehearing limited to construction of clause 36 and the question of personal service.
- LQP v City of York Council & Anor [2022] EAT 196 28 September 2022 This appeal concerns an employment tribunal’s refusal to permit the claimant to amend her claim to plead direct discrimination by perceived disability and its refusal to grant anonymisation. The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal on the amendment point, finding the Employment Judge failed to perform the required balancing exercise and mischaracterised the application, and directed that the amendment should be permitted. On anonymisation, the EAT found the Judge had failed to give proper weight to new medical evidence potentially engaging Article 2, remitted the issue for reconsideration, and made an indefinite anonymity order for the EAT proceedings.
- University of Dundee v Prasun Chakraborty [2022] EAT 150 23 September 2022 The University of Dundee appealed an Employment Judge's Rule 31 order requiring production of an original un-amended investigation report, arguing the original had become privileged after solicitors advised and a privileged amended version was created. The Employment Appeal Tribunal refused the appeal, holding the original un‑amended report was not privileged at creation and did not acquire legal advice or litigation privilege retrospectively merely because a later privileged amended version existed. The order for production therefore stands.
- M Clark & Ors v Sainsburys Supermarkets Ltd & Anor [2022] EAT 143 21 September 2022 This Employment Appeal Tribunal decision considered whether, on a multiple-claim form, Rule 10(1)(c) (and Rule 12) required each claimant to show their own ACAS Early Conciliation (EC) number, and whether a respondent could cross-appeal against another respondent who had not appealed. The EAT held that the rules do not mandate a separate EC number for each claimant where the form contains an EC number that appears on an EC certificate naming the claimant, and it allowed the appeal reinstating previously rejected claims. The purported cross-appeal by a respondent against another respondent who did not appeal was not a valid cross-appeal and was dismissed.
- Oxford University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust v I Khan & Anor [2022] EAT 144 21 September 2022 This case concerns appeals against an employment tribunal finding that Mr Khan assaulted a colleague and that Mr Ali was present but did not actively participate; both men were dismissed by Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. The EAT dismissed both the appeal and cross‑appeal, holding the tribunal's factual findings were open on the evidence but that both dismissals were procedurally unfair because decision‑makers dismissed the employees before key investigatory evidence (finalised notes from investigator Mr Singh) had been finalised and considered. Remedy issues were remitted for further hearing.
- Ponticelli UK Limited v A Gallagher [2022] EAT 140 12 September 2022 This case concerned whether rights under a Partnership Share Agreement (a collateral agreement granting SIP membership) transferred to Ponticelli on a business transfer under regulation 4(2)(a) TUPE. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held those obligations did not arise "under" the contract of employment but did arise "in connection with" it and therefore transferred; the EAT upheld the Tribunal's finding but amended the remedy to require the transferee's written statement of particulars to record the obligation to provide a substantively equivalent SIP.
- Zoe Lucas v Cosmeceuticals Ltd [2022] EAT 141 12 September 2022 This appeal concerned an employee with multiple sclerosis who was dismissed after about five months and alleged disability discrimination under ss.15 and 21 Equality Act 2010. The Employment Tribunal found dismissal for poor sales performance and no evidential link between the disability and the unfavourable treatment; the EAT dismissed the appeal. The EAT held that where there is no evidence on a material issue (including causation), section 136 EA need not be applied, and upheld the Tribunal's findings on the pleaded PCPs, disadvantages and adjustments.
- A Shankar v Genpact (UK) Limited & Ors [2022] EAT 184 6 September 2022 This appeal concerned the Employment Judge’s refusal to allow the claimant to amend his ET claim to add a complaint of indirect disability discrimination. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, holding there was no error of law or perversity in the EJ’s exercise of discretion given the late timing of the proposed amendment, the claimant’s period of legal representation, and the prejudice the amendment would cause the respondents. The refusal therefore stands and the additional claim was not permitted.
- Hilco Capital Limited v Denise Harrington [2022] EAT 156 1 September 2022 This appeal concerned the remedy for unfair dismissal where the claimant made no job applications after dismissal, attributing that to fear of stigma as a whistle‑blower and plans to join a start‑up. The Employment Tribunal accepted the stigma explanation up to the liability decision and awarded 85 weeks' loss. The EAT held the tribunal erred in accepting the stigma reason without evidential support and quashed that finding, remitting mitigation and compensation for rehearing. Other grounds were disposed of by consent.
- Layla Dean-Verity (formerly Anjum Tahirkhell) v Khan Solicitors Limited [2022] EAT 128 31 August 2022 This appeal concerned an Employment Judge's refusal to extend the 14-day time limit for a reconsideration application made nearly six years after a 2014 ET judgment that found serious financial impropriety. The EAT held the EJ made a material error of law by misapprehending or overlooking relevant facts when assessing prejudice to the claimant, allowed the appeal, set aside the ET decisions and remitted the matter for reconsideration of extension of time (and, if extended, reconsideration of the 2014 judgment).
- Anthony Catt v English Table Tennis Association Limited & Ors [2022] EAT 125 26 August 2022 This appeal concerned whether an elected non‑executive director of Table Tennis England was a "limb (b)" worker under s.230(3)(b) ERA. The EAT found the Employment Tribunal had focused improperly on vulnerability/subordination and failed to make a clear, determinative finding on whether the parties intended a contract for the claimant to perform work or services. The ET's decision that the claimant was not a limb (b) worker was set aside and the matter was remitted for rehearing before a different Tribunal.
- Shuhrat Rajabov v Foreign and Commonwealth Office [2022] EAT 112 19 August 2022 This appeal concerned a locally recruited employee at the British Embassy in Dushanbe who claimed unfair dismissal; the Employment Tribunal found it lacked territorial jurisdiction because the employment had a closer connection with Tajikistan and also held the claim was time-barred. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, upholding the tribunal's evaluative judgment on territorial connection and its conclusion that the claim was not presented within time or within a reasonable further period. The EAT held diplomatic or state immunity is a relevant but not determinative factor and that the tribunal was entitled to give little weight to the claimant's asserted assurance of UK-law protection.
- Elly Zhang v Heliocor Ltd & Anor [2022] EAT 152 16 August 2022 This appeal concerned two employment tribunal case-management decisions refusing the claimant's applications to add an individual, Mr Tripathi, as a respondent. The EAT held the tribunal erred by treating the claimant’s later narrative wholly as new material instead of first identifying which parts were voluntary particulars of the original race complaints and which were new allegations, and remitted the matter for fresh consideration of joinder limited to the original ET1 complaints (with any necessary particularisation). The second tribunal decision did not cure that error because it did not properly treat the fresh application as confined to adding Tripathi to the original pleaded complaints.
- Dr TF Piepenbrock v London School of Economics & Political Science [2022] EAT 119 12 August 2022 This appeal concerned the EAT's grant of protective orders for a non‑party, "Ms D", after finding Dr Piepenbrock had made malicious, untrue allegations and was likely to use court materials and publicity to harass and identify her. The tribunal held Ms D's Article 8 rights outweighed open justice and competing Article 6/10 interests, concluding anonymisation alone was insufficient and imposing restricted access to EAT documents and an indefinite non‑disclosure order subject to review.
- MTN-1 Limited v David Ross O’Daly [2022] EAT 130 12 August 2022 This case concerned whether an appellant’s 8 June 2020 email properly instituted an appeal to the EAT, whether the employment tribunal’s 27 April 2020 document headed “Judgment” contained reasons, and whether one day’s late filing should be excused. The EAT held the April “Judgment” did supply the tribunal’s reasons, the 8 June email instituted the appeal but was received one day late, and the CEO’s ADHD and depression, supported by medical and contemporaneous evidence, materially and substantially explained the delay so that time was extended and the appeal permitted to proceed.
- Michael Cowie & Ors v Scottish Fire and Rescue Service [2022] EAT 121 11 August 2022 This appeal concerned whether a fire service’s paid special leave, subject to preconditions requiring exhaustion of accrued TOIL and annual leave, amounted to “unfavourable treatment” under s.15 Equality Act 2010 and whether that precondition caused indirect sex discrimination. The EAT held the tribunal erred by treating the preconditions as separate unfavourable treatment rather than part of the favourable benefit of paid special leave, allowed the employer’s appeal and dismissed the s.15 claims. The tribunal’s rejection of indirect sex discrimination for lack of established particular disadvantage and its decision to award no injury to feelings were upheld.
- Lee Richards v Waterfield Homes Limited & Anor [2022] EAT 148 9 August 2022 This appeal concerned whether a claimant paid through the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) was an employee or self‑employed. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Employment Tribunal erred in treating the parties’ choice to use CIS as determinative of self‑employment and, on the tribunal’s factual findings, substituted a finding that the claimant was an employee throughout the period and remitted the case for a remedy hearing. Directions were given to circulate the transcript.
- Z Sokolik v Kobre & Kim (UK) LLP [2022] EAT 111 2 August 2022 This appeal concerned a litigant in person whose employment tribunal claim was dismissed under Rule 47 for non-attendance after he did not join a remote case management/attendance hearing on 13 April 2021 and had provided medical letters advising non-attendance. The EAT allowed the appeal against the April 2021 dismissal, finding the ET erred in its treatment of medical evidence and in relying on the claimant’s written correspondence to infer capacity to attend, and remitted the matter for further case management. The EAT dismissed the separate appeal against the October 2021 reconsideration decision.
