Karen Shanks v Lothian Health Board
Decision date: 24 November 2023
Neutral citation: [2023] EAT 148
Overall AI summary confidence: high
Short overview
This short overview is intended to summarise the case, issues and outcome so far as they are supported by the judgment.
AI confidence in this short overview: high
This appeal challenged whether regulations requiring facemasks were ultra vires because paragraph 3 of Schedule 19 to the Coronavirus Act 2020 forbids regulations requiring "medical treatment", and whether the Employment Tribunal erred in finding dismissal for refusing to wear a mask fair. The EAT held that "medical treatment" does not, in its plain meaning, cover general infection-control measures like mask-wearing, and found no error in the Tribunal's application of the range-of-reasonable-responses test. The appeal was refused and the Tribunal's dismissal of the unfair dismissal and breach of contract claims was upheld.
Ratio decidendi
This summary is intended to identify the ratio decidendi, meaning the legal reasons for deciding and the binding part of the decision.
AI confidence in this ratio decidendi summary: high
The ratio is that, on ordinary textual construction, "medical treatment" in paragraph 3 of Schedule 19 to the Coronavirus Act 2020 refers to treatment prescribed or administered under medical guidance (for example vaccination or clinical interventions) and does not extend to routine health-and-safety measures such as mandatory facemask-wearing to reduce viral transmission; accordingly regulations imposing such measures are not rendered ultra vires by that exception.
Obiter dicta
This summary is intended to identify obiter dicta, meaning observations made by the way that were not necessary to deciding the case and are not binding.
AI confidence in this obiter dicta summary: medium
The judgment noted (obiter) that Montgomery-style principles about informed risk disclosure in medical treatment did not apply because mask-wearing was not treated as "medical treatment", and that the tribunal process may sometimes appropriately allow an unrepresented or lay advocate to advance arguments beyond a narrowly sifted ground where no prejudice arises.