The No 8 Partnership v Maxine Simmons
Decision date: 8 November 2023
Neutral citation: [2023] EAT 140
Overall AI summary confidence: high
Short overview
This short overview is intended to summarise the case, issues and outcome so far as they are supported by the judgment.
AI confidence in this short overview: high
This appeal concerned an Employment Tribunal’s findings that the claimant was constructively unfairly dismissed and directly discriminated against by association after her employer refused extended unpaid time off to care for her father. The EAT allowed the employer’s appeal, holding the ET unfairly relied on hypothetical comparators without permitting the parties to address them, concluding the discrimination finding was perverse on the ET’s own findings and dismissing the s.13 claim, and remitting the constructive dismissal complaint for rehearing because the ET misapplied the Malik test and gave inadequate reasons. The ET judgment was set aside; the s.13 claim was dismissed and the constructive dismissal claim remitted to a differently constituted ET.
Ratio decidendi
This summary is intended to identify the ratio decidendi, meaning the legal reasons for deciding and the binding part of the decision.
AI confidence in this ratio decidendi summary: high
An Employment Tribunal should not construct and rely on hypothetical comparators central to its decision without first giving the parties an opportunity to adduce evidence or make submissions about those comparators; comparators must be truly like‑for‑like under s.23 EqA (so they must not retain the protected characteristic relied upon for a s.13 claim); and, when alleging breach of the implied term of mutual trust and confidence, the tribunal must consider whether the employer had reasonable and proper cause (the Malik test) and give adequate reasons before finding a breach.
Obiter dicta
This summary is intended to identify obiter dicta, meaning observations made by the way that were not necessary to deciding the case and are not binding.
AI confidence in this obiter dicta summary: medium
The notes indicate obiter commentary that where no immediate direct comparator exists tribunals may properly focus on the respondent’s subjective reason for treatment (the “reason why”), but they must do so based on evidence and after giving parties an opportunity to address relevant hypothetical scenarios; and that findings suggesting bad faith or reliance on improper reasons normally require giving the decision‑maker an opportunity to respond.