- P Williamson v The Bishop of London & Ors [2022] EAT 118 1 August 2022 This appeal concerned whether Employment Tribunal proceedings brought by a person subject to a Civil Proceedings Order (CPO) without prior High Court leave are a nullity. The EAT upheld the ET's decision that section 42(1A) of the Senior Courts Act requires leave before proceedings are instituted, so the claimant's original ET claim was void; the High Court's later "retrospective" permission could not validate those null proceedings, and the appeal was dismissed.
- Ministry of Justice v J McGrandle [2022] EAT 126 26 July 2022 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's 2020 decision by EJ Williams to revoke a 2016 dismissal of Mrs McGrandle's claims after she had emailed to withdraw from the collective proceedings. The EAT allowed the Ministry of Justice's appeal because the judge had relied on a material factual error (the judge was told the claimant's husband had died shortly before dismissal when he had in fact died in 2010), set aside the reconsideration decision and remitted the matter for de novo reconsideration. The claimant’s cross-appeal that her 2016 withdrawal was ambiguous was rejected.
- Scottish Federation of Housing Associations v Polly Jones [2022] EAT 114 21 July 2022 This EAT judgment considered whether s.108(4) ERA prevents a claim of unfair dismissal where dismissal followed the employee seeking to stand as a political party candidate, and whether the employee held a protected philosophical belief under s.10 EA. The tribunal held s.108(4) did not apply because the dismissal related to a contractual requirement of political neutrality rather than to the content of political opinions or party affiliation, but it upheld that the claimant held a protected belief in participatory democracy and allowed the claim to proceed to a full hearing on unfairness and discrimination.
- D Pelter v Buro Four Project Services Limited [2022] EAT 105 14 July 2022 This appeal concerned whether an employer discriminated on grounds of age by providing access to a private health insurance (PHI) scheme that ceased insurer payments at age 65. The tribunal found, and the EAT upheld, that the employer had provided access to an insurer's scheme whose terms crystallised when the claimant became incapacitated in July 2011 and that the subsequent cessation of payments at 65 was the insurer's act under those frozen terms. The EAT held paragraph 14(1) Schedule 9 EQA, as it stood when the scheme was entered into, permitted the scheme terms so there was no direct age discrimination by the employer. The claimant’s limitation challenge also failed.
- H Ahmed v Department for Work and Pensions [2022] EAT 107 14 July 2022 This appeal concerned claims under the Equality Act 2010 for reasonable adjustments (primarily an attendance-trigger PCP, break flexibility and workload) and s.15 disability-related unfavourable treatment. The EAT dismissed two grounds but found errors in the ET’s reasoning about the attendance-trigger adjustment (the Hickman letter changing trigger from 8 to 11 days) and in the application of s.15, and remitted those issues for reconsideration. The EAT held that, absent bad faith, a manager seeking HR advice will not ordinarily be a substantial disadvantage. Parties to be heard on panel composition on remittal.
- Leicester City Council v R Patel [2022] EAT 109 14 July 2022 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal could revisit its earlier reconsideration under rule 13 after having accepted a misnamed claim as rectified. The EAT held that a rule 13 decision is properly characterised as a case management order and can, in principle, be varied under rule 29 where necessary in the interests of justice; the Tribunal was entitled to set aside its earlier reconsideration and accept the claim as presented on 1 May 2020. The appeal was dismissed.
- FDA & Ors v U Bhardwaj [2022] EAT 97 13 July 2022 This appeal concerned EJ Heap’s mixed costs rulings following dismissal of consolidated employment claims by Ms Bhardwaj, challenging refusal to order most respondent costs and the award of privilege costs. The EAT dismissed the respondents’ appeals and Ms Bhardwaj’s cross‑appeal, upholding Heap’s two‑stage application of rule 76(1) (threshold then discretion) and her exercise of discretion. The court held that documented specialist legal advice relied on by a claimant can be a relevant mitigating factor and that costs decisions are highly fact‑specific, not strictly precedent‑driven. Privilege costs were properly awarded and no remittal was required.
- Citibank N.A. & Ors v Niels Kirk [2022] EAT 103 12 July 2022 This appeal concerned liability and remedy decisions after a senior banker (aged 55) was dismissed in a 2017 restructure and alleged unfair dismissal and age discrimination; the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) upheld the Tribunal’s finding that a senior manager made a discriminatory remark but allowed parts of the liability appeal (Grounds 2 and 3) because the Tribunal had not adequately engaged with the respondents’ explanatory evidence about perceived similarity of ages and comparator analysis in respect of an appeal officer. The EAT remitted those limited issues for further fact‑finding, but dismissed the appeals against remedies: the Tribunal’s 15% Polkey/Chagger reduction and its refusal to value the claimant’s post‑dismissal shareholding were upheld, leaving an award of about £2.7m.
- Eniola Onigbanjo v London Borough of Croydon [2022] EAT 46 12 July 2022 This is an EAT appeal from an Employment Tribunal judgment about a trainee social worker with fibromyalgia who alleged victimisation, maternity/pregnancy discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments, unfair dismissal and procedural unfairness following suspension and a fraud investigation. The EAT upheld most of the ET's findings (including that cancellation of a chair‑fitting was victimisation and that suspension, investigation and dismissal were reasonable and not tainted by protected acts) but found the ET had not adequately explained why related restrictions on workplace and IT access were not also victimisation and remitted that issue for redetermination. The appeal was otherwise dismissed.
- S Edey v London Borough of Lambeth & Anor [2022] EAT 94 6 July 2022 This appeal considered whether findings in an earlier tribunal (the Martin Judgment) produced issue estoppel or otherwise justified strike-out of parts of a later post‑termination claim (claim 8). The EAT held it was error to treat the earlier laptop credibility finding as creating issue estoppel, but affirmed strike‑out of some allegations as an abuse of process; it restored the victimisation complaint D12 (relating to the 2018 police report) for hearing and otherwise upheld the strike‑outs challenged on Grounds 1 and 3.
- Kristie Higgs v Farmor's School [2022] EAT 101 5 July 2022 This is an application to recuse lay member Mx C E Lord OBE from an EAT panel hearing Kristie Higgs's appeal against dismissal over Facebook posts about gender and same-sex issues. The President applied the fair‑minded and informed observer test and concluded that Mx Lord's public tweets expressing strong views on transgender matters gave rise to a real possibility of apparent bias. The lay member was recused and the appeal will be relisted with a replacement lay member.
- Hanson Quarry Products Europe Limited of Hanson House v Peter Luck [2022] EAT 98 1 July 2022 This appeal concerns a relief HGV driver who resigned after his employer required him at a return-to-work meeting to sign a drafted statement about a prior dizziness episode, then stopped his pay and threatened disciplinary action. The Employment Tribunal found constructive unfair dismissal and unlawful deduction from wages, with a 25% Polkey reduction; the EAT dismissed the employer’s appeal and upheld those findings. The EAT held the claimant was ready, willing and able to return by early September and that withholding pay and imposing a late, undisclosed condition contributed to repudiatory conduct.
- Dr David Mackereth v The Department for Work and Pensions & Anor [2022] EAT 99 29 June 2022 This appeal concerned whether Dr Mackereth's Christian belief (that sex is binary as expressed in Genesis 1:27) and related lack of belief in "transgenderism" qualified as protected philosophical/religious beliefs under s.10 Equality Act 2010, and whether the Department's requirement to use service users' preferred names/pronouns amounted to harassment or discrimination. The EAT held the ET had erred in excluding the Genesis-based belief (and a narrowly related lack-of-belief formulation) from protection by applying criterion (v) too strictly, but it upheld the ET's alternative factual findings that the Department had attempted clarification/accommodation and that the claimant's complaints of harassment, direct discrimination and unjustified indirect discrimination failed on the evidence. The appeal was therefore allowed only insofar as the preliminary s.10 assessment was corrected; the substantive claims and ET conclusions otherwise stood.
- R Thomas v Expansys UK Limited [2022] EAT 164 27 June 2022 This appeal concerned the Employment Appeal Tribunal review of an employment judge's strike‑out of a litigant in person’s direct race and sex discrimination, harassment and victimisation claims. The EAT upheld the strike‑out, concluding there was no pleaded causation connecting the sole alleged decision‑maker (Mr Capp) to discriminatory motivation and the claimant had multiple opportunities to plead such a connection. The appeal was dismissed; the strike‑out decision stands.
- A Webster & Anor v United States of America [2022] EAT 92 24 June 2022 This appeal concerned whether two civilian employees working alongside United States forces in the UK could pursue employment claims in domestic tribunals or whether those claims were barred by state immunity. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the tribunal's factual findings that the claimants' actual functions were sufficiently connected to US sovereign/military activity and therefore attracted state immunity, so the claims were dismissed. An alternative factual finding that litigation would require inquiry into US policies was noted but not separately decided as a live ground on appeal.
- Bukola Osinuga v BPP University Limited [2022] EAT 53 21 June 2022 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal correctly found the claimant's dismissal was by reason of redundancy and whether it had to consider procedural issues of consultation, selection and redeployment. The EAT upheld the redundancy finding under s.139(1)(b) but allowed the appeal in part, holding the ET had erred by failing to consider and give reasons on Polkey/Williams issues and remitting those matters to a differently constituted ET. The discrimination claim was not remitted.
- N Sejpal v Rodericks Dental Limited [2022] EAT 91 16 June 2022 This appeal concerned whether a dentist engaged under a 2013 Associateship Contract was a "worker" or "employee". The EAT found legal errors in the ET's reliance on written labels and its treatment of mutuality, personal service (given a fettered substitution/locum clause), control and integration, allowed the appeal on grounds 1–5, substituted limited findings that there was a contract requiring some personal service, and remitted remaining issues (whether the claimant carried on a profession/business and whether the respondent was her client) for rehearing.
