J McAllister v Commissioners for HMRC

Decision date: 8 December 2021

Neutral citation: [2022] EAT 87

Overall AI summary confidence: high

AI Notice: Any short overview, ratio decidendi summary or obiter dicta summary shown on this page is AI-generated, provided only to help users assess potential relevance more quickly, and may be wholly inaccurate. No liability is accepted for the accuracy of any such summary, regardless of any AI confidence rating shown. Users should check the underlying decision and obtain appropriate legal advice rather than relying on any summary.

Short overview

This short overview is intended to summarise the case, issues and outcome so far as they are supported by the judgment.

AI confidence in this short overview: high

This appeal and cross-appeal concerned whether dismissal for disability-related absences was objectively justified under s.15 Equality Act 2010 and whether a reduced Civil Service Compensation Scheme (CSCS) payment amounted to unfavourable treatment. The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the Tribunal's finding that dismissal was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim and dismissed the claimant's appeal. The EAT allowed the respondent's cross-appeal, holding that the CSCS entitlement itself was not properly separable from its method of calculation and so the Tribunal had erred in treating the calculation as unlawful unfavourable treatment; the Tribunal was also wrong to address the independent CSAB decision.

Ratio decidendi

This summary is intended to identify the ratio decidendi, meaning the legal reasons for deciding and the binding part of the decision.

AI confidence in this ratio decidendi summary: medium

Where discrimination arising from disability is alleged under s.15, tribunals must (1) identify a real need or legitimate aim, (2) assess whether the measure is appropriate to that aim, and (3) carry out a critical balancing of the discriminatory impact against the employer's needs (applying a Bilka-style proportionality analysis). Further, when a benefit is payable by reason of disability the relevant "treatment" may be the award itself rather than a separable method of calculation; artificially disaggregating the calculation from the entitlement can mischaracterise whether unfavourable treatment has occurred.

Obiter dicta

This summary is intended to identify obiter dicta, meaning observations made by the way that were not necessary to deciding the case and are not binding.

AI confidence in this obiter dicta summary: medium

The Tribunal may, at the liability stage, consider and indicate whether less discriminatory measures were available and what a proportionate alternative might be without finally determining remedy; findings on liability can inform but do not decide remedy. Also, a tribunal should not purport to adjudicate on an independent appeals body's decision that was not before it.