Brian Gourlay v West Dunbartonshire Council

Decision date: 10 March 2025

Neutral citation: [2025] EAT 29

Overall AI summary confidence: high

AI Notice: Any short overview, ratio decidendi summary or obiter dicta summary shown on this page is AI-generated, provided only to help users assess potential relevance more quickly, and may be wholly inaccurate. No liability is accepted for the accuracy of any such summary, regardless of any AI confidence rating shown. Users should check the underlying decision and obtain appropriate legal advice rather than relying on any summary.

Short overview

This short overview is intended to summarise the case, issues and outcome so far as they are supported by the judgment.

AI confidence in this short overview: high

This appeal concerned the tribunal's 80% reduction of a large award for past and future wage and pension loss after findings that the respondent's discrimination caused the claimant to develop a chronic severe depressive episode leaving him permanently unfit for work. The EAT found legal error and perversity in that reduction, set aside the economic loss award (paragraph 2 of the remedy judgment) and remitted quantum for reassessment by a differently constituted tribunal. The respondent's cross‑appeal to limit loss to the date of a hypothetical lawful dismissal was refused.

Ratio decidendi

This summary is intended to identify the ratio decidendi, meaning the legal reasons for deciding and the binding part of the decision.

AI confidence in this ratio decidendi summary: medium

Where discriminatory acts have caused a career‑long incapacity, a tribunal must first ask whether a lawful non‑discriminatory dismissal would have produced substantially the same incapacity before reducing compensation; tribunals must not conflate (a) whether the claimant would have remained fit but for the discrimination with (b) whether, assuming fitness, the claimant would in fact have worked to normal retirement age. Applied here, the tribunal erred in law and made perverse findings when it applied an 80% reduction without properly answering those questions.

Obiter dicta

This summary is intended to identify obiter dicta, meaning observations made by the way that were not necessary to deciding the case and are not binding.

AI confidence in this obiter dicta summary: medium

The judgment suggests that, when hypothesising ill‑health retirement as a counterfactual, a tribunal should allow credit for loss of enhanced (Tier 1) pension benefits or a real chance of them if there is evidential support, and that hypotheses about non‑psychiatric disease progression are speculative absent evidence. These observations were not treated as binding ratio.

Warning

Reasons at remedy hearing are at times muddled and contain an apparent anomaly on causation wording, making parts difficult to interpret. Reasons at the remedy hearing are at times muddled and contain an apparent anomaly on causation wording, so the notes may reflect uneven or incomplete reasoning.