- A Rehman v DHL Services Limited [2022] EAT 90 15 June 2022 This case concerns an Employment Appeal Tribunal decision allowing an appeal from an employment judge's preliminary hearing finding that the claimant was not disabled in respect of keratoconus, TMJ and mental ill‑health. The EAT held the judge had misread a medical report phrase ("unconscious magnification of symptoms") as deliberate exaggeration, which materially undermined his credibility findings across all three impairments, and remitted the disability issues for rehearing before a different judge. The EAT dismissed the separate ground challenging refusal to amend the claim.
- Department for Work and Pensions v Susan Boyers [2022] EAT 76 15 June 2022 This case concerns whether the dismissal of a long-term sick employee with chronic migraines and anxiety was a proportionate means of achieving the employer's legitimate aims under Equality Act 2010 s15(1)(b). The Employment Tribunal found dismissal disproportionate because the employer had not properly evaluated a six-week work trial at another location or considered alternatives; the EAT remitted and then upheld that finding on re-hearing and dismissed the employer’s appeal. The EAT held that tribunals may weigh employer procedural failings, including failure to evaluate redeployment or a work trial, when assessing proportionality and that the assessment is not confined to strict contractual terms nor dependent on a separate reasonable-adjustments duty.
- E Cottrell v Avon Cosmetics Ltd [2022] EAT 89 14 June 2022 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in refusing to reconsider its dismissal of the claimant's claims against Avon for failure to obtain ACAS early conciliation. The tribunal treated the ACAS requirement as mandatory and dismissed the claims against Avon because the claimant had used Echo's EC number for Avon and had not obtained an EC certificate for Avon. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding that the tribunal's administrative letter stating the claim was "accepted" did not confer jurisdiction or make Avon a respondent, and that the claimant's refusal to seek joinder meant no valid application to add Avon had been made.
- S Mogane v Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust & Anor [2022] EAT 139 10 June 2022 This appeal concerned whether an employer genuinely consulted before selecting the claimant (a Band 6 nurse on a fixed‑term contract) for redundancy and whether the employer lawfully set the selection pool. The EAT held the Employment Tribunal erred: the decision not to renew the claimant’s contract was made before any meaningful, formative consultation and the employer had effectively predetermined a pool of one by using contract expiry as the sole criterion without prior consultation. The appeal was allowed, the dismissal declared unfair for lack of meaningful consultation and inadequate reasons, and the case was remitted to a different tribunal panel to determine remedy.
- J v K & Anor [2022] EAT 131 9 June 2022 This appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal challenged a Leeds ET’s costs order of £20,000 against a litigant in person whose claims had been struck out for non‑compliance and who had engaged in voluminous abusive correspondence. The EAT dismissed the appeal, holding the tribunal had considered relevant factors including medical evidence and litigation history, applied correct legal principles, and was entitled to make a summary assessment of costs. The EAT found the tribunal permissibly concluded the claimant’s conduct caused avoidable expense and that the award was compensatory rather than punitive. The costs order was affirmed.
- D Tydeman & Anor. v Oyster Yachts Ltd & Ors. [2022] EAT 115 8 June 2022 The claimants were senior employees dismissed after a transfer; the EAT upheld that the dismissals were automatically unfair but found the Employment Tribunal’s reasoning on whether the claimants would have been dismissed later (for redundancy or misconduct) and on compensation reductions was insufficient and unsafe in material respects. The EAT allowed parts of the claimants’ appeal, disallowed reliance on redundancy on remission, permitted the respondent to pursue Polkey and reductions under ss.122 and 123(1) on reconsideration, and remitted remedy issues to the same tribunal. The ET’s findings on certain alleged misconduct and the probability/contribution calculations were set aside for inadequate reasoning, while the ET’s view that gross misconduct was a live issue was not disturbed.
- A v Choice Support (formerly MCCH Ltd) [2022] EAT 145 7 June 2022 This employment appeal concerned a claimant who alleged rape by a colleague, was suspended and resigned, and brought tribunal claims out of time; the EAT considered two grounds of appeal: that the ET failed properly to consider the manner of suspension and that it erred in refusing to extend time for a harassment claim under EqA s123. The EAT held the ET had sufficiently considered the suspension “in the round” and was entitled to refuse an extension after weighing delay, prejudice to the respondent and equitable considerations. Both grounds of appeal were dismissed.
- INEOS Infrastructure Grangemouth Limited v Jones & Ors [2022] EAT 82 6 June 2022 This appeal concerned whether INEOS's 5 April 2017 unilateral communication of pay increases to employees contravened s.145B TULRCA by having the prohibited result of bypassing collective bargaining. The EAT applied the causation-based test from Kostal, upheld the Employment Tribunal's factual findings that the communication was an offer capable of acceptance and that collective bargaining was not exhausted, and dismissed the appeals. The Tribunal's findings that the employer's sole or main purpose was to displace the union were left intact.
- I Laing v Bury and Bolton Citizens Advice [2022] EAT 85 1 June 2022 This appeal concerned deposit and witness orders and the dismissal of a victimisation claim after the claimant, a litigant in person, failed to pay tribunal-ordered deposits for discrimination claims. The EAT upheld the deposit orders and most witness-order decisions, and held the Grundy tribunal could have granted a retrospective extension but would properly have refused it on the merits; however the EAT quashed and remitted the victimisation decision for rehearing because the tribunal’s reasoning risked unconscious bias from reliance on the claimant’s in-court conduct. Discrimination claims remain struck out for non-payment; the victimisation claim must be reheard by a differently constituted tribunal.
- O Dafiaghor-Olomu v Community Integrated Care [2022] EAT 84 1 June 2022 This appeal concerned how prior payments should be treated when applying the statutory compensatory cap in s.124(5) Employment Rights Act 1996, and whether an ET may refuse an application to reconsider remedies where fresh evidence cannot alter the outcome absent a change in the claimant's position. The EAT held that prior payments identified in s.124(5)(a) and (b) must be deducted from the total compensatory award before applying the cap, varied the ET's order so the claimant is entitled to £74,200, and upheld refusal to reopen remedies; the respondent's cross‑appeal failed.
- Parag Bahad v HSBC Bank PLC [2022] EAT 83 1 June 2022 This appeal concerned an employment tribunal's strike-out at a telephone case-management hearing of a litigant's race, religious discrimination and protected-disclosure claims. The EAT held the tribunal erred in law in striking out the race and religion claims and substituted an order refusing strike out, but dismissed the appeal in relation to the protected-disclosure claim. The case was remitted for further case management to prepare for hearing.
- N Stubbs v Grafters Ltd [2022] EAT 134 31 May 2022 This appeal concerned the striking-out of Mr Stubbs' unfair dismissal claim. The EAT held it was an error to strike out the unfair dismissal claim insofar as it relied on a protected disclosure because s108(3) exempts such claims from the s108(1) two-year service requirement, and that part of the claim is remitted to the employment tribunal. The tribunal was correct to strike out the ordinary unfair dismissal claim for lack of the two-year qualifying service under s108(1). Questions about late presentation and reasonable practicability must be determined by the tribunal on evidence.
- Rentplus UK Limited v Susan Coulson [2022] EAT 81 27 May 2022 This appeal concerned whether a tribunal was entitled to apply the Acas Code and a 25% uplift where an employer characterised a dismissal as redundancy but the tribunal found the consultation and grievance processes were a pre‑determined sham to remove the claimant. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the tribunal's findings that the Code applied (because the employer treated the situation as involving misconduct/capability) and that the maximum 25% uplift was justified; the appeal was dismissed and no Polkey reduction was made.
- Mark Ward v Dimensions (UK) Ltd [2022] EAT 159 24 May 2022 This appeal concerned a £5,000 Employment Tribunal costs order against the appellant, where the ET had recorded his monthly outgoings as £690 despite his witness statement showing £1,245.28. The EAT found the ET had materially mischaracterised the appellant's means and that this made the costs award unsafe. The matter of the amount of costs (and whether to award costs) was remitted to the original ET for reconsideration with the correct expenditure figure and opportunity for written submissions.
- Tariq Sami v Abel Avellan [2022] EAT 72 17 May 2022 This appeal concerned deposit orders and strike-outs of the claimant’s discrimination claims against a non‑UK employer (Second Respondent) and an individual (Fourth Respondent) as having little reasonable prospect of success. The EAT held the employment judge gave inadequate and irrelevant reasons for the deposit order as to the Fourth Respondent and quashed the deposit orders/strike‑outs in respect of both the Second and Fourth Respondents, remitting those claims for further tribunal consideration. The EAT also dismissed a separate ground that s.111(7) Equality Act liability could attach to the Second Respondent because the required relationship precondition could not be met.
- Millicom Services UK Limited & Ors v Michael Clifford [2022] EAT 74 11 May 2022 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal should make non-disclosure/restricted-reporting orders under Rule 50 to protect alleged risks to Millicom employees in a foreign (non‑ECHR) state and to preserve confidentiality. The ET had found insufficient objective evidence of a real and immediate risk engaging Articles 3 or 5 and declined to make the orders; the EAT upheld that conclusion on the human-rights points but allowed the appeal in part because the ET erred in its common‑law "interests of justice" analysis and failed to weigh an express contractual duty of confidence. The parties were directed to agree or propose terms of an order.
- D Rodgers v Leeds Laser Cutting Ltd [2022] EAT 69 6 May 2022 This appeal concerned an automatic unfair dismissal claim under s.100(1)(d)/(e) ERA after the claimant refused to return to work during early COVID‑19. The EAT upheld the employment tribunal’s factual findings that the claimant did not reasonably believe there were serious and imminent dangers at his workplace and, in any event, could reasonably have averted those dangers by measures such as distancing, masks and hygiene. The EAT found no error of law and dismissed the appeal.
