The Advocate General for Scotland v Koren Brown & Anor

Decision date: 20 November 2024

Neutral citation: [2024] EAT 189

Overall AI summary confidence: high

AI Notice: Any short overview, ratio decidendi summary or obiter dicta summary shown on this page is AI-generated, provided only to help users assess potential relevance more quickly, and may be wholly inaccurate. No liability is accepted for the accuracy of any such summary, regardless of any AI confidence rating shown. Users should check the underlying decision and obtain appropriate legal advice rather than relying on any summary.

Short overview

This short overview is intended to summarise the case, issues and outcome so far as they are supported by the judgment.

AI confidence in this short overview: high

This case concerns an Employment Appeal Tribunal appeal by the Ministry of Defence Police against an ET finding that a 7.6 MSFT fitness requirement for authorised firearms officers was a PCP causing indirect sex discrimination and that the claimant was not offered a formal Chester treadmill alternative or adequate assistance. The EAT upheld the ET’s findings on group and individual disadvantage and on failure to offer the alternative/assistance, but allowed the appeal in part because the ET’s proportionality reasoning—particularly whether a less discriminatory alternative could have achieved the MDP’s legitimate aims in the claimant’s specific case—was inadequately explained. The EAT remitted the proportionality issue to the same ET (if practicable) for reconsideration.

Ratio decidendi

This summary is intended to identify the ratio decidendi, meaning the legal reasons for deciding and the binding part of the decision.

AI confidence in this ratio decidendi summary: medium

The judgment establishes that a PCP need not be an absolute bar to amount to indirect discrimination; it suffices that it places a protected group at a particular disadvantage. Where a policy permits different responses, tribunals must assess proportionality both at the general policy level and in its particular application to the individual, including consideration of less discriminatory alternatives.

Obiter dicta

This summary is intended to identify obiter dicta, meaning observations made by the way that were not necessary to deciding the case and are not binding.

AI confidence in this obiter dicta summary: medium

The notes record obiter observations that tribunals should be clear whether they are comparing indirect testing (MSFT) with direct physiological testing (gas analysis/Chester treadmill) when assessing whether an alternative avoids group disadvantage, and that appellate courts should not attempt to reconstruct missing elements of a tribunal’s reasoning where explanations are deficient.