- T Kostakopoulou v University of Warwick & Ors. [2022] EAT 120 6 May 2022 This appeal challenged Employment Tribunal case-management decisions refusing to postpone an interim relief hearing, proceeding in the claimant's absence, and refusing reconsideration. The EAT dismissed the appeal, finding the tribunal's refusal to postpone and its decision to proceed were within its broad discretion and not legally flawed, that a late email did not create "special" or changed circumstances under s.128 ERA, and that reconsideration was properly refused as having no reasonable prospect of change or necessity in the interests of justice.
- A Field v Steve Pye and Co (KL) Limited & Ors [2022] EAT 68 5 May 2022 This appeal concerned dismissal by an Employment Tribunal of claims for discrimination arising from disability, failure to make reasonable adjustments, victimisation, detriment for taking time off, and constructive dismissal by Ms Field. The EAT found the ET erred principally by failing to consider whether the facts before it were sufficient to shift the burden of proof and by making findings inconsistent with respondent concessions and unaddressed evidence. The EAT allowed multiple grounds of appeal and remitted the matter for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal.
- Concentrix CVG Intelligent Contact Limited v D Obi [2022] EAT 149 4 May 2022 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal was right to extend time by one day for three sexual harassment complaints treated as conduct extending over a period, despite finding no satisfactory explanation for the claimant's delay. The EAT held that absence of an explanation is not automatically fatal to an extension but allowed the appeal because the tribunal wrongly confined its forensic prejudice assessment to prejudice from the one-day lateness and failed to take into account earlier findings of forensic prejudice relating to the same incidents. The case was remitted for reconsideration consistent with those findings.
- N Kumari v Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust [2022] EAT 132 26 April 2022 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal may take an assessment of the prospective merits of late or amended discrimination complaints into account when deciding to extend time under s.123(1) Equality Act 2010 or to allow amendment. The EAT dismissed the claimant's appeal, holding that tribunals are not precluded from weighing a merits assessment (short of being plainly hopeless) as one factor in such case-management decisions, provided the assessment is cautious and based on identifiable features in the material before the tribunal. The EAT also found no absolute duty to give a litigant in person specific advance warning that merits would be assessed; what is required is a fair opportunity to advance and respond.
- St Mungo's Community Housing Association v M Finnerty [2022] EAT 117 21 April 2022 This appeal concerned a housing officer summarily dismissed after an incident with a resident captured on silent CCTV; the employment tribunal found the dismissal unfair and also made a wrongful‑dismissal finding. The EAT held the tribunal erred by substituting its own view for the employer’s and failing properly to apply the Burchell/band of reasonable responses analysis to the employer’s reasons, and also found the wrongful‑dismissal conclusion inadequately explained. The EAT allowed the employer’s appeal and set aside the tribunal’s unfair‑ and wrongful‑dismissal decisions.
- Swiss Re Corporate Solutions Ltd v H Sommer [2022] EAT 78 12 April 2022 This appeal concerned whether a without prejudice settlement letter from an employer alleging serious misconduct by an employee was admissible under the "unambiguous impropriety" exception. The Employment Judge found the letter admissible, concluding the allegations had "no basis at all"; the Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal, holding the Judge had erred in making that factual finding at a preliminary hearing without oral evidence. The letter was held inadmissible at the forthcoming merits hearing.
- Natasha Allen v Primark Stores Limited [2022] EAT 57 8 April 2022 This appeal concerned an employment tribunal's rejection of an indirect sex discrimination claim by a manager who said she could not guarantee availability for Thursday late shifts because of sole childcare. The EAT held the ET failed to address the specific PCP pleaded (a requirement to guarantee availability for Thursday late shifts) and therefore wrongly included comparators who were not subject to the same compulsion; the ET's decision was set aside and the case remitted for rehearing. The EAT did not mandate a UK-wide comparator pool but found the store-based pool lacked a logical basis given the ET's failure to test the pleaded PCP.
- Anis Ali v Heathrow Express Operating Company Limited & Anor [2022] EAT 54 7 April 2022 This appeal concerned whether a security-testing exercise in which an open bag with a visible note reading "Allahu Akbar" was left on airport property amounted to harassment of a Muslim employee under section 26 of the Equality Act 2010. The Employment Tribunal found the conduct related to religion but, on the facts and context (including the test's purpose), it was not reasonable to conclude the claimant had been subjected to conduct violating his dignity or creating a hostile environment. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, holding the tribunal's reasoning was not perverse and was sufficiently reasoned.
- N White v HC-One Oval Ltd [2022] EAT 56 7 April 2022 This is an EAT judgment allowing the claimant's appeal against an Employment Tribunal's strike-out of her unfair dismissal claim after she had requested voluntary redundancy. The EAT held the ET erred by failing to take the claimant's case at its highest, ignoring relevant documentary material and treating disputed background facts as irrelevant, such that there was a live dispute about whether the respondent had manufactured the redundancy situation. The ET's strike-out was set aside and the claim was remitted for a full merits hearing before a different Employment Judge.
- Forshaw v Virgin Atlantic Airways Limited [2022] EAT 123 5 April 2022 This appeal concerned a claimant dismissed for taking £1,000 at work who also alleged wrongful dismissal and discrimination arising from disability (panic from depression). The Employment Tribunal found she was disabled but that dismissal was for non-discriminatory misconduct and rejected her disability-based explanation; the Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed her appeals. The EAT upheld the ET's factual findings and held an isolated misstatement about the burden of proof did not affect the operative decision.
- London Fire Commissioner v A Hurle [2022] EAT 55 5 April 2022 This appeal concerned findings that the London Fire Commissioner failed to make reasonable adjustments and discriminated against the claimant by subjecting him to disciplinary procedure and dismissal. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (HHJ Tayler, sitting with the EAT’s permission on two grounds) dismissed the appeal and refused the respondent’s costs application. The EAT held the tribunal had applied the correct test for constructive knowledge of disability and was entitled to find the disciplinary decision was taken with constructive knowledge.
- N Mendy v Motorola Solutions UK Limited & Ors [2022] EAT 47 31 March 2022 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal’s private case management direction (paragraph 3.5 of a November 2020 order) had the effect of removing the claimant’s pleaded indirect race discrimination claim and thereby amounted to a final determination tantamount to striking out. The EAT found the claimant had pleaded such a claim, that the paragraph operated to remove it and was therefore a judgment, and that making that determination at a private preliminary hearing without the procedural safeguards for striking out was an error of law. The EAT allowed the appeal and set aside paragraph 3.5 of the November 2020 order.
- Kuwait Investment Office v Simon Hard [2022] EAT 51 30 March 2022 This EAT appeal concerned whether the Kuwait Investment Office (KIO), a separate legal entity, enjoyed diplomatic or state immunity and whether the employment tribunal had properly ordered specific disclosure in preliminary proceedings. The EAT held as a matter of principle that separate domestic legal personality does not conclusively preclude an entity from forming part of a diplomatic mission, but on the facts HMG had not clearly recognised the KIO as part of Kuwait’s mission so diplomatic immunity was not established and the tribunal’s disclosure and procedure decisions were upheld.
- Scheldebouw B.V v M Evanson [2022] EAT 157 25 March 2022 This appeal concerned whether "without prejudice" privilege attached to settlement negotiations about unpaid holiday pay and when that privilege arose. The Employment Tribunal found negotiations did not become without prejudice until the December 2018 draft settlement exchange, not earlier offers in October; the EAT rejected the appellant's challenges and dismissed the appeal. The ET's order (with an agreed redaction) was upheld.
- S Holmes v Tellemachus Ltd [2022] EAT 71 24 March 2022 This appeal concerned an Employment Judge's failure to decide whether the claimant had been constructively dismissed after resigning and having a £945 recruitment fee deducted. The EAT held that the claimant's attached grievance letters sufficiently raised an assertion of constructive dismissal and that the Judge should have determined whether the respondent breached the implied term of mutual trust and confidence leading to resignation. The matter was remitted for rehearing of that issue; the respondent accepts that if constructive dismissal is found the fee must be repaid.
- Guardian News & Media Limited v Rozanov & Anor [2022] EAT 12 22 March 2022 This appeal concerned a journalist's request for documents referred to in an employment tribunal judgment; the tribunal had refused to order provision of those documents (other than ET1/ET3) after the hearing. The EAT found the tribunal erred by taking too narrow a view of open justice, by giving disproportionate weight to speculative practical inconvenience, and ordered disclosure of the documents referred to in the judgment in redacted form subject to reasonable copying costs. The tribunal's anonymity/redaction Rule 50 order and refusal to grant access to the full trial bundle were not disturbed on appeal.
- A Dodd v UK Direct Solutions Limited & Anor [2022] EAT 44 18 March 2022 This is an appeal against an employment tribunal's refusal to order specific disclosure in a whistleblowing (public disclosure) and constructive unfair dismissal claim. The EAT upheld most of the tribunal's refusals as proportionate and not necessary for fair disposal under CPR 31 principles, but allowed limited further consideration of three furlough-related disclosure requests (requests 1, 5 and 6) confined to documents concerning three named employees and the period up to 30 April 2020. The claimant's broader, unfocused disclosure application was rejected as a fishing expedition and disproportionate.
- R Frewer v Google UK Limited & Ors [2022] EAT 34 17 March 2022 This EAT allowed the claimant's appeal against an Employment Tribunal order that anonymised all of the employer's clients and permitted broad redaction of "commercially sensitive and irrelevant" material. The EAT held the ET failed to give proper weight to the open justice/Article 10 considerations and did not apply a structured, stepwise analysis to redaction and disclosure; the anonymisation and redaction orders were set aside and the matter remitted for rehearing.
- Rolec (Electrical and Mechanical Services) Ltd v J Georgiou [2023] EAT 46 15 March 2022 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Judge’s interventions at a remote ET hearing created an appearance of bias. The EAT found most interventions were legitimate case management and assistance to an unrepresented claimant, but at least three interventions (including comments on mitigation and suggestions of contempt over disclosure) gave the appearance the judge had taken sides and created a real risk of bias. The ET’s decision was set aside and the matter remitted for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal.
- D Warburton v The Chief Constable of Northamptonshire Police [2022] EAT 42 14 March 2022 This case concerns Mr Warburton's victimisation claim after a police vetting/appointment was put on hold and later rejected while he pursued proceedings against another force. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the Employment Tribunal had misstated and misapplied the legal tests for "detriment" and for the "reason why" (causation), quashed the liability decision and remitted the claim for rehearing. The EAT also allowed the respondent's appeal on costs, holding the ET had no jurisdiction under Rule 76(1)(b) to award costs in respect of an application for a stay and set that costs order aside.
- L Tuitt v London Borough of Richmond Upon Thames [2022] EAT 124 9 March 2022 This appeal concerned whether Ms Tuitt's employment transferred under TUPE as a service provision change when Broadland's CCTV contract ended and the Council replaced full-time CCTV operatives with Careline staff whose monitoring was minimal and reactive. The EAT dismissed the appeal, upholding the ET's factual finding that the pre- and post-change activities were not fundamentally the same and therefore there was no transfer under regulation 3(1)(b)(iii); the claimant's automatic unfair dismissal claim failed.
- Parbhjot Singh v Metroline West Limited [2022] EAT 80 8 March 2022 This appeal concerned whether an employer’s withholding of contractual sick pay amounted to a fundamental repudiatory breach and whether the employment tribunal erred in refusing to determine and give reasons for an application to admit video evidence. The EAT held the tribunal had erred in law by finding the withholding was not a fundamental breach and substituted a finding that it was, remitting the case to decide whether the claimant resigned in response. The EAT also found the tribunal erred by failing to give reasons for refusing the video evidence application but concluded the video would not have assisted the tribunal.
- R Kumar v MES Environmental Limited [2022] EAT 60 2 March 2022 This appeal concerned the claimant’s application (Form EX107) for a transcript of an employment tribunal hearing that HMCTS had audio‑recorded and the employment judge’s refusal of that application. The EAT held the judge erred: where HMCTS has made an official recording, a party may in principle apply for a transcript on payment and subject to HMCTS protocols, but there is no right to a raw verbatim transcript of oral reasons because the tribunal’s written reasons are the definitive record. The EAT also retained control over whether transcript material may be put before it on appeal and will require permission and reasons.
- HM Attorney General v David Taheri [2022] EAT 35 25 February 2022 This case concerns the Attorney General's application for a restriction of proceedings order (RPO) against Mr Taheri under the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 after a pattern of c.41–44 ET claims from 2012–2020, many withdrawn, struck out or dismissed. The President found Mr Taheri had habitually and persistently instituted vexatious proceedings without reasonable grounds and made an indefinite RPO, subject to a permission/filtering regime requiring EAT leave to start or continue ET claims.
- M Fentem v Outform EMEA Limited [2022] EAT 36 25 February 2022 This appeal concerned whether an employer’s exercise of a contractual right to end employment early by paying salary in lieu of unexpired notice, after an employee had resigned, amounted to a dismissal. The tribunal, following Marshall v Hamblin, held there was no dismissal; the EAT reviewed arguments to depart from Marshall but concluded it was not manifestly wrong on the material before the court and dismissed the appeal. The tribunal’s decision that the claimant was not dismissed was therefore upheld. The broader substantive question was left for the Court of Appeal.
- Sun Mark Ltd & Ors v Ramandeep Kaur [2022] EAT 32 25 February 2022 This EAT judgment reviewed an ET's findings in claims by Ms Kaur of sexual harassment and of victimisation/harassment/discrimination by senior staff. The EAT held that the ET's treatment of the claimant's good‑faith status for victimisation could not be reconciled with findings she had exaggerated/distorted parts of her account, and that the ET misapplied inference/burden rules in finding Mr Ahuja had used particular words from an email and his non‑response. The EAT remitted the victimisation issues against Mr Ahuja and Lord Ranger for reconsideration but upheld the ET's findings of harassment and discrimination by Lord Ranger in other respects.
- GC Group Ltd v Georgina Young [2022] EAT 40 22 February 2022 The EAT refused GC Group Ltd's appeal against an Employment Tribunal finding of constructive unfair dismissal, upholding a £55,406.85 award. The employer argued the Tribunal applied a subjective test or relied on facts unknown to it and, alternatively, that some factual findings lacked evidence; both grounds were dismissed. The EAT held the Tribunal applied the correct objective (Malik) test and the employer had notice of most complained-of acts; the employer had also failed to comply with case management directions so could not sustain a perversity challenge. No remittal to the Tribunal was ordered.
- M Arian v The Spitalfields Practice [2022] EAT 67 22 February 2022 This appeal concerned the tribunal's refusal to allow the claimant to amend his ET claims to add (i) an automatically unfair dismissal complaint that dismissal was for making protected disclosures and (ii) a fifth alleged protected disclosure. The EAT found the tribunal made material errors (misreading earlier pleadings, over‑weighting delay and not balancing prejudice) and allowed the amendment adding the automatic unfair dismissal claim; the refusal as to the fifth disclosure was remitted for reconsideration by a different judge.
- Health & Safety Executive v M Jowett [2022] EAT 151 18 February 2022 This appeal concerned whether contemporaneous documents from the claimant's 2008–2011 employment were admissible at a remedy hearing in a discrimination claim where future loss of earnings was in issue. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Employment Judge erred in law by not applying authorities requiring assessment of chances/prospects (including <50% chances) when evaluating future loss and by improperly excluding the documents at an interlocutory stage; the exclusion was also perverse on the facts. The EAT substituted an order that the documents are admissible and may be relied upon by both parties at the remedy hearing, with redaction and case‑management safeguards noted.
- W Finlayson, trading as Finlaysons v A McMahon [2022] EAT 30 11 February 2022 This is an EAT appeal by W Finlayson against an Employment Tribunal finding of unfair dismissal and awards of a basic and compensatory award. The appellant argued apparent judicial bias and legal errors in the Tribunal’s remedy and case management, including the judge’s interventions, calling a trainee witness, undisclosed documents, questioning on mitigation, directions on submissions, judicial research and a promotional video. The EAT rejected allegations of apparent bias and found no legal error in the Tribunal’s assessment of loss or mitigation, refusing the appeal and leaving the original awards intact.
- H Wilkinson v Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency [2022] EAT 23 3 February 2022 This case concerns remedy after a finding of unfair dismissal where the Employment Tribunal awarded no compensation because of the claimant’s conduct. The EAT held that blameworthy employee conduct can engage a s.123(6) contributory reduction even if a fair process might have avoided dismissal, but the Tribunal here made unsupported factual findings (including a 100% reduction) and failed properly to consider employer fault, so its no-award conclusion was set aside and the matter remitted for reconsideration.
- K Pubbi v Your-Move.co.uk [2022] EAT 96 2 February 2022 This case concerns a financial consultant (claimant) who became bankrupt and did not inform his employer; after regulatory revocation and an internal disciplinary process he was dismissed for gross misconduct. The Employment Tribunal found the principal reason for dismissal was the claimant's deliberate non‑disclosure, that the dismissal was within the band of reasonable responses and procedurally fair, and the Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the claimant's appeal. The EAT held it could not overturn the tribunal's factual findings and found no error of law warranting interference.
- S Lewis v The Governing Body of Tai'rgwaith Primary School [2022] EAT 16 2 February 2022 This appeal concerned a teacher who was held to have been unfairly dismissed but whose basic and compensatory awards were reduced to nil for 100% contributory fault after the Employment Tribunal found she used unnecessary force on a pupil. The EAT dismissed the appeal, finding the ET's factual finding that the claimant "lost her temper" and used unnecessary force was not perverse, that the ET correctly applied the law on contributory fault, and that the procedural failings identified by the school did not causally contribute to the dismissal so as to entitle the claimant to compensation. The result is that, despite unfair dismissal, no award was payable.
- L Garcia v The Leadership Factor Limited [2022] EAT 19 1 February 2022 This appeal concerned a £500 deposit order and consequent strike-out of Mr Garcia’s direct and indirect disability discrimination claims about a job advert requiring "a clear voice" and asking if applicants were "in good health." The Employment Tribunal assumed disability for the deposit stage, concluded the claims had little reasonable prospect of success (including on justification and genuine interest), and ordered the deposit; the EAT dismissed the appeal and upheld the deposit order and strike-out.
- Abellio East Midland Trains Ltd v K Thomas [2022] EAT 20 28 January 2022 This case concerned whether a quantum meruit (unjust enrichment) claim can be pursued as an unlawful deduction from wages under Part II of the Employment Rights Act 1996. The EAT held that quantum meruit claims do not properly fall within Part II, but accepted the tribunal’s factual finding that the claimant’s Nottingham role was an entirely different post such that a quantum meruit would be recoverable in the ordinary courts. The appeal was allowed on jurisdictional grounds and the tribunal’s decision treating the shortfall as an unlawful deduction was quashed.
- N Brooks v M Pletani & Ors [2022] EAT 88 27 January 2022 This is an EAT appeal by Nicola Brooks against ET findings that she was the claimant's employer and liable for unlawful deductions, harassment and victimisation. The EAT held the ET erred in allowing an inadequately particularised amendment adding Ms Brooks as "T/A The Wellington Club", and that there was insufficient evidence and reasoning to support the employment finding; proceeding and deciding the substantive issues in her absence was unfair. The EAT set aside the ET decisions, quashed the amendment decision, and remitted the case to a differently constituted ET for fresh case-management and rehearing as necessary.
- L Garcia v British Airways PLC [2022] EAT 14 25 January 2022 This is an EAT rule 3(10) appeal by Mr Garcia against an Employment Judge's strike-out of his age discrimination claim and refusal to permit late amendments to add disability and race discrimination claims after disclosure. The Deputy Judge held the age claim lacked reasonable prospects because contemporaneous documents gave an innocent explanation for the employer asking for ID, and refused permission to amend because of delay and weak merits on the disclosed material. The appeal was dismissed on the papers and no further amendments were permitted.
- D Navarro v Eurostar International Ltd [2022] EAT 7 21 January 2022 This EAT appeal challenged an ET preliminary finding on disability after the claimant's double mastectomy, focussing on whether the ET wrongly considered the cause of the claimant's fatigue. The EAT held the ET permissibly treated fatigue as part of the physical impairment (breast pain and right arm stiffness) rather than a separate disability, read the tribunal's reasoning generously, and found no perversity in its factual findings; the appeal was dismissed.
- Liverpool Heart and Chest Hospital NHS Foundation Trust v Dr Michael Poullis [2022] EAT 9 21 January 2022 This appeal challenged an Employment Judge's cancellation of a provisionally listed preliminary hearing to consider the respondent’s application for a deposit order. The EAT held the cancellation was in error because the judge did not identify a material change of circumstances (or other exceptional grounds) justifying revoking the earlier listing, and remitted the matter with directions for how a deposit application (if pursued) should be advanced. The claimant’s originally-expressed judge should not decide the material change question; procedural steps and timelines were set for further representations.
- J Klonowska-Socha v Falck UK Ambulance Services Limited [2022] EAT 77 20 January 2022 This appeal concerned a claimant dismissed during probation who alleged direct disability discrimination; the Employment Tribunal had found she was disabled but rejected discrimination without resolving key factual disputes about pre‑dismissal conduct. The EAT held the ET failed to make necessary findings of fact on material subsidiary complaints and did not demonstrate proper engagement with the Equality Act 2010 burden‑of‑proof regime. For those reasons the appeal was allowed and the matter was remitted for rehearing before a differently constituted Employment Tribunal.
- Reverend J G Hargreaves v Evolve Housing + Support [2022] EAT 122 20 January 2022 This case concerned whether a tribunal's Rule 69 correction to a reserved judgment restarts the 42-day period for appealing. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held that a Rule 69 correction does not ordinarily reset the appeal clock unless the corrected document operates as a substantive substitution of the original decision, but that an extension of time was properly granted here because the tribunal's corrected judgment was sent with a standard covering letter giving a conflicting appeal date. The Registrar's grant of an extension was upheld and the respondent's appeal against that extension was dismissed.
- Christopher Johnson v Transopco UK Ltd [2022] EAT 6 18 January 2022 This appeal concerned whether a licensed Hackney carriage driver who intermittently used the Mytaxi App was a limb (b) worker of Transopco (the respondent) or an independent contractor whose passengers contracted with Transopco as principal. The Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, upholding the tribunal's findings that passengers contracted with the respondent and that the claimant ran an independent taxi business, so was not a limb (b) worker of Transopco. The EAT concluded the tribunal properly evaluated control, financial risk, integration and licensing factors and gave adequate reasons.
- K Dykes v Whitbread Group PLC [2022] EAT 13 18 January 2022 This case concerns an Employment Tribunal "Unless Order" requiring production of medical records described as documents "within your possession". The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Judge erred by construing that order as requiring the appellant to obtain documents from third parties and therefore dismissed for non‑compliance. The appeal was allowed and the dismissal set aside; the claims were remitted for further procedure.
- L Harris v Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust [2022] EAT 41 13 January 2022 This is an EAT appeal by Mrs Harris against an Employment Tribunal's dismissal of her constructive unfair dismissal claim arising from a disciplinary process after she administered an unprescribed unit of blood. The central factual dispute was whether Mr Smith decided to commence disciplinary proceedings on 28 February 2017 or on the morning of 1 March 2017 and whether that decision breached the implied term of mutual trust and confidence. The EAT found the tribunal's detailed factual findings were open on the evidence, identified no error of law, and dismissed the appeal.
- N Leeks v Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust [2022] EAT 153 16 December 2021 This is an EAT appeal against an Employment Tribunal’s strike‑out of a claimant’s claim for alleged material non‑compliance with an unless order requiring exchange of a witness statement by 18 November 2019. The EAT held the document served on 18 November did amount to the claimant’s witness statement for the purposes of the unless order and quashed the ET’s dismissal for non‑compliance. The EAT also held there was no unfairness in the ET proceeding in the claimant’s absence.
- Daniel Beech v Avon Fire and Rescue Service [2022] EAT 21 15 December 2021 This appeal concerned whether Further and Better Particulars that introduced a direct discrimination complaint amounted to a case-management change or an amendment, and whether the Employment Judge fairly assessed the timing of disclosure when refusing the amendment and striking out the direct discrimination claim. The EAT held that changes altering the pleaded case are amendments to be exercised by judicial discretion, found the Employment Judge had reached a factual conclusion about when the claimant became aware of material without adequate procedure, and remitted the decision on amendment to the same Employment Judge for reconsideration. The EAT did not decide the separate strike-out merits ground.
- Sean Thomas Leacy v Building Craft College [2022] EAT 59 10 December 2021 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Appeal Tribunal should postpone a hearing so the claimant could supply detailed particulars and tribunal documents about alleged curtailment of questioning at the original tribunal. The EAT refused the late application for postponement as disproportionate and likely to cause undue delay and expense, finding the notice of appeal lacked adequate particularity about how questioning was cut short and proceeding on the matters pleaded (principally allocation of hearing time).
- J Pryce v Baxterstorey Limited [2022] EAT 61 9 December 2021 This case concerns whether a claimant's email, sent after she obtained an ACAS early conciliation (EC) certificate, amounted to a valid re-presentation of an employment tribunal claim that had been presented earlier without an EC certificate. The EAT held the email did not constitute re-presentation because presentation must be by a completed ET1 in the prescribed form and manner, and that the statutory pre-condition of an EC certificate existing at the time of presentation cannot be waived. The claimant's appeal was dismissed and she was invited to reissue a compliant claim and, if necessary, apply for an extension of time.
- J McAllister v Commissioners for HMRC [2022] EAT 87 8 December 2021 This appeal and cross-appeal concerned whether dismissal for disability-related absences was objectively justified under s.15 Equality Act 2010 and whether a reduced Civil Service Compensation Scheme (CSCS) payment amounted to unfavourable treatment. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the Tribunal's finding that dismissal was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim and dismissed the claimant's appeal. The EAT allowed the respondent's cross-appeal, holding that the CSCS entitlement itself was not properly separable from its method of calculation and so the Tribunal had erred in treating the calculation as unlawful unfavourable treatment; the Tribunal was also wrong to address the independent CSAB decision.
- M Carr v Bloomberg LP [2022] EAT 49 3 December 2021 This appeal concerned whether seven communications by a journalist to his employer amounted to qualifying protected disclosures under s.43B(1) of the Employment Rights Act 1996; the ET had struck out two disclosures and refused to strike out the other five. The EAT dismissed the claimant’s appeal, allowed the respondent’s cross‑appeal, applied Kilraine and Chesterton tests at strike‑out, and concluded all seven disclosures had no reasonable prospect of meeting the statutory tests, so they were struck out. The EAT also found no realistic prospect of the pleadings being amended to succeed before the merits hearing.
- G France v Mahammad Ziaullah Zahi Khan & Ors [2022] EAT 58 2 December 2021 This Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed an appeal against an Employment Tribunal letter of 20 August 2019 which had refused the claimant's pre-reconsideration applications for information, disclosure, inspection and third party disclosure. The EAT found the EJ who decided that letter did not have the claimant's March and June 2018 applications (or the 2016 reconsideration material) before her and gave inadequate reasons, and remitted those applications to the ET for determination (with directions that certain judges should not hear them). The EAT declined to decide the applications itself.
- Howard Waters v The Mote Cricket Club [2022] EAT 28 1 December 2021 This appeal concerned whether Mr Waters was an employee/worker of The Mote Cricket Club or a self‑employed trader carrying on Green Hand Gardens. The Employment Tribunal found the written, closely prescribed contract was genuine and that Waters ran a business whose customer was the Club, so he was not an employee or worker. The EAT dismissed his appeal, holding the ET had applied the correct legal approach (Meek‑compliantly) and made permissible factual findings about control, personal service, hours and monitoring. As upheld, he was not entitled to holiday or notice pay and could not amend to claim unfair dismissal.
- R Gafari Tijani v The House of Commons Commission [2022] EAT 104 1 December 2021 This Employment Appeal Tribunal appeal challenged an Employment Tribunal’s finding that a cleaner was fairly dismissed for persistent lateness while subject to a final written warning. The EAT upheld the ET’s factual findings and conclusion that dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses, rejecting arguments about the absence of the disciplinary policy in the bundle, alleged disclosure failures, lack of named comparators and the scope of the investigation. The appeal was dismissed and the ET decision maintained.
- W Hesketh v Glasgow Caledonian University [2022] EAT 33 30 November 2021 The Employment Appeal Tribunal considered whether the claimant's ET1 (as amended) pleaded an equal pay claim and whether the tribunal had been right to refuse permission to amend to add a new equal pay comparator. The EAT held the ET1 did not, on objective reading, plead an equal pay claim (ground 3 dismissed) but found that an equal pay complaint first advanced in a November 2018 Scott Schedule (the Buckle comparator) was a new claim; the Employment Judge's refusal to permit that amendment was set aside and remitted for reconsideration, including whether s.129 "stable work" timebar principles apply.
- K Paczkowska v R-Com Consulting Limited [2022] EAT 70 26 November 2021 This appeal concerned failures by an Employment Tribunal (ET) in handling co‑pleaded discrimination and time‑bar issues. The EAT found the ET materially erred by declining to decide a direct disability discrimination claim after finding victimisation arising from the same withheld reference, and by refusing to extend time for an April 2016 allegation without considering an earlier application and its reasons. Other challenges (vicarious liability concession, witness evidence, order of evidence) were dismissed. The matter was remitted for the ET to address the identified gaps.
- Z Simmonds-Plummer v London Borough of Hammersmith & Fulham [2022] EAT 50 25 November 2021 This appeal concerned the Employment Tribunal's strike‑out of the claimant's Equality Act 2010 claims for race and sex harassment and victimisation arising from disciplinary proceedings that continued after her resignation. The EAT held the ET had mischaracterised the pleadings as alleging an actual summary dismissal rather than post‑termination discrimination and allowed the appeal. The discrimination claims were remitted to the Employment Tribunal for further consideration; the respondent may later apply again to strike out or for a deposit order and the claimant may be required to provide further particulars.
- Temi Alao v Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust [2022] EAT 135 19 November 2021 The EAT dismissed Ms Alao's appeals against an Employment Tribunal decision that she was not a disabled person for Equality Act 2010 purposes at the relevant time and that her unfair dismissal claim was presented out of time so the ET lacked jurisdiction. The EAT found the ET's assessment of medical and documentary evidence (anxiety/OCD and Access to Work records) and its application of presentation rules were open to it. The appeals were therefore dismissed and the ET's findings on disability and jurisdiction were upheld.
- Cygnet Behavioural Health Ltd v G Britton [2022] EAT 108 16 November 2021 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal was perverse in finding it was not reasonably practicable for Mr Britton to present his unfair dismissal claim in time and that the 62‑day delay after the primary limit was reasonable. The EAT found that, on the ET's own factual findings (depression, dyslexia, engagement in HCPC proceedings, but ability to appeal, contact ACAS, work and move house), it was perverse to conclude he could not discover or comply with the time limit and that the further delay was reasonable. The EAT substituted the only rational outcome: the claim was out of time and was dismissed.
- R Ejvet v Genesis Education Trust [2022] EAT 75 11 November 2021 This is an EAT appeal by a dismissed headteacher against an ET decision rejecting unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and whistleblowing detriment claims. The EAT held the ET’s reserved written reasons complied with r.62(5) (Meek‑compliant), did not take irrelevant matters into account nor omit relevant ones to a degree warranting intervention, and that a late‑disclosed 17‑page letter did not cause material injustice. The appeal was dismissed and the ET decision was affirmed.
- Commerzbank AG v J Rajput [2022] EAT 10 10 November 2021 This appeal concerned whether an Employment Tribunal (ET) should have listed a preliminary hearing to determine which factual findings from an earlier ET would bind a remitted rehearing, and whether the remitted tribunal was bound by those earlier findings. The EAT allowed the appeal, holding the ET erred in refusing a preliminary hearing, vacated the imminent rehearing, directed a preliminary case management meeting, and held that a freshly constituted remitted tribunal was not bound by the prior tribunal’s factual findings on the remitted sex discrimination and harassment claims. The remitted hearing was ordered not to be before the same judge.
- C Knightley v Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2022] EAT 63 9 November 2021 This EAT appeal arose from an employee with a recognised disability dismissed for capability after long-term sickness; the ET found the employer had failed to make a reasonable adjustment by refusing a short extension to appeal but also found the dismissal substantively fair and proportionate. The EAT dismissed the employee’s appeal, holding that the discrete breach of the reasonable‑adjustment duty did not automatically require a finding of unfair dismissal or disprove proportionality, and upheld the ET’s conclusions that dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses.
- SM Trucking Ltd v A Dixon [2022] EAT 66 26 October 2021 SM Trucking appealed an Employment Tribunal decision which had found that Mr Dixon was "entirely to blame" for a road accident that wrote off the employer's only HGV but nevertheless awarded wrongful dismissal and reduced the basic unfair dismissal award by 50%, while upholding a small holiday pay award. The EAT allowed the appeal in part, holding on the Tribunal's own factual findings that the conduct amounted to gross misconduct/gross negligence justifying summary dismissal (so there was no wrongful dismissal) and that the basic award should be reduced to nil; the Tribunal was not wrong to refuse late holiday records and the holiday award stands.
- Citizens Advice Merton and Lambeth Ltd v P Mefful [2022] EAT 11 22 October 2021 This appeal concerned Mr Mefful's dismissal following a restructure and whether that dismissal was because of his disability or protected acts. The EAT upheld that interim CEO Mr Davidson had decided by 19 March 2012 that Mefful would be lost, but held the employment tribunal erred by relying on events after that date when analysing the reason for dismissal and by misdirecting itself on causation for both direct (s.13) and discrimination arising from disability (s.15(1)(b)); those disability findings were set aside. The matter was remitted to the same tribunal to reconsider the limited issues, including the reason for dismissal properly confined to what was known to the decision‑maker and potentially victimisation (s.27).
- V Clark v Kim Middleton & Anor [2022] EAT 31 21 October 2021 This appeal concerned TUPE Regulation 13 information/consultation obligations when a micro-business transferred to a newly incorporated company and the employee later resigned. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s finding that the transferor could rely on a defence that it lacked requisite information from the transferee, and that the employee’s ACAS settlement/withdrawal against the transferee precluded a later Regulation 15(8)(b) award against that transferee. The EAT held the tribunal was wrong to treat failure to notify the transferee’s identity as merely “technical” and to apply Regulation 13(2)(b) rather than 13(2)(a); the zero compensation award was quashed and the matter was remitted for fresh assessment by a differently constituted tribunal.
- Mark Ward v Dimensions (UK) Limited [2022] EAT 110 19 October 2021 This is an EAT judgment dismissing the claimant's appeal against an employment tribunal decision that upheld his dismissal for alleged gross misconduct — namely that he told a colleague he "had a gun with her name on it." The claimant argued the appeal was unfair because the Operations Director (Mr Ellis) who decided the appeal had prior involvement (suspension, sanctioning, and speaking to the complainant) and that the tribunal perversely relied on an alleged admission of past gun possession. The EAT held the tribunal had properly considered Mr Ellis's prior involvement and that any reference to past possession was peripheral and did not undermine the conclusion that the employer reasonably believed the threat had been made. The appeal was dismissed and the tribunal's decision affirmed.
- Trentside Manor Care Limited & Ors v M Raphael [2022] EAT 37 15 October 2021 This case concerns two EAT appeals about disclosure of documents held by a third party, Citation Ltd, in a claimant’s unfair dismissal and discrimination proceedings. The EAT allowed the appeal against a June 2020 case‑management order that required allegedly privileged documents to be shown to the claimant’s solicitors/counsel before the privilege issue was determined, holding that was wrong in principle. The EAT dismissed the appeal against a December 2020 tribunal decision ordering disclosure of Citation’s advice notes up to 29 June 2018, concluding the tribunal could find litigation privilege did not apply before 30 June 2018 and that legal‑advice privilege had not been established for the earlier period. The substantive tribunal proceedings continue.
- C Labongo Alum v Thames Reach Charity [2022] EAT 8 13 October 2021 This appeal concerned whether an employment tribunal wrongly refused a just-and-equitable extension to present discrimination claims after an ET1 was recorded as received three days late. The EAT held the tribunal erred by basing its refusal on an incorrect factual premise about the length of the unexplained delay (the ET1 had been posted on 20 June 2019) and remitted the discrimination claims for reconsideration, while upholding the tribunal's finding that it was reasonably practicable to have lodged the claim with the ACAS number in time for unfair dismissal and wages claims.
- C Tchapdeu v Unipart Group Ltd [2022] EAT 25 12 October 2021 This appeal concerned claims by Mr C Tchapdeu against Unipart Group Ltd for direct and indirect race discrimination, associative disability discrimination and victimisation arising from refusal of flexible working and handling of multiple grievances. The Employment Tribunal found little supporting evidence, preferred the employer's witnesses, and concluded business reasons (not protected characteristics or acts) explained the treatment and that no PCP or ongoing discriminatory conduct was established. The EAT dismissed the appeal, finding no error of law in the ET's reasoning or credibility findings.
- L Garcia v Bigbux & Ors [2022] EAT 95 8 October 2021 This appeal concerned Mr Garcia's challenge to a tribunal case‑management order of 25 October 2020 consolidating multiple discrimination claims for a strike‑out preliminary hearing. The EAT held the order was a valid case‑management exercise under ET Rules 29 and 53, that the judge properly relied on similarities between claims, shared addresses and prior adverse findings as grounds for consolidation, and that there were no reasonable grounds of appeal. The appeal was dismissed at the rule 3(7) stage.
- Lynn Phipps v Priory Education Services Ltd [2022] EAT 129 6 October 2021 This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal's refusal to set aside a strike‑out of a claimant's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims after non‑compliance and apparent failures by her representative. The ET found the representative had misled the claimant and acted improperly, made a wasted costs order against him, and lawfully exercised its Rule 70 discretion to refuse reconsideration on grounds of finality, prejudice to the respondent and wasted tribunal resources. The EAT dismissed the appeal, upholding the ET's approach that representative failings will not generally justify reconsideration though the test is fact‑sensitive.
- Sally Nailard v Unite the Union [2022] EAT 102 1 October 2021 This appeal concerned multiple Employment Tribunal case‑management and factual decisions after findings of discriminatory acts by union officials and assessment of remedies for the claimant. The EAT dismissed Ms Nailard’s appeals, upholding the ET’s approach to burden of proof (refusing to infer subconscious bias), its January 2017 cut‑off for loss, its Polkey reduction for post‑resignation misconduct, and its use and enforcement of an "unless" disclosure order striking out a personal injury claim for conscious non‑compliance. The EAT also refused an extension of time to seek permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal.
- N Hepburn v Crown Prosecution Service [2022] EAT 24 29 September 2021 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal gave adequate reasons in rejecting eleven victimisation/detriment complaints after accepting the claimant had made protected disclosures relating to disability. The EAT concluded that, read fairly and benevolently, the Tribunal had considered the claimed detriments and lawfully dismissed them because the claimant's conduct sprang from an "unjustified sense of grievance," so no detriment was made out; leave to appeal was refused.
- Secretary of State for Justice v Alan Johnson [2022] EAT 1 28 September 2021 This Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the Secretary of State's appeal against an ET finding of harassment linked to an ill‑health retirement (IHR) application, holding the tribunal had failed to identify the specific respondent conduct constituting harassment and to fix the period over which it allegedly extended (notably the date of the 20 February 2013 IHR form). The EAT also found error in the tribunal’s approach to the three‑month limitation and discretion to extend time, requiring consideration of prejudice to the respondent (including stale evidence) and of Adedeji. The matter was remitted to the same employment tribunal, if practicable, to determine the relevant dates/period and then whether it is just and equitable to extend time.
- Adrian Arvunescu v Quick Release (Automotive) Ltd [2022] EAT 26 23 September 2021 This appeal involved a victimisation claim brought after a COT3 settlement; the Employment Tribunal struck it out as having no reasonable prospect and as being compromised by the COT3. The EAT held the tribunal was wrong to strike out for want of reasonable prospect because the pleaded facts could support a claim that the respondent knowingly helped a third party to victimise the claimant under section 112 EqA. However, the EAT upheld the tribunal’s conclusion that the COT3’s very wide wording barred the section 112 claim because the alleged wrongdoing was sufficiently connected to the claimant’s prior employment.
- Solomon Ijegede v Signature Senior Lifestyle Operations Limited [2022] EAT 4 23 September 2021 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal improperly narrowed the issues and misunderstood the scope of Mr Ijegede’s claim by excluding matters that had been agreed as issues and by not treating an emailed grievance document as part of the claim. The Employment Appeal Tribunal found the ET had erred, that its decision was unsafe, and remitted the case for rehearing before a different tribunal, without preserving the original ET’s findings (parties may rely on undisputed recorded evidence).
- B King v Gemalto UK Limited [2022] EAT 29 14 September 2021 This appeal concerned whether the Employment Tribunal erred in refusing to extend time for an unfair dismissal claim by Mr King. The EAT upheld the ET's finding that, given Mr King knew there was a time limit, had means to discover its duration and took no steps to do so, it was reasonably practicable for him to present his claim in time. The EAT rejected complaints that the ET failed to take relevant circumstances into account or gave insufficient reasons, and dismissed the appeal.
- Tamer El-Tawil v Arcadis Human Resources Limited [2022] EAT 39 14 September 2021 This appeal concerned the refusal of an ET to permit amendments to a Scott Schedule which the tribunal found introduced new complaints beyond the pleaded particulars. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s refusal, holding that two specific Scott Schedule paragraphs (5 and 10) introduced new heads of complaint rather than merely particularising the existing pleaded allegations; one other paragraph (1) was withdrawn as a discrete allegation but may be used as background evidence in the claimant’s witness statement.
- John Craig v Abellio Limited [2022] EAT 43 10 September 2021 This appeal concerns Mr Craig’s claim of constructive unfair dismissal after his employer failed to make a promised back-pay payroll payment which he treated as the "last straw" in a series of alleged payroll errors and mishandling of complaints. The EAT found the Employment Tribunal failed properly to apply and explain the "last straw" cumulative-breach doctrine and failed to make or explain necessary factual findings about the history of complaints. The appeal was allowed and the constructive dismissal claim was remitted for rehearing before a newly constituted Employment Tribunal.
- A Thomas v St Mungo Housing Association [2022] EAT 79 7 September 2021 This appeal concerned an Employment Judge's case-management decisions on amendments: allowing a Working Time Regulations (Reg 14) holiday-pay claim (subject to limitation being left open for the final hearing) and refusing amendments for an unlawful deduction and a long-running breach of contract. The EAT dismissed the appeal in full, finding the ET1 did not reasonably disclose a specific Reg 14 claim so amendment was properly required, the tribunal gave adequate reasons in refusing the unlawful-deduction amendment, and the refusal to permit the historic breach-of-contract amendment was not perverse.
- I Mbola v Royal Mail [2022] EAT 2 1 September 2021 This case concerns an appeal by Mr Mbola against dismissal by Royal Mail for alleged intentional delay of mail and for being untruthful. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Employment Tribunal erred in law by recording that the claimant had admitted intentional delay (gross misconduct) when he had denied that element and only admitted lying. The EAT remitted the case for rehearing before a differently constituted tribunal so the actual reason(s) for dismissal can be properly identified and decided.
- E Bayo v Ministry of Defence [2022] EAT 17 26 August 2021 This decision concerns an EAT challenge to an Employment Tribunal’s refusal to reconsider its strike-out of race and religious discrimination claims brought by an Army reservist as out of time. The EAT held the ET erred in law by failing to recognise that a military appeal determination, received only after the ET hearing, constituted new material that could not have been before the ET and which might contain admissions or be dispositive. The EAT set aside the refusal and remitted the matter to the same Employment Judge to reconsider stage one of the reconsideration process afresh.
- Y Saloo v Interserve Learning and Employment (Services) Ltd [2022] EAT 22 5 August 2021 This appeal challenged an Employment Tribunal's finding that the claimant was employed by ESG Saudi Arabia LLC, not by Interserve, and that the UK tribunal lacked territorial jurisdiction over an unfair dismissal claim by a teacher working in Saudi Arabia. The EAT refused permission to appeal, holding the proposed grounds (admission of expert-like evidence, alleged failure to consider or properly weigh evidence including s94(1), and alleged bias) were not arguably sustainable and that any tenuous bias concern was not promptly or sufficiently made out. The appeal was dismissed.
- Haziz Rahim v The Commissioner of Police of The Metropolis [2022] EAT 3 19 July 2021 This Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed Haziz Rahim's appeal against the Metropolitan Police after he failed to attend a 23 October 2019 preliminary hearing from Afghanistan and sought to participate by video/telephone. The EAT held there was no clear, properly served or pursued application for video attendance or postponement before the tribunal, and the claimant's late, ambiguous emails (not copied to the respondent) did not make out unfairness. The strike-out decision therefore stood.
- H Shittu v South London & Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust [2022] EAT 18 13 July 2021 This appeal concerns the Employment Tribunal's assessment of loss of earnings after finding constructive dismissal and disability discrimination. The EAT held the tribunal applied a loss-of-a-chance approach and was entitled to conclude there was a 100% chance the claimant would have resigned when he did, so no compensatory award for future loss of earnings was made. The EAT also held that Perry v Raleys does not displace the established loss-of-a-chance approach in employment dismissal claims. The appeal was dismissed.
- H Fullah v The Medical Research Council & Ors [2022] EAT 45 24 June 2021 This is an appeal in which the EAT held that an employment tribunal was wrong to find a suspension was not a "detriment" for victimisation purposes and had failed properly to address causation in relation to dismissal. The ET had found suspension to be neutral and dismissal due to an irretrievable breakdown in working relationships; the EAT ruled the claimant’s reasonable view that suspension was detrimental could suffice and remitted the case for reconsideration of whether suspension and dismissal were because of protected acts. The EAT did not overturn the ET’s factual findings about the breakdown itself but required fresh analysis of causation and separability.
- A Manning v Walker Crips Investment Management Limited [2023] EAT 79 14 June 2021 This appeal concerned whether an express contractual substitution clause (clause 2.5) negated the claimant's obligation of personal service and whether the respondent was a "client or customer" of a business carried on by the claimant. The Employment Appeal Tribunal held the Employment Judge was wrong to imply a reasonableness constraint into the unqualified substitution clause and substituted a finding that the claimant did undertake to perform work personally. The EAT remitted the remaining issue — whether the respondent was a client or customer of the claimant’s business — to the Employment Tribunal for determination.
- N Brown v Castlerock Group Ltd [2022] EAT 5 31 March 2021 This is an appeal by N Brown against an Employment Tribunal decision finding her dismissal for alleged theft procedurally unfair but reducing compensation to nil because dismissal would inevitably have occurred and for contributory conduct; her wrongful dismissal claim was also dismissed. The EAT (HHJ Shanks) dismissed the appeal, holding the tribunal was entitled to apply a 100% Polkey reduction and related reductions to set awards at nil and to reject the wrongful dismissal claim on the facts.
No cases matched your search.